So after seeing threads like Najo might be crazy and Fixing the holes in 8th I decided to throw out an idea regarding this topic. We host a competition, at Carpe Noctem, in which users can submit their own versions of ninth edition (Just core rulebook). We then, debate, come to a consensus or somehow decide on which version has the best FOUNDATION (not just choosing the most polished and complete one) and work towards improving that edition. We can assign people who know armies to work on armybooks (I'm sure we have representatives of every army) while polishing up the main rules.
I feel this would work better than a giant user input free for all as it would be much more focused, but work better than a one guy does everything. Besides the obvious time saving advantages this would offer all the great ideas that come out of brainstorming but save a lot of hassle. I know I started writing a ninth edition and would be exited to see what Najo could come up with.
A good ninth would include good concepts from various editions as well as good concepts from other games such as KoW and AoS while still being streamlined and easy to play.
Thoughts? o.o
*Edit*
The top choice in poll should read there not their.
I feel this would work better than a giant user input free for all as it would be much more focused, but work better than a one guy does everything. Besides the obvious time saving advantages this would offer all the great ideas that come out of brainstorming but save a lot of hassle. I know I started writing a ninth edition and would be exited to see what Najo could come up with.
A good ninth would include good concepts from various editions as well as good concepts from other games such as KoW and AoS while still being streamlined and easy to play.
Thoughts? o.o
*Edit*
The top choice in poll should read there not their.
Last edited: