Age of sigmar

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Currently I'm reading Quest for Ghal Maraz. It's very interesting and captivating, an all-out war in practically all realms (the most intensive, perhaps, the war with Nurgle in Ghyran, where he captured almost all the world and transformed it into some beta version of his Garden. It feels almost alive). There're plenty of intensive battles, scenarios to recreate them (or play like this), maps and different characters (including some our old fellows like Gutrot Spume or Alarielle). Without the main drawback of FB (that it was a very small and bordered world and constant and futile invasions and wars time and again felt like it's an engine that works but nothing happens) the new universe seems so familiar and yet new and fresh with almost no borders for progress and changes without destroying everything. Quite unexpected but very very welcomed.
 
Reading on, the Stormcasts invade Chamon in order to retrieve Ghal Maraz from Ephryx the Sorcerer, who wants to send it to the realm of Tzeentch where even Sigmar will not be able to take it back. Stormcasts, on their way to the Eldritch Fortress of Ephryx, find out this way won't be easy - warriors of Tzeentch try to stop them in the Shattered City, where they can prevent the enemy from making advantage from their numbers (this time the Stormcasts have come really that large), but they are utterly crushed and defeated (and some part in this takes the Silver Maiden, long-dead banshee who has some scores to settle with the servants of Tzeentch, and she helps the heroes even further up the road). Because of Kairos Fateweaver some skaven try to stop the Stormcasts in their turn - but they also fail. Warriors of Sigmar, finding out that the Eldritch Fortress is gone, roam the realm searching for it, and some forces climb up the molten solid silver falls to the Great Crucible where they find this fortress and lots of enemies up ahead. Despite heavy losses they manage to take the fight to the enemy and make their way to the fortress, crushing lots of barbarians, warriors of Chaos, chaos knights and gorebeast chariots. What's more, they destroy the keep of the local king so that is falls into the sea and sends a wave of molten silver which makes an improvised bridge and prevents the fortress from translocating due to the Alchemist's moon making silver solid again. The crusade for Ghal Maraz rages on!
 
  • Like
Reactions: El Syf
Oh dear Menkeroth, just when I'd stopped ranting! I love your enthusiasm and I'm glad you're enjoying AoS but we must agree to disagree. The designers and marketers have made their money from the Warhammer franchise, and rightfully so; now they've sold it out along with people like me, I still hope they crash and burn.
 
I understand your feelings, and also think it was possible not to destroy the world in order to create a new one. But they were in the position to do so, it's their universe after all. And yet they made a good deal of work to make the new one tightly linked to the previous WHFB in lots of ways, and regarding the new realms are next to infinite in their freedom, it's a good move. And nobody could prevent you keep using 8th WHFB edition rules to play your battles while fighting in a world that is not confined to a small bordered planet and is far more fantastic all along.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet
It's a massive missed opportunity, losing the battle game to push AoS when both systems could represent both eras in the lore. The greatest shame for me is that apart from the crazy costs of their recent releases, the rift between the games systems has left me cold on the new lore.
 

I think the problem with this is this is that it acknowledges that AoS has absolutely no legs as a competitive game AT ALL. Even casually competitive games are laughably broken.

So who is going to play it? Shits and giggles players will play it. People who are really just down for having a laugh and rolling some dice and really truly don't care about who wins.

But those people aren't going to spend the dollars to play something like AoS when there are other games like Yahtzee or Monopoly available.

Fair play to people who like AoS. I just think the lore is silly, the models are silly, the gameplay is silly, and the army-building is silly. It has no attraction for me on any level.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Draykorinee
I largely agree with Blutslauger, although from my understanding of the matter most competitive players are happy to comp the officially backed option. The real problem is there are more balanced systems to compete in, more immersive worlds to engage with, many cheaper games to pass the time with, and more principled companies to back.

I believe that GW are more than ever in the market of selling a passable but overpriced product to people who don't know better. They're lucky to have the loyalty of even a percentage of their veterans.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blutsauger
It's a massive missed opportunity, losing the battle game to push AoS when both systems could represent both eras in the lore. The greatest shame for me is that apart from the crazy costs of their recent releases, the rift between the games systems has left me cold on the new lore.
Aye, that's true, but don't be in despair and miss your chance to get into the new lore just because of this, for it's really great.

I think the problem with this is this is that it acknowledges that AoS has absolutely no legs as a competitive game AT ALL. Even casually competitive games are laughably broken.

So who is going to play it? Shits and giggles players will play it. People who are really just down for having a laugh and rolling some dice and really truly don't care about who wins.

But those people aren't going to spend the dollars to play something like AoS when there are other games like Yahtzee or Monopoly available.

Fair play to people who like AoS. I just think the lore is silly, the models are silly, the gameplay is silly, and the army-building is silly. It has no attraction for me on any level.
I understand why, but let me assure you, you're wrong. Completely, especially in lore, for WHFB was small, confined, bordered and predictable, with endless invasions being nothing at all in the end. ;)
I largely agree with Blutslauger, although from my understanding of the matter most competitive players are happy to comp the officially backed option. The real problem is there are more balanced systems to compete in, more immersive worlds to engage with, many cheaper games to pass the time with, and more principled companies to back.

I believe that GW are more than ever in the market of selling a passable but overpriced product to people who don't know better. They're lucky to have the loyalty of even a percentage of their veterans.
Aye, but it ain't WH anywhere but here, and other worlds are mostly shallow and bleak. Any rules could be used if you wish, it's the minis (aye, overpriced sometimes here and there) and the lore which must keep you. If not, it's only excuses, don't bother yourself with them :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet
My dear Menkeroth, this is what happens when an irresistible force meets an immovable object! To you the continuity in the lore is there and I respect that, but to me the Warhammer world isn't in Age Of Sigmar either, and the only points of contact are as implausibly bolted on as an Ork's bionic eye! If everyone has a shot at godhood by being good at magic, why weren't there more attempts at achieving it? More wise words from sages preferring death to adopting the mantle of a god? And why on Earth would I, in the very common position of having a glut of models to play with and a free set of rules to at least entertain, go out and spend £50 to £100 on a story book I already have misgivings over?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menkeroth
You shouldn't either, but your collection still allows you to use it in battles untold across the realms of the Winds of Magic, which are quite familiar to you, are they not? Imagine, that your favorite Shyish wind created a realm of death, pyramids, bone-sands and desolations and you could fight there feeling like it's yours, your long missed home. Storybooks could be read on the Internet, but any rules you prefer and your models which stay with you just as usual still are eager for battle and conquest of new worlds! Just think of that for a moment :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet
I might give the stories some Internet time; I bought the AoS starter book on eBay and it did nothing for me so I reckon they got enough out of me there. As for playing in a dead, desolate wasteland of my own imagining with little company but sorrow and anguish reflected in the sullen gaze of your former comrades and no hope of change... Welcome to Legacy Warhammer! I still prefer it to the GW tables though ; p
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menkeroth
Meanwhile Ghal Maraz was finally retrieved with Sigmar planning to launch war for the Allpoints. It's even more interesting, though, that at the end of the book there're rules and warscrolls explaining. Probably all or most things and issues in rules are covered.
 
All this plane hopping winds of magic nonsense is impossibly lame, IMO. As always, opinions will differ, but I personally can't stand the new lore.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet
It suffices as it allows to make new worlds almost infinite in size. I'm glad they didn't make the same mistake twice. And it's standard for high fantasy, it's more fantasy than ever. Planescape, Warlock 2, Sacrifice - this concept is old but always works.
 
I have not read any AoS fluff but based on what I've seen here I ain't too impressed.

In a way, this world seems even more stale than before. Playing in a world of infinite possibilities sounds boring in my ears. Without limits there is no purpose. Not sure how to explain it but too me it seems they've created a world can do anything they want with but without anything really happening. In the old world there was at least always the looming threat of something happening, although it never did (until the End Times). It wills so disconnected from the real world that nothing matters. If chaos rises and destroys countless lives, there is still infinite left. Maybe I just don't get it.

Also, the thing that bothers me the most about it. What's with all these old characters that "survived" the End Times? Is there ever any explanation given to how that is possible? Not only was the world destroyed but didn't sever thousand years pass in this new world before the current date? One of the things I was looking forward to the most when reading the End Times was introduction of new special characters in the world after the apocalypse, but now it seems all the old ones are there without any real explanation.
 
One of the reasons I kinda wished they had just made up a whole new world instead of this idea. Ok, maybe nagash as the God of the dead, but they could have just ended it. We all know it's so they wouldn't get to much flak back about selling stuff that was now dead...er Deader in some cases, but in the end I would have been fine with just a whole new fantasy era world without sigmar, mork and such.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet
While we're arguing on the Age itself, the second part of the searching for Nagash is out and called Sands of Blood. I'm excited about what's next!
I listened to it. It's really neat, mild spoilers for it:
there's a desert made of dried blood, some more humans with a female warrior leading them. There's also this neat pacificst vampire cult.
I really enjoyed it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menkeroth

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu