Forge
Crypt Horror
Gladius Rex said:You seem to have this impression that the people in my store are not playing for something. We do have a league that runs in 2 month spans. Prizes are store credit. Whoever wins the most games places first. Second goes to the person who played the most games period, and third goes to the person who has played against the most number of different players.
Now when I line up on the table against a foe, I don't typically give them the same look twice. Sometimes I run the very GG heavy list that you run. Sometimes I don't. Since all our battles are scheduled ahead of time, and 80% or better are just pitched battles and a known point value, my opponent can never rely on how much shooting to bring against me. My HE friend did try some seaguard in a recent game, but it didnt do him alot of good. My OnG friend brings doom divers and spear chuckas, he just never seems to hit with them. Maybe when he gets his new book (which I hear is today) he will make me change my tune when I play him next.
I think if there is anything at my shop that causes our games to steer away from shooting, is the presence of Warhammer 40K.
Warhammer 40K (from what I see at my shop) looks like a pretty heavy shooting game. So at my shop, if you like shooting, you go play with the 40K people where shooting is king. If you like close combat, you go play Fantasy.
Not suprising, the couple of people who do both 40K and Fantasy... play Dwarves and Dark Elves.
So i wouldn't say that it is an issue of competitive, or their not caring if they win or lose, or them just not trying, I think if my local metagame differs (which we all know everyones metagame is different) it differs in that the people there use magic as their ranged far more than they use shooting. Either way, my Blood Knights come out unscathed. I am also pretty sure that my game shop is not unique. It may not even be the minority. There are 4 game shops within an hour of me that i know of, and from what I gather, none of them sound anything like what you are speaking of, Forge.
I can agree with you, that the way you talk, shooting plays a HUGE roll in your local metagame. that would make any unit susceptable to shooting seem less viable.
I guess in the end every player who reads these forums has to take into account their own local metagame. It is mentioned in EVERY single thread that goes for more than 10 posts at some point or another, that your local metagame may not allow for a certain tactic. The armies you see at your shop may alter your perception. I think these things are all givens. Anyone who is taking ANY advice on this forum as 100% guarantees for success without first taking into account their local metagame is asking for trouble. So that being said... my advice stands.
Blood Knights CAN work as a hammer unit. You just have to go about it differently than if you are going to go the easier route of using GG with GW as your hammer unit.
this is where our stores differ entirely, I have no idea who im playing in advance most the time, and even when I do I dont tailor my army to beat them, I play fantasy in the off days to practice for the tournament each month which features pretty much every army and I dont see half the guys that play in the tourny until tourny day because they live 40 miles away. I build all comers lists, my opponents do the same. I could tailor armies to people and absolutely massacre them but O dpmt think its in the spirit of the game and takes the challenge out of making lists. My local WoC player tho who hasnt been able to beat me in awhile is starting to add in hell fire sword, fire banner and fire spells just to get me haha, but chances are in the tourny we wont play because his tailored list will lose to someone else and we wont end up getting paired up. as for your store situation this is my opinion, which is based just off what you've told me.
Im sorry, but if your skaven player isnt playing shooting heavy, your HE player isnt playing lots of WL and sea guard and ballistas, and among the other armies you play against dont take their uber cheap artillery, they arnt playing NEARLY to their potential, ive seen a skaven player wipe a WoC army off the table second turn just from shooting and magic. artillery is 100 billion times better this edition, and if players are playing to their full even half their potential they should have enough power to wipe a 5 man blood knight unit from the face of the table turn 2. Ive lost more then 4 blood knights a turn from most armies out there, I play ALOT of games.
I never said blood knights dont work, I said 5 blood knights is impractical and will usually fall no matter how hard you try to protect them, since LoS is really not an issue these says, and cannons and stone throwers dont care.
Math wise and experience wise to everyone else but Gladius, take 7 at least with a lord with blood drinker and banner of blood keep(no champ unless you get some more knights), this is why.
1: You should keep up your Look out Sir until you reach combat, losing your 400 point character is all bad.
2:why a lord? A thrall only has 3 attacks, and wont have red fury so the needed power to keep your knights up cant be fulfilled by this guy as strength 5 isn't that great.
3: your knights will be able to see combat reliably against even some of the most shooty armies
4: you can lose 2 before you start losing 3 attacks a pop reducing the killing efficiency of blood knights (thats why your buying them right?)
Why you might as well take 9
1: its only 110 points
2: you add to your survivability from shooting and if a close combat goes bad
3: you can survive getting charged in the flank(which will probably happen because of frenzy)
4: You can now break ranks
So why pay the extra 110 points over what I would say is "Minimum"?
Your 110 extra points buys you the ability to have your blood knights survive longer, more attacks, +1 combat resolution, breaking ranks, and being able to function on their own rather then wait for infantry, reducing the damage taken from shooting. it also means you can charge anything and do ok rather then having to think if you will survive that charge, at this point you might as well charge straight ahead into a unit, just because once you cut it down you dont get charged in the flank, although a flank charge is ideal because your likely to break the unit right there, just make sure you contemplate the overrun otherwise it could be the end of that unit, I always make way with my vamp lord tho so my unit takes less blows.