scream vs archaons armour of morkar

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

owain_b

Ghoul
Feb 3, 2014
176
Zombies
115
Hey guy, as in the title how does this work? Does the scream have to role to wound on a 3+ for each wound?

Armour says hits that automatically wound still need to roll to wound on a 3+, but I'm not sure the scream counts as hits?
 
Yeah I figured that to be the case, and things like poison and runefangs, but I'm not sure the exact ruling for the armour, so was wondering if this had come up before for anyone, or if anyone had the WoC book to check it
 
Ok i understand, he cannot do 3+ save with his armor but he can do his 3+ save with his talisman + tzeench mark.

So instead of having two save at 3+, he have Just one.

Am i right?
 
I don't think that is correct.

Armour of Morkar:
No attacks against Archaon may ever have a better chance To Wound than a 3+. This includes, for example, attacks that wound automatically, or which always wound on 2+.

Death Shriek:
...A death shriek is a special attack... For each point by which the result exceeds the target unit's Leadership, the target suffers 1 wound with no armour saves allowed....

The death shriek is an attack that causes wounds. No attack can ever cause a wound on Archaon with a better chance than 3+.

The 3+ is still a To Wound roll so the no armour save part does not ignore it. Arguing that the Death Shriek doesn’t need to make a To Wound roll doesn't work as neither does explicit automatic wounds. The text also says that automatic wounds and "always 2+" wounds are examples, suggesting that there are other kinds of attacks also included. Finding all of those and writing them down would probably be quite a shore so a bit of RAI arguing says that the writers just wanted a simple way of saying that you must always roll a 3+ to wound when attacking the freaking Everchosen.
 
I don't think that is correct.

Armour of Morkar:


Death Shriek:


The death shriek is an attack that causes wounds. No attack can ever cause a wound on Archaon with a better chance than 3+.

The 3+ is still a To Wound roll so the no armour save part does not ignore it. Arguing that the Death Shriek doesn’t need to make a To Wound roll doesn't work as neither does explicit automatic wounds. The text also says that automatic wounds and "always 2+" wounds are examples, suggesting that there are other kinds of attacks also included. Finding all of those and writing them down would probably be quite a shore so a bit of RAI arguing says that the writers just wanted a simple way of saying that you must always roll a 3+ to wound when attacking the freaking Everchosen.
But it's not a TO WOUND roll. There are no hits, so there is no to wound. Even if you did consider the scream as a to wound, you need at least a result of five to do anything in the first place (I know that's the scream wounds don't follow the same format, but that's irrelevant for this argument). It may be that RAI means you roll the "2d6+remaining TG wounds-LD=wounds" then roll a die for each wound caused and on a result of 3+ the wounds go through, but RAW, I don't see how it could be. Besides, the scream is not automatic wounds; it could cause 0 wounds. It is an automatic hit (which could also be argued), but not auto wounds.
 
How is causing 1 wound (for each point over the Ld of the target) not a wound?

I'm not saying it causes automatic wounds, I'm saying that just like automatic wounds the shriek does not roll to wound. If auto wounds have to roll the same goes for each wound caused by the shriek.
 
If the scream is an automatic hit, then in order to wound, you have to roll at least a 5 (granted, it's on 2d6, but still higher than 3) in order to cause ANY wounds and greater than that to cause more, which is still higher than the required 3+. If the TG has taken any wounds, that number is higher, so I don't see how the 3+ in order to wound matters, since you already have to roll at least 5.
 
But that same logic could be applied to a dude with a Runefang.
Empire player: "I wound automatically"
WoC player: "You still have to roll 3+"
Empire player: "But I just did, one my To Hit rolls"

Empire player had 4 attacks, each had a 4+ chance to hit (WS6 vs WS9), each hit causes an automatic wound. Each attack therefore had no better than a chance of 3+ To Wound. The Armour of Morkar makes no mention of any hits, it just say that no attack can have a better chance than 3+ To Wound.

...I guess this could be the actually RAW to play... It's a strange use of the word chance. 3+ is not a measurement of probability. Since D6 is the base it could be that they mean a 2/3 chance. But that would cause crazy results since the chain goes from attack to wound. You would have to calculate what chance you have to hit and then multiply it with the chance to wound, if that is greater than a 2/3 chance to wound you would instead of rolling to hit and everything just roll a D6 and hope for 3+ (i.e. a 2/3 chance of the attack causing a wound). I don't know, I'm confusing myself at this point...
 
Example: Something strikes at Arachon and should against a normal dude with the same stats hit on a 2+ and wound on a 2+. The probability of that attack causing a wound is 5/6*5/6 =25/36

However, 2/3=4/6=24/36

Since 25/36 is bigger than 24/36 each attack has a greater chance than 3+ to cause a wound.

So instead of rolling to hit and then rolling to wound you just roll 1 die for each attack, on a 3+ it causes a wound.

I don't what to think about what this would mean for complex attacks such as the Death Shriek right now.

Good night.
 
I don't know about the runefang, because he is rolling to hit and not to wound and the armor would basically mean the Empire player now also has to roll to wound. For the TG, the 2d6 IS the to wound roll, in essence. That's how I read what you posted.
 
It's pretty clear to me: You roll 2D6 + wounds - LD = W (number of wounds no armour saves). Archaon says need 3+ to wound no matter what so take W dice and roll. On a 3+ each of those dice wound no armour saves. Archaon takes his ward saves. Done
 
Archaons 3+ works on any to wound attempt, a wound and a to wound are two different things. Something that completes its to hit and the to wound wounds on a 1+ ignoring auto fail on one (automatic hit) still has a to wound, most just don't bother to roll it because it always succeeds. The scream does not have any to wound rolls, not even automatic ones, it skips the to hit and to wound and immediately moves to causing wounds.
 
no because a miscast is not an attack.

how can it wound if it isnt an attack? a to wound only happens during an attack. unless of course causing wounds and a to wound roll are two entirely different things. the to wound roll is the rule archaons armor is overriding, not actually taking wounds. A scream doesn't roll to hit or to wound, it just causes wounds. Saying the to-wound is implied just because its defined source is an attack seems more nitpicky and ignoring of RAW and RAI then the other interpretation to me.
 
ai
 

Attachments

  • Captain-Picard-Facepalm.webp
    Captain-Picard-Facepalm.webp
    10.8 KB · Views: 83
I agree with @Mad'at : TG scream is an attack. It causes automatic wounds. Armour of Morkhar says you must always roll 3+ to wound. Ergo you must roll an additional 3+ to wound the Everchosen with any wounds caused by the terrorgheist. All you need to trigger the Armour is an "attack" that "causes wounds."

Miscasts would be an exception, as they are not attacks. You would wound him based on his toughness. Unless someone finds language in the miscast chart saying that they are, indeed, an attack.
 
The miscast table actually calls them hits, which is more indicative of an attack than a TG scream. Result 2-4=S10 hit, 4-5=S6 hit. Miscast already allows armor and ward saves, so why wouldn't Archaon's armor protect against the S10 hit?

I stand by the TG already having to roll a minimum of 5 in order to wound Archaon in the first place, so whether it's RAI or RAW is irrelevant. The only time it might be relevant is if Archaon's LD is 7 or below. Even then, there's a 1/36 chance you snake-eyes so it won't really matter anyways. It just doesn't make sense to roll for each wound caused by the scream. If you do, then what about Spirit Leech?? It follows the same dynamic. There are no hits, just wounds, again that don't allow armor. They aren't auto wounds, because you have to take a test. Now the S/T spells from Death Lore are different, and his armor should affect those because they specifically state they wound on a 2+.

Based on your logic, if Nagash were to cause a wound and multiplied to 3, would you have to roll 3 more dice and they only apply on a 3+? No, so why would it apply for a TG, TB, or Spirit Leech?
 
Maybe I am not reading it right but I always thought the scream roll was not a to wound roll but rather a how many wounds roll. The number of wounds are then automatic no to wound roll normally required. Kinda like rolling a d3 for a multi wound weapon just to figure out how many wounds, just in this case the number could be 0 wounds.

Same would apply to spirit leech
 
  • Like
Reactions: owain_b

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu