Ophidicus said:
Flap: I'm not convinced about spreading wounds when crumbling, one has to consider if a Banshee (or any other champion) is a character when allocating crumbling wounds, because, if so, it should count as a character in all respects, not just the respects you want it to be for, because that would mean you were using the rules selectively, which would be terribly unsporting. And cheating.
You're not being terribly clear here? Champions are considered separate models akin to characters when it comes to shooting casualties, this is 100% correct as per the rules.
A champion is not a character therefore:
-Wounds may be allocated to it before rank-and-file troops
-It must be removed as a whole model, the wounds cannot be spread to other models
What do you base this "must be removed as a whole model" thing on? It certainly doesn't tell us to do this in the
VC book. So I'm guessing that you're referring to the section on multiple wound casualties, which states that when a unit takes enough damage to remove an entire model, it must do so. However, when a champion is considered a separate model, that doesn't quite apply, it just means that, say, if you lose 4 wounds, then that means you must take off two complete Wraiths and you can't allocate one wound to 4 separate Wraiths. It doesn't mean that if a skaven template busts up a unit of Wraiths and does 1 wound to a Wraith and 1 wound to a Banshee that you'd have to allocate both wounds to the same model. Now replace the Skaven template attack with any other cause of damage, such as crumbling...
Tomb Kings have their own version of crumbling rules, and have been splitting wounds across complicated units (E.g. Tomb King on Chariot, in a unit of Chariots with a Champion- that's 4 different elements they can split the wounds between!) for years.
Crumbling damage does not follow the casualty removal rules for shooting, so champions are not treated as different models, because if they were they would be treated in the same way as characters, and therefore could not be removed before R&Fs.
You're right, I'll agree it doesn't follow casualty removal rules for shooting. However champions are still separate models when it comes to dishing damage regardless of that, and have their own separate pool of wounds. Crumbling does not require the removal of whole models- just where have you gotten this from..?
Anyways, thanks for the responses, this is just what I was hoping for, some discussion as to whether it's wrong or evil. I still don't think it's either
