Wraith Scythes: why farm implements?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Danceman said:
Grim Reaper, Harvester of Souls, Gatherer of Souls and so on. Death traditionally are the ones who collect the souls of humankind and not really the fighters we see in warhammer.

Did a quick wiki search and Grim is actually derived from Grimnir which is a name of Odin. But upon further reading death's form is by not means universal. Sometimes it is angel with a sword, sometimes it is just a hooded figure, sometimes a man or sometimes a woman. At other items it is skeletal rather than human.

As in warhammer, some of our traditions are very strongly rooted and verily easily stifle out thinkng when it comes to creatures like Wraiths and so on.

Another powerful image would be the image of an executioner.
This is absolutely true, and something I thought was already apparent; I thought everyone knew that the Incarnation of Death with a scythe is but one of many. It's just the most popular form. What I am trying to do is make people aware of this and challenge their stance on the matter. If they know all this and still prefer Scythes fine; but be aware of what you like and why.

Almost all weapons have a reason for being. Whether cost, easy to train, effectiveness vs. certain enemies (pikes for cavalry, two handed swords for pikes, rapiers for plate), you can't definitively say one weapon is better than another weapon (from the same time period obviously; I would argue a machine gun is better than a flint axe). You can only say one weapon is better than another in certain situations.

My argument is that the Scythe isn't a weapon. Someone brought up War Scythes; while having the same name, they are not the same thing. At all. They merely take the blade off the scythe and attach it to a pole to make a weapon for peasants. This would be very cheap to make, and probably fairly effective. Not as effective as a weapon made from scratch for a particular purpose. Its a peasant weapon, like nunchuks were. A tool converted into a weapon. Not as effective as a straight up weapon.

@Master Vampire:
You can convert more than just models! Just ask Missionaries :D
What I'm trying to convert is people's way of thinking about the image of Grim Reaper, Death, and the idea that Wraiths emulate this. It probably happened that Death was known as the harvester of souls, so someone went "Eureka! I got it! I'll paint him with a scythe!". And then a bunch of people saw it and went... "Oooh, I get it! Harvester of Souls, and a scythe! How clever!". But its not clever, at all.

@Count Erik:
Dacian Falx; did some research, and this is a weapon built for war. It is not a scythe, it is a curved blade resembling a scythe. They did not use this weapon to harvest grain. This is not a tool, its a weapon. I'm not talking about Scythe-like weapons, or weapons made from Scythes, I'm talking about the GW scythes on their wraiths. This guy: http://www.informallearning.com/archive/1999-0506-b-scythe.JPG

Wraiths modelled with Dacian Falx's would be awesome and bad ass. At least they'd have a weapon!
http://www.theancientweb.com/discussion/default.aspx?g=posts&t=88
 
A weapon is something that someone uses to kill people. If I pick up this laptop, and start bludgeoning you to death with it, it is an improvised weapon.
A war scythe is a scythe retooled for war. Just like a battleaxe is an axe redesigned for war, and etc.
 
Well you COULD argue that you could use sarcasm as a weapon. Why not arm all your Wraiths with that? Or the crushing power of Reason to reason your opponents to why they should not be fighting at all?

I'm not saying a Scythe designed to harvest wheat can't kill. I'm not saying a Laptop, a rock, or anything else can't kill. Even a box of tissues can kill if you jam them down someone's windpipe.

What I'm saying is that if you go to War, you better not arm yourself with a Laptop. Cause a sword is going to cut your head off before you can do any damage with that Laptop. And if you arm yourself with Farm tools and I arm myself with weapons designed for war? I think you're going to be in for a world of hurt.
 
I am pretty sure an ethereal ghost with an ethereal weapon that weighs nothing but kills like a real weapon, who can also fly and go through solid matter is going to wtfpwn any guy with a sword. Unless his sword is magical and he is reallly skilled.
 
All conventional weapons i.e. everything before guns, were adapted from tools though. The Falx to me just looks like the gap filler between the farmers tool and the weapon. The point is though that Scythes (the farmers tool) were used as a weapon as were pitchforks, hoes, shears and anything else within arms reach.

A Cairn Wraith would look absolutely naff with any other weapon IMPO and against the fluff (Bound in the mortal realm to tombs and barrows, swathed in robes of shadow like visions of Death) there could really not be any other weapon choice.

If GW's Cairn Wraiths were modeled with swords everyone would bitch that they should have Scythes.:zombie1:
 
Also, if you take away gravity, weight, solidness, etc, the long blade and wide arc of a scythe swing would probably be pretty effective.
 
This is absolutely true, and something I thought was already apparent; I thought everyone knew that the Incarnation of Death with a scythe is but one of many.

Thought it was a rather fun fact to see Grim Reaper was actually a name, rather than a description of 'the' reaper as in death itself. Never really bothered to go beyond the traditional form, well, in so far as calling the other incarnations as Death anyways.

The image of the Wraiths roaming the field for a plentiful harvest of souls is pretty terrifying. Which is mirrored in the warhammer world too. Warhammer is laden with symbolic meaning from our world, ie the real world. The powerful symbol of death is probably the reason they cause terror rather than just fear.

Though a flail or axe would look pretty impressive.

I don't think anyone is disputing that it is a poor weapon of choice. Predictable point of attack and rather clumbersome would put you in situations where you would be at a severe disadvantage.
 
Also after looking at some pics of war Scythes it is quite obvious that the main reason they have been modified is for reach, the blade and shaft are still the same.:zombie1:
ai835.photobucket.com_albums_zz279_abbysal27_stuff_weapon_scythe.webp

http://images.google.com.hk/imgres?imgurl=http://medieval.stormthecastle.com/images/warhammers/medieval-warhammer.jpg&imgrefurl=http
ai835.photobucket.com_albums_zz279_abbysal27_stuff_unstraightened_war_scythe_beginning.webp


Kama are Okinawan and Japanese weapons that resemble traditional farming devices similar to a scythe. It was originally a farming implement, used for reaping crops. During the annexation of Okinawa all traditional weapons were outlawed. This led to the development of the kama and other kobudo weapons. It is sometimes known as a 'Hand Scythe'. Not a specific ninja weapon but they were definitely used by ninja.
ai835.photobucket.com_albums_zz279_abbysal27_stuff_kama.webp
 
Danceman said:
I don't think anyone is disputing that it is a poor weapon of choice. Predictable point of attack and rather clumbersome would put you in situations where you would be at a severe disadvantage.
This is precisely what I'm getting at. Some guy made a painting years ago, and it became popular. Then it sits side by side with our image of death. We think the Scythe is cool cause other people told us it was. Is that why you buy Tommy Hilfiger, and go to the most popular clubs? No. But its one of those things that became so popular it ingrained in peoples minds. Like wearing black at a funeral. Or giving a Diamond ring (that was ONE hell of a marketing campaign by DeBeers btw...)

Who knows? If something like a Tommy Hilfiger becomes popular enough, it may well indeed be ingrained into our collective consciousness. Perish the thought.
 
I don't think anyone is disputing that it is a poor weapon of choice.
I think that if Ninjas used them then they are probably a damn fine choice for a weapon.
This is precisely what I'm getting at. Some guy made a painting years ago, and it became popular.
Maybe our vampires shouldn't have large canines or drink blood then, Chinese vampires just hop around in silly costumes and get stopped by monks attaching pieces of parchment to their foreheads.

Wraiths are Hammers version of Death and as such should conform to our visual understanding of the mythical being, Scythe and all.
Obviously only IMPO.:zombie1:
 
Remember, as ghosts, Wraiths are the embodiment of peoples' fears and terrors. If you picture Death, that is what you get. Accordingly, in the WH world where such emotions physically manifest themselves such as with Wraiths, that would mean that is how Wraiths appear. Even if it silly. Just like imagining a woman who's going to moan at you until you croak- yes, the Banshee is basically a "mother-in-law", which while is terrifying to most people, the mothers-in-laws of ages past were not actually used on the battlefield to terrifying effect.
 
Well, our Vampires don't look like Dracula, that's for sure, so some changes can be made.

And yes, I know about Chinese Hungry Dead (which aren't exactly Vampires). The missus is from Guangzhou, and I've seen Mr. Vampire. Terrible movie. She enjoyed it though.

The WHFB Vampires are not the same as our standard idea of vampires. They have made liberal changes to them; not just weapon options. If I use your logic, we should go with the standard image of what Death should be. We are not going with the standard image of what a Vampire should be, so I don't follow your logic here. There are similarities, yes, but there are many more fundamental changes to their nature than a weapon swap.
 
Count Flapula said:
Remember, as ghosts, Wraiths are the embodiment of peoples' fears and terrors. If you picture Death, that is what you get. Accordingly, in the WH world where such emotions physically manifest themselves such as with Wraiths, that would mean that is how Wraiths appear. Even if it silly. Just like imagining a woman who's going to moan at you until you croak- yes, the Banshee is basically a "mother-in-law", which while is terrifying to most people, the mothers-in-laws of ages past were not actually used on the battlefield to terrifying effect.
Heh. I'm going to model my wraiths as Ecological disasters, Global Thermal Nuclear war (although honestly how many people are afraid of this), maybe one as John Rambo....

Unless everyone's worst nightmare is a dude with a Scythe...
 
We are not going with the standard image of what a Vampire should be
Drink blood, have the ability to change form, spectral, bestial etc.. capes, red Armour long fangs, coffins. Yep they're pretty much the way Western Vamps have been envisioned for centuries.
Unless everyone's worst nightmare is a dude with a Scythe..
Not everyone's worst nightmare,just everyone's idea of Death and anything that is modeled on that image.:zombie1:
 
Well I'd like an explanation of the Hungry Dead are vampires but in another thread... from what I understand, they're more akin to zombies.

Anyways. You're all wrong. Scythes suck. Get a real weapon.
 
Grish said:
Anyways. You're all wrong. Scythes suck. Get a real weapon.

You can't argue against that! :thumb:

...And that is an awesome picture Aegis. Poor bunny.
 
Also remember that the warrior's badassery increases more the worse weapon he uses.

That one over there who killed your fellow bandit using a sword? Nice but nothing to worry about.

That one over there who did the same deed except that he was using a spoon? Better start running.
 
...I'm finding it...really really hard to keep to my promise about not letting my anger get the better of me from a few weeks ago.

Dacian Falx; did some research, and this is a weapon built for war. It is not a scythe, it is a curved blade resembling a scythe. They did not use this weapon to harvest grain. This is not a tool, its a weapon.
That's just...completely one sided reasoning. That's like saying I cant go take a war axe and chop wood with it, or I cant go take a rifle and shoot deer with it.

Wraiths modelled with Dacian Falx's would be awesome and bad ass. At least they'd have a weapon!
Yea, cus a three foot razor blade is nothing...

What I'm saying is that if you go to War, you better not arm yourself with a Laptop. Cause a sword is going to cut your head off before you can do any damage with that Laptop. And if you arm yourself with Farm tools and I arm myself with weapons designed for war? I think you're going to be in for a world of hurt.
For gods sake HAMMERS are farm tools that have been used for war!
None of your arguments hold any weight at all, it just shows you have a biased opinion when it comes to Scythes!

You say you don't like Scythes because their 'farm tools', but then why in the hell dont you like Hammers, Axes or Bows?
You say its because 'those are designed for war' but that's simply not true. Some of them where modified for war but we still call them, and consider them 'Axes' 'Hammers' and 'Bows'. English Longbowmen used THE EXACT SAME WEAPON THEY USED FOR HUNTING in warfare to devastating effect, as any French Knight at Crécy, Poitiers and Agincourt will attest.
We show you exampled of a Scythe modified for warfare, and then you discount it because it 'isn't a scythe'! Your changing the rules to fit your opinion.

A scythe can be used as a real weapon just as much as an axe, spear, bow or sword is. If you don't like them, fine, but your only fooling yourself with they idea they aren't a 'real weapon'
For heavens sake, they even included them in fencing manuals!
http://daten.digitale-sammlungen.de/~db/bsb00006570/images/index.html?seite=411

And if you arm yourself with Farm tools and I arm myself with weapons designed for war? I think you're going to be in for a world of hurt
An Arming Sword (a typical weapon in use of the 16th century) has a 3 foot blade.
A Scythe has a three foot blade on a six foot staff.
I'm going to have an advantage in both reach, and power over you, and as anyone who has any experience in mixed weapon fencing (or common sense...) will tell you, being able to strike at someone at a distance where they cant strike back is a massive advantage. Oh, and the ability to send the force of a 6+foot swing into a razor sharp metal tip will give you armour penetration your never going to get with any kind of sword.

Anyways. You're all wrong. Scythes suck. Get a real weapon.
No. I'm sorry, your wrong. A scythe is as much a weapon as any.
 
Count Erick said:
...I'm finding it...really really hard to keep to my promise about not letting my anger get the better of me from a few weeks ago.

You should want to see to it that you do though, it's really nothing to get upset about. :)

About this though...
That's just...completely one sided reasoning. That's like saying I cant go take a war axe and chop wood with it, or I cant go take a rifle and shoot deer with it.
...that'd depend on the war axe in question. The one I mentioned on the first page of this thread has got a thin and elongated head which would come under a lot of stress if you were to start chopping into solid wood with it. A more experienced wood chopper than myself could probably go about it just fine though..

Anyway, after looking into the matter more closely I've come to the conclusion that, despite how effective a scythe would be in personal combat, I'd really like to try my hand at mowing a lawn with one. xD
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu