Pirate Robot Ninja of Death
Vampire Thrall
It's so interesting to me to hear these discussions because back in my time, this would have been a no-brainer. There were a few counters to infantry-heavy armies, but most of them had to do with more infantry (the WoC for example used to favor massive amounts of flail-armed Khorne Marauders who were cheap and could essentially blanket the entire board). The real key and what we thought was the downfall of Cavalry lists was the Steadfast rule. Large blocks of Steadfast infantry could take a cavalry charge to the face and easily hold despite massive casualties. Then with the impetus of the charge gone, a counter-hammer could be brought around to deal with the big baddies, or you could just leave them alone for as long as it took them to chew through your rank bonus.
And to an extent, I think that a massed infantry list would still effectively counter a cavalry hammer list (though it's a little invalidated if there's a Red Fury VLord going off in everybody's face), but the existence of all these super-mobile builds has totally changed the game. An infantry list might counter a cavalry build, but it would be bit of a risk to take to a tournament because you might run into a list that counters you right back.
I guess it's a bit of a misnomer to talk about "cavalry builds." Really, they're more like "bus builds." That is, a bus of hearty cavalry protecting a whack of super killy characters. Some examples are:
Lizardmen cold one riders filled with old blood and scarvet cowboys.
VC black knight buses filled with blender lords and baby blenders
DE brolock buses, comprised of a unit of warlocks with MR(2) and a bunch of cheap masters/dreadlords.
HE silverhelm buses, with a BSB with BotWD, a prince with Ogre Blade, and a mage with the book of hoeth and sword of antiheroes.
WE sisters bus, also with MR(2) and movement banner and two level 4 mages and a BSB with GW, all of which is basically uncatchable.
These lists aren't countered by infantry lists. In fact, if played right, THEY are the hard-counter in that matchup. Your S3/4 infantry will struggle to scratch their defenses, and backed up by things like eagles, dark riders, direwolves+free zombies, skink skirmishers, etc they will keep your elite infantry bricks from seeing combat all game.
The list I'm taking to a tournament next weekend (2500 point uncomped filth fest) is a double-blender BK bus. I give so little fucks about breaking steadfast that I run my black knights 3-wide. Two vampire lords will grind out an infantry block in two rounds of combat flat, protecting me from shooting during their turn and freeing me up for a charge in time for mine. It's fast cav lists that concern me, as they have the mobility to dance around my dance and my redirectors. Also 1+ armour spam lists, as outside of my bus I really don't have many answers for armour (my terrorgheist won't be finished in time, sadly).