What would you change about the new book?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Von Calyptra said:
I want the rest of the bloodlines back, particularly the Necrarchs and Lahmians.
Seconded. They made all the vampire characteristics a large hotpot, where everybody can take everything... It is so good that there is already someone who works hard to bring the bloodlines back to us - have a look at the "Bloodline Legacies" in the Necrarch workshop! It's an amazing undertaking.
 
I want vamp's to be able to make units march. Simple.

Ghouls have their role, I dont use more than I need to and I don't think skirmish would help them. I miss my skirmishing wraiths more.

I always though frenzied knights was fluffy and characterful for our army.

I too wish the horrors, and terrorghiest had a better regen save. We're saddled with it as is because of our magic, but that's too unreliable for them.

Black Coach :'(
 
After playing my first tournament with the Vamps things I would like different
1) Banshee's scream should affect all units within range or something like that. It's a bit weird that it his one unit but not the guys standing in front of them.
2) Zombies need some sort of rule which makes deploying them in a horde a good idea. Maybe a maximum limit on crumble?
3) I'd like some Skeleton light cavalry, skeleton archers, skeleton war machines
4) I think several of our units shouldn't be undead- Fell Bats, Bat Swarms, Dire Wolves, Ghouls, and perhaps controversially vampiric units.
5) I don't think invocation should bring back D6+lvl grave guard. Every time I did this I felt like a cheesy git.
6) I'd like to see a unit of Newby Vamps. Come in units of 5. Be like WS2, S8, T2, I6, A3, Ld 3. Give them Hatred, Frenzy and choice of great weapons or additional weapons and red fury. So basically massive glass cannon. Could be fun.
7) Fell bats could be T4
8) Vampires should be able to turn enemy characters. Like if you slay them in a challenge they move into your unit. Also it would be cool if you could cast a hex on the enemy so every time you kill any of their models they immediately turn into zombies would be cool
9) Change the way crumble works so it does a total amount of wounds which you can allocate. So say you are fighting a unit of swordmasters with a unit of zombies and a unit of grave guard. You lose combat by ten. Ten Zombies die, the grave guard are fine. Otherwise you can't really bother combo charging anything.
10) I think necromancers should be a bit more different to vampires. Having the same spell casting abilities seems a bit weird to me. I think Necro's should be more like a unit champion upgrade. Who only know invocation but can cast it on a 3+ but only with one dice.
11) It should be easier to take a Vampire with Red Fury and Forbidden Lore (Beasts) as this combo would rock.
12) Scenarios do not work because we have to stick all our units near the general and other armies don't.
 
Bounce said:
Zombies need some sort of rule which makes deploying them in a horde a good idea. Maybe a maximum limit on crumble?

I don't know about that. They are meant to be cheap tarpits so if they were also somehow good in combat they would be really undercosted as they are now.
 
I don't think they should be good in combat. They should just be better off deployed in horde formation because they are a horde.
The game seems silly when I have a unit of zombies five wide and my opponent has multiple white lion hordes.
 
Zombies are fine. Field em so they receive fewer attacks. Horde is for maximising attacks. I don't see zombies benefiting from that.

Skelletons on the other hand seem meh to me now. I have 50 of them and I'm not sure about how to use them anymore.
 
Thats what i mean a horde should not be for maximizing attacks it doesn't follow reasonable fluff. A horde should be so you can fit a ridiculous amount of really rubbish troops on the board.
 
I absolutely agree with Bounce here. Every piece of Zombie fluff ever written, has their main advantage being the numbers to slowly surround and overrun the enemy formation, but the game mechanics of the zombies don't take this into account at all. We now field them in nice orderly marching columns instead, which is more than a little at odds with the fluff... This CAN be fixed by modifying the game mechanics of the zombies themselves, so it is not really the fault of the BRB as such.
 
There is a simple way to fix zombies so they are flullfy:

"all zombies are toughness 1"

Before you dismiss this I add the following.

"for every 2 ranks they increase their toughness by 1 please note this is rule does not work if fighting none infantry or cavalry eg. Ogres etc"

Simple and fluffy
This emphasises that they have the ability to overwhelm people and thats how they tend to be successful
 
How about something like this special rule:


Relentless Tide!: Zombies press on, without any concern for themselves or their fellow zombies at all, making them a very daunting prospect to face if the Zombies outnumber their foes.

A Zombie Horde unit counts as having the Fight in Extra Ranks special rule. Note that Horde here refers to the unit name, not the Horde special rule.
If a Zombie Horde has more models in their front rank, than the total number of enemy models facing their front, then each combat resolution point for having additional ranks are doubled, to a maximum of +6.

This does the following:

A: Encourages you to use them in proper hordes, ten or more wide.
B: Use them in large numbers to get the most out of the extra attacks and possible double rank bonus.
C: The increased damage capacity, and possible double rank bonus, help protect them from crumbling as fast as they do today.
D: Makes it hard to deal with large zombie hordes, but easy to take on small ones (which it should be, as taking out zombies that you outnumber should be a breeze for most halfway competent warriors of the warhammer world).

This is part of my solution to the issue for the Bloodline Legacies project.
 
I reckon zombies would be better if they were stronger for more zombies you had in a unit, so for every rank they increase their WS ,T or something as after all zombies are pretty weak on their own but a whole horde of them can drag down anything, of course as the size of the unit decreases the zombies get worse in combat while if you increase them with magic they become very hard to wipe out fully
 
I think the best way of representing the sheer numbers winning out would be to give the zombies in subsequent ranks the ability to attack. So, for every rank after the first two the unit gets to make an additional d3 attacks or something. Sure they still won't kill much, but I agree that they should have some sort of fluffy strength in numbers rule
 
I'm not sure increasing their strength is so much in line with the fluff.
I like CB's d3 extra attacks, but maybe after the fourth rank. Combined with a rule like this may be quite interesting:
Each enemy unit engaged with a unit of zombies at least 40 strong has their T value reduced by one, representing the stamina expended in fighting off a relentless horde.
 
Or perhaps over 40 they get a big hit to their fear tests? Like they can't use inspiring presence or hold ground because they're so terrified by the endless numbers of unwavering dead

That would be cool...
 
I have actually play tested the kind of rule with additional attacks based on ranks that Chaos Born proposes above , and the main problem with it is that in encourages the five models wide, with maximum number of ranks all too much. With no limit on the number of additional ranks, you soon start to realize that the unit becomes much too dangerous, as the number of ranks increases. You simply get a unit that can take too much damage, and dish it out all to well for such a small frontage as well, especially considering their low point cost.

On a fluff perspective, it also favors ranks instead of an "overlapping"/outnumbering from the zombies standpoint, and lets face it, a unit of something like dwarf longbeards (just one of innumerable examples) could take on zombies on a one on one basis for a long time, rank upon rank, zombie after zombie, and wouldn't rally be all that threatened unless the individual dwarfs got flanked and had to deal with lots of zombies at the same time.
 
"When in horde formation, add their current rank bonus to the to hit score. If a zombie would normally hit on 5s, and has two ranks, it will not hit on 3s.

Also, to represent the swarm nature of zombies attacking, when attacking an enemy they will roll to hit against their initiative".

Simple, zombies die just as easily, but it big numbers can be a lot more dangerous.
 
What would I change about the new book?

Give Corpse carts the relentless dead rule allowing it to march
Have a 5 point bloodline that lets undead units within 6" of a vampire to march
Black periapt should be 35-45 points
Master of the black arts should be 50-60 points
Big version of Wind of death only needs to be 21+ to cast
12" Invocation 10+ to cast 18" invocation 15+ to cast
Ghouls 8-9 points
Varghulf 150 points
Dark acolyte: Changed to allow recasting of invocation even after loss of concentration.
Skabscrath 60-65 points
Nightshroud should affect all attacks aimed at bearer
Zombie Cannon (Str 6 d3 wounds)

asome are nitpicks others make sense in the current game, it is a pretty good book overall. The Zombie cannon is wishlisting, it just sounds cool.
 
I have yet to read all the posts in this thread, so apologies of some of these have already been brought up:

1) More magic items! I know that this is a problem with all the 8th edition army books, but I'm still going to bring it up. It just feels far too constrained to me - it would be nicer to have some more army-specific options, rather than having to use the bland items from the core rulebook. I mean, we get 1 magic weapon, which costs 75pts (immediately preventing heroes from having it, and making it a terrible option on Vampire Lords), which basically has niche appeal. Couldn't we have a more general weapon, like the new Blood Drinker Vlad uses?

2) non-vampiric units can march if they're not within 12" of the general, so long as a vampiric lord/hero is attached to the squad.

3) Master Strike lets you designate a single attack to count as a Heroic Killing Blow, with other attacks being made normally (so it no longer makes the vampire [undefined=undefined]worse [/undefined]in combat).

4) Varghulf gains The Hunger ability.

5) It would be nice if Vampires and Vampire Lords had some sort of resistance to crumbling.

6) Either let the Corpse Cart march (even though it's a chariot), or make it fast enough to keep up with the rest of the army.


Fluffwise, it would be nice if some of our special characters were still alive (or, at least, as alive as vampires can get). I don't know, maybe I'm alone in this, but I just find it depressing that virtually all our characters have already been obliterated.
 
Fashionably late to the party :innocent:

The cover is awful, quite possibly the worst ever. I would change that straight away.

Overall, the book is quite bland. it doesn't have the same feel as previous incarnations. Maybe this is just because I have the previous versions back to the original Undead book, this one seems a bit "cut and paste".

The fluff is regurgitated from previous books. There's a couple of extra pages but not much new for vets to get their teeth into. I don't expect a complete rewrite of the history, that would be silly, but a little extra spice would have been nice.

Some of the new units leave me cold. The concepts are just too childish - sorry but I think the engine model is pretty awful. Not that keen on the supersized terrorgheist either. And why are the VC characters such awful sculpts?

On the plus side there is far more choice now, so players can pick and choose for the feel of their army. More choice, but less flavoursome, in a nutshell for me.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu