Ricw said:
Exactly, If you go to the battle reports section there is a great report on VC vs. wood elves. At 2500 points he starts with 2 lines of 40 zombies and the wood elves are decimating something like 38 models a turn just in their shooting phase. Nobody has that many powerdice. I would rather start with a unit of zombie and keep it healed then try to summon and replenish up to fighting size..
Keep in mind though, Zombies vs Wood Elves is really no good. You'll have numbers, but as you say, they can easily bring enough shooting power to blow that away in a round. The player was better off taking Ghouls or Skeletons for that occasion.
Nikkelhero said:
Point being, no matter who the foe, you will always lose equal to or less ghouls than skeletons.....so that armour save that you think will do your skeletons good....yeah, it really won't. The higher toughness and better WS of the ghouls by far trumps that. You do always have to account for the randomness of the dice, but mathematically, ghouls are better both offensively and defensively.
Fair enough, I love mathhammer.
Ghouls may be better at that, but they can't take Standard Bearers. And Skeletons can add a magical one to it, which was impossible in 6th edition. They also have a pretty varied choice on the banners - they can take 7 different ones. I think the Dead Legion banner is a good one, as it doubles US and grants +1 CR. Add in a Musician, you get the possibility to win a draw.
So there you have it. Ghouls may have better protection/offensive power, Skeletons can get +2 extra static CR. It's just about how much you want to gamble winning combats.
From that point of view, I think starting with Skeletons might be best for new players. Ghouls require a, if I may say so, un-
VC like strategy.