Black Knight vs Blood Knight

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Black Knights are better because they don't take up a Rare slot, which is very valuable in the VC army (while we have a ton of spare specials).

Both have advantages and disadvantages -

Blood Knights are harder to maneuer (frenzy and no ethereal movement)
Blood Knights hit harder (can take out a lot of the best units all by themselves)
Black Knights hit hard enough (good enough for supporting infantry, flank charges and eventually front charges with appropriate support of banners and/or helm and/or character)


In the end of the day I believe that Black Knights are better, because for the points with which you would take Blood Knights, you take pretty much the same number of Black Knights + Varghulf (6 vanila Bloods = 330; 6 Black Knights /w barding + Varghulf = 168 + 175)
 
Blood Knights are a tatical nuke that can win you the game if you deliver them to the right place. Just get them safely to where they need to be...they will take care of the rest.

Black Knights can only be committed in special circumstances where they have a nice safe flank to hit (or soft support troops). They just dont have enough attacks to be truly hitty. Sure, you can create a BK battle bus, but 4 vanilla BldKs are a battle bus all by themselves (esp with strigos std).

Sure, both have their uses (strengths and weaknesses), but to say Black Knights are better is nuts, IMO. I agree VC rare slots are precious, but BldK's are worth it. They have never let me down, if I haven't misplayed them egregiously.
 
Jnr said:
When will blood knights win when they get flank charged????
I mean I play them with a bsb with blood drinker and Ihate and if they get charged by lets say a unit of empire static infantry with a captain(wich isn't so hard because the empire dude WILL be able to shoot 14 wolves and 3 fell bats to bits).

Let's count: for static you have 2 being the bsb and a regular standard (if you don't play war banner wich I prefer to have on GG or skellies)
He has 3 ranks banner 1 units strength 1 flank 1= 6
Then captain challenges and attacks: 3*1/2*5/6*2/3= 0.83wounds
Lets say he kills the blood knight, if not the blood knight won't do much against1+ as
So you loose with 5 and 1 blood knight was killed so your BSB is alone against a units static infantry.

As I said before I think the optimal vampire counts build doesn't include blood knights but they are hard and fun to play with. And in some countries a complete surprise last weekend I was playing in Germany and I was the only vamp player with blood knights (there were 3).

So as a conclusion use blood knights if you want a challenge or if you like their fluff. Otherwise I would say black knights is more your cup of tea.

I'm sorry to say but thats your own fault if you get trapped by footmen.

Even so, with the proper setup you have a BsB with Drakenhoff and the Dreadknight and Walking death power. Gives you a static result of 3.

The knight will last a round against a captain, and ive never seen a captain on foot taking the armor of meteoric Iron so a 2+ save max would be viable.

My first point stands though, if you let yourself get trapped by footmen you really did something wrong.

Juli 26 we have our next tournament, i'll be sure to note my tactics and movement so you can have a proper understanding of how I combine my knights with my zombie dragon lord.

adrift said:
Blood Knights are a tatical nuke that can win you the game if you deliver them to the right place. Just get them safely to where they need to be...they will take care of the rest.

Black Knights can only be committed in special circumstances where they have the a nice safe flank to hit (or soft support troops). They just dont have enough attacks to be truly hitty. Sure, you can create a BK battle bus, but 4 vanilla BldKs are a battle bus all by themselves (esp with strigos std).

Sure, both have their uses (strengths and weaknesses), but to say Black Knights are better is nuts, IMO. I agree VC rare slots are precious, but BldK's are worth it. They have never let me down, if I haven't misplayed them egregiously.

I cannot agree more with adrift here.
 
Hermit said:
Some times I even LET them get trapped so they can hold up an opponents unit and I finish them off with my charging zombie dragon lord.
So Bloods are better than Black because your opponent failed to notice your counter charging Zombie Dragon? Riiiight...

adrift said:
Black Knights can only be committed in special circumstances where they have the a nice safe flank to hit (or soft support troops). They just dont have enough attacks to be truly hitty.
On the contrary - it's Bloods that can only be delivered to the desirable target if your opponent failed when creating an army list (no diverters/baiters in army), failed at deployment/tactics, or failed to dispel Vanhels. As mentioned above, Blacks are hitty enough.

This:
Vic said:
Both have advantages and disadvantages -

Blood Knights are harder to maneuer (frenzy and no ethereal movement)
Blood Knights hit harder (can take out a lot of the best units all by themselves)
Black Knights hit hard enough (good enough for supporting infantry, flank charges and eventually front charges with appropriate support of banners and/or helm and/or character)
Black fulfil more roles. Because Black hit hard enough. Black can be both hammer and anvil where Bloods are only hammer.

The most common Black unit you see, is the bus with at least 10 models, including a fighty character. Suddenly they hit almost as hard as the same point cost of Bloods, with more static CR and survivability. You don't hold this unit back much, you send it down enemy center and force your opponent to react to your play. You need a minimum of babysitting. Unlike Bloods you can afford to expose them to a good deal of shooting and magic without severly affecting their combat performance.

There's a reason as to why Black Knight units are punished in the swedish comp system, where Bloods are not.

No one is saying that Bloods suck. But they are a fragile scalpel and requires that you build your army around them. As mentioned, to some extent this discussion is pointless, as Bloods and Black have different roles in the army. I have army lists with both a Black Knight bus and two unit of Bloods, or two buses and one Bloods. It's all good.
 
Hermit said:
Jnr said:
When will blood knights win when they get flank charged????
I mean I play them with a bsb with blood drinker and Ihate and if they get charged by lets say a unit of empire static infantry with a captain(wich isn't so hard because the empire dude WILL be able to shoot 14 wolves and 3 fell bats to bits).

Let's count: for static you have 2 being the bsb and a regular standard (if you don't play war banner wich I prefer to have on GG or skellies)
He has 3 ranks banner 1 units strength 1 flank 1= 6
Then captain challenges and attacks: 3*1/2*5/6*2/3= 0.83wounds
Lets say he kills the blood knight, if not the blood knight won't do much against1+ as
So you loose with 5 and 1 blood knight was killed so your BSB is alone against a units static infantry.

As I said before I think the optimal vampire counts build doesn't include blood knights but they are hard and fun to play with. And in some countries a complete surprise last weekend I was playing in Germany and I was the only vamp player with blood knights (there were 3).

So as a conclusion use blood knights if you want a challenge or if you like their fluff. Otherwise I would say black knights is more your cup of tea.

I'm sorry to say but thats your own fault if you get trapped by footmen.

Even so, with the proper setup you have a BsB with Drakenhoff and the Dreadknight and Walking death power. Gives you a static result of 3.

The knight will last a round against a captain, and ive never seen a captain on foot taking the armor of meteoric Iron so a 2+ save max would be viable.

My first point stands though, if you let yourself get trapped by footmen you really did something wrong.
Ok if you get flank charged by a unit of 9 knights with a warrior priest. Is that looking better???

But still the infantry: why would you not play a mounted character in a infantry unit??? I agree, if you have the drakkenhoffbanner you will survive the round for sure but you are using the drakkenhoff banner wich people in my neighbourhood "frown uppon".
 
How are Blacks hitty enough? One attack apiece is not hitty in my book. On the contrary. I guess with the Bnr of Barrows AND the Helm in the vicinity (hitting on 2's now) AND a wight king, then they start to approach hitty... Throw in a vampire and the valuable ethereal movement is out the window.

People make it sound like redirecting is so easy. It CAN be easy, if the BldK player is a chump. But with tons of our own cheap redirecting troops (which cause fear and never run away), it gets a lot less easy; not to mention the ability to create new units and magically move them in...

Nagash bless GW for dire wolves and fell bats. They enable so much of the VC army to function. I have cussed wolves for being so completely inept in combat before, but the more I play with them, the more I come to relish their ridiculous speed, maneuverability, and CHEAPNESS! 40 points for a unit of 5 18" moving, fear causing, unbreakable, US 10 wolves?!? Booya!
 
I don’t necessarily think redirecting is easy for your opponent to do, however I don’t think not being redirected is easy to do either! :) It comes down to the armies your playing as some armies have very good redirecting troops (harpies for instance) and the relative skill of both players at using the resources they have available.

I do agree though black knights really are not all that killy without significant extra support pumped into them.
 
Yeah, I didnt mean to totally discount the weakness of susceptability to redirection, but neither do I think it is a gimme, especially with the counters VC provide.
 
adrift, I've been playing lately with 2 units of Black Knights in my infantry rooster - one unit of

6x with Banner of Barrows and Champion
and 5x with Royal Banner of Strigos + Red Fury, Balefire Spike vampire hero

When I charge the second in a unit of Warriors of Chaos, I'm confident that I'm going to break them, and that speaks for itself.

The 1st unit easily makes 6 wounds to T3 infantry with 4+ save (or even T4 for the matter), which is more than enough to have them breaking - 3 ranks + outnumber + banner for them vs. 6 wounds (5 from knights, 1 from horses) + banner = Knights winning by 2.

2 is good enough for me to do such charges head on. If they do pass their break test, I'm confident enough that my knights will survive a turn on their own and on the 2nd turn reinforcements will come.


Also keep in mind that even when you put a vampire in the Black Knights, they still are more maneuverable than Blood Knights, at the very least because you don't have to keep a unit of dire wolfs or fell bats in front of them, so they get better LoS arc AND vampire could charge out of unit, allowing for better tactical options.
All that still costs as much as a single unit of Blood Knights.




Another thing I like about Black Knights is that if you take most of your characters mounted (like I do), but intend to put them in infantry units, against certain opponents you can easily swap your strategy form Death Star-ish unit with lord and vampire, to 2 units with single hero level in them and so on; while it's almost never worth it to put characters in Blood Knights, because if they can already kill anything why overdo it?
 
How does the first one get 5 wounds from knights? Hit on 3's, wound on 2's, no armor save...that is 3.8 wounds. Horses add 0.75. Total 4.5. + Banner = 5.5

Enemy unit gets static 5.

You are on the knife's edge of losing that combat...not a good proposition, IMO. And you have to have the movement to ensure you get both corners touching. No charges near max range.

I must be missing some other factor for that to work.

4 bloods with std (240 pts versus 6 blacks with champ and barrows + musician (since it can be close!)=229; add 24 more points to get to the same 2+ armor save and you cost more than the bloods) get CR of 9.4 versus the same unit.

Sure, you need bats and/or wolves with the bloods, but it isnt like those are wasted points. They can and should be set up to fulfill other objectives as soon as the bloods are unleashed (if for nothing other than table quarter claiming, or laying in wait behind the charged unit to make sure they dont get away).
 
Yep, your right Adrift we do have some decent counters for having our blood knights baited, so less of a worry than for other armies with frenzied troops. It always makes for an interesting game of cat and mouse, with people trying to redirect your knights, and you trying to negate their efforts.
 
I don't really see why a hero that in the end costs 300 points ( drakenhoff ) gets frowned upon.

Pretty much every army has some sort of fire attacks which negates it completely or killing blow for that matter ( stupid cauldron ).

Lately we have been having a discussion in big dutch tournaments over how easily people find something cheesy these days, the end pretty much resulted in the opinion that people really cry to much these days and when they lose a battle it is hardly ever their fault.

lets say you get charged by 9 inner circle knights and a warrior priest ( which is a really stupid setup to run knights with these days).

Lets say 2 knights can hit and the warrior priest.

The warrior priest: Estimated number of wounds caused: 0.25
Knights: Estimated number of wounds caused: 0.65
Horses: Estimated number of wounds caused: 0.0625

So you might lose a knight, fair enough. Combat result:

You: Banner, BSB and Walking death makes 3
Enemy: 1 wound, banner, outnumber, flank and rank makes 5

Your BSB ignores 1 and the other has a 50% chance of surviving the crumble wound that is left. Now, which part of this was the problem ?

Next round estimated wounds:

Warrior priest: Estimated number of wounds caused: 0.16666666666667
Knights now have str 4 ( lol ): Estimated number of wounds caused: 0.125
Horses: Estimated number of wounds caused: 0.041666666666667

Your chances to wound
Knight: Estimated number of wounds caused: 0.37037037037037
Horse: Estimated number of wounds caused: 0.055555555555556

You suddenly have more of a chance to wound then the empire knights!?

This is if you were stupid enough to have nothing standing ready to counter charge.
 
I think the thing that annoys people about the drakenhof, somewhat understandably, is that it basically reduces any wounds caused by crumbling by 3/4, because you get to regen the wound and then regen the crumble. As we pretty much all know, a unit that is not killed outright can be made whole again with enough application of magical power. So the drakenhof makes it very difficult for the enemy to wipe out units in one/two combat turns, before we can start casting invocation to re-fill the ranks. This is even more of an issue on 4+ save infantry (who get D6 models back) or 2+ save knights.

Don't get me wrong, I've used it in armies, and I agree with Hermit that some people will look for any excuss as to why they lost, rather than their own game play. I also think there is usually a few grim item/units/special characters in most army books, but lets not pretent that the drakenhof banner is not a very good item, up there with the best of magic items.
 
Indeed the power of the regeneration is in my eyes, more the regeneration on crumble than the actual save you get.

You do pay 125 points just for this, which I think is a fair price for what it does. Even if it is only on 5 knights.

Anyhow, because a magical item is good it should not be used?
 
No, it should be used. Hell, I've used it in armies from time to time, so I'm definately not standing in judgement over people using it. However it is one of the best items in the game, in my opinion. It's in the same vein as Hydra's or the reverse ward save dark elf item. They are both things that I think are very cost effective for their points, and really good, but I'd still play against people using them.

On the other hand, it is kinda nice to see a really expensive banner/sword/armour actually being worth it's cost. :)
 
Wow, ok my head is really spinning at this point...I think I read the thread too fast lol.

Ok...lemme see if I can say something substantial without sounding like a total newb.

First, I am not concerned with the point differences between Blood and Black Knights... coming from an ogre background I pay 48 pts for one stupid Irongut and its only 3 attacks at WS3 with a great weapon and a 5+AS. I look at things from a "how do I kill my opponent's army with this unit."

Blood Knights kill anything they hit really, but they are fragile in the respect that it is harder to resurrect them and they CAN be baited easIER than the Black Knights.

Black Knights have the versatility of being a good flank hammer, or a head-on tarpit. But they dont have as many attacks and arent going to kill as much as the Blood Knights.

So it seems to me if you are deciding betwixt which to run (meaning "I will either run X or Y but not both") then it is a matter of how you want to win. Through the attrition of undying legions...or making your opponent a greasy spot on the charge.

Personally, I have to side with the neutrals here and say that you really are comparing apples to oranges. They both have their place in lists, and it depends on how you want to try to win. I personally think it would be cool to just field both of them and have a really fast moving knight based army that has maneuvaribility threats (Black) and killability (Bloody).

But...I am a newb to VC so I may be way off base here. I think I will point up a list with both though and post it for critiques...
 
I wouldnt call Black Knights an effective tar pit. There are not enough models to sit around and take attrition damage. They cannot afford to lose combat, especially multiple ones. They need to win combat from the first, but they need to do it from the flank to beat most ranked units.
 
I prefer Blood Knights. I was playing my buddies Demon army with BK for the 3rd time(first two times he wiped them out with no kills on their part). I took ten BK the 3rd game we played and he surrounded them on all sides with Plague bearers, Juggernaughts of Korne with Skulltaker, and Bloodletters. I thought for sure my unit Lord and BSB were gonners. In the end that entire flank was killed and all that was left was my BK after several rounds of combat. Ever since then I've used my 10man BK deathstar with amazing effect. We usually play 3k+ pt games.
 
Lord Curtis, I agree 100% with your point of view. I think it all boils down to how you want to play your army.
 
Okay my view. Get ready its long.

Many people talk about how Blood Knights are too expensive. In my opinion they only become extremely expensive when loaded down with expensive banners and characters. The problem is Blood Knights don't need either of those things to be effective.

If you look at a standard Blood Knight it basically has the same offensive ability as a Vampire with Dread Knight and Infinite Hatred. Those Vampires costs 150 points each! Sure they don't frenzy, can cast and have access to magical items but at almost a 100 points more you would expect then to have some advantages.

How about this for a cost effective Blood Knight unit:

4 Blood Knights
Standard with Strigos Banner

That will give:
12 x str 7 hits @ ws5
8 x str 4 attacks @ws3

All of them with rerolls to hit. You can't beat that for 275 points. That unit will bash anything on the charge except for tooled up Greater Ds, Swordmasters or stubborn units.

Blood Knights, rather then be too costly, are probably one of the most cost effective units in the VC list. People who stick a 250 point BSB (regen banner) and a 400+ point Lord into the unit deserve to lose. The unit does not need the extra killing power and putting such important and expensive characters under the effect of frenzy is stupid.

Now Black Knights.

Okay one thing first: Black Knights will never have the hitting power of Blood Knights no matter how many shiny toys you buy them. Black Knights can be decent shock cavalry but will never do the Steam tank destroying, dragon killing, unit annihilation that Blood Knights will.

A standard 5 strong unit of Black Knights:

5 Knights
Champion, Standard, Barding (no musician)
25 point Banner (Warbanner, Dread Legion, etc)

Comes in at 197 points (only 78 points cheaper then Blood Knights). They have:

6 x str 6 attacks @ ws3
6 x str 3 attacks @ ws2

Not quite in the same league is it? They are more maneuverable and can run through terrain but at best then will be a flank charger or archer killer.

Lets say you soup then up with a character.

Say:

Wight King (to maintain mobility)
Barded Skeletal Steed, Lance (free magic attacks and KB please)
BSB, Banner of Barrows

Comes in at 177 points

Now you have 9 str 6 attacks and 7 str 3. All the str 6 hits have +1 to hit.

The unit and character now come in at 374 points (almost 100 more then Blood Knights). They are STILL not as good at fighting as Blood Knights.

Blood Knights don't seem so overcosted now do they? Nothing in the VC list can do what Blood Knights can at the same cost.

Use Black Knight as flankers, archer killers, etc and use Blood Knights as shock troops. Neither can do the others roles cost effectively so they really aren't competing for the same spot.

Finally Drakenhof Banner.

...is (in my opinion) not worth it. Or should I say not worth it in a VC army.

Such an expensive banner can really only be used in 3 units:

1. Grave guard
2. Black Knights
3. Blood Knights

I don't like it in GG because it makes one of your slowest units (infantry, no GhoulKin) even higher on the 'do not fight list'. Everyone knows GG make killer tarpits. Hence we can bet any opponent with half a brain is not going to send his Lord on a Dragon or Heavy Cav anywhere near it. Expect a smart opponent to march block it and dispel any VHD cast on it. If they are really tricky they may let your VHDs cast on your faster units to get through to try and split up your army.

Some armies can get away with a big, slow and expensive blocks of Infantry (Dwarves come to mind) because they have a way of making your come to them (in Dwarves' case its powerful Warmachines). As a VC general though you don't have powerful missile attacks and you can bet your bottom dollar that no one is going to be chasing after your 400+ point GG tarpit unit except their own tarpits.

I don't like it in Black Knights because it does nothing to help them with what they are good at.

Black Knights are flanking. How does the banner help?
Black Knights are picking on weak, small infantry units. How does the banner help?

But it protects me from from crumble wounds!

My response is: Why is your Black Knight unit charging a unit that its not going to beat on the charge? If str 6 attacks and attacking first aren't enough to beat a unit then str 4 attacks attacking at crappy initiative (after first round) sure as hell ain't going to do much.

My second response is: Why are your grinding stuff with your cavalry when you have multiple units of 8 point itp, unbreakable infantry....

But it protects them from Missile attacks!

If your using your Black Knights as frontline shock troops get Blood Knights instead. They are miles better at it.

In addition, a 5-6 strong unit is too small to take advantage of the regen. A few unlucky rolls and 400+ points goes down the drain. So you bulk out the unit a little....

....now the unit costs over 500 points. And it still does not fight as well as the Blood Knight unit which costs half as much.

If your using them as lighter cavalry then sticking in a 250 BSB is kinda pointless. For the same points you can buy 2 x 5 units of standard Black Knights.

As for using it in Blood Knights, I have already touched on some points already with Black Knights. Basically, it does not help them do they job (kill stuff). It won't make them any safer since sticking a 250 BSB in a unit that costs 275 will make them a unit that gives up 525 VPs for 5 models. They will not survive the battle against any opponent with a pulse.

You could make a case for putting into a Ghoul or Skel unit but why put a 250 point BSB into such a vulnerable position when you could just buy more Ghouls/Skeletons? 250 points is a lot of expendable bodies.

To top it off, despite all the disadvantages, your opponent will call you a power gamer for using it!

Thus ends my overly long post on why:

Neither Blood Knights or Black Knight sucks (they have very different roles) and why the Drakenhof Banner does.
 
Only one point, you can't use the Darkenhof with Black Knights, only a BSB has enough bearer points to use it. Unless you're going to send your BSB with those units.

I would think that two units of 5, or one unit of 10 Black knights would be better than the Blood knights, depending on your army list.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu