This is absolutely true, and something I thought was already apparent; I thought everyone knew that the Incarnation of Death with a scythe is but one of many. It's just the most popular form. What I am trying to do is make people aware of this and challenge their stance on the matter. If they know all this and still prefer Scythes fine; but be aware of what you like and why.Danceman said:Grim Reaper, Harvester of Souls, Gatherer of Souls and so on. Death traditionally are the ones who collect the souls of humankind and not really the fighters we see in warhammer.
Did a quick wiki search and Grim is actually derived from Grimnir which is a name of Odin. But upon further reading death's form is by not means universal. Sometimes it is angel with a sword, sometimes it is just a hooded figure, sometimes a man or sometimes a woman. At other items it is skeletal rather than human.
As in warhammer, some of our traditions are very strongly rooted and verily easily stifle out thinkng when it comes to creatures like Wraiths and so on.
Another powerful image would be the image of an executioner.
Almost all weapons have a reason for being. Whether cost, easy to train, effectiveness vs. certain enemies (pikes for cavalry, two handed swords for pikes, rapiers for plate), you can't definitively say one weapon is better than another weapon (from the same time period obviously; I would argue a machine gun is better than a flint axe). You can only say one weapon is better than another in certain situations.
My argument is that the Scythe isn't a weapon. Someone brought up War Scythes; while having the same name, they are not the same thing. At all. They merely take the blade off the scythe and attach it to a pole to make a weapon for peasants. This would be very cheap to make, and probably fairly effective. Not as effective as a weapon made from scratch for a particular purpose. Its a peasant weapon, like nunchuks were. A tool converted into a weapon. Not as effective as a straight up weapon.
@Master Vampire:
You can convert more than just models! Just ask Missionaries
What I'm trying to convert is people's way of thinking about the image of Grim Reaper, Death, and the idea that Wraiths emulate this. It probably happened that Death was known as the harvester of souls, so someone went "Eureka! I got it! I'll paint him with a scythe!". And then a bunch of people saw it and went... "Oooh, I get it! Harvester of Souls, and a scythe! How clever!". But its not clever, at all.
@Count Erik:
Dacian Falx; did some research, and this is a weapon built for war. It is not a scythe, it is a curved blade resembling a scythe. They did not use this weapon to harvest grain. This is not a tool, its a weapon. I'm not talking about Scythe-like weapons, or weapons made from Scythes, I'm talking about the GW scythes on their wraiths. This guy: http://www.informallearning.com/archive/1999-0506-b-scythe.JPG
Wraiths modelled with Dacian Falx's would be awesome and bad ass. At least they'd have a weapon!
http://www.theancientweb.com/discussion/default.aspx?g=posts&t=88