Terrorghiest shriek in close combat

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Yorga said:
TobiasRathein said:
Right, and people used that argument against screaming into combats. It was proven to be wrong.

As has been said before, the only targeting restrictions for Deathly Shriek are plain as day in the book. Within 8" and LoS. Remember that the Deathly Shriek is a magical attack and, for all intents and purposes, essentially ignores other targeting restrictions not outlined in its own rules.

Tobias:

If the Terrorghiest IS in close combat and you need LOS to target a unit, just HOW do you target a unit out of combat considering the Terrorghiest practically has it's head on the ground? Where is your LOS that allows you to target any other unit than the one it is fighting?

hmm... flank chargeed and rear charged atleast come in mind... not trying to be witty or anything but.... atleast then you could use it...
 
I suppose that is possible. But I would deal with the most immediate threat. I guess maybe you can't draw LOS to your flank or rear but the rules say you may so.....
 
And what if you thought what charged was not a threat or you had reinforcements for melee charge into the fight or you were banking on the giant beast killing the threat without the scream.

moot point/I think not?

Why waste a scream on re-directors and trash if a hi profile heavily armored cav unit is near by worth a lot of points per model.

As fore the line of sight issue the model now draws line of sight from the ACTUAL model not the base. Well since the thing is the size of a large barn i think it draws line of sight over infantry just fine.
 
Then I would measure what's in range and wiegh the options. I am not incompetent. And if it's the case that it's line of sight based model not base, heh, just model the guy on his back legs towering over giants. lol. And you're assuming that it's always going to be chaff smacking into your TG?
 
Well lol my point wasn't to suggest to model to advantage that is cheating. And I always use the dimensions of the current released model for determining things like line of sight and base size.

And never did I suggest anyone was incompetent. I was just showing that there is a reason why the FAQ is less than complete with handling this issue.

However, screaming from combat to an unengaged unit is a viable tactic in a pinch and think more clarification is in order for this topic.
 
I know, I was joking on the model for advantage point. (I've seen people do that quite a bit at one club lately so I don't go there). But Yorga is right, the TG's head is almost on the base making it hard for it to look over things. Is he allowed to scream in all directions or just in the arc of his head?

I wasn't meaning that you were trolling or anything innane like that. I only meant that as anyone would, it's subjective to the game in progress what I would do. In reality, I would prefer to never get my TG into combat and have him happily skip around singing to everyone. :perv:
 
Yes sing indeed :innocent:

I know its never intended to get the beast into combat but sometimes someone makes a hail Mary pass and catches the ball. In which case I am sure this scenario will come up.
 
Count Matthewzilla said:
Oh, yeah. I've caught my wife's Dwarf Lord Torpedo hail mary enough times to know that. lol.

Your wife sounds like a particularly devious wench. ;) Keep an eye on that one...:|

Oh and what is the 'Dwarf Lord Torpedo'?
 
Lol. It's just a really tooled up Dwarf Lord charging out of a unit. She does that when she can catch something off guard.

And she is a devious wench. But I like playing with her even if she brings cannons or that dang anvil.
 
Another version has a min unit of hammerers standing behind thim to give him stubborn. He is unkillable and stubborn and can hold any unit all game. Dwarfish filth:lol:
 
Johnny-Crass said:
Another version has a min unit of hammerers standing behind thim to give him stubborn. He is unkillable and stubborn and can hold any unit all game. Dwarfish filth:lol:

Conga line Dwarfs? :O
 
Yorga said:
From the model's mouth which almost lines on the base.

Why would you measure from the TG's mouth? Death shriek is not a breath weapon. You measure from the base.

And in one instance I was watching a game and a TG had 2 units of HE's in front of it, one behind the other, and the VC player wanted to scream at the unit behind. Now with TLoS and were our TG's head is at he didn't have TLoS to the unit behind. So technically he could not target them. Now for me that is just being a true git...:slapface:. When people use a dynamically posed model and others then put restrictions on it cause the way it was modeled. Time to find someone else to play.....:thumbsup:

And as for modeling for advantage. The last Colonial GT I was at there was a VC player who had a TG mounted on a GW abandoned building so it looked like it crashed into the top of it. It looked freaking awesome. And I don't thing I heard anybody say he was modeling for advantage. Sure he could see most anything up that high. But as AEDIN stated....The thing is the size of a large barn....:perv:
 
Ok apparently this requires some clarification.

Line of sight is determined by looking from the actual current developed and unmodified models eyes not its mouth BRB p.10

The only reason to measure from the base is to determine distance and ARC of sight. BRB p.39

You must be able to trace an unblocked line of sight from the EYES of the model to any part of the BODY of the model you intend to target.
Note: weapons, banners, wings, tails, ect cannot determine line of sight. It must be the body.

So when I measure Line of Sight I always use the point of reference from the current designed model for the game. If you dont then your modeling to advantage and cheating.

Of course someone will now mention what about older models like the 4th edition zombie dragon. Ya "technically" if you use a model like this you use its eyes and its base but is well not within the "fair spirit" of the game and you wont catch me doing it. That's why I say "actual current developed and unmodified models eyes". (I have modified models I just use the original dimensions)

Now what about the question at hand.

The monster could be monopolizing the top of a hill so~ now that the scenario is valid (and you parked your barn on a hill) what about screaming from out of combat into an uninvolved unit within line and arc of sight within "8".
 
Aedin said:
Ok apparently this requires some clarification.

Line of sight is determined by looking from the actual current developed and unmodified models eyes not its mouth BRB p.10

The only reason to measure from the base is to determine distance and ARC of sight. BRB p.39

You must be able to trace an unblocked line of sight from the EYES of the model to any part of the BODY of the model you intend to target.
Note: weapons, banners, wings, tails, ect cannot determine line of sight. It must be the body.

So when I measure Line of Sight I always use the point of reference from the current designed model for the game. If you dont then your modeling to advantage and cheating.

Of course someone will now mention what about older models like the 4th edition zombie dragon. Ya "technically" if you use a model like this you use its eyes and its base but is well not within the "fair spirit" of the game and you wont catch me doing it. That's why I say "actual current developed and unmodified models eyes". (I have modified models I just use the original dimensions)

Now what about the question at hand.

The monster could be monopolizing the top of a hill so~ now that the scenario is valid (and you parked your barn on a hill) what about screaming from out of combat into an uninvolved unit within line and arc of sight within "8".

As the rules permit, I would say if it's in your best tactical interest, then scream away.

You are correct, the BRB is very well specified on modeling for advantage. Not that conversions don't look amazing when they are done well; you have to take into account that you are changing the model and some will say that's unplayable or you have to be restricted to use it. It's like trying to call in a warrenty on an electronic that has a sticker that says void if opened and you have opened it to mess with the inside. Rules as written your warrenty is gone. It's the same here. Modifying a model, while subjective to how its modified will have to be discussed with your oppenent.
 
What do you mean "technically" the Terrorgheist does not have eyes?
I see eyes and in the VC army book it's painted with eyes.
 
This is why playing with unit "sizes" win the TLoS

ie. bigger can see over smaller and smaller one's cant see behind the greater models.


swarm 0

infantry 1

cavalry/monstrous 2

Monsters 3

Do you have to put the terrorgheist on the stones that are submitted with th model?. if not thn lowering his arse nd rasising the head is viable as the opponent cant claim bonuses of the torso?
 
TLOS is such a better system than Unit Strength and unit strength you say little screens of units blocking bigger units from being shot. Was stupid
 
What part of technically is difficult for you to understand? The sarcasm or the literal definition?

I'll elaborate: we are discussing LOS, which uses the eyes of the model. The Terrorgheist has no eyes. It has a snout, replete with nostrils and what look to be sinus cavities, but no sockets and no eyes because it is a giant undead bat that uses sound and smell to see. Or it did, when it was alive.

Perhaps the humor of my comment was lost on you then, but by my estimation that means it can never scream at all since it can't see and thus has no Line of Sight.

Foolishness aside, using normal los rules makes perfect sense, and a range of 8" doesn't give a lot of leeway. Mount that sucker on a tomb from the Gardens of More set to get a better vantage of all those juicy targets!
 
@Vortaine Just your whole idea with Terrorghiests without eyesockets. I have here in my hands the terrorgheist head. I give you there are no eyes, but I have to insist that there are eye sockets where you would find eyes on a normal bat. This also makes sense since real life Bats do actually have eyes. Don't be too hard on me for discussing a bit of anatomy here. It is after all a field closely related to necromancy and such.

And yeah, I suppose it's kind of funny that many undead models don't actually have eyes but only eye sockets. I guess it would make it hard to charge with a unit of skeletons too if the LOS rules were taken that literally.

Anyway. I love the LOS rules in 8th edition too, and with only 8" range of the terrorghiest, it's not often it even has change to scream over another unit.
 
Vortaine said:
What part of technically is difficult for you to understand? The sarcasm or the literal definition?

I'll elaborate: we are discussing LOS, which uses the eyes of the model. The Terrorgheist has no eyes. It has a snout, replete with nostrils and what look to be sinus cavities, but no sockets and no eyes because it is a giant undead bat that uses sound and smell to see. Or it did, when it was alive.

Perhaps the humor of my comment was lost on you then, but by my estimation that means it can never scream at all since it can't see and thus has no Line of Sight.

Foolishness aside, using normal los rules makes perfect sense, and a range of 8" doesn't give a lot of leeway. Mount that sucker on a tomb from the Gardens of More set to get a better vantage of all those juicy targets!

Modeling for advantage much me thinks.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu