The Black Coach will be too awesome unless nerfed in next edition

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Here's my 2penies worth

Magic - Roll for winds - then absorb. Any other way is just stupid and broken

Flying March. It is not a hard and fast rule, but you can only have it one way or the other. So it is either:-

A: A Chariot (regardless of flying) so can therefore not march move - ever

or

B: It can march when it gains flying rule, but loses the chariot rule at that point and therefore impact hits.

I will be playing A: but if anyone wants to play against me with B: then fine
 
Indeed this is no different to how it was in 7th edition, occasionally I'd have opponents give me the Puss in Boots look before rolling for their Banner of Sorcery and asking if we rolled the Black Coach's dice before generating the additional dice, but the response then is the same as the response now (it's a bit dismissive so I won't post it ;) ). There are certain things in the game that rely on players not acting like they have problems with social interaction. If the Coach's rules tells you to roll the pool dice that are generated each turn, then you wait until the dice are generated before testing if they are sucked up or not. The only people I know that would force WE Wardancers to wait until after they've been attacked to pick their dance are the kind of people I wouldn't want to have any interaction with away from the tabletop. If being that guy is your thing and how you win your games, more power to you, as you need it more than I do ;)

And the great thing about tournaments is that they are invariably run by some of the smartest people in the hobby, the guys that know the loopholes and are happy to close them. Only the crummy little 8-man tournaments run by people who only play 40K and don't have a clue about fantasy are ever going to rule these things in the stupid manner. Swedish tournament players are a good bunch and if GW don't correct the FAQs or if they ignore them (based on the idea that their gamers are smart enough to work it out all by themselves) then the guys running the big, respected tournaments will tell you how they should be played.

I've said it before and I'll say it again: the transition from 7th edition to 8th edition is bound to have all kinds of weird anomolies and odd-sounding stuff. You can either leap on every dodgy interpretion of each potential loophole and insist that the ridiculous-sounding way to play it is the proper way, or you can work together with your buddies to have an enjoyable game that doesn't revolve around who can twist the rules the most. If that means you're using a houserule, then that's not the end of the world.
 
As I tried to argument and also Kalandros pointed out, there is no such a thing as a void power poll. So, the idea to have the VC player rolling before the WoM roll is not a RaW interpretation of the rule, it would seem to be a poor reading of the new section on magic. I think that the only matter of choice is relative to channelling after the evocation (and that could be useful also for the VC player as the BC keeps sucking dice even after it is fully powered...:slapface: ).
 
Lord Fear said:
I've said it before and I'll say it again: the transition from 7th edition to 8th edition is bound to have all kinds of weird anomolies and odd-sounding stuff. You can either leap on every dodgy interpretion of each potential loophole and insist that the ridiculous-sounding way to play it is the proper way, or you can work together with your buddies to have an enjoyable game that doesn't revolve around who can twist the rules the most. If that means you're using a houserule, then that's not the end of the world.

Words of wisdom.

Every time I hear someone invoke RAW I die a little inside. I prefer RAPBG(Rules As Played By Gamers).
 
Kalandros said:
Shadowfax - claiming to know the intent and therefore ignoring the written rules is not only wishful thinking but also somewhat cheating.

You're not supposed to play the rules how you "feel they should be interpreted" unless something is REALLY unclear.
Which is not the case here, the rules complete each other, so just because you don't like that its no reason to make your own rules.

When you put it that way, it sounds as if it's cut and dried and that you've stated a truism. But.... For those who have played 40K, there was a period of time in which Blood Angels Rhinos didn't have exit points. That's right, a transport without doors! It was not unclear in any way, but the intent was OBVIOUS. So, by the strict RAW (and your) interpretations, they were cheating to exit from their rhinos.

The problem with RAW is that it assumes that the game designers were fully intentional about every nuance of every rule that they write, and that such rules were written perfectly.

Back on subject, I have to agree that Black Coaches will never march due to their status as chariots. But if someone asks you to use your invocation of death before the Winds of Magic dice are rolled (as well as channeling), kindly put your black coach into a sock an explain the errors of their ways. Don't be a git when you're playing, and don't assume that the games designers are perfect, because they've proven over and over again that they are not.
 
i think people forget that its a chariot so evan with the best upgrade it can only move 10 inches with fly because it cant march and it will steal your power dice at the time when you really needed added with unstable are some of the reasons i dont rate the block coach [/align]
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu