Skeletons Bad?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

jlay

Zombie
Jun 4, 2013
10
Zombies
6
Are skeletons really that bad?
In my mind at least I see a 5 point skelly as better than a 10 point ghoul, maybe that just me idk?
what do you guys think?
 
Hello there

I for one do not believe so and I know that there are those who would agree. Some folks no longer even take ghouls at all, they just run a block of 40 skellies 4 wide with Banner of Swiftness as a nice little bunker for the general (sometimes you'll see lists that put another character in the front rank like a vamp hero and then they place 2-3 banshess in the second rank for some screamy goodness) in addition to some zombie blocks to hold up enemies and perhaps a few dire wolves.
Another way to field skellies is to try out Johhny_Crass' list. He fields a horde of them with spears and brings along 2 level 2 vamps with forbidden lore for the mindrazor spell (shadow). Due to the general's leadership, the skellies will strike at str 10 so...ouch!
You could of course try another alternative and bring two blocks of 40 where others would use one unit of 40 ghouls. The parry save would benefit this army more than most others since we are capable of healing our troops.
There are other ways of making the most out of your skellies and I believe the above 3 examples are good methods of fielding them so bring 'em out of their crypts and have fun with those guys! :)
 
Skeletons are by no means bad in my books. It depends what you want them for. they are a relatively reliable core unit that isn't xpensive, especially when compared with ghouls and as Sen said, they can be great with some magical backup (lore of metal for enchanted blades and glittering robe for instance). Most of the time I end up taking 40 skeletons, 40 ghouls and 40 zombies in a 2500 point game. Each unit has their uses.
 
They are not bad at all. Our 4 core units have 4 different uses as I see it:

Zombs: One of the best tarpits in the game. Rezzed at 2d6+level that goes over starting size? Please, yes and thank you.
Skels: Point for point not as good a tarpit as Zombs but they have some other advantages: They can carry a banner. They do not bleed CR as much as Zombs which makes them ideal for character bunkers/delivery systems. They can actually fight if you get Mindrazor on them.
DW: Amazing chaff/redirector unit. Can even conga-line if you bring a champ(sorry for all the lingo, just ask if you're confused what it all means). Also really good warmachine hunter.
Ghouls: Our only fighting unit in core. This is the reason that I bring them in most of my games. I like things that can actually fight, and it's good to fill core with some combat blocks so I usually bring 40 in horde, but this is in now way mandatory since our real fighting choices is Special and Rare.

Hope this helps!
 
My last game a unit of 15 skeletons (on fire from a high magic spell at the time), with a command but no characters in it, sent Tyrion running for his life. Thanks to a bad flee roll, they even ran him down and killed him (from which he failed to resurrect). I know it was a bit of a fluke of the dice, but the event forever endeared them in my heart.
 
I love skeletons as well! I'm bringing two big blocks of them in my lists. I think I goofed up though as I've already built all 70+ models with sword and shield.
 
Nothing wrong with having them all sword and shield. I personally prefer that setup so if you ever wanted 2 units, you'd have two decent sized blocks with 5+/6+ saves that are unbreakable and can be healed back.
 
Yeah, skeletons are definitely more my cup of tea than zombies.

I use skeletons to put characters in and to hit flanks if I need some combat res from static res. Ghouls I use in 2000+ point games because, as previously noted, they're our only core that can fight on their own. Cast Vanhel's Dance on them and they're actually quite good.

I used to take multiple small units of skeletons and have my level 4 necromancer use Master of the Dead to increase them past starting size, but that has backfired on me in the past. So now I just start the game with 35-45 skeletons in a unit, 5 wide, sword and board. They definitely stick around longer than you think they will.
 
On top of that the skeletons are imo the best models of the three, zombies speak for themselves they're old sculpts with HUGE hands and ugly cloth.. Some of the ghouls are rather good but they line up horrible so gaming wise I hate using them (although I do still take them)..

I've become more and more fond of the skeletons overall!
 
Bullhax said:
On top of that the skeletons are imo the best models of the three, zombies speak for themselves they're old sculpts with HUGE hands and ugly cloth.. Some of the ghouls are rather good but they line up horrible so gaming wise I hate using them (although I do still take them)..

I've become more and more fond of the skeletons overall!
Don't you find the Skellies constantly fall over? Especially standard bearers? They need to heavier.
 
Oppenheimer said:
Bullhax said:
On top of that the skeletons are imo the best models of the three, zombies speak for themselves they're old sculpts with HUGE hands and ugly cloth.. Some of the ghouls are rather good but they line up horrible so gaming wise I hate using them (although I do still take them)..

I've become more and more fond of the skeletons overall!
Don't you find the Skellies constantly fall over? Especially standard bearers? They need to heavier.

I magnetize everything, so I never have a problem with stuff falling over. I do have issues with the sword arms of skeletons breaking however. Once they break, they're forever weakened due to the width of the arms - so no matter how much you glue them, they continue to break ad naseum.
 
One tried and true fix that I've found to keep top heavy models from falling over is to glue a coin underneath the base. Dimes should work for the skellies. Nickles for the larger ones.
 
I love my Skeleton block. 40-50, HW/Sh, FC, 5 wide with characters. They're cheap, they have parry, they can carry a banner and they can deliver heroes or bunker up my casters. They're really just cheap bodies that are hardy enough for 5 points. I'm going to make a 40+ Horde with Spears at some point because I love my Mantic models and having a bus and a horde on the table will look badass, and all for around 500.

Ghouls can fight. I usually take a unit of 20-24 5 or 6 wide on the flank. For me, they're too expensive to take a horde of. A medium unit with smart deployment can be effective at clogging a flank or adding flank combat support to other units.

When comparing the two - Like everything else it all depends on what you want your units to do and how to synergize your army, internally. The VC of this edition is awesome in that we can mix and match several different things and use them effectively, and our Core all have uses thta differentiate them. Magic will certainly make Skeletons better in combat but remember, ANY spell that makes Skeletons better in combat is even more effective on Ghouls because Ghouls are inherently better at combat than Skeletons, and they should be for double the points.
 
Count Velkoth said:
One tried and true fix that I've found to keep top heavy models from falling over is to glue a coin underneath the base. Dimes should work for the skellies. Nickles for the larger ones.

One dime for each of my infantry size models sounds like it could get expensive :|
 
LOL, yeah it could get quite expensive but I was thinking about the standard bearer. Forgot about the gajillion other models that show up with him. :vampire3:
 
Skellies look great, but tactically they don't seem to have as much going for them as zombies. Zombies are a great tar pit, and skeletons, which die nearly as fast, but cost more and res slower, aren't. You can use them as a bunker, but zombies bunker pretty much the same. You can use them as character delivery, or to take a charge before counter charging, but their offensive and defensive abilities, while slightly superior to zombies, are still so poor that you'll end up hemorrhaging combat res. Skeletons aren't bad, but imo they're not different enough from zombies, who are just far better at what they do.

Ghouls are very points inefficient, but that matters less in Core where we're typically trying to find things to spend obligatory points on rather than trying to find was to cut costs, and they can actually fight - well enough to beat chaff and light infantry anyway, and well enough to be threatening to lightly armored melee infantry as well if you get some spell support on them. None of our other core can claim that. Zombies (tar pits, bunkers), Dire Wolves (chaff), and Ghouls (light melee infantry), all have distinct contributions to make. Skeletons... not as much, due to too much overlap with zombies. Last edition, that made zombies look bad (though both were overshadowed by under-priced and over-supported ghouls). This edition, that's makes skeletons look bad.

Hopefully next time around we'll see them get to be more of their own thing. Maybe more resilient, to give up less combat res and make support charges more palatable? Maybe some sort of 'bony body' +1 armor save rule for skeletons & wights, with associated points increase, of course? I don't know. Something. But as long as skeletons and zombies are both 'dirt cheap undead infantry with terrible offensive and defensive stats', then they're going to be too similar and one or the other is just going to look worse by comparison.


In the mean time, skeletons still aren't terrible. I've had them prove useful once or twice for the ability to hold the flaming banner, if only to pass that ability on to the wraiths in the front rank. And I still use them as bunkers every once in a while, and try to pretend that their lich bone pennant and 5+ save makes up for the fact that they cost more and res slower than zombies, even if I know it doesn't really.
 
Skellies are good in my opinion as are all of our core at what they do. The advantages skellies have over zombies is they have the potential to hurt the enemy a lil and their spears can help this for a war of attrition really, but I really like their other advantage, that 5+/6++ for sword and shield means that you can actually support them in the flank without basically ordering your unit to commit suicide. Its a minor advantage but it can make a surprising difference. I've managed to hold onto a unit by just one skellie because of that parry denied them the last kill and point of combat res required to kill the unit. While the extra bodies of zombies may make up for this in a way, it can't make up for any other units that are supporting and every wound the skellies cause is potentially saving you a wound the zombies might not have given you.
 
I don't think they're bad per se, but I think they could do with a bit more identity.

I mean, their role is basically 'Not-as-cheap-or-easily-raised-as-zombies-but-a-little-more-survivable-tarpit.' And 'Not-as-good-as-ghouls-in-combat-but-cheaper-and-can-have-full-command-and-a-magic-banner.'

If they could be upgraded with bows or halberds, then it might help give them a more distinct niche.

As it stands, they're decent if you want to bunker your lord in a unit with a musician and/or magic banner. And, they're an ok (if expensive) tarpit if you're running a magic-light army.
 
If they were mid way between ghouls and zombies they might have some more identity, but they aren't. If zombies were at "1" and ghouls at "10", then skeletons would be at "3". They're not enough better than zombies to be a real melee unit, and the idea that they're enough more durable that they can be supported by flank charges just isn't true in my experience - most enemies I play against still hit them first, hit on threes, wound on 2s or 3s, and leave them with only a 6++ save, which just doesn't count for anything, and I regularly deal zero wounds in return. Skeletons, ime, die nearly as fast as zombies, making them unsuitable for offensive melee duties, even in combination with other units, while at the same time lacking the increased ressing abilities and cheaper price that make zombies excellent tar pits.

Again, it's not that they're terrible or unusable, just that the few things they do better than zombies they can't do enough better to stand out as a very meaningful alternative.

As for what would help them, I don't know. But they certainly need something. Different equipment options - bows, halberds, heavy armor, or the like? Better Ws and Bs? A special rule (again, I like +1 armor save for bony units)? Something. Something to distinguish them. Most of that would need to come with a points increase, but honestly putting them a couple points further away from the cost of zombies would also help provide some design room in which to distinguish them.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu