Teach an Old Dog New Tricks

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Bravo_10

Dark Lord of Eternal Sorrow
True Blood
Jul 26, 2010
1,285
Atlanta, Georgia, USA
Zombies
1,851
Hi everybody.

My name's Bravo, and I haven't posted in this forum for nigh on three years. Many of you have never met me before, but I used to be a moderator of this here forum (in fact, Johnny Crass is the only To War! mod who joined while I was still active!). I was a tactics mod, so I know my way around the tabletop, but the metagame has changed drastically since I last played. I've given myself a crash course by reading the VC guide here, which is very nice by the way, and it's kind of cool to see that some of the popular choices during my time are still considered powerful (like the Red Fury + Quickblood + Ogre Blade meat grinder build on a Vamp Lord, which I'll totally take credit for inventing xD). But there are somethings which have changed a lot.

Back when I played WHFB, infantry spam was the name of the game. Black Knights were cool because of how easily they could be res'd, Hexwraiths were seen as effective but expensive elite killers, and bat swarms were seeing some niche use as charge supporters because of how they could confer ASL. That said, every non-infantry unit's purpose was primarily to either support an infantry charge or to prevent the other guy's non-infantry from interfering with your infantry fight. The primary threats in the metagame for VC were Empire gunlines, Swordmaster-heavy HE lists, and those evil Unbreakable Lizardmen Temple Guard.

But from how the guide mentioned that "Black Knights are the backbone of any mounted Lord list," it seems like mounted lists might be much more viable now? And Crypt Ghasts are among the best tanks in the game? And SPIRIT HOSTS ARE SUPER VIABLE NOW?? Amazing.

So essentially what I'm looking for is a rundown on what the biggest threats for VC lists are today. Are certain armies particularly difficult for us? And how do VC lists usually play these days (like what are the main goals we'll seek to accomplish to win games)? Any general metagame tips will be appreciated too.

/edit: I'll probably post an old army list later too, just to see how it stacks up against current ones.

-Bravo
 
Hello there

-Spirit hosts are indeed good at holding up chariots and monsters that have no magical attacks among other things (hello, steamtank) but I prefer taking a wraith hero instead. He fits inside a unit til you need to charge him out so he's protected by magic missiles til you need him to do his thing. He also actually kill enemies unlike the spirit host.

-I think you meant crypt horrors, not crypt ghasts? Horrors are indeed a viable choice and I never leave home without my block of 8 with champion. Fielded 4x2 and with 3 casters using IoN to back them up, I don't fear much when having them engage something.

-Black Knight buses are one of the more powerful builds. Fielding knights on their own, you can't expect much out of them as they need character support to reliably generate CR. Banner of Swiftness on a unit of 10-12 with a VL tooled for combat is a popular setup. Some players throw in a WK BSB with Nightshroud as well and place him next to the VL (who is on the corner of the unit).

On threats;

-Wood Elves. In my opinion, our number 1 or 2 toughest matchup. They have magical arrows on their scouts and glade guard (glade riders, too) and can play avoidance all day long. Waywatchers ignore armor with their arrows so knights are in trouble if 10 of those boys are flitting about. You will usually see a unit of scouts with Starfire arrows, giving them flaming shots and making our crypt horrors very sad.

For combat units, 2 groups of 7 or so wild riders are what is normally fielded. They hit like a ton of bricks but are frenzied so use that to your advantage. All the forest spirits lost a point of strength since you were last around in addition to their ward saves going from 5+ that doesn't work against magical sources to a solid 6+. Only the treeman is a real threat. I've personally used a cube of 4 treekin off and on and enjoyed them but they are considered to be quite the inferior unit now.

To combat woodies, use vargheists since glade guard bows lost the strength 4 buff at close range in exchange for armor piercing. Many wood elf archers will have poison shots however so you need to make the most out of terrain and your other support units. A black coach is a surprisingly effective choice against them due to having high toughness and high armor (and a sodding ward save!). The new morghasts are also worth a look with their T5 and armor.

-Dark Elves. My nemesis. A top DE general will bring the mother of all avoidance lists complete with 3-4 RBT's and about 3 pegasus characters. Dark riders, shades and the new doomfire warlocks are the staples of such an army. The warlocks are a rare fast cav choice with a 4+ ward that is negated by anything Slaaneshi (hehe). They have two swings at strength 4 and act as a level 2 caster with Doombolt and that lore of death spell I always use but forget the name of (I always forget the name, just like the MR 3 item...).

DE will take you apart with shooting, use the double flee tactic with their riders and get points from using Lore of Death on vulnerable characters. They were the number 2 army in the U.K. last year and I don't doubt it.

To combat DE, use offensive spells on things like riders, darkshards (crossbowmen) and shades. Get those little guys out of the way. Consider a refused flank strategy so they can't hit you from both sides.
If you are facing executioners, then you have some nice almost-free points coming your way. CoY/Wind of Death/Gaze them. They are quite fragile with just T3 and a 5+ armor save.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bravo_10
D'oh. Yes, I meant Crypt Horrors. Shows how rusty my terminology is. And I'm really surprised to see Black Knights doing so well, I guess it relates back to how easy they are to raise considering their power level. I might stick with Grave Guard blocks in my list, but BK's are always super-cool.

And I didn't realize that Wood Elves finally got a book! They were on their 6th edition book for like 7 years. Sounds like they could be nightmarish though, ignoring armor saves is just insane against almost all of our heavies, and flaming attacks would take care of ones without armor! Plus VC have never been particularly fleet of foot, so running away and shooting being an effective tactic worries me.

I'm also surprised at these new choices. I've not seen Morghasts, but T5 and armor already sounds like music to my ears. I'll have to see if I can get updated on all of the options everybody (including us) has gained since I left.
 
Yeah, sorry. I meant to add more armies but I'm busy til the end of the night. I'll throw in some stuff when I get a chance.

Yeah woodies got a new book and despite ring considered weakest of the three elf races, they are a very nasty matchup for some armies.

I stopped using GG awhile ago because stomps and thunder stomps are bloody annoying and Crypt Horrors have regen and are much cheaper.

The rules for Morghasts actually come in the box so you don't have to buy Endtimes Nagash if you don't want to.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bravo_10
What you basically need to understand the new meta is monster cav, demon princes, chimeras, and frost phoenixes. Basically, a bunch of meta-defining big gribblies that are nigh impossible for infantry to wound, and with attacks and stomps grind infantry at a staggering pace. They're also too fast for infantry to reliably pick their fights, which leads to very bad matchups for infantry-heavy armies.

On the flip side is elven fast cav. Dark riders, warlocks, sisters of the thorn, wild riders, as well as DE peg masters. They're extremely fast, relatively hitty, and can (again) will never fight a unit of infantry unless they KNOW they can win. Against an army like this your infantry bricks are next to useless, as they'll never fight combat save on the enemy's terms.

That's why the name of the game has shifted away from infantry and towards options that are either a) maneuverable enough to pick combats and dictate the movement phase, or b) sturdy enough to take a charge from nearly anything and give up no points.

For us that's vargheists, black knights, and crypt horrors.

Terrorgheists still have a place, but with all the poisoned shooting out there they've fallen way down in terms of effectiveness. Mortis engines are out as they rely on an infantry-based list, and are much too vulnerable to things like the Cloak of Twilight peg master.

The new name of the game with VC is to control the movement phase with our incredible chaff (wolves, hosts, fellbats, and free zombies), then rush in for the kill with a double-blender BK bus. TG scream at things locked up with skeletons (better than zombies, because champions can hold up solo chars). Vargs shred their back field. Crypt Horrors slam into anything unarmoured and grind/poison it to death.
 
That was an amazing post, man. I wish I could like it twice!

It's kind of sad to know that big monsters are starting to rule the metagame, people always used to joke about how "Monsterhammer" was the name of the game with all of GW's big monster releases, and I guess it's sorta become reality. Those fast cav lists though, I think that's actually kinda cool. That's the sort of thing that was completely invalidated by how reliable and sturdy infantry blocks had become upon 8th edition's release, and many non-infantry choices would be completely bogged down with steadfast units. Looks like the tide has finally turned on the Skavenslave spammers!
 
That was an amazing post, man. I wish I could like it twice!

It's kind of sad to know that big monsters are starting to rule the metagame, people always used to joke about how "Monsterhammer" was the name of the game with all of GW's big monster releases, and I guess it's sorta become reality. Those fast cav lists though, I think that's actually kinda cool. That's the sort of thing that was completely invalidated by how reliable and sturdy infantry blocks had become upon 8th edition's release, and many non-infantry choices would be completely bogged down with steadfast units. Looks like the tide has finally turned on the Skavenslave spammers!

Thanks :)

Yeah, complete about-face. If you can't deal with ridiculously mobile lists cav lists then you're sunk. Very different game than from even when I picked this game back up in 2013.

Note though that it's not ANY monsters in ascendence...just flying ones with ward/regen saves. Frost phoenixes, chimeras, demon princes, etc. Highly mobile ones with ward/regen saves are strong too (Kdaiis, HPAs, etc). Also note that it's less that these lists are dominating, as it is that they're OUT THERE and if you face them with an infantry list you auto-lose.

Same with fast-cav builds. Face fast cav avoidance with an infantry-based list and you again basically autolose. There's just nothing much that you can do to stop them. They'll run circles around you, pick off easy points, and you'll end the game with zero victory points scored unless they screwed up big time.

The exception are infantry-based lists that can pick up points at range, and even then it depends on the comp pack. Foot WE gunline. Dwarfs. Light Council empire. Chaos Dwarfs. Skaven.

...but even then, it's not the infantry that are doing the work, it's the shooting. The infantry are just there for area and points denial. Slog across the board towards a Dwarf gunline and you arrive to find giant T4 stubborn dwarf bricks that you get zero points out of until you kill them to a man.
 
@Bravo_10 Welcome back you old buffoon! Awesome to see how some of the old guys resurrect once in a while. Also glad that you enjoyed me and @najo's guide :)

To bring you up to speed I'll add that much has changed recently with the advent of End Times. In my humble opinion we are now one of the best and fastest hammer armies in the game. With a combination of Morghasts, Terrorgheists, Vargheists and other fast choices (like fielding double blenders in Skeleton Horsemen with Light armour) we can outrun and outfight most armies.

So what do we fear? Nothing, we're unbreakable dude...

Seriously though it really depends on what army you want to bring. Grave Guards are no longer considered competetive, but they can work if you have love for them. A footslogging army is still really viable but you should watch out for fast shooty armies like the elves.
 
  • Like
Reactions: najo and Bravo_10
Hahah it's kind of weird to be one of the old guys, 22 feels a bit young for that. :redface: But thank you! And I've seen this End Times thing on GW's website, looks like there are several books that I might have to check out if I really want to have a good grasp on it (which is unfortunate because ugh... those prices). The new models look sweet anyway, so at least there's that. Morghasts are looking like the stuff of my nightmares. Literally. Have you seen those things?

And it would be nice if WFO were still a thing. I still don't have any idea of who I could get a game with, but I do know one guy back in my hometown who's probably pleased as all heck with his Wood Elves. Mobile, shooting builds were always kinda his schtick.
 
Nobody remembers little old Lynks even though he's an admin these days :(. Cursed Johnny Coming and stealing my thunder!

I'll say the same thing I've always said, unless you are playing in a Win at all costs environment, basically every choice is still viable- this is coming from someone who routinely runs an army consisting of as many corpse carts, black coaches and coven thrones that i can bundle into a list.

And there's still plenty of infantry lists going about too- with dwarves and VC probably in the best of positions to pull it off, dwarves for their stubborn, us for our unbreakable and easy ressing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: najo
Lynks! It's been forever, man. Also I'm surprised to learn that I actually joined the forum before you. :innocent: Cool on you for becoming admin though, that's awesome! You know, I was a huge proponent of corpse carts when Balefire became a thing, having dual carts to subtract 2 from most of your opponent's casting rolls screwed with their power dice economy and made it more likely for them to mismanage.

And I don't think I've ever played a WAAC list, but then again I never was able to find a tournament in my area to enter. My main playing partner was a Skaven player anyway, so if I play the dude again, you can bet he'll be packing lots of infantry for me to throw my hordes against. And an HPA. Which I still hate, after all these years. Stupid coming-back-to-life rule...
 
Most people shied away from the corpse carts when the 8th edition book rolled out because balefires don't stack anymore and they are incredibly slow, but I just find it so fun pulling off a triple charge with three corpse carts and flailing wildly against a unit in the hopes it dies (and often does).

HPA isn't that scary a threat anymore, we've got reasonable access to flaming attacks and it's pretty easy to down, just don't send anything you care about after it.
 
Hmm Balefire doesn't stack anymore? I played well into 8th edition, but I don't remember that at all. Hahah proooooobably because three years ago is a long time.

My best double-cart experience was one time when I'd spaced them perfectly across my line and gave my whole army ASF from a single casting of VHD. Close combat was fun that turn. :vampire3:
 
Hahah it's kind of weird to be one of the old guys, 22 feels a bit young for that. :redface: But thank you! And I've seen this End Times thing on GW's website, looks like there are several books that I might have to check out if I really want to have a good grasp on it (which is unfortunate because ugh... those prices). The new models look sweet anyway, so at least there's that. Morghasts are looking like the stuff of my nightmares. Literally. Have you seen those things?

And it would be nice if WFO were still a thing. I still don't have any idea of who I could get a game with, but I do know one guy back in my hometown who's probably pleased as all heck with his Wood Elves. Mobile, shooting builds were always kinda his schtick.
You can get by with just picking up End Times Nagash. Morghasts are awesome by the way, very reliable units. Infantry is very viable in 8th edition between step up, supporting attacks and steadfast, 8th made infantry very effective at controlling the battlefield. The trick is fielding them in the right sizes and formations.
 
Well hiya najo, looks like it's a To War! mod party up in here! And I'm glad you think infantry still can work well, I guess I won't know if my own army is still viable until I test it out in battle. From what I've heard, I feel like I lack a lot of the mobility that will be required to deal with speedy lists, but I might be able to squeeze by if I roll the right battle scenario.

Also this goes for both you and Sun King, amazing work on that guide. Cool to see that two guys who joined up after I'd left took up the torch so successfully.
 
  • Like
Reactions: najo
Well hiya najo, looks like it's a To War! mod party up in here! And I'm glad you think infantry still can work well, I guess I won't know if my own army is still viable until I test it out in battle. From what I've heard, I feel like I lack a lot of the mobility that will be required to deal with speedy lists, but I might be able to squeeze by if I roll the right battle scenario.

Also this goes for both you and Sun King, amazing work on that guide. Cool to see that two guys who joined up after I'd left took up the torch so successfully.
Thanks Bravo, that book was quite the labor of love and Sunny and I loved making it. As for VC infantry armies, they are very viable. I personally play footslogging WAAC armies and I have a solid win/loss ratio of about 70% in competitive metas. If you want pointers just ask. Also, throw a list together and post it and we can give some criteques.

Any rate, welcome back!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bravo_10
Hahah actually, I already posted a list. I didn't give much thought to a new one, I just posted the last one I played with to see if it would stack up. But now that you mention it, developing one from scratch might be a better idea. But only after I've taken a look at these new choices I have to play with (like I have no idea what Morgheists really do, gonna have to figure that stuff out).
 
I'll say the same thing I've always said, unless you are playing in a Win at all costs environment, basically every choice is still viable- this is coming from someone who routinely runs an army consisting of as many corpse carts, black coaches and coven thrones that i can bundle into a list

WAAC is a silly label unless you're talking about people who microwave their dice. What are these "costs" you speak of? If it's just competitive lists you have an issue with, then what is and isn't a competitive list is a matter of extreme subjective variability from player to player.

What is or is not a viable choice in any army depends on your own individual meta. That is, the sorts of things your friends or regular opponents bring. If your friends all play soft, infantry-heavy hobbyist lists then all sorts of things that aren't viable in the present tournament meta become solid choices.

Issue is...talking about those sorts of lists don't make for very good collective discussion. EVERYONE can get behind talk of the general 8th edition metagame, in a competitive environment where you need an all-comers list tuned to take down the sorts of armies you could expect to see at a GT. Beyond getting offered-up a tip or two, you're going to have trouble getting people fired up about discussing the very specific meta of you and your handful of gamer buddies.

And quite frankly, in that environment there's a much more limited number of competitive choices available without comp specifically incentivizing some over others. Black Coaches don't have the teeth to earn points, and are overcosted by about 90 points. Blood knights will die before they see combat. Cairn Wraith units are too slow, too expensive, and too fragile. Varghulfs are worse vargheists, and are at least 30 points overcosted. Coven Thrones cost as much as a grave guard brick or a blender lord, and have no staying power. Grave guard are too expensive, too slow, and too fragile.

That leaves black knights, vargheists, hex wraiths, terrorgheists, crypt horrors, and characters. In addition to core and chaff. I would even argue that with WE so prevalent in the meta, and with magic missiles all the rage, hex wraiths aren't particularly competitive right now either.Unless you have comp making things like Varghulfs look more attractive.

Thanks Bravo, that book was quite the labor of love and Sunny and I loved making it. As for VC infantry armies, they are very viable. I personally play footslogging WAAC armies and I have a solid win/loss ratio of about 70% in competitive metas. If you want pointers just ask. Also, throw a list together and post it and we can give some criteques.

Any rate, welcome back!

Depends on what your expectations are. Nobody is saying that footsloggers can't win games. However there are games that are nigh unwinnable for a footslogger list that a cav list can deal with, whilst there are essentially no matchups that's true for the other way around. I've played both and the cav build is just...better.
 
I don't necessarily see footslogger lists as unplayable, the approach with them has definitely changed though. Footslogger lists hold your points amazingly well, but you need multiple means to score avoidance and help mitigate the speed and maneuverability in a lot of the meta game.

I'm not sure if it was clear, but black knights aren't actually good, they are just good as a character delivery system. Since you are experienced i'm presuming you already knew that, but I wanted to make sure (a local player in my area heard black knights were popular, bought ten, and got frustrated when they didn't perform as elite cav).

Elves are a big threat, which is one reason I want to start giving mortis engines a real try. I am new to Vc, but I played Dark Elves for the last year and a half, and that pulse is pretty scary from an avoidance perspective.

For warriors, I think ranked infantry can be a great counter if you can stop the combo charges and use your support units well. A demon prince can be stuck in challenge limbo very easy by challenging with a skeleton, the Demon Prince has to accept, he kills it, you raise it back, rinse repeat.

I would strongly recommend checking out the 4 (ish) most recent episodes of Heelanhammer, they talk about beating warriors (in 2 parts over the course of two episodes) and do the same for Dark Elves. These two armies are the top of the competitive scene and the hosts of that show do a great job explaining why and how to counter it.

I wouldn't say we are in monster hammer, minus Frost Phoenix, Chimeras, and our own Terrorghiest there arn't many monsters (unless you count greater demons and demon princes). Most monsters are still consider a pretty soft choice since they are easy to target and a ton of points.

Welcome back to the game.
 
There was a time, far beyond the realm of human memory, when I bought a group of Brettonian knights and combined them with Grave Guard to make my first conversion: beautiful Brettonian Black Knights. I was enamored with how cool they looked, and I decided to include them in every army list I would make forever more.

...and after five battles of them hitting with roughly 30% of their lance attacks, I decided that they were absolute garbage and would never see combat again without support from a Wight King or Vampire Lord. :thumbsdown:

Lol so yeah, I figured. It's not like they magically gained good weapon skill since I left, but a big block of them is cheap for how solid they are, and characters will be protected well enough from shooting as they move in. Nice stuff!

Funnily enough, WoC were one of the best armies before their book was updated too. And forcing challenges with champions has always put in massive amounts of work for VC because our champions come back. My only worry of course would be outmaneuvering big flying monsters like DP's with my slow undead infantry, but tar pitting has always been a key strategy of mine.
 
Depends on what your expectations are. Nobody is saying that footsloggers can't win games. However there are games that are nigh unwinnable for a footslogger list that a cav list can deal with, whilst there are essentially no matchups that's true for the other way around. I've played both and the cav build is just...better.
Cavalry armies can't do attrition like infantry and monstrous infantry can. Also, like Grok said, black knights really only do character delivery. This doesn't mean they are bad, but they have their own strengths and weakness to infantry. I play both as well, and I find that infantry synergizes best with Vampire Lore and character hopping/ position tricks. You can get a much more powerful punch and movement tricks out of massive core units with vampire and ethereal characters than you can a black knight bus with vampire characters. Focused ranged attacks (especially ones that ignore armor) onto a unit of black knights vs a unit of 40+ ghouls or skeletons is going to destroy the unit before you can heal it too.

To clarify, I'm not saying use no cavalry. I merely referring to the primary build of the army and how it delivers its vampires. I tend to use things like crypt horrors, hexwraiths, morghasts and varghiests in my infantry armies.
 
Welcome back, Bravo. We 22 yo's can start to learn the game together now. So far this thread as been amazing. There's so much good stuff in here. Keep it up, guys! I'm learning so much from just the headsup on what's good in the meta nowadays.

Also, I gotta say I like the monsterhammer possibilities. It enables you to play big games without painting 300+ zombies and skeletons. When I started playing 8th edition a couple of years ago, I found out both my armies were completely useless because I didn't play huge blocks and hordes of infantry. I really didn't enjoy the fact that I had to get 3 boxes extra of each unit before they got effective. Now with our monsters (also the HE monsters, which I played before) we can get away with a combo of big blocks and big monsters. Love that!

Regards,

Nef
 
Last edited:
@Pirate Robot Ninja of Death I agree with your assesment that discussing individual metas is obsolete. However I disagree strongly that footslogging lists aren't competitive. Take a look at the national team players lists... most of the VC players rock infantry lists. Last weekend I went to a tournament with an infantry list I was placed the upper third and another VC infantry list got third place.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Grok and najo
@Pirate Robot Ninja of Death I agree with your assesment that discussing individual metas is obsolete. However I disagree strongly that footslogging lists aren't competitive. Take a look at the national team players lists... most of the VC players rock infantry lists. Last weekend I went to a tournament with an infantry list I was placed the upper third and another VC infantry list got third place.

What was the comp pack like? Did it favour infantry armies?

Again, I'm not saying infantry armies can't win games. They can. They just have some extremely bad matchups, a problem that cav lists don't have as much an issue with.

EDIT: there's one footslogger VC list at the US Masters. 8.5 comp under Swedish, if I'm not mistaken. It will be interesting to see how he does, but based on the field he's facing I'm going to guess that he'll struggle.
 
It's so interesting to me to hear these discussions because back in my time, this would have been a no-brainer. There were a few counters to infantry-heavy armies, but most of them had to do with more infantry (the WoC for example used to favor massive amounts of flail-armed Khorne Marauders who were cheap and could essentially blanket the entire board). The real key and what we thought was the downfall of Cavalry lists was the Steadfast rule. Large blocks of Steadfast infantry could take a cavalry charge to the face and easily hold despite massive casualties. Then with the impetus of the charge gone, a counter-hammer could be brought around to deal with the big baddies, or you could just leave them alone for as long as it took them to chew through your rank bonus.

And to an extent, I think that a massed infantry list would still effectively counter a cavalry hammer list (though it's a little invalidated if there's a Red Fury VLord going off in everybody's face), but the existence of all these super-mobile builds has totally changed the game. An infantry list might counter a cavalry build, but it would be bit of a risk to take to a tournament because you might run into a list that counters you right back.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu