Will this work with Death Shriek

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Magpie said:
Death Shriek makes the qualifier that is can be used by a unit engaged in close combat, so "but by your logic the death shriek could not be used during the shooting phase, because it is being used in close combat." doesn't follow. It is being used while engaged in combat, not "in close combat"

The fact still remains that "wounds in close combat" can only be caused in the close combat phase.

But can Hex spells only be cast on a unit in combat during the close combat phase?

They too say that they may be cast on an enemy unit "in close combat". Not a unit engaged in close combat.

So, your argument that anything that doesn't say 'engaged' can only refer to the actual close combat phase doesn't hold up.
 
Vipoid said:
Magpie said:
Death Shriek makes the qualifier that is can be used by a unit engaged in close combat, so "but by your logic the death shriek could not be used during the shooting phase, because it is being used in close combat." doesn't follow. It is being used while engaged in combat, not "in close combat"

The fact still remains that "wounds in close combat" can only be caused in the close combat phase.

But can Hex spells only be cast on a unit in combat during the close combat phase?

They too say that they may be cast on an enemy unit "in close combat". Not a unit engaged in close combat.

So, your argument that anything that doesn't say 'engaged' can only refer to the actual close combat phase doesn't hold up.

That's not my argument.

My argument is : Wounds caused outside of the Close Combat Phase are not being caused in close combat as the ability to cause wounds in Close Combat is limited to the Close Combat Pahse by the rules I quoted earlier.
 
Magpie said:
Vipoid said:
Magpie said:
Death Shriek makes the qualifier that is can be used by a unit engaged in close combat, so "but by your logic the death shriek could not be used during the shooting phase, because it is being used in close combat." doesn't follow. It is being used while engaged in combat, not "in close combat"

The fact still remains that "wounds in close combat" can only be caused in the close combat phase.

But can Hex spells only be cast on a unit in combat during the close combat phase?

They too say that they may be cast on an enemy unit "in close combat". Not a unit engaged in close combat.

So, your argument that anything that doesn't say 'engaged' can only refer to the actual close combat phase doesn't hold up.

That's not my argument.

My argument is : Wounds caused outside of the Close Combat Phase are not being caused in close combat as the ability to cause wounds in Close Combat is limited to the Close Combat Pahse by the rules I quoted earlier.

However by letting the Shriek happen in the shooting phase, and while in close combat, these are wound done in close combat.
are they wounds done from close combat attacks, no, but that is not what matters.
 
TinTip said:
However by letting the Shriek happen in the shooting phase, and while in close combat, these are wound done in close combat.
are they wounds done from close combat attacks, no, but that is not what matters.

No they are wounds done WHILE in close combat not IN close combat.

By way of a gross example. There is a difference between reading a book in the toilet and reading a book while in the toilet.

The first will result in a damp book the second just means your in there for a fair while.
 
I think that it works. Every time you scream for each wound that gets dealt I think you get that many more screams. So think about it, after you scream down whatever unit you were engaged in close combat with... You now have like 5 or more screams to use on OTHER UNITS WITHIN RANGE.

So you scream at the Statetroops and do 3 wounds. Then you get three more screams. Then you get NINE SCREAMS. So lets assume the unit is dead. Now you can use any of your nine screams on their Steamtank within 8 inches. EL OH EL!

We should all thank Tintip for this super pro trick.
 
Magpie said:
No they are wounds done WHILE in close combat not IN close combat.

By way of a gross example. There is a difference between reading a book in the toilet and reading a book while in the toilet.

The first will result in a damp book the second just means your in there for a fair while.

Actually, that is a very bad example, and depends very much on your interpretation.

If someone said to me "I read this book in the toilet." I wouldn't automatically assume that they had to mean the toilet bowl.

In fact, many people say toilet, but refer to the room their toilet is in, rather than the toilet itself. Honestly, I'd read both your above statements as meaning the same thing.

Honestly, I don't think there's enough certainty in "wounds caused in close combat" for you to say that it refers specifically to wounds caused in the close combat phase, as opposed to wounds caused in close combat.

It's not helped by GW's crippling fear of consistent rules language.


Also, we're now 3 pages in and are discussing toilets. It can only go downhill from here... :clown:
 
The term "In close combat." is used multiple times through out the main rule book interchangeably with both "While in close combat." and
"Engaged in close combat.".

example:
  • pg16, Under the heading "can I charge?", first paragraph, second sentence, "The most common reason for a unit being unable to charge is because it is already fighting in close combat,".
  • pg38, under "Nominate unit to shoot", the third listed point, "They're fighting in close combat (and therefore for their lives).".

So unfortunatly (or fortunatly depending on your opinion.) it is possible to activate red fury off of a death shriek attack.

so now that that is (hopefully) resolved would the extra attacks granted by RF be death shrieks or normal attacks?[/align]

Ps: this is all just theoretical for me as I myself would never actually play it this way as it's kind of a dick move. also if you try to use this in a game be prepared to have a five hour debate with your opponent beforehand as without a FAQ this is a real hard sell.

(yay first post! xD)
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu