Skeleton hw/s vs spears smackdown.

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
It isn't about the Skeleton's getting hit on 4+ as much as it is about them getting to hit the other guy on 3+. 3+ is the new black, don't ya know!
 
OK, so I've some some simulation analysis of Skeletons against a variety of enemy Core troops. As every unit that I've posted against them is significantly more expensive, I can't say I really expected them to win combat. However, I think this gives a good inkling at how vanilla Skeletons perform:

Without further ado... I unleash the Wall of Text!

Vampire Counts Skeleton Analysis

Vs. 40 Beastmen Gors with Additional Hand Weapons:

5 wide, HW+Shield

Gors go first. 24 attacks, hit on 3's with a re-roll, wound on 4's, allow 5+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (24)*(8/9)*(1/2)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 5.93 Wounds ~ 6

Skellies go second. 10 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow no save.

Math: (10)*(1/2)*(1/3) = 1.67 Wounds ~ 2

Lose by 4.

5 wide, Spears

Gors go first. 24 attacks, hit on 3's with a re-roll, wound on 4's, allow 5+ armor.

Math: (24)*(8/9)*(1/2)*(2/3) = 7.11 Wounds ~ 7

Skellies go second. 15 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow no save.

Math: (15)*(1/2)*(1/3) = 2.50 Wounds ~ 3

Lose by 4.

10 wide, HW+Shield

Gors go first. 40 attacks, hit on 3's with a re-roll, wound on 4's, allow 5+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (40)*(8/9)*(1/2)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 9.88 Wounds ~ 10

Skellies go second. 30 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow no save.

Math: (30)*(1/2)*(1/3) = 5.00 Wounds ~ 5

Lose by 5.

10 wide, Spears

Gors go first. 40 attacks, hit on 3's with a re-roll, wound on 4's, allow 5+ armor.

Math: (40)*(8/9)*(1/2)*(2/3) = 11.85 Wounds ~ 12

Skellies go second. 40 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow no save.

Math: (40)*(1/2)*(1/3) = 6.67 Wounds ~ 7

Lose by 5.

Vs. 40 Dwarf Warriors with Great Weapons:

5 wide, HW+Shield

Skellies go first. 10 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow 5+ armor.

Math: (10)*(1/2)*(1/3)*(2/3) = 1.11 Wounds ~ 1

Dwarfs go second. 21 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 2's, allow 6+ parry.

Math: (21)*(2/3)*(5/6)*(5/6) = 9.72 Wounds ~ 10

Lose by 9.

5 wide, Spears

Skellies go first. 15 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow 5+ armor.

Math: (15)*(1/2)*(1/3)*(2/3) = 1.67 Wounds ~ 2

Dwarfs go second. 21 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 2's, allow no save.

Math: (21)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 11.67 Wounds ~ 12

Lose by 10.

10 wide, HW+Shield

Skellies go first. 30 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow 5+ armor.

Math: (30)*(1/2)*(1/3)*(2/3) = 3.33 Wounds ~ 3

Dwarfs go second. 30 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 2's, allow 6+ parry.

Math: (30)*(2/3)*(5/6)*(5/6) = 13.89 Wounds ~ 14

Lose by 11.

10 wide, Spears

Skellies go first. 40 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow 5+ armor.

Math: (40)*(1/2)*(1/3)*(2/3) = 4.44 Wounds ~ 4

Dwarfs go second. 30 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 2's, allow no save.

Math: (30)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 16.67 Wounds ~ 17

Lose by 13.

Vs. 40 Empire Halberdiers with Halberds:

5 wide, HW+Shield

Halberdiers go first. 21 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (21)*(2/3)*(2/3)*(5/6)*(5/6) = 6.48 Wounds ~ 6

Skellies go second. 10 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 4's, allow 6+ armor.

Math: (10)*(1/2)*(1/2)*(5/6) = 2.08 Wounds ~ 2

Lose by 4.

5 wide, Spears

Halberdiers go first. 21 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor.

Math: (21)*(2/3)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 7.78 Wounds ~ 8

Skellies go second. 15 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 4's, allow 6+ armor.

Math: (15)*(1/2)*(1/2)*(5/6) = 3.13 Wounds ~ 3

Lose by 5.

10 wide, HW+Shield

Halberdiers go first. 30 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (30)*(2/3)*(2/3)*(5/6)*(5/6) = 9.26 Wounds ~ 9

Skellies go second. 30 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 4's, allow 6+ armor.

Math: (30)*(1/2)*(1/2)*(5/6) = 6.25 Wounds ~ 6

Lose by 3.

10 wide, Spears

Halberdiers go first. 30 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor.

Math: (30)*(2/3)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 11.11 Wounds ~ 11

Skellies go second. 40 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 4's, allow 6+ armor.

Math: (40)*(1/2)*(1/2)*(5/6) = 8.33 Wounds ~ 8

Lose by 3.

Vs. 40 Saurus Warriors with HW+Shield:

5 wide, HW+Shield

Skellies go first. 10 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow 4+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (10)*(1/2)*(1/3)*(1/2)*(5/6) = 0.69 Wounds ~ 1

Saurus go second. 24 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (24)*(2/3)*(2/3)*(5/6)*(5/6) = 7.41 Wounds ~ 7

Lose by 6.

5 wide, Spears

Skellies go first. 15 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow 4+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (15)*(1/2)*(1/3)*(1/2)*(5/6) = 1.04 Wounds ~ 1

Saurus go second. 24 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor.

Math: (24)*(2/3)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 8.89 Wounds ~ 9

Lose by 8.

10 wide, HW+Shield

Skellies go first. 30 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow 4+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (30)*(1/2)*(1/3)*(1/2)*(5/6) = 2.08 Wounds ~ 2

Saurus go second. 40 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (40)*(2/3)*(2/3)*(5/6)*(5/6) = 12.34 Wounds ~ 12

Lose by 10.

10 wide, Spears

Skellies go first. 40 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow 4+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (40)*(1/2)*(1/3)*(1/2)*(5/6) = 2.78 Wounds ~ 3

Saurus go second. 40 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor.

Math: (40)*(2/3)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 14.81 Wounds ~ 15

Lose by 12.

Vs. 12 Ogre Bulls with Ironfists:

5 wide, HW+Shield

Both parties go at the same time.

Skellies - 10 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow 5+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (10)*(1/2)*(1/3)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 0.93 Wounds ~ 1

Bulls - 18 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor and 6+ parry. 3 stomps, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor.

Math: (18)*(2/3)*(2/3)*(5/6)*(5/6) + (3)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 7.22 ~ 7

Lose by 6.

5 wide, Spears

Both parties go at the same time.

Skellies - 15 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow 5+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (15)*(1/2)*(1/3)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 1.39 Wounds ~ 1

Bulls - 18 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor. 3 stomps, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor.

Math: (18)*(2/3)*(2/3)*(5/6) + (3)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 8.33 ~ 8

Lose by 7.

10 wide, HW+Shield

Both parties go at the same time.

Skellies - 24 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow 5+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (24)*(1/2)*(1/3)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 2.22 Wounds ~ 2

Bulls - 18 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor and 6+ parry. 3 stomps, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor.

Math: (18)*(2/3)*(2/3)*(5/6)*(5/6) + (3)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 7.22 ~ 7

Lose by 5.

10 wide, Spears

Both parties go at the same time.

Skellies - 32 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow 5+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (32)*(1/2)*(1/3)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 2.96 Wounds ~ 3

Bulls - 18 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor. 3 stomps, wound on 3's, allow 6+ armor.

Math: (18)*(2/3)*(2/3)*(5/6) + (3)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 8.33 ~ 8

Lose by 5.

Vs. 50 Chaos Marauders with Great Weapons and Mark of Khorne:

5 wide, HW+Shield

Skellies go first. 10 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 4's, allow no save.

Math: (10)*(1/2)*(1/2) = 2.50 Wounds ~ 3

Marauders go second. 24 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 2's, allow 6+ parry.

Math: (24)*(2/3)*(5/6)*(5/6) = 11.11 Wounds ~ 11

Lose by 8.

5 wide, Spears

Skellies go first. 15 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 4's, allow no save.

Math: (15)*(1/2)*(1/2) = 3.75 Wounds ~ 4

Marauders go second. 24 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 2's, allow no save.

Math: (24)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 13.33 Wounds ~ 13

Lose by 9.

10 wide, HW+Shield

Skellies go first. 30 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 4's, allow no save.

Math: (30)*(1/2)*(1/2) = 7.50 Wounds ~ 8

Marauders go second. 40 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 2's, allow 6+ parry.

Math: (40)*(2/3)*(5/6)*(5/6) = 18.52 Wounds ~ 19

Lose by 11.

10 wide, Spears

Skellies go first. 40 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 4's, allow no save.

Math: (40)*(1/2)*(1/2) =10.00 Wounds ~ 10

Marauders go second. 40 attacks, hit on 3's, wound on 2's, allow no save.

Math: (40)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 22.22 Wounds ~ 22

Lose by 12.

tl;dr: 5-wide and HW+Shield makes the Skeletons survive the longest in the great majority of cases. The additional kills from the Spears don't seem to be worth giving up the parry save.
 
Do you not think that it is disingenuous to maximise all of the attacks against the Skeletons (by putting the enemies in horde)? I mean, 40 Halberdiers, just as a single example, getting 21 attacks vs the Skeletons with their 10 doesn't exactly represent a fair like-for-like comparison. Unless, of course, you meant simply to show the differences between spears and hand-weapons + shields.
 
That's the key point here, yeah - to see whether Spears or HW+Shields are the better option against commonly fielded units (looks like HW+Shield wins), and whether formation changes anything (Horde tends to do worse than 5-wide).

As for the aside, I don't know why you wouldn't run the Halberdiers in Horde, to be honest with you. If you're looking for a unit to hold people down with, Swordsmen are over that way.
 
rothgar13 said:
That's the key point here, yeah - to see whether Spears or HW+Shields are the better option against commonly fielded units (looks like HW+Shield wins), and whether formation changes anything (Horde tends to do worse than 5-wide).

As for the aside, I don't know why you wouldn't run the Halberdiers in Horde, to be honest with you. If you're looking for a unit to hold people down with, Swordsmen are over that way.

You're missing out on a bit of the reason for going into Horde (As I understand it).

Most of the mortal races can maximize their efficiency by going into a 5xDeep for Steadfast, which allows them to have far more staying power than they normally would. Going into Horde for most mortal races is less appealing because it opens the chance that you might be beaten in combat, and forced to take a Ld test with more penalties and actually flee (And potentially lose an entire unit).

For us Undead there is no fear of breaking, so if we Horde up, we take advantage of more supporting attacks while not forgoing any staying power. All we give up is breaking their 'Steadfast' advantage. However to break their Steadfast with our Core is a poor option, since our core often can not match them on the combat front, so even if they don't get their steadfast, we most likely are not crushing them enough to actually break them anyhow.

So let them have their steadfast, and let them find safety in numbers, because we will throw the uncountable at them, and grind them down.

Plus it is a fool who matches 1-for-1 any VC core vs any other Armies. Our army does not get by on their exemplary stats. They thrive on our magic, our Re-rolls to Hit/Wound, and ASF, our ability to raise the fallen back. Not our ability to go toe-to-toe with anything.

If that was our only option we would surely lose.

In your example
Vs. 40 Beastmen Gors with Additional Hand Weapons:

5 wide, HW+Shield

Gors go first. 24 attacks, hit on 3's with a re-roll, wound on 4's, allow 5+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (24)*(8/9)*(1/2)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 5.93 Wounds ~ 6

Skellies go second. 10 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow no save.

Math: (10)*(1/2)*(1/3) = 1.67 Wounds ~ 2

Lose by 4.

5 wide, Spears

Gors go first. 24 attacks, hit on 3's with a re-roll, wound on 4's, allow 5+ armor.

Math: (24)*(8/9)*(1/2)*(2/3) = 7.11 Wounds ~ 7

Skellies go second. 15 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow no save.

Math: (15)*(1/2)*(1/3) = 2.50 Wounds ~ 3

Lose by 4.

10 wide, HW+Shield

Gors go first. 40 attacks, hit on 3's with a re-roll, wound on 4's, allow 5+ armor and 6+ parry.

Math: (40)*(8/9)*(1/2)*(2/3)*(5/6) = 9.88 Wounds ~ 10

Skellies go second. 30 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow no save.

Math: (30)*(1/2)*(1/3) = 5.00 Wounds ~ 5

Lose by 5.

10 wide, Spears

Gors go first. 40 attacks, hit on 3's with a re-roll, wound on 4's, allow 5+ armor.

Math: (40)*(8/9)*(1/2)*(2/3) = 11.85 Wounds ~ 12

Skellies go second. 40 attacks, hit on 4's, wound on 5's, allow no save.

Math: (40)*(1/2)*(1/3) = 6.67 Wounds ~ 7

Lose by 5.

We should be getting our 7 wounds with the Skeles vs their 5 with a ranked up unit of Gors (Possibly not 5xX, maybe 6? Depends on their preference), which would actually end up winning us a combat, on raw stats. But we still aren't about raw stats, it's all about the magic support we can throw at our units.
 
I can tell you for a fact all those units love going Horde. The loss of ranks for Steadfast is irrelevant when you win combat regularly, and these units do (OK, maybe not the Halberdiers, but most of them win regularly).

While these combat results are obviously all losses, that's not the point. The point is that if you have to leave a unit out on an island, HW+Shield will last longer. Additionally, you usually are looking to enhance the performance of the unit that's doing better in the first place, because it makes a victory more likely. The Spears more often than not have to overcome a gap to just come on par with HW+Shield, so who cares if they get a marginally better benefit from buffs? They needed to catch up to begin with.
 
drmooreflava said:
My arguement against using mortis engine is that Regen is becoming a liablilty vs many opponents. Using regen as a crutch for your army is so last book :tongue: Everyone has caught on to that 'one trick poney' as they say.

My arguement against using LD combo is that it is dependant upon your opponent and Absolutely worthless vs immune to psych. Banshee isn't worth he pts as a hero IMO. Even if your opponent fails his fear rolls, hes only hitting your skeletons of 4+ :rolleyes: Seems to me like screaming banner isn't worth taking on anything that isn't WS 3.

My advice on hero choices in combination with skeletons is: Take a wight bsb with enchanted sheild and a wraith for terror. This way you have the ethereal to take challenges or you have the killing blow WK if you think you can win a challenge. On rank and file you are getting +6 attacks and +1 combat res from the bsb and a -1 to instability casualties, because face it, we will lose combat more often than not.
Some say that Staff of damnation is good on them, I agree, however, I see that item nulified by your enemy the moment they find you that you have it. If I were to go with a bound item to help them out, I'd use rod of flaming death so that the opponent can't double charge me in the 10 wide front.
6+ regen is hardly a crutch :rolleyes: :tongue:
Mortis engines offer so much utility (aside from the regen save), and so if you're taking one anyways, the 6+ regen is usually superior to parry save (flaming/KB attacks being the exception.), and add in extra attacks and it becomes a why not? If an enemy decides to use his flaming attacks (which are usually rare) to fight CC against skellies, then mission accomplished.

Even without mortis engine, +5,7 or 10 attacks is almost always worth the 6+ ward save you give up.
Failing fear test affects any heroes/lords in the unit which is what makes it so sweet. I wouldn't go overboard with trying to fail the fear, but certainly a screaming banner isn't a huge investment, and adding in a fear incarnate occasionally if I want a thrall in the unit anyways, and total investment is ~45 points and there is a decent chance of having a unit be reduced to WS1. Even with nothing else, +1 to hit enemies and -1 to hit to your skellies is still pretty fine.
Immune to fear is somewhat rare (TK, Ogres and our army not withstanding), and especially so for fighting hordes of skeletons (since ItP is usually reserved for more elite units, something that enemies don't throw at skellies).

I don't think I would want a wraith to take challenges (since most guys issuing challenges have some sort of magic weapon), besides skelly champ can do that just fine (res him again and again). Personally, I prefer the BSB WK in a unit with GG (along with burrows)as they are generally fighting tougher battles (with generally lower # of stronger attacks) and the +1 CR goes farther. Keep in mind the -1 from crumbling can be accomplished without sticking the BSB in the unit.
Other than that though, I think including fighty heroes is one tactic to make skellies work well. Skeletons ideally need support from either combat heroes (fairly reliable but only works for the unit the hero is in), or magical support (less reliable but can work on multiple units that hero isn't in... plus more fun I think!)
 
thanks for all the math hammer i really enjoyed that heh xD

its a shame that u didnt factor in the 6+ regen save that we are considering a major reason running skellies w/ spears over hw/s tho.
if it didnt take so long id ask u to do another one for everything after the enemy had failed a fear test with the skellies hitting on 3's and enemies hitting on 4's too. giving the unit a maxed out fear bomb combo is expensive and its not useful against all opponents, so itd be good to know just how much more effective it is against the units that it does work against so i can weigh my options for all those points properly.

its not just that u have to use magic to make spear skellies keep up with the hw/s skellies effectiveness either, its that if u put the same buffs on both units, then the spear wielders will get more benefits out of it. i just find it so easy to give them re-roll to hit (VHD + BoA), and not too difficult to give them re-roll to wound if u play your spells at the right time. i love the cursed book in the front of this unit as well, its great dont underestimate it.

if you are going to put 50-60 skellies in a horde with spears then its going to be worth using ur magic to help them win combat. other units like GG, crypt horrors, vargs etc dont need that magic support as much to keep them reinforced or to help them win combats. this makes me think that the best place for my casters is near the skellies. there they can make sure i have a solid center because i keep raising them back, and that they can win combats when u give them the support they need to do so. thats why i run a hybrid lvl4 red fury vamp lord who sits in there.

if you just want ur skellies to block/tarpit for a little while and you dont want to worry about magic support for them then yes, go 5 wide hw/s and deep. the maths make it so.

if you want core that can be more effective with less magic support, go with ghouls. ghouls can also be even more devastating with lots of magic support. i like hordes of skellies aesthetics and fluff better, thats all :thumbsup:

in answer to another question, mostly i think u should let the enemy charge your skellie horde. that way they only get one combat phase before u get to ur next magic phase where they will be pressured to stop every one of your spells. cursed book, raising skellies back that they just killed, re roll hits/wounds, and curse of years will all be priority dispels. they cant get em all :devil2: (im also assuming that the mortis engine is nearby with the magic support)

my bottom line is that if you are running skeletons and want them to be a threat instead of a temporary road block, support them with magic and characters like VC are built to do. skellies w/ spears and in horde formation take the most advantage of this imo, so thats how im using them xD
 
I agree with Tawg :cheers:

VC core needs to grind down opponents with as many attacks as possible + magic support + bsb (if you run it) to be able to hold steady while some part of your army actually lays the smack down :smash:

Horde form + Spears on skeletons are an option to roll as many attack dice as possible and hopefully roll well. Grinding down enemy units to a manageable size is invaluable to our army because we CANNOT afford to lose any combats with our precious units. I beleive "Tar Pitting" Power should be left up to the zombies(because of their easy ressurection). If you really want to hold an enemy up, just take them instead. HW + Shield skeletons just fall short in both categories in my mind. Granted, I don't run fear bomb combo or the pitiful mortis engine. Iron curse icon on a Wight king bsb in 55+ spear skeletons is all you really need to put a thorn the the lion's paw.
 
People talk about tarpitting with Zombies a lot, but here's the problem I have with that - most of the time you can't support a Zombie unit that's holding something up, because they're absolutely BLEEDING combat resolution, much more so than the Skellies. If your goal is to just hold that unit up there for most of the game with a low point investment, I guess that's fine, but I would actually be looking to jam something fighty (like Vargheists) into that flank and try and turn the fight into a favorable one so I can get some VP's out of it all. You can't do that very well with Zombies, because Unstable will come back to bite you big time. You can, however, do it with Skeletons. You see that some fights here are being lost by 4-5 points. I'm pretty sure 6 Vargheists in the flank with their 21 attacks and +2 static res from a flank charge can make up that gap without much trouble, even with the enemy claiming a bit more res from slapping on a Wound or two on them.

The reason I ran the sim without external support is because I feel it really complicates things, and not just on the VC side. For example, that Gor unit I describe doesn't run around at S3 - it has a BSB with a magic banner that makes the entire unit S4, and sometimes it'll have a fighting Shaman that's popping Skellies to use as power dice next turn. That's going to drastically change how that unit performs, and it's going to be a pasting for the Skellies, so it's not going to tell me much about relative gaps in performance.

I'd consider adding the Screaming Banner to it and calculating the odds those units have of failing a Fear test, but I can tell you right now they won't be good - a lot of 'em are ItP or cause Fear themselves, and most of the ones that aren't have great Ld anyway (Ld 9, or 8 on the 2 lowest of 3 dice). I only see the Gors and Halberdiers as being remotely susceptible to this sort of thing.
 
Hey! That huge block of math was something I was really hoping someone had done/had a resource going over it. Super thanks!
 
rothgar13 said:
People talk about tarpitting with Zombies a lot, but here's the problem I have with that - most of the time you can't support a Zombie unit that's holding something up, because they're absolutely BLEEDING combat resolution, much more so than the Skellies. If your goal is to just hold that unit up there for most of the game with a low point investment, I guess that's fine, but I would actually be looking to jam something fighty (like Vargheists) into that flank and try and turn the fight into a favorable one so I can get some VP's out of it all. You can't do that very well with Zombies, because Unstable will come back to bite you big time. You can, however, do it with Skeletons. You see that some fights here are being lost by 4-5 points. I'm pretty sure 6 Vargheists in the flank with their 21 attacks and +2 static res from a flank charge can make up that gap without much trouble, even with the enemy claiming a bit more res from slapping on a Wound or two on them.

The reason I ran the sim without external support is because I feel it really complicates things, and not just on the VC side. For example, that Gor unit I describe doesn't run around at S3 - it has a BSB with a magic banner that makes the entire unit S4, and sometimes it'll have a fighting Shaman that's popping Skellies to use as power dice next turn. That's going to drastically change how that unit performs, and it's going to be a pasting for the Skellies, so it's not going to tell me much about relative gaps in performance.

I'd consider adding the Screaming Banner to it and calculating the odds those units have of failing a Fear test, but I can tell you right now they won't be good - a lot of 'em are ItP or cause Fear themselves, and most of the ones that aren't have great Ld anyway (Ld 9, or 8 on the 2 lowest of 3 dice). I only see the Gors and Halberdiers as being remotely susceptible to this sort of thing.

Uh, if you're tar pitting that means you're walking away from what ever you just threw those zombies at, or at the very least you're using that time they are tied up to kill something else on your terms. I do not think that multiple units in close combat is a good idea for VC unless you are certain you will be making much more of a splash than the opponent. The possibility that units can be dragged down by negative CR from zombies is exactly the reason you just don't play that way. You don't say Skeletons do it better, you're asking for a different role when you say that. An Anvil and a Tar pit are completely different, and Skeletons make alright Anvils depending on what they are fighting (IE, a bit of other armies core?); Zombies being a tar pit means you're just going to watch them die, and that's what was always intended, plus if you have a necro in range to cast IoN then you can even just fluff their waning numbers as they get tore up, as long as they buy you turns.

Yeah but it's completely illogical to compare units in a vacuum since they will almost never actually see that situation. What VC army will run no support for it's units? And sure other armies will be throwing clever combos at us as well, but you should be ready for that too, not just their base-line.

So yeah skeletons get beat the hell up, and hell yes they fail even harder when the opponent tries to kill stuff, but that's why you throw 5 zombies at them instead of 3 skeletons. They are both going to die, so just use their numbers if it's going to be that bad (Plus 2d6 on IoN vs 1d6 is pretty big, especially with the CC around.). Eh, at least that's how I see it. Zombies fodder better, and skeletons provide sub-par anvils, or more expensive pits.
 
Here's the key point, though. The back-of-the-envelope math shows that even while unsupported, Skeletons aren't losing some of those fights by all that much. If your choices are between bringing a more numerous unit that loses the fight by a lot and thus is only aiming to hold the opponent there for as long as possible, and a unit that can't hold them for as long but can battle back well enough for support to come in and turn the tide, which do you pick? I know I'm picking option B, because it offers me a chance at actually gaining Victory Points out of it all.
 
rothgar13 said:
Here's the key point, though. The back-of-the-envelope math shows that even while unsupported, Skeletons aren't losing some of those fights by all that much. If your choices are between bringing a more numerous unit that loses the fight by a lot and thus is only aiming to hold the opponent there for as long as possible, and a unit that can't hold them for as long but can battle back well enough for support to come in and turn the tide, which do you pick? I know I'm picking option B, because it offers me a chance at actually gaining Victory Points out of it all.

If this is a discussion of victory points, horde form skeletons win it everyday of the week, especially in large units because they have to be killed to the man for the enemy to get the VP's. Spears give you the best chance to deal wounds(and eventually gaining victory points for killing the enemy unit) by giving you the most possible attacks. That's why staff of damnation is so dangerous on spear skeleton horde units. Just to clarify, that's a max of 50 attacks if you don't have characters or a champion. Imagine getting rerolls from spells too!

The fact is, skeletons get clobbered by anything that is somewhat strong. And if you think whatever you are fighting is worthy of a flank charge (To bring us into multiple units in 1 combat), then it's propably a unit that you neeeeed a flank charge to kill, meaning, it is probably the enemy's nastiest unit + general or bsb. Losing combat with two units in the same combat doubles the casualties from instability. Simply rolling bad can lose you a combat that you should have won(according to your math crunches), and lady averages isn't always so consistant. And so your game winning flank charge turns into you handing the battle away on a silver platter. I've personally had this happen to me with a unit of Black knights that missed half their attacks and wounded once. Both units popped, including my general and lvl 2 vampire.
 
This is something that's not necessarily true - Skeletons are perfectly capable of holding up a Horde of Core troops while something else savages the flank. And I can tell you that there are a lot of Core troops out there that you can hold up, but that Horde formation + Spears won't help you beat in a straight fight. Hammer + anvil tactics are a resource that Skeletons have available to them, and as any good resource, it should be exploited.

To be brutally honest, that argument regarding deviations from the norm doesn't hold much water. If you run that scenario 10 times, 8 out of 10 you turn the game around, and that's worth the 2 times you fluff the roll and lose. Also, Vargheists are better hammers than Black Knights precisely because of this - they attack a ton of times, so it's harder to fluff the roll completely, and they have Stomps for autohit goodness.
 
rothgar13 said:
This is something that's not necessarily true - Skeletons are perfectly capable of holding up a Horde of Core troops while something else savages the flank. And I can tell you that there are a lot of Core troops out there that you can hold up, but that Horde formation + Spears won't help you beat in a straight fight. Hammer + anvil tactics are a resource that Skeletons have available to them, and as any good resource, it should be exploited.

To be brutally honest, that argument regarding deviations from the norm doesn't hold much water. If you run that scenario 10 times, 8 out of 10 you turn the game around, and that's worth the 2 times you fluff the roll and lose. Also, Vargheists are better hammers than Black Knights precisely because of this - they attack a ton of times, so it's harder to fluff the roll completely, and they have Stomps for autohit goodness.

Yeah, I had the BK + Varghulf combined charge, and in the second round, they lost combat by like 5 (BKs hit nothing, Varghulf hit like once). I lost the 'Ghulf and nearly the entire unit of knights. Granted that was one of my first games and I had no idea about Thunderstomp, which I feel would have turned things around quite a bit, since the opponent didn't roll well either, he just got rank+Standard vs me.

But that does make the Vargheist stomp a strong argument in my book. BKs feel almost more like an anvil than a hammer, being that they can take such a hard beating, but have just so few attacks (Perhaps the Staff of Damnation would like to have a talk with them).

More on topic though, I just ran a 1.5k army in a 2v2 (3k total points), with 53 Spear Horde Skelies; I wanted to see how much work they really did. Unfortunately they scarcely got into combat before the game was pretty much conceded. The skaven player unleashed an irresistible plague spell that killed 25 of the skeletons in one go, plus my allies unit of Corsairs.. along with nearly his entire unit of Plague Monks + Plague Priest (The big S10 template miscast, ouch) and 15 of his 30 strong clan rat unit. They were kinda over after that.

But I feel like the Horde Skeletons would put in good work against my friends unit of Blood Letters, since their biggest weakness IMO is low number of attacks. I feel like throwing as many attacks back at him is really the way to bludgeon that unit to death. Granted they have high Str, so the Sword and Board are specifically worse against them (I guess unless you want the parry?) so maybe in other applications I could see Sword and Board being better.

Moral of the story being, it kinda depends on what you're going up against. Unless you are planning a 'All comers' style tournament list, which I would personally assume the Sword and Board are better for baring the inclusion of a mortis engine or two, where the parry save loses value.
 
This is a great thread and is worth a revival :thumbsup:

I'm considering NOT running 2 units of 30 zombies and instead replacing them with with:
40 skellies HW/shield.

My reasonings:
My magic caster is in a BK bus far away from buffing my infantry
No Engine
My zombie units die too quickly
I'm afraid to charge things the zombies tie up due to Unstable
Don't care about the 1 less deployment by reducing 2 units into 1
Maybe able to hold things up in time for the BK bus to swing into action

Any skellie proponents agree?
 
Malisteen said:
If you're not putting a caster in, then yeah, zombies won't do much for you. But then again, you really should have a caster or two in your infantry line. All of our infantry are pretty dependent on it, with the possible exception of grave guard.

I hear ya Malisteen, and I do have a level 1 necro on foot in there (to prevent crumbling of the lord in the BK bus), however I drop his only spell to ION. But you're right, it's tough to buff the units without any Engine/Cart/casters.

Although even with a few IONs on my zombies they just dieeeeee. With a big block of skellies, I can get them into combat, hold things up (in time for the BK bus to flank), use ION effectively to keep alive.

With a points denial list, I'm definately feeling the love from skellies!
 
Just make sure you don't leave them on an island for too long - they do go down after a while, and barring IoN there's nothing you can do about that, as playtesting has proved to me.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu