The Black Coach will be too awesome unless nerfed in next edition

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Drakim

Skeleton
Apr 23, 2010
92
Zombies
67
It's IMO very likely that the erranta thingy that comes out changes the Black Coach. However, if it does not, then we are in great luck. I shall be using this post to tell you exactly how overpowered the Black Coach would be.

Note that I have based this post on rumors I've heard about the 8th edition. I like to think of myself as fairly updated, but it's very possible I'm missing some rumor being disconfirmed, or have simply heard something wrong. Please correct me if you know better.

7th edition Black Coach had it's uses but was often looked down upon complared to the awesome Blood Knights and the Varghulf. The new changes in 8th edition are going to tip the scales a lot though. Let us take a look:

Changes to the magic system
It will in the next edition on average drain slightly more than 1 PD per magic phase, giving it about 2 PD per turn on average (and very likely more with channeling and magic items generating PD).

This means that the Black Coach will be gaining the benefits on the chart extremely fast. It can easily be fully powered by turn 3.

Survivability
The sickest aspect of the Black Coach will be it's magic resistance combined with it's wardsave. If magic resistance truly improves existing ward saves with 1 for every level of magic resistance, then it means the Black Coach will have a wardsave of 2+ against spells and be etheral. That's nearly unkillable!

Regular physical things like shooting won't be able to harm it, and spells will be nearly useless. Only Skaven shooting (being all magic) and Dwarves with magical runes on their war machines will be able to hurt it at all, and even against them it's putting up a pretty good fight with T6, 4+ ward save and 3+ armor save.

It doesn't help that it's flying, meaning it's easy to get it into combat to keep it safe from the few ranged things that might hurt it. You are also able to heal it with IoN should it come to that. :D

Offensive Power
This is the only area where the Black Coach suffers. It won't be able to charge into things and break them anymore. But I think the Black Coach will have a shift in it's role, not really being used as a Chariot but more like some sort of freaky monster with tons of special rules.

Still, with the new magic draining speed it's offensive capabilites is not totally worthless:
D6+1 impact hits at S5 with killing blow.
3 Wraith attacks at WS3 S5 with hatred and killing blow.
2 Nightmare attacks with WS3 S4 with hatred and killing blow.

Having fly will ensure that the Black Coach doesn't have any problems getting into combat. Choose who you charge a little wisely and it's not going to be lackluster at all. And the facts is, even if you do charge into a large rank&file unit that you cannot hope to break, your Black Coach is most likely going to be fine. It might suffer against SCR, but as long as you choose your targets wisely and manage to inflict some casualites a round, you are pretty safe.
 
Yep, it's going to be a very nasty addition to the army in 8th! Also you didn't mention the loss of S7 auto-kill, which also really helps. CR is another bonus: with +1 for charging and no outnumber, and the fact that the parry save does not work vs impact hits, means you'll be more likely to win on the charge vs enemies. You won't necessarily break them so easily, but you'll almost never lose either. Then just bring the Skeletons ranks in a turn later and run them down nicely...
 
I cant see the coach being any better apart from the strength 7 thing, once it is in combat it will die to CR unless combined with other units that are going to win combat every time.
It breaks units better now than it will in 8th due to steadfast and you cant bring a unit in on the next combat phase, your enemy can though so unless you were in a combined charge your alone for a phase against the block.

Best use for it will be hunting siege weapons and things, threatening fast cav, fliers and skirmishers. ok it will be hard to kill by shooting and magic but in big combats its not going to be that good
 
loquar said:
I cant see the coach being any better apart from the strength 7 thing, once it is in combat it will die to CR unless combined with other units that are going to win combat every time.
I was trying to put emphasis on this. Some match-ups simply suck. It's just like how nobody would try to shoot a cannon at a small skirmisher unit. Nobody should charge a too large rank&file unit with a lone chariot. :p
It breaks units better now than it will in 8th due to steadfast and you cant bring a unit in on the next combat phase, your enemy can though so unless you were in a combined charge your alone for a phase against the block.
Not all units in the game going to have steadfast though. It's pretty much reserved for the large rank&file troops.

And even so, if you charge, win first round of combat due to impact hits, and then lose the next by say, two, then it only means you suffer two wounds which you can take your ward save on. That's two rounds which the unit has been locked with the Black Coach. Surely by now you can bring in SOMETHING to help?
Best use for it will be hunting siege weapons and things, threatening fast cav, fliers and skirmishers. ok it will be hard to kill by shooting and magic but in big combats its not going to be that good
I think it can be good in big combat as long as it's a good situation. For example, if you are having a big infantry vs infantry battle, sending in the Black Coach might give you the advantage by reducing his ranks below that of yours, making them lose steadfast.
 
All units will have steadfast, its not reserved for any units in particular. Its based on having more ranks at the end of combat and the coach has no ranks so any block it hits will have steadfast unless in a combo-charge with a larger undead unit
 
It doesn't ever apply to skirmishers, and obviously troops in one rank, like cavalry, or those reduced to one rank by the time you're counting up CR (E.g. 10 x 2 crossbowmen, charge in, kill 6, no longer steadfast) will run quite quickly. I still reckon stuff like Shades and Flamers are going to be the #1 nastiest units in the game, so something that can take the fight to them from far away will be lovely jubbly.

Also remember this edition we pretty much have to take like 3 massive units of infantry, so have them support the Coach for pure ranks and they have a fine job to play. Also I would advise a bit of sneakiness in this respect: charge the coach as far to one side of a ranked unit as you can and move the zombies/skeletons/ghouls alongside the other side, so that when you charge in the next turn, you only get something like 2 models in contact, meaning the enemy doesn't rack up cheap kills on the poor infantry :D
 
loquar said:
All units will have steadfast, its not reserved for any units in particular. Its based on having more ranks at the end of combat and the coach has no ranks so any block it hits will have steadfast unless in a combo-charge with a larger undead unit

That's horribly wrong. It doesn't apply to all units, only units which can have ranks.

Flyers, skirmishers, cavalry and small rank&file units all miss out on the steadfast rule.
 
Drakim said:
loquar said:
All units will have steadfast, its not reserved for any units in particular. Its based on having more ranks at the end of combat and the coach has no ranks so any block it hits will have steadfast unless in a combo-charge with a larger undead unit

That's horribly wrong. It doesn't apply to all units, only units which can have ranks.

Flyers, skirmishers, cavalry and small rank&file units all miss out on the steadfast rule.

I was on about blocks lol, if you read my posts propperly you will see I was discussing the coach going into a block. All blocks have the rule. I even said that in the bit that you quoted me on.... So it wasnt horribly wrong, it was accurate, you just read it wrong.

Also are you sure that cavalry cannot have the steadfast rule. If they have more ranks then they have it dont they? (im not talking fast cav btw)

I also said that the coach would now be best suited to hunting war machines, fast cav, skirmishers, fliers etc. Please read the whole post propperly not just taking a tiny bit in isolation and ignore the rest
 
loquar said:
I was on about blocks lol, if you read my posts propperly you will see I was discussing the coach going into a block.

Sorry, I was kinda confused since you started an entirely new post declaring "All units will have steadfast, its not reserved for any units in particular" which is horribly wrong. All units don't have it, and it is reserved for a specific unit in particular.

All blocks have the rule. I even said that in the bit that you quoted me on.... So it wasnt horribly wrong, it was accurate, you just read it wrong.
You formulated it in really really weird way, as noted above. I was wrong, but I don't really see it that weird that somebody would read it wrong when you say "all" but actually mean "some" and when you say there are none exceptions, there are actually tons of exceptions.

Also are you sure that cavalry cannot have the steadfast rule. If they have more ranks then they have it dont they? (im not talking fast cav btw)
You are going to need a LOT of cavalry. Ten at least I think. And if even a single one dies from the charge, it doesn't gain the steadfast. So you'd have to have like, 15 to be safe.
 
Yep its going to be awesome, I am thinking of using two coaches in my 2250 point list:P. They actually will cause problems to my opponents magic face this way.

Question: Will it be able to killing blow ogre sized units?

The only real problem I see is that it weakens your magic face and after turn 3 (fully buffed) will continue to do so with no gain for you.
 
The coach will be very good, and at the bare minimum, be well worth its points.

It might not be able to hurtle recklessly into combats, but even in 7th that was risky at best.

It'll be a supporting unit, or hunting down lighter troops. I think it will shine as a supporting unit, coming in later. Pin the enemy down with a block. They're likely told as, while we can raise up more, a lot of units have a decent shot at having at least as many ranks. Slam the coach in for more combat res, and to hopefully reduce a rank down (depending on if the unit is horde or going for max ranks, granted). The extra +1 I assume you'll get from a "fresh unit charging" helps too.

We're going back to attrition, much like I remember 6th edition was for us. The coach, really helps swing that one turn to hopefully breaking the enemy.

Plus consuming massive amounts of dice will be rather valuable. Our biggest threat, I think, will be Dwarf cannons which just got a lot better due to D6 wounds. Though with special slots freed up in favor of points, we can afford more bats to hunt those cannons.
 
It's too early to say anything substantial about VC power changes, before the FAQ. I have a gnawing suspicion that Undead along with Daemons will lose the current mechanics to crumble were we can save crumbling with ward save or regeneration. Which would make the Black Coach much more restricted in targets. You can't really charge a big block in the front alone, if you can't save the wounds you suffer from CR.
IF it's not changed, then yes the Black Coach will become THE rare choice. Don't forget outnumbering is gone, so a block can only win by 4, not counting items and wounds on either side.
My personal favourite is that the Wraith regains his S5. The S4 Wraith is a pet peeve of mine.
The +1/+2 to CR for flank/rear attacks is a nice boon too, for the Coach.

Drakim said:
7th edition Black Coach had it's uses but was often looked down upon complared to the awesome Blood Knights
Lol. Awesome Blood Knights, really? Now everything you say after that will be filtered through that statement. Thanks for the warning! :)

Drakim said:
Changes to the magic system
It will in the next edition on average drain slightly more than 1 PD per magic phase, giving it about 2 PD per turn on average (and very likely more with channeling and magic items generating PD).
How exactly, with an average 7 power dice and stealing 1 die in every 6, will the Coach drain 2 dice per magic phase on average? Don't confuse max with average.

I don't see the role of the Coach to change much - it will still be a support hammer, only on the flanks will it be able to operate on it's own, just like now.
 
He said 1 per phase and 2 per turn... doesn't take a mechanic to work out he means per full turn encompassing both players.

Not sure why anyone would say Dwarf Cannons are that much of a threat. They already auto-destroy the Coach after wounding in 7th edition, so to only kill it half the time is a vast improvement. Perhaps he means because they'll still be able to target it when ethereal due to runes (boo!). I personally think the Screaming Skull Catapult will be nastiest!
 
I am not so certain. Monsters and such are very much supportive in their roles. It will be better than before, that is for sure but before it was fairly mediocre so this is not enough for me to call it awesome but rather more viable. Our rare's are all solid choices, though Blood Knights are risky due to initiative order and steep cost of the unit but still one of the best cavalry units in the game.

My initial response in the 8th and to army list composition(the standard seem to end up aroun 2500 points) I am going to include of Black Coach, most definitely, and the rest are quite open as I do not see the other rare's as being a definite choice. Varghulf has a good play, fast and hit a whole lot harder than before. Wraiths allows me to field more Banshees which can be horribly effective with certain spells(Doom & Darkness is not -3 to LD tests anymore but a solid modifier, for example).

Dwarf cannons are now D6 wounds instead of D3, all cannons are. This is why people speak of their increased effectiveness. Much more deadly VS monsters and multi-wound models overall.
 
yeah, so even if the cannons cannot instantly destroy a chariot on a to-wound roll, since most chariots have either 3-4W (Waltar has 5 I think) cannons will still destroy most chariots in one 'ball
 
Lord Fear said:
He said 1 per phase and 2 per turn
That he did, serves me right for sloppy reading. Yes it will climb the ladder faster, by turn 2 it should have gained +1 impact hits and hatred, imo the most useful powers as it makes the Coach reliable on the charge.

All our rare choices gained in power. Even the Wraiths, mostly due to DoC losing power (thinking meta game here) and magic taking a turn against unit buffs instead of dakka spam.

I think we should make an 8th ed meta game thread, were we can theorize over were VC will be in the new meta. A buff is not a buff if everyone else got a bigger buff.
 
N.I.B said:
My personal favourite is that the Wraith regains his S5. The S4 Wraith is a pet peeve of mine.

Woops! I've played all the way through 7th edition forgetting great weapons only gave +1 strength when you were mounted! :redface:
This probably has had some effect on the games I have played.. :O

About the whole PD stealing, I wouldn't be surprised if it was changed, so that the Coach generates an amount similar to the current one. That's assuming GW makes those darn erratas.. Which I really hope they do, but fear they won't..
 
The BC just needs a longer list of buffs for gobbling PD.

10+ - The nightmares pulling the Black Coach are replaced with 2 Zombie Dragons.

Similar well-considered additions would be most welcome.
 
Why are people going on about the coach powering up faster? Do the maths. If it is faster then its only very very slightly.

Average 7pd in your magic phase, used to be 12+ so thats 1 rather than 2 6's(slower). then 1 on average in the enemy phase instead of none on average.

So its hardly any difference at all
 
Average 7pd in your magic phase, used to be 12+ so thats 1 rather than 2 6's(slower).

Except those 12+ PD aren't in the pool, they'll mostly be tied to characters and characters don't have to be tied to a single point. 8th ed moves most of the dice from characters to the pool meaning the coach just has to be on the field somewhere to threaten most, if not all, of your opponent's (and your) power dice rather than having to be very close to any wizard in the last edition.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu