OT: I'm not planning on becoming active. I've been thinking of painting mini's in some weekends when I'm at my parents, though. But these weekends happen irregularly.
lynks said:
the trouble with the first idea is that that has the possibility to reduce the number of people attempting to use chat, as if you can see that no one is in there you are less likely to join
I don't think this is necessarily true. As people have been mentioning that they often find an empty chat room, if they wait a bit they can be joined by others who see someone's in the chat room. I get the feeling people tend to wait some time before closing the chat.
lynks said:
The trouble with the second idea, which sounds much like a shoutbox is that you tend to not get long running conversations going and they resort to more passing comments or repeating because of the limited space to view what has previously been said so traffic might increase but it;s a definite change in quality.
True. This is primarily what will happen. Though, isn't banter the generic topic on the chat room? If anything serious is being discussed, it would counter-produce the forum (in effect).
This brings me to the next question: what is the chat room exactly used for? I feel awkward because of this, because I think I was the first to mention a chat room when I was still active as admin. But being relatively objective now (as in: not active), I feel the forum takes care of most topics already. CN has an off topic forum, on topic sections,
40K, user projects and roleplaying. The chat room functions as a faster method to get response on questions regarding these topics. But I'm not sure of this.
An interesting idea is to have a chat for all
WHFB related fora. I believe it existed in the past. That 1) increases member base for the chat and 2) opens up possibilities to easily chat with people from other fora. This generates new interest.