You know,there are different aspect of the situation that ,seems to me,are always left outside of the discussion.
Let's take for example when the codex (1994) were pure fun to read,great fluff,great illustration, great tip how to fix YOUR.OWN.SHIT (base,terrain,movement trays,etc.). Yes they had some insane rules here and there,but hey, does Purple Sun of Xereus ring any bells?
Let's take White Dwarf, when was a great and necessary accessorize to the game: how to paint,battle report,Golden Daemon news,insight of the GW headquarters etc. Also when it cost wasnt a dime per page...
Let's take the miniature themselves, when the price was cheaper (we had a 4 page discussion with data and inflation rate data,but reality,as facts, are part of what googles are you given and decide to wear in life. Somebody pray a white arab with blue eyes that moonwalk on water,others a dude called Ron that wait with a spaceship to bring you home).
Let's take the miniature themselves for a moment. Yes they are more detailed and versatile,but so many details are not that important in a 150+ game as you don't and can't see them (for those who paints their miniature,not for the grey army dudes). Plus an aestethical POV, the new are too much 40k for mine and many other people taste (oh yes,those who buys GW toilette paper as well).
Now,this ETC capaign has been what we call at home "Scrape the bottom of the barrell". And for make some extra $ they KILLED the fluff and the rules, the last 2 best things that all the "HATERS" keep on loved and appreciate, but maybe they are not worthy of be listened,cause they don't invest capital money in the big mom GW. My last 5 weeks in the USA showed me very well this kind of mentality. And is exactly what me and most of "us" don't like and dislike of GW nowadays, The empty suit mentality that just keep on pushing the game on selective elite, daddy buys it, "Hail GW" kind of mentality, from their "special GW water container" to the 70$ models that you can use 6 months and than you put em on a shelf to to collect dust.
As for me I used to love GW and I used to hate em,no I have a constant mid disappointment that is transforming in calm acceptance of the End of Games Workshop as miniature company and its transformation in a toy figure collective only company. Be as it may,I care no more, my Mantic mini get compliments wherever i go ( I am the slow but persistent motherfucker that paints his mini, which is why i don't buy half new army every 4 months,if do you guys have all that time and all that money,well you should feel a little more fortunate than,let's say, 99,95% of the world population), I buy from Wayland games new minies when i like em, I buy used when i need the core to start an army and I'm tryn different recaster to see if they are worthy or not.
And to come back to topic,The ETC was probably necessary and a nice change of pace,still,after the first 2 books,was mostly garbage,on any angle, just to rush things to an end and bring down to hell the last money possible.
I hope the 9th will be good but,mark my words here, I am really skeptical any big positive change will happen. I forseen a shitstorm over the horizon worst than we ever seen,if not, I'll be the happiest motherfucker in the block.
EDIT: I forgot the main thing: the retail seller/ game house,that is as me and ,dunno at least 50-70 people from my hometown in the early 2000 got to really get into the game and start to play tournaments and stuff. GW themselves cut em out,only for ONE reason = money. They could had an even/minimum loss income from them but use em as a base to get fresh blood and show themselves.Now if that wasn't an idiotc,greedy heartless decision, I don't know what it was.