Can 9th just come out already?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Via Marcus Beli by Zamerion. The rumor comes from a guy who confirmed some things from GW, I do not care who is taking canes or who would be retail, for me it is the same !!!!

EDIT: The above sentence was not typed by Seneschal. Just an fyi as afterwards I realized it may sound a lil' confrontational

- The 9th edition of Warhammer th come for summer
- On the Bases: We play with square bases but after the departure of the 9th edition sold all models come with bases You round.
- You can play with everything in the skirmish game mode. GW will bring movement trays for this mode.
- For the listing will be much more freedom than now but using consolidated lists will be encouraged. There will be scenarios and objectives to keep (such as 40k) if you have a list of a consolidated army you will maintain the target enemy unit while having a close but instead if you have a more open not ready. They said something about a bonus points by killing the enemy commander. It will encourage play both styles but in different ways
- A new faction, the humans will consist basically of Empire, Bretonnia and some new troops confirmed. It was very clear that is not going away any army.


Via Bird in the Trees: 5-23-2015

- All books and miniatures may be used in the 9th edition of Warhammer
- 6 major factions (including combinations of independent book, see End Times).
- Some existing units can ally with multiple factions.
- The End Times sets the pattern for building restrictions armies.
- Skaven will look much more Steampunk.
- Glotkin becomes the “new” world.
- Some factions despite being playable may have an uncertain future regarding news.
- The world will change with the possibility of total destruction or being restored from the hands of capricious gods and mighty heroes


The last for today:

- May 30 – Space Marines (week-1)
- June 6 – Space Marines (week-2)
- June 13 – Space Marines (week-3)
- June 20 – Dark Angels (week-1)
- June 27 – WFB 9th Releases begin


via Steve the Warboss 5-27-2015

WFB 9th Release Window Details

-6 Weeks of Releases
-Rulebook and Accessories
-Starter Set
-First Armybook (Empire)
-Released in quick succession
-“Sigmarites” are only another Knightly Order



glotkkin is the new world? the gods fixed it, though. all the rot was removed at the end of book 2

 
Last edited:
Lots of interesting stuff there, although glottkin being the new world is strange. They were back in Nurgles garden in a jar. So that will take some explaining.
Which GW probably won't feel like doing also would prefer it if the sigmarines are a standalone army.
 
Yeah, I don't see them putting out new round base trays for all the various round bases they're introducing. Also, I've never seen a daemon player use those trays in their army - for one, they disrupt the actual unit footprint, sometimes dramatically. For another, they lock you into particular rank widths that are all mostly the wrong numbers. For a third, from my own experience with war of the ring, they're awkward as heck to actually use, to the point that you might as well be moving the models individually, unless you're building unit trays for your unit trays.

No. No, that's not happening, and if it was it would actually be worse.
 
Yeah, I don't see them putting out new round base trays for all the various round bases they're introducing. Also, I've never seen a daemon player use those trays in their army - for one, they disrupt the actual unit footprint, sometimes dramatically. For another, they lock you into particular rank widths that are all mostly the wrong numbers. For a third, from my own experience with war of the ring, they're awkward as heck to actually use, to the point that you might as well be moving the models individually, unless you're building unit trays for your unit trays.

No. No, that's not happening, and if it was it would actually be worse.


I'm not seeming to recall that the LOTR trays are too wide. I have, however, seen people use THESE sorts of "conversion tray" products before. Or just magnetize their miniatures to a standard modular movement tray. Not too many people, but then there aren't too many demons players in our neck of the woods for whatever reason.

As for awkwardness...can't really speak to it. However, for anyone who's ever pushed around trays of infantry models that weren't magnetized...yeah that's pretty damned awkward too. I can imagine the rounds being a lot easier either way.

Not that I'll ever be rebasing my VC any time soon. My bases took about 30 minutes each between carving, painting, and sealing, so I'll be damned if I'm going to redo any of that work.
 
This might seem like a noob question, but I didn't see it answered anywhere else other than folks talking about 40k. I'm still pretty new to Warhammer in general, I don't get to play often. If someone DID answer it, I apologize for missing it! What is the advantage to them using the round bases? Like, I get that 40k has smaller groups, but what rational do they have to use the round base? Other than trying to force the game to use smaller groups?
 
This might seem like a noob question, but I didn't see it answered anywhere else other than folks talking about 40k. I'm still pretty new to Warhammer in general, I don't get to play often. If someone DID answer it, I apologize for missing it! What is the advantage to them using the round bases? Like, I get that 40k has smaller groups, but what rational do they have to use the round base? Other than trying to force the game to use smaller groups?
Two things happen. You give the model more room for more dynamic posing. You sacrifice facing and arcs. GW doing this makes fantasy look more like 40k and war machine. It sends a message very loud and clear that the game has been changed. Personally I think it means we are losing regimental play, but we will have to see the final results. I didn't think they would go this far with basing. There have been rumors off and on about new movement trays that work with the circular bases and luck them in. I guess we will have to see if that is true. If it's is, that could be OK then as we have skirmishing units that can rank up too and still have a solid tactical game.
 
Two things happen. You give the model more room for more dynamic posing. You sacrifice facing and arcs. GW doing this makes fantasy look more like 40k and war machine. It sends a message very loud and clear that the game has been changed. Personally I think it means we are losing regimental play, but we will have to see the final results. I didn't think they would go this far with basing. There have been rumors off and on about new movement trays that work with the circular bases and luck them in. I guess we will have to see if that is true. If it's is, that could be OK then as we have skirmishing units that can rank up too and still have a solid tactical game.

1) Warmachine has facings.

2) Round bases =/= removal of regimental play.


As I've said before, my guess is that they'll just change how the game calculates who can and cannot fight to something most abstract, as most new players seem to assume it works anyways. "No you can't just attack the unit, you're only in base contact with my vampire lord, a wight king, and a champion. And the champion you can only do a maximum of one wound to within the same initiative...any further wounds are lost for combat resolution purposes. Also these four models strike at ASL because of the night shroud, and this one must make a leadership test at -3 or reroll successful to hits. Hmm....what am I forgetting....oh yeah, these three models reroll successful ward saves. Please allocate your attacks."

Abstract that down to where units can simply output a certain number of attacks towards each facing, and suddenly it doesn't matter who is in base contact with whom. Which means that it doesn't really matter what base sizes models are on either.
 
Regimental playing with round bases isn't fun. Honestly, neither is working out model facings in war machine, particularly in larger games with more models on the table. IF GW tries to 'have their cake and eat it too' with a round based regimental game, it's not going to work out well for them or for us.

And base size/shape/spread not mattering breaks down as soon as somebody breaks out the templates.
 
1) Warmachine has facings.

2) Round bases =/= removal of regimental play.


As I've said before, my guess is that they'll just change how the game calculates who can and cannot fight to something most abstract, as most new players seem to assume it works anyways. "No you can't just attack the unit, you're only in base contact with my vampire lord, a wight king, and a champion. And the champion you can only do a maximum of one wound to within the same initiative...any further wounds are lost for combat resolution purposes. Also these four models strike at ASL because of the night shroud, and this one must make a leadership test at -3 or reroll successful to hits. Hmm....what am I forgetting....oh yeah, these three models re-roll successful ward saves. Please allocate your attacks."

Abstract that down to where units can simply output a certain number of attacks towards each facing, and suddenly it doesn't matter who is in base contact with whom. Which means that it doesn't really matter what base sizes models are on either.
Ok, facing on round bases is crappy and skirmish games where models in a unit can all be facing different ways is a mess and scales terribly. Warmachine can't scale in size like Warhammer partly because of it.

Same goes for regimental play. Its WAY easier and more intuitive with square bases. GW moving away from square bases means most likely we are headed towards a 40k like skirmish system with the fantasy setting, which is likely why fantasy 9th that was due in May of 2014 was sent back to the design table in 2013 and 7th edition 40k was fast tracked and released with a psychic phase in its place.

GW is not going to do painted lines on base edges for facing. So facing will work like 40k for non-regimental units. They are not going to do regimental rules unless they have a movement tray made for it that works with circular bases. Its easier to lose regiments and focus on warbands of various sizes fighting in a fantasy setting with objectives and missions like 40k. A game like that is easier to teach and get new players for too. Regimental play is literally to complex for some players. I've seen it first hand for over 25 years now.
 
It might be easier to teach new players and play faster and be more streamlined. It might turn out to be a decent ruleset and actually have some tactical value (although with 360 LoS I can't see how), but without regiments and facings it just won't be WARHAMMER. That's my main gripe: I would love for there to be a skirmish entry level game that scaled up to something like we have now, but it seems we might not be getting that.
 
@najo: Issue is...who is going to be teaching those new players? GW's new "one man stores" certainly aren't equipped to be doing that. They will be relying very much on existing players to bring new people into the fold, and that's not going to happen if they alienate us by turfing the system we've all been playing in.


8th edition is already a great system, and I think they're aware of this. Tweak the rules a few different ways and you could freshen it up a bit to keep us mass battle fans interested. Then roll out a new skirmish game, with round bases and small warbands...a game that actually works with a starter kit level of models. That game gets people into your system, and is a gateway to other products (like WHFB mass battles).

The only question there is cross-compatibility. Skirmish games work better on round bases, but mass battle on squares? What do you do?

Well, as I said, conversion trays are VERY EASY. People have already been doing them with demons. You use the facing of the tray, and there's really no issues so long as the size is roughly comparable. Solo models I expect facings won't matter as much for, or they will simply be incorporated into the units. Honestly, it's kind of silly how narrow the field of view is for a big-ass guy on a dragon, who really ought to be able to wheel his head around a bit. I get it for regiments though, who aren't quite as maneuverable. Also for heavy cavalry, but round bases on them I expect will mean something similar.
 
@najo: Issue is...who is going to be teaching those new players? GW's new "one man stores" certainly aren't equipped to be doing that. They will be relying very much on existing players to bring new people into the fold, and that's not going to happen if they alienate us by turfing the system we've all been playing in.


8th edition is already a great system, and I think they're aware of this. Tweak the rules a few different ways and you could freshen it up a bit to keep us mass battle fans interested. Then roll out a new skirmish game, with round bases and small warbands...a game that actually works with a starter kit level of models. That game gets people into your system, and is a gateway to other products (like WHFB mass battles).

The only question there is cross-compatibility. Skirmish games work better on round bases, but mass battle on squares? What do you do?

Well, as I said, conversion trays are VERY EASY. People have already been doing them with demons. You use the facing of the tray, and there's really no issues so long as the size is roughly comparable. Solo models I expect facings won't matter as much for, or they will simply be incorporated into the units. Honestly, it's kind of silly how narrow the field of view is for a big-ass guy on a dragon, who really ought to be able to wheel his head around a bit. I get it for regiments though, who aren't quite as maneuverable. Also for heavy cavalry, but round bases on them I expect will mean something similar.
I agree with your points and it is how I would do it to if I was GW and I was dead set on round bases for fantasy. Also, I think 360 arcs for non-regiments would be fine. I've been saying for some time fantasy should at its core be simple skirmish rules that are easy to get new players in to and then units ranking up is a thing they do that adds a layer of complexity to the game. This would allow small point games to play fast and be easy to fight in any terrain or scenery. Then as a player's collection grows and they become more advanced, they are able to play with more and more models and regimental maneuvering. Advance players would take to bigger games out of the gate, but the more streamlined movement and skirmishing allows for us to play a much wider degree of scenarios and campaign style encounters. Building rules and Seiges become easier to as units go into 40k style skirmishing to enter and move about them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Sun King
I strongly disagree on any skirmish game using different bases from the main game. The entire point of having a smaller skirmish game is to allow a cheaper buy in price, from which players could then expand into the full game. If you can't use the same models in both games because they require different bases, that would defeat the entire point.
 
Several of the most recent posts on Bell of Lost Souls indicate round bases are where it's going with the round base movement trays for ranking up. :( Two articles at the top of their page today discuss it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eternal flitter
I strongly disagree on any skirmish game using different bases from the main game. The entire point of having a smaller skirmish game is to allow a cheaper buy in price, from which players could then expand into the full game. If you can't use the same models in both games because they require different bases, that would defeat the entire point.


This. Very much this.

A skirmish game would work very well with square bases as well, it only depends on the rulesset.

After all, Mordheim never had any issues using square bases and it kept the models compatible with your WHFB armies.


As for doom & gloom predictions, I strongly feel that we'll indeed be seeing a set of rules split over three books (which will be released one or two weeks apart each and which you'd need to buy seperately of course, given GWs latest trend of spamming players with releases), one for the skirmish / intro rules, one for more or less 'traditional' WHFB games (albeit with a large amount of 'formations' or overpowered Battlescrolls messing up the game) and one for apocalypse-style / 3.000 points and up / End Times style battles.
That's what I call milking the cow.
But it would fall in line with GW releasing everything seperately of late, best example would be the idiotic Skitarii / Cult Mechanicum codicees and the Imperial Knights codex which was updated after ONE year .... right, thank you GW.
Well, in the end it doesn't matter, really. Most people I know prefer to play 30k instead of 40k, and have agreed to stick to WHFB 8th edition for their fantasy battle games if the new edition will be sucky.

On a sidenote: People probably noticed that the latest edition of 40k was never officially dubbed Wh40k 7th edition.
The same will come true for fantasy: The edition indicator will disappear entirely, it'll only be named 'Warhammer' from now on. ;)

Yeah ... back to assembling more 30k Alpha Legion and warp cult models and teaching two new players the ways of WHFB 8th edition ...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet
What I wanted was a game that scales down better, defaulting to a smaller size, but still regimental in nature, one where my undead are still a relevant faction. Sadly, apart from maybe the down scaling, non of that seems to be what's happening. I'll still give 9e as fair a shake as I can manage, but I'm not starting a new army, so unless there's considerable overlap between old undead and new undead, this may be the end of warhammer for me.
 
Pah, just the end of my custom for them. My mates aren't budging from 8th anyway, and my local hobby shop will still host 8th as well. Besides, I've come too far with my beloved army to quit on them, even if GW does.
 
via one of gary’s birds

“Age of Sigmar will be not the first part of a Three-Part Ruleset in the 9.Edition, it will be the Name of the first Starter Set. The Set includes Simplyfied Fantasy Rules, based on the new Edition with Skimisher Rules. Age of Sigmar will be an easy and “cheap” introduction for new People and the first Release of the new Edition. Soon after the Set GW will release the Full Rulebook with full skimisher and standard Rules. Later in this Year, there will be a classic Starter Set like the previous with two Armies and a Full Mini-Rulebook.”

copied from BoLS on 30 May 2015

ed
it TheSunKing, earlier in the thread we posted some links to pics of studio models with round bases
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu