Skeletons, Zombies, or Ghouls?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

What is your preferred infantry core choice?

  • Predominantly Skeletons

    Votes: 62 47.3%
  • Predominantly Zombies

    Votes: 6 4.6%
  • Predominantly Ghouls

    Votes: 36 27.5%
  • Predominantly a Mix

    Votes: 27 20.6%

  • Total voters
    131
  • Poll votes is visible for users with special permission.
So would I be right in thinking then in a low points game 500 to 1000 summon from scratch could work well but in higher points games need to take a unit to build on?
 
Spartan said:
So would I be right in thinking then in a low points game 500 to 1000 summon from scratch could work well but in higher points games need to take a unit to build on?

The answer is "depends". If you need a cheap core unit to fill in core slots, or if you really are depending on having a block of zombies to tar pit a flank, then buy one (or more) as core. Unless you have an overwhelming magic advantage, raising a unit of zombies and buffing it to respectable size will always have an element of risk associated with it. Plus those are dice you could be using to do other things. But a necrarch lord with the Sceptre de Noirot (and power stones?) can probably be expected to raise (and buff) some decent sized zombie units. Properly used, this can be a very powerful strategy (keeping in mind zombies' limited capabilities).

There is no pat answer, really. I think a core block of zomboids has a role in both small and large games (in large games, possibly multiple zomboid blocks). and bring a block almost every game. If nothing else, they are a block that distracts my opponents, and can claim/dispute a board quarter. That is a favorite use of mine with "spare" dice...raise small units of zombies to march off and claim board quarters (the ones I have vacated in my advance, specifically). I usually cast those spells early, daring my opponent to dispel them and consume dice. He either chooses to let my later spells go off to prevent my board quarter claimers from being created, or he has to expend effort to prevent their creation. And then once they are created, he either concedes the VPs for those quarters, or has to expend effort in chasing down and killing the nearly worthless zombie units. Brilliant! :mrgreen:
 
The 5+ AS (4+ in HtH) for skeletons is definitely trumped by the Ghouls extra toughness. To elaborate, no matter who or what the opponent is, whether it be knights, shooting, etc, you will always mathematically lose equal to or LESS ghouls than skeletons.
Three examples:

A) 6 High Elf arrows hit a unit of Skeletons.....3 of the 6 will wound and you will save 1. Leaving 2 dead skeletons.
6 arrows hit Ghouls...2 should be wounded and killed.
So in exhibit A, equal models are lost.

B) 6 Empire hangunnders hit unit of skeltons....4 will wound and the Armour save is deducted. Four dead skeletons.
Now take a look at the same six shots on ghouls. Because of their extra toughness, only 3 will be killed. So in exhibit B, you lose less ghouls.

C) A large unit of Bretonnian Knight Errant have 12 attacks against a unit of skeletons. The knights need 3's to hit so 8 will be hit. With a toughness of only 3, the knights will only need 2's to wound. Mathematically speaking, approx 6.7 will be wounded....so basically seven wounds. Strength five attacks negate all but a 6+ AS so you should save approx. 1. So approx 5-6 dead skeletons.

Now look at the ghouls. The ghouls have a weapon skill equal to the Knights, so they need fours to hit.....meaning only 6 ghouls will be hit. The ghouls are also armed with a better toughness so the knights will need 3's to wound instead of the 2's they needed on the skeletons. This means that 4 ghouls will be wounded. Once again, you lose more skeletons than ghouls.


Point being, no matter who the foe, you will always lose equal to or less ghouls than skeletons.....so that armour save that you think will do your skeletons good....yeah, it really won't. The higher toughness and better WS of the ghouls by far trumps that. You do always have to account for the randomness of the dice, but mathematically, ghouls are better both offensively and defensively.
 
Ricw said:
Exactly, If you go to the battle reports section there is a great report on VC vs. wood elves. At 2500 points he starts with 2 lines of 40 zombies and the wood elves are decimating something like 38 models a turn just in their shooting phase. Nobody has that many powerdice. I would rather start with a unit of zombie and keep it healed then try to summon and replenish up to fighting size..

Keep in mind though, Zombies vs Wood Elves is really no good. You'll have numbers, but as you say, they can easily bring enough shooting power to blow that away in a round. The player was better off taking Ghouls or Skeletons for that occasion.

Nikkelhero said:
Point being, no matter who the foe, you will always lose equal to or less ghouls than skeletons.....so that armour save that you think will do your skeletons good....yeah, it really won't. The higher toughness and better WS of the ghouls by far trumps that. You do always have to account for the randomness of the dice, but mathematically, ghouls are better both offensively and defensively.

Fair enough, I love mathhammer.

Ghouls may be better at that, but they can't take Standard Bearers. And Skeletons can add a magical one to it, which was impossible in 6th edition. They also have a pretty varied choice on the banners - they can take 7 different ones. I think the Dead Legion banner is a good one, as it doubles US and grants +1 CR. Add in a Musician, you get the possibility to win a draw.

So there you have it. Ghouls may have better protection/offensive power, Skeletons can get +2 extra static CR. It's just about how much you want to gamble winning combats.

From that point of view, I think starting with Skeletons might be best for new players. Ghouls require a, if I may say so, un-VC like strategy.
 
how about?

ghouls and skellies in combat with WS 3 ST 3 troops, when you have the helm of commandment nearby to give your units WS7

in this case skellies outlast ghouls
 
dabber said:
The problem is with using zombies to anchor and enemy in place and then hit them with something nasty. Hitting an enemy while he has zombies to kill is a really really bad idea. You kill some and get a flank. He kills LOTS of zombies and wins combat thanks to slaughtering zombies.

+1 What he said. Zombies are really only useful in limited roles for combat....things with only a few attacks (no matter how powerful) and little to no static CR.

Another point in skellie favor...a sword which raises them back up with every wound inflicted (although I have never used it).

I use a mix myself, leaning towards ghouls for the tougher fighting. Two attacks with poison is aces.
 
kia said:
how about?

ghouls and skellies in combat with WS 3 ST 3 troops, when you have the helm of commandment nearby to give your units WS7

in this case skellies outlast ghouls


Well yeah, if you start adding magic items, spells, etc, then skeletons have the capacity to outlast ghouls. But head to head straight up units, they won't mathematically.
And even in the scenario you gave, the differential is only saving .25 skeletons.
 
Tons of Skeleton supported by a number of ghouls, I voted mix but I personally prefer skeletons cause I simply love them.
 
Master Vampire said:
Ricw said:
Exactly, If you go to the battle reports section there is a great report on VC vs. wood elves. At 2500 points he starts with 2 lines of 40 zombies and the wood elves are decimating something like 38 models a turn just in their shooting phase. Nobody has that many powerdice. I would rather start with a unit of zombie and keep it healed then try to summon and replenish up to fighting size..

Keep in mind though, Zombies vs Wood Elves is really no good. You'll have numbers, but as you say, they can easily bring enough shooting power to blow that away in a round. The player was better off taking Ghouls or Skeletons for that occasion.

Nikkelhero said:
Point being, no matter who the foe, you will always lose equal to or less ghouls than skeletons.....so that armour save that you think will do your skeletons good....yeah, it really won't. The higher toughness and better WS of the ghouls by far trumps that. You do always have to account for the randomness of the dice, but mathematically, ghouls are better both offensively and defensively.

Fair enough, I love mathhammer.

Ghouls may be better at that, but they can't take Standard Bearers. And Skeletons can add a magical one to it, which was impossible in 6th edition. They also have a pretty varied choice on the banners - they can take 7 different ones. I think the Dead Legion banner is a good one, as it doubles US and grants +1 CR. Add in a Musician, you get the possibility to win a draw.

So there you have it. Ghouls may have better protection/offensive power, Skeletons can get +2 extra static CR. It's just about how much you want to gamble winning combats.

From that point of view, I think starting with Skeletons might be best for new players. Ghouls require a, if I may say so, un-VC like strategy.


True, skeletons do have access to standards/musicians/ and magic banners, but those all cost extra points.
20 ghouls w/ champion cost 168 points.
20 skeletons w/ command and magic banner (let's just say its the dead legion banner) costs 205...leaving us with a difference of 37 points PER UNIT.


The way I play my VC army is to have large blocks of core units (ghouls) act as a super-swarm while my heavy hitting troops come in on the flanks. Those extra 37 points (which could be doubled or tripled depending on how many units of skeletons you initially fielded) could be used more important areas.... like buying your Vampire Lord that extra magic item, giving Blood Knights a magic banner, buying a unit of dire wolves, heck, even buying more ghouls!

You also have to consider that ghouls come with poison and an extra attack for FREE. So that possible +2 CR you are paying for in skeletons will probably be nullified by what you already get at base price in ghouls.

So the bottom line to consider is this:

Skeletons - Less durable, more expensive, gain of +1 CR (possibly 2 depending on magic banner)

Ghouls - more durable, cheaper, +1 attack, and poison.

IMO, ghouls are the much better choice.
Just something to think about!!! :idea:
 
I hope it's all right that I bring this up again. I'm actually beginning to have a change of heart on this topic. Time and time again, my hordes of ghouls are being annihilated by my dark elf playing friend. They're resistant to his crossbow fire but in close combat they are consistantly outclassed and due to their lowish CR, they get destroyed at an alarming rate.

Against hydras, black guard, witch elves and corsairs, the armour save and extra CR + musician of the skeletons will allow the boney critters to stand a chance (a decent one against all but the black guard, I'd say!) as long as the unit size is large enough. Atleast this is what I would like to believe. I haven't been given a chance to try them out in a game yet but to our next game I will attempt to bring two units of 25 skeletons, along with all of the usual raising goodness. Since they'll be carrying banners I want to protect that VP investment through greater numbers, heheh.

For so long I've been anguished by those pesky hydras in particular. Might this be a better solution than hoping to get lucky with the ghouls, as well as hoping that the opponent flunks his attacks back? Is this the beginning of a new reign of skellie-power? :D
 
I agree masterspark which is why I've recently changed from ghoul units to skeleton units. If you look at ghouls vs skeletons straight up the ghouls win but when you take standards and the items we have available to us i think Skellies leapfrog ahead.
 
As I've said before in other threads - I'm a skellie man for the majority of my core. I prefer them fluff wise, plus I use my core to act as my main tarpits / holding units. I feel they do this better with their standard and possible magic banner,

In regards to ghouls, I use them in the context of detachments. They stick close to their parent skellie unit and hopefully charge into the flanks of attacking units providing extra kills to help with the skellies CR
 
I prefer ghouls simply because:
1) I like the figures
2) I'm a predominantly W40k player, so I'm use to wounds only counting for CR :rolleyes:. Need to get use to the contrary...

Cheers, Warlock593
 
I tend to favour skeletons, although that is also affected by having a load from when they raisable in new units from last edition!

I think It also depends on your meta-game in your area. My most common foes are Elves (of all types), Brets, and Dwarfs, so the Ghoul extra WS makes almost no difference most of the time. Additionally, alot of them are often hitting with strength 3, and this is when toughness 3 and +4 save is statistically better than just toughness 4. Combined with the extra CR from banner, Mus and possible magic banner, they just seem more reliable. Agreed, it does cost a bit more, but we only need to win by one to auto-break (barring double 1's), so I'd rather spend a few more points to try to cause that to happen with more certainty.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu