8th Edition Blood Knights - More Viable?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Gladius Rex said:
You seem to have this impression that the people in my store are not playing for something. We do have a league that runs in 2 month spans. Prizes are store credit. Whoever wins the most games places first. Second goes to the person who played the most games period, and third goes to the person who has played against the most number of different players.

Now when I line up on the table against a foe, I don't typically give them the same look twice. Sometimes I run the very GG heavy list that you run. Sometimes I don't. Since all our battles are scheduled ahead of time, and 80% or better are just pitched battles and a known point value, my opponent can never rely on how much shooting to bring against me. My HE friend did try some seaguard in a recent game, but it didnt do him alot of good. My OnG friend brings doom divers and spear chuckas, he just never seems to hit with them. Maybe when he gets his new book (which I hear is today) he will make me change my tune when I play him next.

I think if there is anything at my shop that causes our games to steer away from shooting, is the presence of Warhammer 40K.

Warhammer 40K (from what I see at my shop) looks like a pretty heavy shooting game. So at my shop, if you like shooting, you go play with the 40K people where shooting is king. If you like close combat, you go play Fantasy.

Not suprising, the couple of people who do both 40K and Fantasy... play Dwarves and Dark Elves.

So i wouldn't say that it is an issue of competitive, or their not caring if they win or lose, or them just not trying, I think if my local metagame differs (which we all know everyones metagame is different) it differs in that the people there use magic as their ranged far more than they use shooting. Either way, my Blood Knights come out unscathed. I am also pretty sure that my game shop is not unique. It may not even be the minority. There are 4 game shops within an hour of me that i know of, and from what I gather, none of them sound anything like what you are speaking of, Forge.

I can agree with you, that the way you talk, shooting plays a HUGE roll in your local metagame. that would make any unit susceptable to shooting seem less viable.

I guess in the end every player who reads these forums has to take into account their own local metagame. It is mentioned in EVERY single thread that goes for more than 10 posts at some point or another, that your local metagame may not allow for a certain tactic. The armies you see at your shop may alter your perception. I think these things are all givens. Anyone who is taking ANY advice on this forum as 100% guarantees for success without first taking into account their local metagame is asking for trouble. So that being said... my advice stands.

Blood Knights CAN work as a hammer unit. You just have to go about it differently than if you are going to go the easier route of using GG with GW as your hammer unit.

this is where our stores differ entirely, I have no idea who im playing in advance most the time, and even when I do I dont tailor my army to beat them, I play fantasy in the off days to practice for the tournament each month which features pretty much every army and I dont see half the guys that play in the tourny until tourny day because they live 40 miles away. I build all comers lists, my opponents do the same. I could tailor armies to people and absolutely massacre them but O dpmt think its in the spirit of the game and takes the challenge out of making lists. My local WoC player tho who hasnt been able to beat me in awhile is starting to add in hell fire sword, fire banner and fire spells just to get me haha, but chances are in the tourny we wont play because his tailored list will lose to someone else and we wont end up getting paired up. as for your store situation this is my opinion, which is based just off what you've told me.

Im sorry, but if your skaven player isnt playing shooting heavy, your HE player isnt playing lots of WL and sea guard and ballistas, and among the other armies you play against dont take their uber cheap artillery, they arnt playing NEARLY to their potential, ive seen a skaven player wipe a WoC army off the table second turn just from shooting and magic. artillery is 100 billion times better this edition, and if players are playing to their full even half their potential they should have enough power to wipe a 5 man blood knight unit from the face of the table turn 2. Ive lost more then 4 blood knights a turn from most armies out there, I play ALOT of games.

I never said blood knights dont work, I said 5 blood knights is impractical and will usually fall no matter how hard you try to protect them, since LoS is really not an issue these says, and cannons and stone throwers dont care.

Math wise and experience wise to everyone else but Gladius, take 7 at least with a lord with blood drinker and banner of blood keep(no champ unless you get some more knights), this is why.

1: You should keep up your Look out Sir until you reach combat, losing your 400 point character is all bad.
2:why a lord? A thrall only has 3 attacks, and wont have red fury so the needed power to keep your knights up cant be fulfilled by this guy as strength 5 isn't that great.
3: your knights will be able to see combat reliably against even some of the most shooty armies
4: you can lose 2 before you start losing 3 attacks a pop reducing the killing efficiency of blood knights (thats why your buying them right?)

Why you might as well take 9

1: its only 110 points
2: you add to your survivability from shooting and if a close combat goes bad
3: you can survive getting charged in the flank(which will probably happen because of frenzy)
4: You can now break ranks

So why pay the extra 110 points over what I would say is "Minimum"?

Your 110 extra points buys you the ability to have your blood knights survive longer, more attacks, +1 combat resolution, breaking ranks, and being able to function on their own rather then wait for infantry, reducing the damage taken from shooting. it also means you can charge anything and do ok rather then having to think if you will survive that charge, at this point you might as well charge straight ahead into a unit, just because once you cut it down you dont get charged in the flank, although a flank charge is ideal because your likely to break the unit right there, just make sure you contemplate the overrun otherwise it could be the end of that unit, I always make way with my vamp lord tho so my unit takes less blows.
 
This topic is 7 pages long and I read about so many imaginery situations that I actually got bored...So I will give you my opinion in general about hammer units.

I play warhammer about 10 years and took part in a lot of different tournaments (including extremely competitive ones) as well as different hobby shops, but I found out that there is one common thing between all.Every single experienced player I encountered made his list with a SINGLE tactic in mind. If you make an ALL assault army, you will include blood knights because EVERY SINGLE THING in your entire army is supporting each other. If you use a hybrid army there is mediocre support making them very likely to be butchered.

So to summarise... If you want to make a Blood Knight list you must design an All Assault one. (The flag of Blood Keep, a caster to ION & VDM) because any other way is not viable.At least to me...

But Forge plz stop saying that a unit is useless...
A Warhammer player knows that everything have it's uses...


P.S. If an entire army shots at one unit then that unit will be propably be evaporated but they will give their points back to you by covering everything else. And the better they are, the better they will last, making your oponent obsesed with killing them, thus leaving you the opportunity to lead him to tactical mistakes, and as a result you win the game... Everything is about tactics...(It's sais so in your sig Forge)
 
leandros said:
This topic is 7 pages long and I read about so many imaginery situations that I actually got bored...So I will give you my opinion in general about hammer units.

I play warhammer about 10 years and took part in a lot of different tournaments (including extremely competitive ones) as well as different hobby shops, but I found out that there is one common thing between all.Every single experienced player I encountered made his list with a SINGLE tactic in mind. If you make an ALL assault army, you will include blood knights because EVERY SINGLE THING in your entire army is supporting each other. If you use a hybrid army there is mediocre support making them very likely to be butchered.

So to summarise... If you want to make a Blood Knight list you must design an All Assault one. (The flag of Blood Keep, a caster to ION & VDM) because any other way is not viable.At least to me...

But Forge plz stop saying that a unit is useless...
A Warhammer player knows that everything have it's uses...


P.S. If an entire army shots at one unit then that unit will be propably be evaporated but they will give their points back to you by covering everything else. And the better they are, the better they will last, making your oponent obsesed with killing them, thus leaving you the opportunity to lead him to tactical mistakes, and as a result you win the game... Everything is about tactics...(It's sais so in your sig Forge)

Re-read my sig, it means, tactics do help win games, but most of the tactics you employ start with the unit choices you take, and take into account their "give and take"

coming back from a 1/4 of your armies point value lost in 2 turns is near impossible, or even someone in their right mind wrapping 1/4th of their points into a 7 wound unit.

Give and take dude, losing 1/4th or more of your army just to gain nothing back in return is not "acceptable casualties," if your soaking 600 points into a unit that will most likely be dead by the end of the game that doesnt do much damage (because your losing alot of attacks for every model you lose) your pretty much signing your own loss card. killing 600 points of your opponents army is not very easy, its usually 2-3 full infantry units, tand thats just what you need to break even!

Theoretically if your opponent knows what hes doing, that blood knight unit will not see the end of the game, even with a streak of bad luck, they should still die.

its like the old lord kroak

If he dies the best you can pull off is a tie(by ruling)
but hes so many points if he dies you more likely going to lose anyways because you cant make up the points.

if your going to buy 5 knights of some kind to go take out weak units, then take black knights, they are half the price, have ethereal movement, and have more then enough power to get the job done. but 5 blood knights will have a huge red crosshair painted on them saying "shoot me, Im an easy 600 points" and they still cant kill off big units by themselves (because they will NOT reach combat at full strength, and they cant break steadfast) and they have way more power then they need to take out the units they can kill.

and honestly, people can shoot cannons at my grave guard all day, I could care less, they are 13 points a pop compared to 55, I have alot more of them, and I get the same save as blood knights against them, and I can raise the dead with one casting of IoN.
 
leandros said:
A Warhammer player knows that everything have it's uses...
Not trying to derail the topic, but I see this phrase a lot as kind of an escape for weaker units/builds.
Everything has a use, but what you give up for that use makes it worthwhile or not. For example, bat swarms have a use: they can jump right behind an enemy unit in combat and wait for them to break... now who's excited to pay 105 points for that use? Creatures of the night has a use, to make it easier to cast IoN on bats and wolves. Who wants to give up 15 vampire power points for it?
And this same concept applies to bld knight: they have a use (beat things up), but their fragility and high point cost make them less practical to use, especially considering other units can do the job just about as well (GG, blk knights).
 
I wholeheartedly agree with you Leandros and that is what I have been trying to say on here for a while now.

What I find is also true is that if I come to the table with the same TACTIC every time i play, my opponents know me very well and will tailor their list to it. It is not rare for me to find people with the Flamming Banner now, because they know the Hoff might be there. I also tend to find alot of Lore of Fire used when applicable and even back in 7th ed before Fate of Bjuna, my WoC friend was sniping at me with Magnificent Boubos (or however that is spelled) to take out my BSB.

So if I fielded just GG every game, with a skellie bunker, and a pack of ghouls and rely on the Hoff to lead me to victory, I would probably win about 25% of my games because my foes adapt pretty quickly. If you are not mixing it up, you can expect to win your first game, and probably lose every other game til you show them something different.

I do agree that i think alot of players have a playstyle and thus a tactic that they like best and that they are the best at doing. I also think the more you attempt a specific style of list or tactic the better you get at making it work. When I first started trying to field Blood Knights (back in 7th ed) i was doing it all wrong. I was charging the wrong things, and not utilizing terrain properly, and so basically i really stunk at using Hv Cav. (i mean if you cant get blood knights to survive, you probably are not going to fare better with Black Knights) but after some trial and error, I figured out ways to get them to work. I don't think that is something that is unique to smaller game shops or non competitive atmospheres.

@Dklyn - Noone is saying that Blood Knights are the most practical nor would we make the same claim on Bats, but i think what we are saying is that you can make them still beat things up if you build a list to accomidate their weaknesses and showcase their strengths.

@ Forge - I honestly don't know what all my opponents CAN do. I know what I have SEEN them do and i know my fellow players at my game shop well enough to engage them in psychological warfare. So should my HE friend be using more Seaguard? He uses a few, but should he use more? Maybe. I don't particularly know. He claims they don't do alot and the few he has fielded didnt to much to me. He does field some WLs and he is quite good with them too (how can you be BAD with WLs right?). Should my Skaven frield field more shooting? Probably? Maybe I will recommend it to him for the next time I play him, just to see how nasty it can get. i bought the Isle of Blood, maybe I will lend him a few extra models if he doesn't have them to try it. Really in the end, I don't concern myself with what my opponent will do, I create my list with the intent of what I want to do and let my opponent worry endlessly about what he might see from me. At least that seems to be the trend and it seems to be working quite well.
 
I think a big difference here Gladius, is that for almost all advice on the forum, a couple of assumptions are made:

1) You do not know what army you will be facing.
2) No one knows who they are facing.
3) You will play multiple games with the same list.

So there is no tailoring of any kind going on. If you are playing tailored lists, then most of the advice here goes out the window. Tailored lists are a complete separate discussion I believe. So yes, if your opponent knows what you are bringing to the table, they can devise an appropriate counter tactic, and thus changing up your list to keep them guessing is important.

That said, the default for advice giving assumes the above 3 items. If you would like army specific tactics, go for it. Example: Corpse Cart isn't great. But against Dwarves/LZ the ASF on ghouls helps tremendously as you can reroll misses. Against HE, ASF won't do nearly as much. Should you take a corpse cart to a tournament? I'd say there are other options that would improve your chances of winning more.

However, there's always a locale's metagame, which is what armies and tactics are dominant, what are the armies to beat, which can influence list design.

So 7 pages full of this, and not a lot more being brought to the table. You've both made your points abundantly clear...
 
I'm pretty new to this board. I was an OnG player and an active poster on that army's board that is very similar to this one. That one seems much more "friendly" then this one. You guys are not going to convince each other that your view is correct and the other persons is incorrect. Some people will use the blood knights, some won't. Some BELIEVE they are great, some BELIEVE they suck. You can debate a thought or an idea, but not a belief. You guys obviously believe you are each right.

In closing, stop trolling and agree to disagree.
 
@ Forge If you don't like them don't use them. You do not want to change your mind, not even considering our thoughts, so it is just pointless to continue arguing.

P.S. I completely believe that everything has it's uses because there are hundreds of combinations for you to try. Take creatures of the Night for example, have you ever tried a full creatures army? (within their legal limits ofc) If not how do you know that it's useless? You have to create a mindset in which you focus around a particular tactic. Then more or less everything will fit the puzzle...

And plz don't use examples of outdated armies as an answer
 
leandros said:
@ Forge If you don't like them don't use them. You do not want to change your mind, not even considering our thoughts, so it is just pointless to continue arguing.

P.S. I completely believe that everything has it's uses because there are hundreds of combinations for you to try. Take creatures of the Night for example, have you ever tried a full creatures army? (within their legal limits ofc) If not how do you know that it's useless? You have to create a mindset in which you focus around a particular tactic. Then more or less everything will fit the puzzle...

And plz don't use examples of outdated armies as an answer

I know this will pain some people to hear, but warhammer is a game of numbers, it just is, if everything is based on a stat line or has a basis of a number it is a game of numbers. and what makes it a game rather then a "Ill just take the best stuff and win" thing, is the randomness factor of dice and certain other things, also the ability to increase your probability of winning combat by using things such as shooting and magic to influence close combat, or magic and close combat to influence shooting. also the ability to choose what faces what and on what terms (I.E Tactics)

whether you choose to throw your unit at something that numerically it cant beat is where your flaw in tactics comes, if your good at math your that much better at warhammer. given alot of people dont do the math, they do the math subliminally based on experience.

You can add and subtract support to your units, you can add in factors that up a stat, or adds another stat entirely (a ward save for example)

your all playing mathhammer YOU JUST DON'T REALIZE IT.

what makes you debate charging a unit of skeletons into a block of WoC chosen half its numbers?

answer me this please.

Math wise a unit of 5 blood knights (in a general sense here not taking your local meta game into consideration, with everything Grish said taken into account) will not survive the battle, nor will it make up for its points, infact will be a detriment to your end score.

There is a reason people take GG with drakenhoff, purely because from experience they are very good. and if you actually sit down and do the math like I have, Grave Guard with drakkenhoff are by far the best unit in the game and can go head to head with any unit in the game, and in alot of cases multiple units at once. for example yesterday my stores beastmen player charged his untouched doombull deathstar at my grave guard, first turn he loses by 4 and breaks, I chased him down and slammed into his general on chariot. compared to their point values GG are worth their weight in platinum (in game terms) unlike skeletons that would probably be worth their weight in steel (in game terms) but you get alot of them for a relatively small price which makes it ok, Blood knights are like silver, if you have a little bit of them they arnt worth much but for some reason you paid alot for them at the store(your army book), but in large amounts you will actually find they are worth something.


as far as an all creature army goes, its not possible first off, none of the core creatures count towards core, second if you did take your minimum core and then dump the rest into bats, wolves, and fell bats im almost positive youd lose. they are all strength 3 toughness 3, bloody expensive, and you wouldnt have enough break points to survive a game of blood ad glory, there are reasons no one plays a full "creatures" army, and its because subliminally they know they suck just by looking at their stats and point values and knowing the rules. simple............ as............. that
 
Grish said:
If you would like army specific tactics, go for it. Example: Corpse Cart isn't great. But against Dwarves/LZ the ASF on ghouls helps tremendously as you can reroll misses. Against HE, ASF won't do nearly as much. Should you take a corpse cart to a tournament? I'd say there are other options that would improve your chances of winning more.
Just to say, ASF is great against HE as it denies them their reroll to hit. But the overall point works. I would add to the list of assumptions that your opponent is playing competitively. If your opponent is not playing competitively, then just about any strategy can work and it's sort of a moot point to discuss what's better.
If your opponent is not playing to his potential then you can get away with less effective tactics, but that doesn't change how good they are. What I am still waiting for is a common situation or an army where bld knights will prevail and GG won't; at best it seems they'll match what a GG unit can do. Gladius had implied that there isn't one and that makes it a closed case in my mind: GG are simply better than bld knights at their job. Whether or not someone should use them at this point isn't a tactical decision anymore but a flavor one. I don't see anything wrong with someone wanting to use them; I certainly enjoy using creative list from time to time but I wouldn't recommend them to someone as a tactical advantage. If they want to try out a challenge (but not as challenging as using zombies or bat swarms) then it's a great unit for that, however that's not a tactical advantage from my standpoint.
Having said that I think there is more than one good list out there for our army and several highly effective ways to play for several environments. I have yet to even use the hoff banner, partially because my opponents always bring flaming banners just in case I do.
From a strategic standpoint, I'm just not quite sure when you would want bld knights instead of any other hammers (particularly GG) except for the most extreme circumstances, and after reading this thread, it doesn't seem anyone else does either. Therefore, my mind is pretty much settled on the matter.

"Take creatures of the Night for example, have you ever tried a full creatures army? (within their legal limits ofc) If not how do you know that it's useless?" I don't have to try something to know it won't work well. I can look at the T3 no armor and determine it won't live well in combat. I can think about the fact they only receive one wound from IoN and know that they don't recycle well (i.e. I can't rez them back), so they overall have lowest survivability in our army. That would make me ask do they at least pack a punch? being str 3 and no offensive abilities, would lead me to say nothing special no. So how would they win any combat? What would I use them for? They do have their uses, but not as a base for an army and the fact they can't win general combat is the reason why. Their advantage is speed, but you can't harm the baddest unit of your opponent with speed by itself, they need a strong/expensive support from a hammer, GG blk knights w/e. You don't need experience to see what would happen in a combat with dire wolves and bretonnian knights, or saurus warriors, or even dwarfen warriors (all common foes of mine) no matter how many I had. That's why creatures of the night mastery power is not a good strategic choice: you're better off grabbing summon ghouls/skeletons and keeping whichever is your core gong. I certainly can't hypothesize a list where creatures of the night was competitive and an all army of bats/wolves would have a hard time not being crushed.

Fun to try out though.
 
[/quote]
as far as an all creature army goes, its not possible first off, none of the core creatures count towards core, second if you did take your minimum core and then dump the rest into bats, wolves, and fell bats im almost positive youd lose. they are all strength 3 toughness 3, bloody expensive, and you wouldnt have enough break points to survive a game of blood ad glory, there are reasons no one plays a full "creatures" army, and its because subliminally they know they suck just by looking at their stats and point values and knowing the rules. simple............ as............. that
[/quote]

I said to the legal limit... You take 25% of core and THEN you fill it up with creatures... That would be fun though...

@Forge So if everything is about stat lines then Blood Knights is a great choice...
But you really got to decide is it stat line or tactics? Or both? If the answer is both, you really got to start playing with blood knights cause there are tremendous if used properly. And as I said tactics+blood knights= profit

So we agree that Blood Knights are a great investment.
 
@DKlyn - I would totally run a creatures list if the blasted things actually counted towards my core points lol. If I could make list around packs of Dire Wolves and leave skellies or ghouls at home, I probably would try it just to see if move 9 could be the deciding factor.

I also do not necessarilly agree with Grish.

You look around the forums and there is ALOT of people who post on here saying "playing Dwarves, need help" Playing LM soon, what do i do?" "need help vs Empire".

People do campaigns, they do arranged games, and even the upcoming Ard Boyz tourney at my shop in two weeks, I already have the attendance roster for.

To say that people NEVER know who they are playing is perhaps true at your game store, but I don't think that any advice can be assumed unless the OP states such. If the OP says (2k game, all comers) then sure, throw GG at it all day long, but if someone asks generally IF a unit can be used effectively, I always keep all scenarios in mind, thus you will notice that i have said repeatedly, that in tournament situations, you may want to go with the safer choice of GG.

When I decide to take Blood Knights as my hammer, it is not a decision made where I feel that I have to quantify some advantage over the GG. If I take Blood Knights its typically because I know if I use them right they will do the job I need them to do. Would GG do the same job? Probably, but thats not really the issue. Noone is saying that GG are horrible, but I don't think we can outright say that Blood Knights are horrible either, you just have to treat them differently.

Now having said that, there are a couple of mathmatical advantages to Blood Knights.

Advantages of Blood Knights
-higher move value + Swiftstride feature, making flank charges easier and overruning easier.
-better AS than GG
-higher ws than GG
-more attacks then GG and at 1 higher strength on the charge - better at breaking opponents on the charge
-can actually go first via VdM or Corpse Cart, GG can only go on their initiative if not last.
-count as vampires for the purpose of marching
-come standard with a 4+ ward vs ranged banner, no extra character required for that bonus
- champion can take a 25pt magic weapon

So to say that there is NO advantage to Knights is untrue. You can say that you don't care for the advantages and that is a matter of opinion and you are welcome to it, but it doesnt make it bad advice to say that if a person wants to utilize the advantages of a unit or build a list around it, that they can make it work.

Advantages to Grave Guard
-easier to raise with IoN
-higher strength after round 1 of combat with their GW
-10 models or more can cause disruption if you get into a flank with them
- more capable of head on charges
- Banner of Burrows allows them to hit on 3+ without aid from a character, even with their crappy ws of 3.
- they have killing blow - very useful for killing opposing characters
-special choice as opposed to rare - easier to field in smaller point games
- Look Out Sir rolls

in my opinion, those are the list of advantages straight up unit to unit comparison. If you start getting into discussions about the Hoff, Helm of Command, Blood Drinker.... then you are not so much arguing that the unit is better, you are arguing the magic items or characters are better when geared certain ways.

Some people dont prefer the Helm of Command because they dont want to feel like they have to keep their Lords Combat stat line out of combat. Some wont field the Hoff because they would rather equip their WK BSB with magic items, or because their foes pack alot of flamming attacks.

So if you take your 400 points of GG and you want to compare them to the 5 knight unit of blood knights, thats well and good, but if you toss in a WK BSB with Hoff, you are adding in 200 points, then a Lord with the Helm of Command (by the time you are done) is going to add in another 300 to 400 points.

Now you are talking about comparing 1000 points worth of unit + characters to achieve x, y, and z bonuses. Do those bonuses work, sure they do, but it is 1000 points of investment, so should that outperform a unit of 5 knights at 400 points (hell even 600 points if you add in the mounted thrall with blood drinker)? Absolutely. If it didn't then we would be in real trouble as Vampire Counts if our Vampire Lords and our BSBs were that worthless.
 
as far as an all creature army goes, its not possible first off, none of the core creatures count towards core, second if you did take your minimum core and then dump the rest into bats, wolves, and fell bats im almost positive youd lose. they are all strength 3 toughness 3, bloody expensive, and you wouldnt have enough break points to survive a game of blood ad glory, there are reasons no one plays a full "creatures" army, and its because subliminally they know they suck just by looking at their stats and point values and knowing the rules. simple............ as............. that
[/quote]

I said to the legal limit... You take 25% of core and THEN you fill it up with creatures... That would be fun though...

@Forge So if everything is about stat lines then Blood Knights is a great choice...
But you really got to decide is it stat line or tactics? Or both? If the answer is both, you really got to start playing with blood knights cause there are tremendous if used properly. And as I said tactics+blood knights= profit

So we agree that Blood Knights are a great investment.
[/quote]

Point cost dude..... amount of wounds, grave guard are more likely to deal out wounds in addition to having killing blow and 1/4th the price, and will be dealing out more attacks as well since you will be fighting with at least 10 models when you get to combat.

you and gladius are both horribly hard headed.

spending extra points on a helm of commandment is something every VC player should do anyways, buying the hoff banner BSB equals about as much as a thrall with blood drinker so I dont see your point.

Overall the grave guard will deal more damage, take less damage, and be more resistant end game and can clash head on with anything in the game.

to say blood knights in a small number is anywhere NEAR as good as grave guard points for points shows your ignorance.
 
Excuse me but I am not hardheaded. I agree to disagree and that's that. (and I enjoy teasing hardheaded people to be honest:lol:)
Afterall it is just a game...
I don't want to prove you wrong, I won't you to stop trying proving us wrong and stop taking so serious.

And for your information a friend of mine went to the Greek Warhammer Tournament last year (8th ed) playing VC and he came 2nd (out of 64 people)... Using Blood Knights... And believe me tournaments here are very competitive.
So I suggest that you should at least try them (because I have this feeling that you have used them 1-2 times had bad results and you just dropped them.) and then we could continue this discussion.

Finally I would kindly ask you not to call me ignorant. It is rude. And rudeness is weakness, it just shows that you are out of arguements.
 
Gladius Rex said:
@DKlyn - I would totally run a creatures list if the blasted things actually counted towards my core points lol. If I could make list around packs of Dire Wolves and leave skellies or ghouls at home, I probably would try it just to see if move 9 could be the deciding factor.


You look around the forums and there is ALOT of people who post on here saying "playing Dwarves, need help" Playing LM soon, what do i do?" "need help vs Empire".

To say that people NEVER know who they are playing is perhaps true at your game store, but I don't think that any advice can be assumed unless the OP states such. If the OP says (2k game, all comers) then sure, throw GG at it all day long, but if someone asks generally IF a unit can be used effectively, I always keep all scenarios in mind, thus you will notice that i have said repeatedly, that in tournament situations, you may want to go with the safer choice of GG.

Sure you can run a creature heavy list, but I don't see it working in a competitive environment. If it does, let me know in another thread, as I'd be interested in hearing what the hell happened. Raising only one at a time with IoN really kills that strat for them as a base, even if dire wolves worked for core.

I think what's safe though is if you don't mention a specific army, then it's assumed that you're making one against an unknown army! Sounds reasonable to me :D.

Ok so I tried posting using color to comment on your post so you'd see what exactly I was referring to without using a million quotes but it won't lemme post... so here's everything I wrote in a jumbled mess and just know it's referring to something in your posts... maybe I'll sort it out in between studying for my many tests today.

One thing most people forget when comparing units is to control for point cost, and I'm afraid that's a mistake here. You need to compare 55 points worth of GG (4.2 or just 4 for simplicity) to one bld knight.

having 3 extra armor is nothing compared to 3 extra wounds from GG (4 GG to one bld knight right? :D)

The # of attacks for bld knights is a little misleading... one bld knight has more than one GG but 55 points of GG have more attacks than bld knights. However it's a little complicated since GG will only get 10 attacks and a bld knight unit will get more from the front rank, but I would say it balances out from the extra ranks GG provide, not to mention the stepping up rule, since 3 extra ranks make up for 5 extra attacks. Also GG can't lose their attacks, but bld knights can. Not a perfect comparison but pretty close. The overall is that this advantage generally speaking would go to GG IMO.

I said that "I'm just not quite sure when you would want bld knights instead of any other hammers (particularly GG)". They have advantages (speed is really the big one, summarized by swiftstride, movement 7, and vampire march) and even then they still should be near the general/BSB to not fail their frenzy tests so you can't really take full advantage of their movement anyways right?. I can't think of any non-reaching situation where these advantages would be worthwhile compared to their disadvantages. Speed is great, but I don't know when I would want to get rid of 75% of my wounds for it. Bld knights just have a lot of needs in order to be effective (need to have banner protecting from ranged, need to strike first in combat, need to have blood drinker) that GG just don't have. To just list out the advantages like this I feel is a little misleading (unintentionally of course) as bld knights have far more disadvantages associated with their high cost than what's reflected by a simple pro's list. Those disadvantages have been rehashed all over by forge in particular and ignoring them while building a list will certainly end in disaster against a skilled opponent. The fact that if you use bld knights you HAVE to account for their disadvantages, and even then you're unlikely to make it worthwhile is what makes their usefulness less of a matter of opinion and more of a matter of fact in my mind. Now if someone wants to include them for flavor reasons, then it's good for them to be aware of their weaknesses to try and cover for them and also be aware that they will be at a disadvantage. It can work but it's not the strongest way of going about it

I would add can break steadfast to the list for GG since we're comparing to Bld knights

The banner of burrows makes up for the lack of WS completely in my mind... of course throwing in the HoC makes it go even further than it would if it was used on bld knights! Compared to the blood keep banner bld knights get... it doesn't make up for the GG advantage of having 4 times as many wounds per model. This leads to another flaw of a basic pro's list: not every advantage is equal. Having the bld knights always able to march is not nearly as good as KB on GG or receiving d6 models worth of IoN, especially considering that bld knights can't really be too much on their own or else they'll start frenzing it up. Speaking of which, not frenzied is an advantage GG have over bld knights :D

I'd agree it gets difficult to compare units when you throw magic items into the mix... however it's worth noting that if you're going to mention WS as an advantage/disadvantage, that you can cover that up much easier than any other weaknesses. Blood drinker does go farther on bld knights for sure, however it's a substantial investment to get it to work effectively (kite a thrall for combat/mount) and it's not guaranteed. If someone is using a combat lord, then the WS would likely make a difference then. Hoff I would think would work equally well on both units... except then the bld knights would either give up their blood drinking thrall or have two thralls which just adds cost to an already pricey unit[

Come now, adding in 300-400 points for HoC is not a fair way to view it. You're getting a lord anyways, and a lot of magic out of it, it's a matter of if you can spare the 30 points in items or not, which in my mind is a matter of if he's a backline lord or not. No one spends 300+ points just to get hoc! That's like saying "well you have your lord casting IoN so that's 400 points..." Compare to say getting a thrall just to have blood drinker, now that's something you say you do. Therefore, 200 point investment is about fair since that's what the thrall costs and that's his primary (and almost only) function is to carry and use that blade (sure he's a lvl 1 caster two but that hardly comes into play). Same with hoff BSB, I would say the investment of 225 points is fair for him since you're getting him just for the hoff (even though you technically get attacks and other stuff too)

As I pointed out your reasoning for 1k points for a GG is soundly off as you add in way too many points for HoC, including the entire general! You're also comparing a unit with regen to one without any ward saves whatsoever! You don't have to have the hoff banner or even HoC for GG to outperform bld knights.

leandros said:
Excuse me but I am not hardheaded. I agree to disagree and that's that. (and I enjoy teasing hardheaded people to be honest:lol:)
Afterall it is just a game...
I don't want to prove you wrong, I won't you to stop trying proving us wrong and stop taking so serious.

And for your information a friend of mine went to the Greek Warhammer Tournament last year (8th ed) playing VC and he came 2nd (out of 64 people)... Using Blood Knights... And believe me tournaments here are very competitive.
So I suggest that you should at least try them (because I have this feeling that you have used them 1-2 times had bad results and you just dropped them.) and then we could continue this discussion.
I totally agree there is no reason to get heated and take out personal insults. I'd like to think most people know that my posts, while blunt at times, are never meant to be offensive. The bluntness is just a way for me to get to a point. And sure, I can tear into people's logic/post, but it's just a way for me to pick their brain. If I think someone is stupid, I wouldn't waste my time discussing with them. Just different people discussing their perspectives on a unit is all I see in this thread and it's been interesting for me.
I can't speak for forge, but for me, my attitude is I see all these issues with using bld knights and I have yet to see how to deal with them or even why to deal with them (from a strategic standpoint). GR has mentioned a lot of strats (which I won't go into for brevity) but in short don't seem reliable or realistic to me. These posts are discussing what problems I see with these strats and I hope to get feedback on how he overcomes them. Perhaps these strategies work because, for one reason or another, those he plays against don't make my concerns an issue, in which case I'm glad GR is having success but sadly common foresight lets me know the same strategies would not bring good harvest here as bld knights would aggravate my issues instead of resolving them.
Along with that, not to be offensive, but to be blunt: simply saying "my friend used them and they were great" doesn't help me. I'm sure your friend did more than simply put bld knights on the table and won. There was some clever way he overcame their problems, or some way he manipulated to make their small advantages invaluable... but I don't know what those tactics are and by simply fielding them I won't figure it out.

This isn't a matter of convincing people of anything, it's a matter to hear what worked, what didn't why it worked etc. to see what I can use in my next game.
 
its ok Dklyn, we are playing good cop bad cop here.

Blah, so.

where to start, Dklyn has pointed out the 4 grave guard for every blood knight, and come to think of it roughly the amount of points you would spend on a grave guard unit with BSB and hoff is about the same price as a 5 man unit of blood knights with banner of blood keep and thrall with blood drinker.

29 grave guard 452 pts
FC
Banner of the barrows

Wight King BSB 225 pts
Drakkenhoff

total 677

Blood Knights x 5 400 pts
FC
Banner of Blood Keep

Thrall 190
Infinite Hatred
Dread Knight
Blood drinker

total 590

so less the 100 points difference, what do you gain by taking Grave Guard? heres a pro's and con's list fro ma strictly combat stand point, it gets even WORSE for blood knights when end game point values are taken into account.

Grave Guard vs Blood Knights

Pros:
Break steadfast
+4.57 wound/wound ratio
Killing Blow
Look Out Sir for expensive characters
+3 combat resolution
Strength 6 always
4+ "ward" in hand to hand (in addition to shooting and magic, with few chances of negating it)
Leadership 9
21(24) attacks (give or take depending on the amount that get there, if you horde, which most people do, and enemy frontage)
Can lose combat without losing the whole unit due to unstable
Gain full response from IoN
Magical Attacks
+1 to hit (which is usually 3's unless presented with WS7, but if you have helm of commandment 2+ or 3+ at worst)

Cons:
Slower
average weapon skill
cant march on their own
-3 armor save
always strikes last


Blood Knights vs Grave Guard (5 blood knights with character)

Pros:
Faster
can claim 4+ ward from flaming attacks
+3 armor
strength 7 on the charge
Iniative 4

Cons"
Frenzied (must overrun and must test to restrain a charge)
-4.57 wound/wound ratio
No ward in hand to hand
No Look out sir on expensive characters
May only gain one wound from IoN
Ld 7
Must answer a challenge
Takes dangerous terrain tests unlike infantry
(19)Loses 3 attacks for every model lost due to time spent out of combat (a variable)
Cannot break steadfast
Cannot afford to lose combat even by 1
The character is vulnerable in hand to hand
Vs strength 5+ models in hand to hand the unit's survivability dwindles


If I added in all the math on the ease to kill each one of these units you would find Black knights are a better choice or dumping the points into something more useful. you can have 21 barded Black knights for the price of 5 blood knights and a thrall. something to consider if you must run cavalry. as far as helm of commandment being a factor or not, id consider it a factor to and infantry unit, only because its one of those things MOST vampire count players dont leave the house without and is usually kept in range of of grave guard and your support blocks. there are few occurrences that helm of commandment does not lend a hand on my grave guard if they are in combat, and even fewer chances of my helm of commandment not being useable at all, and as a note I usually take the support caster vamp I always plan on taking anyways with a forbidden lore and helm of commandment. so it is a cheap 30 point tack on for an item id pay 100 points for.
 
Dklyn said:
Along with that, not to be offensive, but to be blunt: simply saying "my friend used them and they were great" doesn't help me. I'm sure your friend did more than simply put bld knights on the table and won. There was some clever way he overcame their problems, or some way he manipulated to make their small advantages invaluable... but I don't know what those tactics are and by simply fielding them I won't figure it out.

The whole strategy works like this...

1 caster lord (lore of shadows)
1 cc thrall
5 blood knights (flag of blood keep)
10 wolves
20 gg

The caster lord casts hexes on the enemy unit (While being inside the blood knights)... You switch places with thrall that is inside the gg (lore of shadows special rule)... You use the wolves as a screen charging the weekest unit so your enemy cannot use them to lure your frenzied knights.And you charge with the BK. Then you VDM your grave guard units (with a necromancer or whatever you like) charging the enemy thus supporting the Blood Knights.
He gave his caster lord MR(2) thus improving the ward saves of the BK protecting them from magic...

That's pretty much everything...
 
Stop the madness! Stop the trolling! We all play the same army, try and show some solidarity. Agree to disagree and move on.

Moderators lock this thread I do not think it will serve any more purpose. When a "discussion" degenerates into name calling it is time to stop....

BTW Zombies are the best choice for our army so you are all wrong!!!! :perv:
 
There is no trolling going on here apart from you zombieboy. this is a genuine arguement
However, I agree that this is going nowhere, and it seems everyone understands this, so why continue? you will never share each others opinions after this long
 
So I ran some Knights for fun against a potential ard boyz Empire list.

Nothing spectacular happened but I discovered that if you really feel like it you can make prob one of the most if not the most devastating on the charge, expensive (in cash and points), coolest looking, survivable and crazy units.

Note: This is not really a viable army tactic-wise, but perhaps parts of it may be useful to consider when making a list.

Vampire Lord
General
Talisman of Preservation
Dread Knight
Earthing Rod (for when i inevitably roll that 4 on the miscast chart)
Aura of Dark Majesty

Vampire Lord
Blooddrinker
Dragon Helm
Crown of the Damned
Infinite Hatred
Dread Knight
Red Fury

Wright King
Steed
Flag of Blood Keep

Vampire
Dread Knight
Obsidian Lodestone

Vampire
Dread Knight
Helm of Discord
Scepter of Stability

Vampire
Dread Knight
Dispel Scroll

Blood Knights - 12
Banner
Musician
Banner of Strigos

2162 points in one unit... def not a good strategic plan, even for a death-star.

Toss the Gen and bsb in the second rank while going 5-6 wide to keep them protected. Gives you a rank or two to play with, good protection and a couple of tricks.

The blooddrinker lord is nasty anytime, esp in Knights BK or BK:tongue: (provided your club does a 1kill - 1raised knight).


Suffice to say while nothing could dmg these guys, they cant kill enough fast enough to make the points you need to win. The battle ended pretty close as most of his points were in 2 tanks (which i dint even consider charging) and a large unit of 40 greatswords (which became unbreakable last turn)

But hey if you like the Knights, I say go for them and have some fun doing it. I used them in 7th and 8th and always find a use for them.
 
Allrighty then... Just played a dwarf gun line list and went cavalry heavy.

I... Was pleasantly surprised.

Here was what i run, roughly:
2500 Pts - Vampire Counts Roster

Vampire Lord (1#, 445 pts)
1 Vampire Lord, 445 pts (General; Vampire; Level 3 Upgrade; Hand Weapon; Lance; Undead)
1 Nightmare
1 Blood Drinker
1 Dragonhelm
1 Channeling Staff
1 Crown of the Damned
1 Dark Acolyte
1 Dread Knight
1 Forbidden Lore
1 0. Invocation of Nehek

Lord of the Barrows (1#, 255 pts)
1 ~[(^One or more selected options present a potential usage conflict]×~[(#]Wight King (Battle Standard Bearer), 255 pts (Always Strikes Last; Barding; Hand Weapon; Great Weapon; Heavy Armour; Shield; Battle Standard Bearer; Undead)
1 Skeletal Steed
1 The Drakenhof Banner

Vampire (1#, 200 pts)
1 Vampire, 200 pts (Vampire; Hand Weapon; Undead)
1 The Flayed Hauberk
1 Dispel Scroll
1 Ghoulkin
1 Infinite Hatred
1 0. Invocation of Nehek

Crypt Ghouls (30#, 240 pts)
30 Crypt Ghouls, 240 pts (Poisoned Attacks; Undead)

Crypt Ghouls (30#, 240 pts)
30 Crypt Ghouls, 240 pts (Poisoned Attacks; Undead)

Skeleton Warriors (30#, 285 pts)
29 Skeleton Warriors, 285 pts (Musician Mus; Standard Bearer Std; Hand Weapon; Light Armour; Shield; Undead)
1 War Banner
1 Skeleton Champion (Hand Weapon; Light Armour; Shield)

Blood Knights (9#, 620 pts)
8 Blood Knights, 620 pts (Vampire; Musician Mus; Standard Bearer Std; Hand Weapon; Lance; Heavy Armour; Shield; Frenzy; Undead)
1 Kastellan (Hand Weapon; Lance; Shield; Frenzy)
1 The Flag of Blood Keep
9 Nightmare

Dire Wolves (5#, 40 pts)
5 Dire Wolves, 40 pts (Undead)

Dire Wolves (5#, 40 pts)
5 Dire Wolves, 40 pts (Undead)

Dire Wolves (5#, 40 pts)
5 Dire Wolves, 40 pts (Undead)

Dire Wolves (5#, 40 pts)
5 Dire Wolves, 40 pts (Undead)

Dire Wolves (5#, 40 pts)
5 Dire Wolves, 40 pts (Undead)

Wolves slowly went across the center to see where he deployed. Gunline, 7 machines, three cannons, two grudge throwers, 2 organ guns. Runes everywhere, anti magic heavy, heavy shooting in general.

Cavalry went up the right side of the board on the first turn, with the wolves moving up and around them. The infantry went up the left side of the board. A bunch of things for him to shoot at, spread out fairly nicely. Got Boosted pha's protection off, protecting knights and all the wolves. He spent his turn shooting at the infantry, and killed roughly 10 ghouls from both units and 15 skeletons. Second turn knights hit his iron breakers in the front, he stopped my magic phase entirely. Blood knights more or less slaughtered the unit. I lost two knights to his return hits, and i killed 17. Get of two charges with wolves at one cannon and one thrower. other side advances further. He was stubborn for breakers, then, his turn. He flank charges me with a 25 block of warriors with great weapons. I get back two of my knights with my lord, they go in the back of my long line and get shifted over to his dwarves. They kill 5 to that side with horses, and i wipe out the ironbreakers. Win combat, turn to the warriors, facing down his line, roughly. Finish off the grudge thrower, cannon im down to one dog, he has one crew. Second dog into the first cannon for a charge for me, another guy, another guy, fail one charge with ghouls, get the other off into another block of warriors. three warmachines unengaged, all but one thing of ghouls and one skeleton unit not in cc. Magic, get off two invokes into one ghoul unit.

Long story short... That damn knight unit refused to die once in close combat. With the lord in there, it refused to die, nothing he had could stand up to me going first, and hitting/wounding mostly on threes. My infantry hit his left side and tied up half his army while the wolves went for his machines and the knights ran up the right. By the time my knights came back around, everything else he had was engaged and held in place for one double run down his line, hitting one, breaking, and overrunning into another.

Knights CAN work.... Just requires your list being built to protect them... And light is GREAT for that.

BTW: Net of amyitok is AMAZING on a war machine... It auto fails it... I shut down his organ gun for a turn with it... handy, no?
 
First off I kinda like the idea of good cop bad cop with forge... "you wanna back this hard? Sign the confession or I leave you with forge. He will take out his mathhammer and BREAK YOUR KNUCKLES WITH IT!"
Leandros: why would he have anything supporting GG? The nice thing about them is they don't need another unit nearby (bld knights) for them to work well (at most, HoC)... and of course by putting his mounted lord in the GG... isn't it in CC anyways? So what's the point of switching them? And if the lord stays in the GG, doesn't he lose Lo,S making him VERY vulnerable to template/siege attacks (no ward/armor save from those!)? How did he survive those?

And once again: looking at strategy forums as a way to "convince" or pursued others isn't the right attitude.

@Mortus Once again, no one is saying bld knights can't work, it's just in any situation GG or arguably blk knights will work better. I'm starting to notice a trend with Bld knight success stories: they involve a combination of opponent's firing on infantry and insane luck (getting two wounds on ironbreakers with str 5 thrall is just unrealistic, especially without hatred. That's 3+ hit 3+ wound and a nice armor save/parry save to get through, as well as inflicting 17 wounds with the blood knight unit against ironbreakers since they have the same WS and the back row only gets 1 attack, wolves frequently killing artillery crew?). Every combat you reported had luck overwhelmingly in your favor...

What do you mean by "anti-magic heavy?" you got two spells off at critical points in time (pha and net), got two IoN off in one phase and you don't even have MotBA... either you miscast like crazy (and managed to not blow up your knights) or your opponent fell asleep during dispel. My dwarf friend's anti-magic list generally involves anvil of doom (+3 DD IIRC) and rune of balance, stealing one of my PD and changing it into a DD, giving him a hefty advantage in the magic phase even with MotBA. That would mean even if you rolled 12 PD, it would end up you have 11 and he has 10 (and that's the best you can hope for!) That's not even including all the possible anti-magic gear he could use (multiple dispel runes etc.). At the very least, he should've stopped your pha's protection, especially since there wasn't any other threatening spell for the first round (time warp/speed of light wouldn't have done much since no CC, magic missile spells are fairly weak, and net is much better option than pha).
How did you run your knights mortus, i.e. how wide were the ranks? I ask b/c I'm confused what you mean by "they go in the back of my long line and get shifted over to his dwarves."
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu