Unseen Tactics, what your opponent WON'T expect

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Ah. Always worth giving them a cheap weapon purely for the magical attacks in that respect, like 5 pts for a Biting Blade. Doesn't make alot of difference to his combat prowess, but lets him attack stuff like that, and get rid of things like ward saves on dryads. Something I always do unless its a caster character in a bunker, for example.
 
Fodderboy said:
I cry shenannigans on that one. Unless it's a unit of characters, you have to collect wounds as much as possible. Under the rules for multi-wound units in the BRB.

That's what you do if a unit is hit by a cannon spreading multiple wounds out over the unit. The champion is still treated like a separate model for it. If you did have to allocate crumble wounds as per that section on shooting, then you would actually have to randomise where the damage goes in such a small unit, which again could lead to the possibility of 1 Wraith and 1 Banshee each losing a wound :)
 
Count Flapula said:
Fodderboy said:
I cry shenannigans on that one. Unless it's a unit of characters, you have to collect wounds as much as possible. Under the rules for multi-wound units in the BRB.

That's what you do if a unit is hit by a cannon spreading multiple wounds out over the unit. The champion is still treated like a separate model for it. If you did have to allocate crumble wounds as per that section on shooting, then you would actually have to randomise where the damage goes in such a small unit, which again could lead to the possibility of 1 Wraith and 1 Banshee each losing a wound :)

Sometimes shenanigins are good things :D
 
Flap: I'm not convinced about spreading wounds when crumbling, one has to consider if a Banshee (or any other champion) is a character when allocating crumbling wounds, because, if so, it should count as a character in all respects, not just the respects you want it to be for, because that would mean you were using the rules selectively, which would be terribly unsporting. And cheating.

A champion is not a character therefore:
-Wounds may be allocated to it before rank-and-file troops
-It must be removed as a whole model, the wounds cannot be spread to other models

Crumbling damage does not follow the casualty removal rules for shooting, so champions are not treated as different models, because if they were they would be treated in the same way as characters, and therefore could not be removed before R&Fs.
 
Spreading wounds when crumbling is one of the grey areas of the undead rules. Technicallyif the banshee has already suffered a wound there's nothing stopping you from removing a wraith first, and vice-versa, because crumbling isn't technically spreading wounds, it's taken in place of a break test. Since the multiple-wound model rule is mentioned in the shooting phase section of the BRB, and crumbling is done in place of a break test, a VCs player can very easily argue that killing models off after another has already suffered a wound.

And, since I'm delving into extremely stupid and annoying speculation, if you argue that the multiple wound thingy is mentioned in the shooting phase section and that you have to remove wounded models first, you could also argue that the unit champion is treated as a character when allocating shooting hits, which means that if the Banshee is the champpion she would get a "Look Out Sir" roll.

Basically what I'm saying is that everything I have just said is bullshit, speculation and interpretations of an idiot. And all of that is null and void because of the sentence: "Close Combat casualties are removed in the same way as shooting casualties." Blah blah blah. The crumbling/multiwound thing is a point that can be argued all day, one person quoting the VC book and the other quoting the BRB. Simply because there's nothing technical to say you can't because crumbling does not specify allocated as for shooting, or in any other way. BUT since all casualties are technically removed in the same way (and shooting basically only changes the allocation when there's less than 5 models in the unit and/or when its from a war-machine/template (ie Look out Sir), otherwise its essentially the same), you could argue that wounds cannot spread out simply because multiwound models can't unless they're characters (which are in effect seperate units to the unit they may/may not be in).

I can exaggerate all day, but the point is there's nothing to say you can OR can't, so the best way is to roll off at the beginning of the game in my opinion, or sort it any other way you wan't to.
 
That's a lot of counter-arguments. One thing though:

"The crumbling/multiwound thing is a point that can be argued all day, one person quoting the VC book and the other quoting the BRB."

To argue the rules you need to quote both.

On Page 36 it states that "excess casualties are removed as normal" which, given the top paragraph, would imply that the shooting phase casualty rules are the 'normal' rules, and, unless otherwise specified, is how all casualties should be removed.

"...because crumbling isn't technically spreading wounds, it's taken in place of a break test."

Allocating wounds to intact models when there is already a wounded model is 'spreading wounds' and ya can't do that.

It would be useful if GW would clarify how the rules refer to multi-wound champions, but, well, this close to 8 Ed. it's kinda too late...
 
See what I mean? You made an argument to all the key points in my 'essay'. That whole thing was a vague attempt at sarcasm, that in a situation like this there'll always be an alternate view.

The point (from a sensible point of view) is that its a direct contradiction, in which case the BRB takes precedence in my opinion (although its very rare situations come up like this, since this is a unique case to undead). Its not exactly a written rule in tournaments that the BRB takes precedence, but the BRB isn't biased and because its not to do with any particular army overall, therefore its neither balanced nor imbalanced, but if you make an army book take precedence (without it saying that it takes precedence, which is generally something that happens in army specific rules, eg. Dwarf's "Relentless," in this case taking precedence over the Enemy Within 8") then its going to end up imbalanced in some way because army books are designed to be balanced. Whether they wrote it clearly or not, GW knew what they wanted to happen when they wrote the rule book, and so rolling off (which is the evident result of things like this) when there is two outcomes (ie not when there is no conclusion at all) gives you a 50:50 chance of giving a player a slight advantage.

Applied to a general situation as opposed to the multiwound rules, the players need to decide which rules would sensibly take precedence. In this case I'd say the Rulebook takes precedence, but there are inevitably a few situations like this flying around the game.
 
"See what I mean? You made an argument to all the key points in my 'essay'. That whole thing was a vague attempt at sarcasm, that in a situation like this there'll always be an alternate view."

That's what happens when you post your opinions on an internet forum, nobody's going to take the words "everything I have just said is bullshit, speculation and interpretations of an idiot" to mean "please don't respond to what I say because I can't decide if I think it or not." Nothing personal, and not a dig at you, 's the way the internet works innit?

I don't think it's a contradiction though, since you only apply an 'abnormal' use of the rules if it specifically says that the 'normal' rules are not applied. Relentless, like all special rules, is an abnormal application of the rules. Nothing in the crumbling rules suggests that an abnormal application of the rules for casualty removal [as opposed to the abnormal application of damage replacing the normal procedure of break tests] is permissible, so we use the normal rules.

"Applied to a general situation as opposed to the multiwound rules, the players need to decide which rules would sensibly take precedence. In this case I'd say the Rulebook takes precedence, but there are inevitably a few situations like this flying around the game."

I agree.
 
To be honest its not that I can't decide what I think, the last quote you said is what I think. Its more the fact that typing in general isn't anywhere near good enough at representing sarcasm :S I didn't expect anybody to understand realy, just fancied entertaining myself ^.^

In this case its more a shady area than a direct contradiction, you're right, which is why you're right that the normal rules take precedence like I said, but its kinda for other reasons. It's more the fact that there's no reason or allowance to do anything else, as opposed to it being an (albeit abnormal) application of any one rule.

In the case of relentless, it IS a direct contradiction, but one that specifies which rule takes precedence. Its not an abnormal application of the 8" rule, but an ignorance of it altogether, and you don't apply the rule because it says not to. In this case it's kind of a contradiction (but not a completely direct one) because there is no reason to say the normal rules apply, but there is no reason to say they don't. And it is because there is no reason to say they don't apply, that we do apply them, because going with former could pose a complication when later applying the rule and could allow a slight advantage to the VC player in question, or whoever is in control of whatever this situation is generally applied to.
 
You guys are doing it again.
The whole "argue about how the arguments are presented instead of discussing the actual point being argued" thing.
 
Ophidicus said:
Flap: I'm not convinced about spreading wounds when crumbling, one has to consider if a Banshee (or any other champion) is a character when allocating crumbling wounds, because, if so, it should count as a character in all respects, not just the respects you want it to be for, because that would mean you were using the rules selectively, which would be terribly unsporting. And cheating.

You're not being terribly clear here? Champions are considered separate models akin to characters when it comes to shooting casualties, this is 100% correct as per the rules.

A champion is not a character therefore:
-Wounds may be allocated to it before rank-and-file troops
-It must be removed as a whole model, the wounds cannot be spread to other models

What do you base this "must be removed as a whole model" thing on? It certainly doesn't tell us to do this in the VC book. So I'm guessing that you're referring to the section on multiple wound casualties, which states that when a unit takes enough damage to remove an entire model, it must do so. However, when a champion is considered a separate model, that doesn't quite apply, it just means that, say, if you lose 4 wounds, then that means you must take off two complete Wraiths and you can't allocate one wound to 4 separate Wraiths. It doesn't mean that if a skaven template busts up a unit of Wraiths and does 1 wound to a Wraith and 1 wound to a Banshee that you'd have to allocate both wounds to the same model. Now replace the Skaven template attack with any other cause of damage, such as crumbling...

Tomb Kings have their own version of crumbling rules, and have been splitting wounds across complicated units (E.g. Tomb King on Chariot, in a unit of Chariots with a Champion- that's 4 different elements they can split the wounds between!) for years.

Crumbling damage does not follow the casualty removal rules for shooting, so champions are not treated as different models, because if they were they would be treated in the same way as characters, and therefore could not be removed before R&Fs.

You're right, I'll agree it doesn't follow casualty removal rules for shooting. However champions are still separate models when it comes to dishing damage regardless of that, and have their own separate pool of wounds. Crumbling does not require the removal of whole models- just where have you gotten this from..?

Anyways, thanks for the responses, this is just what I was hoping for, some discussion as to whether it's wrong or evil. I still don't think it's either :thumbsup:
 
Gah! My logic circuits are all fried!

I'll try anyway... as you can probably tell, I've actually changed my mind about supporting this tactic, nor for any moralconcerns, just because I've re-read a few bits of the rulebook.

You're not being terribly clear here? Champions are considered separate models akin to characters when it comes to shooting casualties, this is 100% correct as per the rules.

My point is that since we consider them to be Characters for shooting, we should also treat them as Characters for purposes of crumbling, and so they must take wounds after at least one wound has been allocated to other models. This is necessary for the sake of consistency and not being selective in our application of the caualty removal rules. As an example, if a unit of four Wraiths and a Banshee took six wounds from CR two Wraiths would be romoved (the first four wounds each allocated to one Wraith, which would default to two wounds each on two wraiths), a fifth wound would be allocated to the Banshee, and the fifth again to the R&F, causing a wound on an unwounded Wraith. If only four wounds were suffered, as per the 'normal casualty removal rules' they would all be allocated to Wraiths, as the Banshee is treated as a character and so cannot be allocated wounds until after R&Fs.

You're right, I'll agree it doesn't follow casualty removal rules for shooting. However champions are still separate models when it comes to dishing damage regardless of that, and have their own separate pool of wounds. Crumbling does not require the removal of whole models- just where have you gotten this from..?

I think it does require the removal of whole models, because we use the 'normal rules' in absence of anything telling us to use 'abnormal rules'. The 'normal rules' are those on WFB p.31, "Removing Casualties."

Tomb Kings have their own version of crumbling rules, and have been splitting wounds across complicated units (E.g. Tomb King on Chariot, in a unit of Chariots with a Champion- that's 4 different elements they can split the wounds between!) for years.

[Petulant teenager] Death is so unfair!! [/pteen] :lol:

No more logic please, I've got a hangover.
 
While I don't think the multiple wound casualty stuff has any bearing on this matter (I just read a thread at warseer where someone wanted an opponent to remove a whole ogre after doing 2 wounds to 1 model and 1 to the champion, instead of splitting the wounds- that seems to be what you think would happen? It's madness either way!), I think you're probably right that if we treat all instances of casualty removal as being the same manner in which we normally remove casualties, i.e. as shooting, and add in the rules for crumbling that says characters are affected last, then seeing as we would treat a Banshee as a character, the Banshee would have to be removed last indeed. Curses, foiled again! No pumpkin-flavoured easter egg this time :pumpkin:
 
"I don't think the multiple wound casualty stuff has any bearing on this matter..."

I think that was just me arguing both sides of the case at once, whether we treat a Champion as a Character or not, glad we got it sorted in the end though. Much as I love dichotomies, they do drive me crackers.

"I just read a thread at warseer where someone wanted an opponent to remove a whole ogre after doing 2 wounds to 1 model and 1 to the champion, instead of splitting the wounds- that seems to be what you think would happen? It's madness either way!"

Not at all, if the Champion takes a wound because he's been attacked separately then the Champion takes a wound, and probably ain't pleased about it.
 
'Unseen Tactics'

Vamp Lord + 3 Vamps all with Fly and maybe one with Lycni Talis, in Ghoulkin'd unit, all charging the same unit? O:
If placed in different units of ghouls this could be pulled off.

Or send 2 at one target, 2 at the other, and being on foot gives 360 line of sight for charging next turn, since you should charge light stuff and warmachines deployed on the edge (hellblaster, organ gun) while making sure you dont get blasted by cannons the next turn.
 
3 vamps and a vamp lord? all with fly? charging the same unit? Of course, they won't expect you to waste 3/4ths of your points to take on one unit.
 
Kalandros said:
Or send 2 at one target, 2 at the other, and being on foot gives 360 line of sight for charging next turn, since you should charge light stuff and warmachines deployed on the edge (hellblaster, organ gun) while making sure you dont get blasted by cannons the next turn.

I had someone try a similar thing against me at a tournament. I fled with the unit (which rallied), and on my turn 1 he lost 400 points of Vampires. This is only worth doing if you know your opponent has no decent ranged attacks or spells. With 3-4 Vamps their shooting protection is going to be spread pretty thin...
 
Humaneater said:
See what I mean? You made an argument to all the key points in my 'essay'. That whole thing was a vague attempt at sarcasm, that in a situation like this there'll always be an alternate view.

[mod]
Humaneater

This kind of posting is not something I am happy with on CN, and something I will be clamping down everywhere.

The following is directed at everyone, not jut Humaneater:

DO NOT POST if your post is going to be:

Sarcastic
Insulting
Derogatory in anyway to other members

Tone and inflection do not work over the internet. Trying to be sarcastic, or even having a joke, which involves phrases that can be insulting does not work. All it does is make you look like you are being aggressive and insulting.

I will not have other members feel put off or intimidated by the fact that when they post they may get an insulting remark in return.

I do not care if this is how you post elsewhere, or that we are all adults etc. The fact is that you can state your point in a civil way without being demeaning to others.

If you cannot do that, then you cannot post on CN.

If anyone has any questions please PM me.

Disciple of Nagash
Carpe Noctem Administrator
[/mod]
 
Okay, I can understand the anti-sarcasm bit. My point wasn't really to be insultingly sarcastic, more to be sarcastic so that people were more likely to understand my point after the follow-up posts. No insults to people's intelligence itended, just incase it seems that way. Sorry if it seemed like that., perhaps it was easy to take the wrong way.

As for the all flyers charging the same unit, you could be pouring alot of points into a limited resource there: ie losing out on other powers which could ultimately help your army more. Using this tactic is effectively giving yourself a compulsory charge like being frenzied, because if you don't use the tactic, you're again wasting points, which is leaving yourself open to abuse. On the other hand I can see it being done well, if and how it is used cleverly. Using an all-risk tactic like this is more dangerous here than in other armies because we rely heavily on vampires to keep our army alive, and marching.
 
Indeed, when you commit so many points in a character multi-charge you should consider the opponents options of having a way out.

1. How likely is it that your opponent will just declare a flee reaction. What special rules might apply, and so on.
2. Is the charge going to worth it? Is it perhaps better to wait?
3. You've charged, won the combat. Where will you end up? Next to a barrage of shooting, or will you get get charge yourself.
4. You've charge but woe betide you! You've fluffed your attacks and are now stuck in a bad place where you might be counter-charged.
5. Do I really need my Lord and three vampires, perhaps the lord + 2 vamps is enough.

In short, this tactic was 'all the rage' when the book first came out. While sneaky it isn't that unexpected now. If your opponent notice you've put all your characters together they're likely to already have figured out what will come next. Granted, against an unwary opponent this may very well work. With good planning it might also do a number on more experienced players.
 
I do love seeing a good Ghoulkin rush work though. I just... haven't in a long while. A lot of the time people think that because they can do something, that means it's a good idea, and as a result I've seen other players throw away even their Vampire Lords on what seems like a sure thing, but where even success results in little gain. But Kalandros is a smart guy and of course isn't referring to the situations where it won't work, so I'm sure as a group we can come up with ways to get the most of the abilities. Sadly it's tough in UK tournaments as most are limiting flying units really heavily, I really wanted to include one flying Vamp in a list for an upcoming tournament but my silly insistence on a unit of Bat Swarms to go with my Fell Bats took up all those slots. Now 3 or 4 flying Vamps, and that's only going to be possible at a fully uncomped tournament- and you need to be spending them bloodline points on better powers (It restricts all hero vamps to level 1, and at least, you could do with powers that aren't going to be made useless at the key time vs every nasty Skaven army due to their damned Storm Banner). But there's still potential I think :)
 
I did it with my orcs and goblins against Warriors of Chaos all Khorne army.

He knew he was going to get Frenzybaited so he moved everything forward. So I charge 3 heroes at him after my extra move of WAAAGH and ... he rolled so many saves I lost by 1... 3 heroes one on chariot against 6 chaos knights + jugger hero and I couldnt kill enough to win... but I won 2 rounds after and made a nice hole in his battle line ;D

Its risky for vampires due to crumbling but it can work - you have to know what you're going up against and all the possible outcomes.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu