TeflonTron
Skeleton
It isn't about the Skeleton's getting hit on 4+ as much as it is about them getting to hit the other guy on 3+. 3+ is the new black, don't ya know!
rothgar13 said:That's the key point here, yeah - to see whether Spears or HW+Shields are the better option against commonly fielded units (looks like HW+Shield wins), and whether formation changes anything (Horde tends to do worse than 5-wide).
As for the aside, I don't know why you wouldn't run the Halberdiers in Horde, to be honest with you. If you're looking for a unit to hold people down with, Swordsmen are over that way.
Vs. 40 Beastmen Gors with Additional Hand Weapons:
5 wide, HW+Shield
Gors go first. 24 attacks, hit on 3's with a re-roll, wound on 4's, allow 5+ armor and 6+ parry.
Math: (24)*(8/9)*(1/2)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 5.93 Wounds ~ 6
Skellies go second. 10 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow no save.
Math: (10)*(1/2)*(1/3) = 1.67 Wounds ~ 2
Lose by 4.
5 wide, Spears
Gors go first. 24 attacks, hit on 3's with a re-roll, wound on 4's, allow 5+ armor.
Math: (24)*(8/9)*(1/2)*(2/3) = 7.11 Wounds ~ 7
Skellies go second. 15 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow no save.
Math: (15)*(1/2)*(1/3) = 2.50 Wounds ~ 3
Lose by 4.
10 wide, HW+Shield
Gors go first. 40 attacks, hit on 3's with a re-roll, wound on 4's, allow 5+ armor and 6+ parry.
Math: (40)*(8/9)*(1/2)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 9.88 Wounds ~ 10
Skellies go second. 30 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow no save.
Math: (30)*(1/2)*(1/3) = 5.00 Wounds ~ 5
Lose by 5.
10 wide, Spears
Gors go first. 40 attacks, hit on 3's with a re-roll, wound on 4's, allow 5+ armor.
Math: (40)*(8/9)*(1/2)*(2/3) = 11.85 Wounds ~ 12
Skellies go second. 40 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow no save.
Math: (40)*(1/2)*(1/3) = 6.67 Wounds ~ 7
Lose by 5.
Gannen Harst said:Forgive me if Im a noob but don't spears give a strength bonus aswell?
6+ regen is hardly a crutchdrmooreflava said:My arguement against using mortis engine is that Regen is becoming a liablilty vs many opponents. Using regen as a crutch for your army is so last book :tongue: Everyone has caught on to that 'one trick poney' as they say.
My arguement against using LD combo is that it is dependant upon your opponent and Absolutely worthless vs immune to psych. Banshee isn't worth he pts as a hero IMO. Even if your opponent fails his fear rolls, hes only hitting your skeletons of 4+Seems to me like screaming banner isn't worth taking on anything that isn't WS 3.
My advice on hero choices in combination with skeletons is: Take a wight bsb with enchanted sheild and a wraith for terror. This way you have the ethereal to take challenges or you have the killing blow WK if you think you can win a challenge. On rank and file you are getting +6 attacks and +1 combat res from the bsb and a -1 to instability casualties, because face it, we will lose combat more often than not.
Some say that Staff of damnation is good on them, I agree, however, I see that item nulified by your enemy the moment they find you that you have it. If I were to go with a bound item to help them out, I'd use rod of flaming death so that the opponent can't double charge me in the 10 wide front.

rothgar13 said:People talk about tarpitting with Zombies a lot, but here's the problem I have with that - most of the time you can't support a Zombie unit that's holding something up, because they're absolutely BLEEDING combat resolution, much more so than the Skellies. If your goal is to just hold that unit up there for most of the game with a low point investment, I guess that's fine, but I would actually be looking to jam something fighty (like Vargheists) into that flank and try and turn the fight into a favorable one so I can get some VP's out of it all. You can't do that very well with Zombies, because Unstable will come back to bite you big time. You can, however, do it with Skeletons. You see that some fights here are being lost by 4-5 points. I'm pretty sure 6 Vargheists in the flank with their 21 attacks and +2 static res from a flank charge can make up that gap without much trouble, even with the enemy claiming a bit more res from slapping on a Wound or two on them.
The reason I ran the sim without external support is because I feel it really complicates things, and not just on the VC side. For example, that Gor unit I describe doesn't run around at S3 - it has a BSB with a magic banner that makes the entire unit S4, and sometimes it'll have a fighting Shaman that's popping Skellies to use as power dice next turn. That's going to drastically change how that unit performs, and it's going to be a pasting for the Skellies, so it's not going to tell me much about relative gaps in performance.
I'd consider adding the Screaming Banner to it and calculating the odds those units have of failing a Fear test, but I can tell you right now they won't be good - a lot of 'em are ItP or cause Fear themselves, and most of the ones that aren't have great Ld anyway (Ld 9, or 8 on the 2 lowest of 3 dice). I only see the Gors and Halberdiers as being remotely susceptible to this sort of thing.
rothgar13 said:Here's the key point, though. The back-of-the-envelope math shows that even while unsupported, Skeletons aren't losing some of those fights by all that much. If your choices are between bringing a more numerous unit that loses the fight by a lot and thus is only aiming to hold the opponent there for as long as possible, and a unit that can't hold them for as long but can battle back well enough for support to come in and turn the tide, which do you pick? I know I'm picking option B, because it offers me a chance at actually gaining Victory Points out of it all.
rothgar13 said:This is something that's not necessarily true - Skeletons are perfectly capable of holding up a Horde of Core troops while something else savages the flank. And I can tell you that there are a lot of Core troops out there that you can hold up, but that Horde formation + Spears won't help you beat in a straight fight. Hammer + anvil tactics are a resource that Skeletons have available to them, and as any good resource, it should be exploited.
To be brutally honest, that argument regarding deviations from the norm doesn't hold much water. If you run that scenario 10 times, 8 out of 10 you turn the game around, and that's worth the 2 times you fluff the roll and lose. Also, Vargheists are better hammers than Black Knights precisely because of this - they attack a ton of times, so it's harder to fluff the roll completely, and they have Stomps for autohit goodness.
Malisteen said:If you're not putting a caster in, then yeah, zombies won't do much for you. But then again, you really should have a caster or two in your infantry line. All of our infantry are pretty dependent on it, with the possible exception of grave guard.