Warhammer 9th. . .Carpe Noctem Style

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

What Would you Prefer to See Done with 9th Edition

  • I'm done with Warhammer. Their should be no 9th.

    Votes: 3 27.3%
  • I'm really excited about projects going on right now such as the ninth age.

    Votes: 2 18.2%
  • I like your idea about Carp-Noctem-Hammer

    Votes: 6 54.5%
  • I want this Forum to have a fan made 9th edition but your method just isn't cutting it.

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    11
  • Poll votes is visible for users with special permission.

Quinten

Grave Guard
Jul 17, 2014
267
Zombies
240
So after seeing threads like Najo might be crazy and Fixing the holes in 8th I decided to throw out an idea regarding this topic. We host a competition, at Carpe Noctem, in which users can submit their own versions of ninth edition (Just core rulebook). We then, debate, come to a consensus or somehow decide on which version has the best FOUNDATION (not just choosing the most polished and complete one) and work towards improving that edition. We can assign people who know armies to work on armybooks (I'm sure we have representatives of every army) while polishing up the main rules.

I feel this would work better than a giant user input free for all as it would be much more focused, but work better than a one guy does everything. Besides the obvious time saving advantages this would offer all the great ideas that come out of brainstorming but save a lot of hassle. I know I started writing a ninth edition and would be exited to see what Najo could come up with.

A good ninth would include good concepts from various editions as well as good concepts from other games such as KoW and AoS while still being streamlined and easy to play.

Thoughts? o.o

*Edit*
The top choice in poll should read there not their.
 
Last edited:
Makes sense to me, although I don't know how hard to orchestrate it would be. There are certainly many veteran players around, and plenty of players with design experience or knowledge that could contribute.

Honestly, The-Game-That-Was WHFB was a bit too cumbersome IMO. I like a lot of the changes in AoS, though I certainly see the lost elements that were taken away as well.

I don't think your idea is a bad one, although I feel it should be a bit closer to an 8th re-work specifically and not as open ended. Because there are a lot of philosophic design questions that a bit harder to get people to agree on, like if points need to exist. Or things like how much of an impact should spells be permitted to have on the battle, and the foresight to design magic without loop holes that would result in odd interactions or encourage poor play (Like 6-dicing spells to Irresistible). But then, the definition of "poor play" is up for debate as well.

So again, while I like the notion, it may be easier for people to break into teams of like-minded individuals, and I am unsure if there is a cohesive enough mentality here on CN to cobbled together a version of the game everyone agrees on.

Ideally there could a base-line rule set, with modifications for different play styles (Like bringing back way powerful magic with a certain variant of the rules, or Hero-Hammer where characters are simply much more powerful). That would be very interesting, if that could be designed. Essentially a bit like what people decry GW for NOT doing with AoS: They wanted a base game, and anything they didn't like about AoS to have simply been "optional". Making a solid base + Options for play styles would be quite interesting and possibly a good solution for many issues.
 
I see your point about different people wanting different things but I feel if it really comes down to the wire we could probably pick a couple base systems and then put it to a vote. Anyone who was dissatisfied didn't have to continue on with the system. I like your idea about options and feel that may come about by 'combining' two (or more!) systems people come up with. I think Carpe Noctem is the biggest WFB forum that is dedicated to a specific army so here is as good a place as any to do this. You can never get everyone to agree but I feel this is the best way to design a Carpe Noctem version of warhammer.
 
Hey Quinten, this is a great idea! I'm sorry to say that I won't be able to bring much to the table, I'm not big on rules, but can I suggest that as a pretty big project, you may get more contributions with subforums for each phase? It may be that those competing for best CN9 rulebook could use those subforums as a resource to draw from instead of having to go through all the subforums, websites and books for reference? It'd give us all a chance to be a part of developing it!
 
I seem to recall when 8th first came out that we talked about how to tweak 8th ed. It could be interesting to go look at that and see what in that could be changed and how our views have changed since then.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet
Im interested in any/all mods of 8th/new 9th whfb, but im loving kow at the moment, especially the non overpowered magic, more strategic placement/movement and simplified rules compared to 8th. So for a new/modded whfb to draw me back it would need to go at least somewhat in those directions, especially reigning in of the magic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet
Like the support guys!
@Dragonet although the phase thing could work I feel it is better to have one person hammer out the base rules. If only one person does it he/she will likely have a vision as to what the game should play like. Alternatively what if you think the way the phases are organized is messed up? What if you want to re-do the phase set-up? This is why I feel it is always best to have one maybe two people hammer out the core rules. You can then go by committee after that but having a game built by a committee the whole way leads to a disorganized game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet
Well I actually like how in warthrone you alternate units rather than alternate armies. I think it can lead to a far more tactical game.

As for the actual turn sequence I always preferred how it was in 5th.
 
Does anybody here play together, like in the same gaming club? If not, then even if the lot of us could come up with a pile of house rules we all liked together, then it wouldn't mean anything. We couldn't take it to anyone else to play. The internet has enough go-nowhere 9th edition projects. Play 8th or don't. Play some earlier edition if you want. Discus house rules with the people you actually play with. But there is no universal rule set any more, nothing you could take to a store looking for pick up games with, and there isn't going to be.
 
Fair point Quinten, it's too hard to innovate within a commitee, in the end you need one vision to get anywhere with a new project. I was hoping that the new ruleset would be a mod for 8th rather than a less recognisable version of Warhammer, but I know there's a lot that people would like to change...

As far as the validity of the project goes, it's true many of us may never meet, but it's a fun project that judging by the talent available on this forum, could well develop into something bigger if successful. The universal rule set is the 8th Edition rulebook; let the best mod win!
 
Does anybody here play together, like in the same gaming club? If not, then even if the lot of us could come up with a pile of house rules we all liked together, then it wouldn't mean anything. We couldn't take it to anyone else to play. The internet has enough go-nowhere 9th edition projects. Play 8th or don't. Play some earlier edition if you want. Discus house rules with the people you actually play with. But there is no universal rule set any more, nothing you could take to a store looking for pick up games with, and there isn't going to be.
While I agree that it is unlikely to hit it off as a "universal" rule set, and certainly it is unlikely that you'd end up finding strangers who subscribed to the rules we on CN agreed upon by chance, it isn't a fruitless discussion as game design in general is quite interesting. It also helps players develop arguments over why something is or isn't better (A certain way to play the magic phase for example) which could then be used, at the very least, to sway the opinions of those who they can play with at a local club.

I think the discussion of rules is a fair debate to be had almost always. Although I also don't think we're going to break magic ground that doesn't exist, and strike it big with a rule set that everyone falls in behind, with CN being a glorious savior to the masses of disgruntled players.

On a side note, I actually did play against another member of CN once, without knowing to have been at the same FLGS as him. I recognized his models instantly from following his Plog, and knew he was someone I knew on CN. It was kind of funny. Although I don't think Warhammer has that much of a following around here much at all anymore. Even my FLGS never really had a following, though they have play space open for up to 6-8 matches at once. Rather the times when the game was organized and played it was a group of players from across my state that all were part of a facebook group/organization. It wasn't just a facebook thing, but I know they often set things up with it (Not really sure, don't have facebook). It'd actually be fairly interesting to see how that group is doing with AoS, if they've decided to just bail on Warhammer or try to start up something for AoS.

Either way, I still support the notion that a discussion of what makes.. or made.. warhammer good is not a bad thing.

Well I actually like how in warthrone you alternate units rather than alternate armies. I think it can lead to a far more tactical game.

As for the actual turn sequence I always preferred how it was in 5th.
I am personally a huge fan of that style of interaction as well. Most notably Malifaux uses that sort of activation sequence, and I love that game. I also just started looking into Wrath of Kings (The CMON ks'd game), and it uses a similar turn structure, so I'm quite excited to see how that works out. Though I have no idea when I'll be able to get a match of that in any time soon, perhaps once I have an army or two put together so I can bring both and.. well essentially demo.. the game with strangers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet
Do you alternate units in warthrone? I thought it was player a moves. player b moves. player a shoots. player b shoots. Sort of thing.
 
Well it says you alternate playing in each phase, I assume this means units, I could be mistaken.

@Tawg I had a quick look at that, haven't got time to read the rules but the models do look nice! It's great to see more wulfen style models being made :)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu