Dealing with a Daemon Prince

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
bigbadbat said:
@ Dread King - WLC and doom wheels have random strength.
@ Johnny - Master Strike!? Surely the apocalypse is nigh!

Just the strength is random, right (excluding the misfire chart and the rules for a normal cannon)? And the strength is determined by the artillery dice, I presume (sorry for going off-topic)?

I wouldn't panic when master strike gets picked. When GW prices stop going up, THEN the apocalypse is nigh.
 
WLCs also fire in a straight line as a cannon, but at the end of the bounce a small template is placed. And, being a Warpstone Weapon, the damage is Magical. Beware, Ethereals.
 
Thanks, guys, for the clarifications!

Yeah, my wraiths have been suffering against the skaven. Though my other stuff tears them to pieces in the games I play against this friend.

I'll have to tell him about the bounce template, and the random strength. Games against him are never going to be so easy as before...xD
 
While we're briefly derailed: the WLC shot dissipates if the bounce roll is a misfire, if I remember. (I never field them--Abom and 2 Doom Wheels for me.) And the template does damage in addition to the straight line from the bounce. Thought I should clarify if we're teaching a new ratty general.
 
logan054 said:
Gatti said:
logan054 said:
Honestly that isn't that impressive, a nurgle daemon prince could happily grind that down and your pretty screwed if they decide to go glittering scales (which I have seen mentioned several times).

Firstly, note I provided the math of that match-up in my post. The vampire averages more wounds, and if the prince fails beguile, the lord will kill him. Sure, if the prince keeps passing beguile every round, the vampire lord will die first because the prince has 1 more wound on his profile, but if he starts failing beguile, or if you can get through a lore attribute wound to your lord (or deal 1 or more wound to the prince before challenging him with the vampire lord), the prince will go down first on average.

+1 to hit is more reliable and cheaper on a model with WS9 and S6 and allows for additional items, be that a dragon helm, a charmed shield, whatever. So while you've run some maths it based on a false assumption that daemons princes will have ASF, I don't think many will unless they want poison and/or flaming attacks. So sure, if he fails his leadership test you can force him to reroll, its just a shame its still hitting on a 2+ and has a chance to regain wounds for every wound causes

For striking, the statistics are 0.77 for fail and 0.93 for pass when mounted on a nightmare. If on a hellsteed, it climbs to 0.96 and 1.15 wounds/round respectively. Still not a done deal, especially since I have at no point suggested sending this vamp lord into an unwounded prince if you can avoid it. My suggestion was to weaken first then send in the vampire lord if the initial attacks didn't kill him.

Also note that for the soul stealer ability, if the daemon prince only deals 1 wound to the vampire lord, it has the same chance of regaining a wound as the vampire lord does with the hunger rule. I think we can agree here that those odds aren't that great.

Also, I have faced two different daemon princes so far. One DID have ASF (helm of many eyes), the other had a dawnstone. I agree striking is a better build. I calculated those above, and the statistics are not much different, as you can see.

2+ re roll which I have faced is also statistically worse than 1+ against high strength attacks (like S7 attacks), so I did not calculate for that either.

Also note, that in both games against a daemon prince, I have killed the daemon prince with that vampire build. So for the record, it does work if the prince is wounded as I recommended. The proof is in the pudding, as they say.


logan054 said:
And why would anyone go glittering scales? A 6 always hits (doesn't necessarily always wound, but always hits)


I have seen it mentioned several times, however as he will be forced into a challenge more often than not, anything WS5-9 will hit him on a 6, anything WS10 will hit him on a 5+.

I don't care that characters hit on 6s. I can't imagine anyone taking this. If he does, cast magic missiles at him and laugh. Skinks will ruin him. Archers could kill him even. I don't think anyone will take this, it makes him too vulnerable to shooting (particularly ballistic shooting (RBTs, handgunners, crossbows, SKINKS, etc), and makes him too vulnerable to lower strength attacks. Not something I would expect for an all comers list.
 
Gatti said:
Also note that for the soul stealer ability, if the daemon prince only deals 1 wound to the vampire lord, it has the same chance of regaining a wound as the vampire lord does with the hunger rule.

Well, actually, if a VL is fighting a DP then (unless he kills it) he has a 0/6 chance of regaining a wound - so the DP is still doing better in that regard. ;)
 
So i was thinking that there was a lot of "waisted points" with this coven throne build.

Vampire lord
Quick blood
Aura of dark Majesty
Beguile
Fear incarnate
Dread Knight
LVL4

+2 strength blade
4+ ward
Ots
Heavy armor
Sheild
Mounted on a Coven Throne.

I dont know if the coven throne gives the armor save or the ward save to the Vamp.
If he can use the thrones Ward save he can drop the talisman.

Fear Incarnate, and begile are kind of redundant with the coven thrones battle of wills. Dreadknight would only really come into play if you got 1-2 result on the coven throne, and MAYBE hit on 4s instead of 5s. but i dont have the rule book near me to check the table on hits. But if not thats useless too.

So still with the vamps ward save that is 45 points saved bring it down to 649. If the vamp gets the ward save then its down to 604 points.

But still dont know if its worth taking the coven throne against the DP
 
You get neither the AS nor the Ward, it's a separate model. An easier source of CR for the Daemon, too. I wouldn't chance a Coven Throne as it likely does more harm than good, because let's not forget that Vampires, especially lone Vampires, crumble.
 
the average 7 S3 hits, 2 S5 hits and 5 S5 hits would lose combat with a 5+ armor and 4+ ward for the throne 2+A and 4 + ward for the vamp? even with the reroll to hit from battle of wills?

With the LD 8 i think the DP would have to roll a 1 for BoWills and the Vamp have to roll 4+ to get ld 14 so the DP hits itself?

Dp rolls 1 50% chance dp his self
dp rolls a 2 23ish% chance? (needs a 5)
Dp rolls rolls a 3 is a 16% (need a 6)
4+ always reroll.

Still not worth it?
 
Gatti said:
Also note that for the soul stealer ability, if the daemon prince only deals 1 wound to the vampire lord, it has the same chance of regaining a wound as the vampire lord does with the hunger rule. I think we can agree here that those odds aren't that great.

As Vipoid said, you have the hunger rule wrong, you can only regain wounds by killing a model, wounding does not allow a roll.
Here is the problem

All your maths shows is that a 450pts character will have a slightly better chance of beating a 350pts character, however in a 2k game this means that you can only have a lvl2 wizard at most while the chaos player still has 150pts to spend on magic levels.

I don't care that characters hit on 6s. I can't imagine anyone taking this. If he does, cast magic missiles at him and laugh. Skinks will ruin him. Archers could kill him even. I don't think anyone will take this, it makes him too vulnerable to shooting (particularly ballistic shooting (RBTs, handgunners, crossbows, SKINKS, etc), and makes him too vulnerable to lower strength attacks. Not something I would expect for an all comers list.

Small arms fire is hardly a issue (it can however still have a 4+ save with a -2 to hit in h2h), the main reason here is that it isn't a large target and can use other targets to provide cover. Trolls or dragon ogres would be good for this. With wings it will have no issues charging over the screen either.

Of course the irony is killing me, heres my Vampire lord tooled up to kill a DP followed by "I can't see a -2 to hit daemon prince in a all comers list..
 
zzanxy said:
the average 7 S3 hits, 2 S5 hits and 5 S5 hits would lose combat with a 5+ armor and 4+ ward for the throne 2+A and 4 + ward for the vamp? even with the reroll to hit from battle of wills?

With the LD 8 i think the DP would have to roll a 1 for BoWills and the Vamp have to roll 4+ to get ld 14 so the DP hits itself?

Dp rolls 1 50% chance dp his self
dp rolls a 2 23ish% chance? (needs a 5)
Dp rolls rolls a 3 is a 16% (need a 6)
4+ always reroll.

Still not worth it?

Over ranks and a banner and possibly a BSB? And providing easier CR for the Daemon Prince to pick at (hits the Throne on a 2+, wounds it on a 3+)? Entirely plausible. Moreover, those points ensure that the Daemon Prince will be bending you over in the Magic phase, because he'll be a L4 caster and you won't be. Last but not least, you will engage on his terms, because he will be more mobile than you. Bad. Idea.

Frankly, I'm surprised this topic has dragged on as long as it has, given that the "easy and effective" answers were covered in detail so early on. I guess I underestimated this community's fervor for cramming that square peg into the round hole. :tongue: In all seriousness, though, don't run in and fight the guy unless he has been weakened first, and even then be careful.
 
Well, the model's still worth having around if you make it as a Mortis Engine. There are a couple of solid lists around these parts that use the ME.
 
logan054 said:
Gatti said:
Also note that for the soul stealer ability, if the daemon prince only deals 1 wound to the vampire lord, it has the same chance of regaining a wound as the vampire lord does with the hunger rule. I think we can agree here that those odds aren't that great.

As Vipoid said, you have the hunger rule wrong, you can only regain wounds by killing a model, wounding does not allow a roll.
Here is the problem

All your maths shows is that a 450pts character will have a slightly better chance of beating a 350pts character, however in a 2k game this means that you can only have a lvl2 wizard at most while the chaos player still has 150pts to spend on magic levels.

Firstly, what I meant by the hunger is that dealing 1 W with soul stealer has the same odds of regaining a wound as our vampire lord does when he kills rank and file infantry (a 1/6 shot, or 16.66% chance). It isn't likely.

Secondly, you seem to forget a vampire lord can be a LV 4. I play 2500, so my lord is a LV 4 as well. Also, a fully kitted daemon prince with LV 4 is about 600 pts anyway, so you also won't be seeing a fully kitted prince at 2k with a LV 4 as backup. You won't even be seeing a daemon prince with LV 4 in a 2k game. A prince is similarly costed to a vampire lord.

Also, your argument failed to counter the fact that my vampire lord thus kitted DID kill TWO Princes in two games. Proof is in the pudding, man.

QED.

logan054 said:
I don't care that characters hit on 6s. I can't imagine anyone taking this. If he does, cast magic missiles at him and laugh. Skinks will ruin him. Archers could kill him even. I don't think anyone will take this, it makes him too vulnerable to shooting (particularly ballistic shooting (RBTs, handgunners, crossbows, SKINKS, etc), and makes him too vulnerable to lower strength attacks. Not something I would expect for an all comers list.

Small arms fire is hardly a issue (it can however still have a 4+ save with a -2 to hit in h2h), the main reason here is that it isn't a large target and can use other targets to provide cover. Trolls or dragon ogres would be good for this. With wings it will have no issues charging over the screen either.

Of course the irony is killing me, heres my Vampire lord tooled up to kill a DP followed by "I can't see a -2 to hit daemon prince in a all comers list..

I don't know what to tell you. I only play all comers game. This IS my all comers vampire lord. I take him in every game, regardless of opponent. My entire gaming group only takes all comers lists as we are all tournament geared players. In my meta, I can't see it appearing because skinks are too common, and a unit with a 12" march that can march, free reform, multi shoot, and auto wound on 6s for a cheap core unit is too hard a counter for something with only a 4+ armor save and 5+ ward.

Also, being a large target doesn't mean he can't get cover. Large target only means he cant get cover from defended obstacles. Large targets can still get cover from intervening units if they are tall enough (like dragon ogres) Read the rulebook closer.

But this is clearly possible to be worked around, particularly by some units like skinks. If it weren't, you wouldn't see skinks sniping keepers of secrets as often as they do, or any unarmored solo models, large target or no. It can be worked around and I think that's a major problem with only a 4+ armor on him. That also means he can't take charmed shield, which is another hurdle if ironblasters or empire are common in your meta. It's a build with even more counters than otherwise. As I said, a prince can kill a vc lord unless the prince is wounded (major premise of my strategy). The scales may make him survive against characters, but it weakens him against block units and makes him more vulnerable against other lists. That's why I see it as uncommon.
 
Gatti said:
Firstly, what I meant by the hunger is that dealing 1 W with soul stealer has the same odds of regaining a wound as our vampire lord does when he kills rank and file infantry (a 1/6 shot, or 16.66% chance). It isn't likely.

While that is true you are talking about a vampire lord trying to kill a daemon prince in combat, his likely hood of regaining a wound against rank and file doesn't matter and isn't comparable, the soul feeder ability is better, especially if you have a daemon prince vs a character.

Secondly, you seem to forget a vampire lord can be a LV 4. I play 2500, so my lord is a LV 4 as well. Also, a fully kitted daemon prince with LV 4 is about 600 pts anyway, so you also won't be seeing a fully kitted prince at 2k with a LV 4 as backup.

Many people do not play above 2k, be it because they attend throne of skulls, they play with more confined space or simply do not have the time. at 2k you will see a daemon prince along the lines of

Daemon prince
MoN
lvl4
breathe weapon
Sword of striking
Charmed shield
dragonbane gem
Soul hunger
Chaos armour
scaled skin

Thats bang on 500pts, so at 2k WoC can have a daemon prince who is M8, is a lvl4 death mage and is good in combat, some may want a wings over a extra level however with M8, wings are not a auto include. Being a lvl4 wizard is only 50pts more than a vampire lord who is kitted to kill him and is a lvl1 wizard. Daemon prince are cheap for what they bring, cheaper than a vampire lord who require far more upgrading to compare.


Also, your argument failed to counter the fact that my vampire lord thus kitted DID kill TWO Princes in two games. Proof is in the pudding, man.

Great, I had a chaos warrior unit champion kill a couple of high elf heroes before, does that mean that chaos warrior champions are better than HE Heroes. I had a unit of chaos warriors kill a entire 2k HE army before (I'm sure Lord fear remembers that ;) ), did that mean the chaos warriors from the HoC book are broken (this was against the current HE book). I can throw out random examples, its proves nothing, it just shows the dice favored you on that day.

Also, being a large target doesn't mean he can't get cover. Large target only means he cant get cover from defended obstacles. Large targets can still get cover from intervening units if they are tall enough (like dragon ogres) Read the rulebook closer.

Being a large target makes it far harder to get cover, regardless, he isn't a large target which removes this.
 
Dice gods can be more fickle than Chaos gods :)

I saw a unit of Gors take down a fully kitted DP yesterday.

They're just 500 point steam tanks without a cannon... Deal with them accordingly.

I could only imagine the outcry on opposing teams' forums when the blendy vamp lord first arrived on the scene.
 
eggspr said:
Dice gods can be more fickle than Chaos gods :)

I saw a unit of Gors take down a fully kitted DP yesterday.

They're just 500 point steam tanks without a cannon... Deal with them accordingly.

I could only imagine the outcry on opposing teams' forums when the blendy vamp lord first arrived on the scene.

I know as a chaos player until now we had very little that could stand up to a blender lord, the only real way to deal with it was to kill its unit, not always as simple as it sounds.
 
Logan, not sure what your issue is. This entire thread, you had tried to discount or undermine any theory of how to deal with a prince. The OP asked for ideas of how to deal with one, and you seem determined to believe they are invincible. They aren't sorry to break it to you. While it is hard, they are killable, and more killable than a Tzeentch LV 4 or a Tzeentch lord with the stubborn crown.

I answered the OP with my own theory. In summary, the flow of our two arguments and the basis for such arguments are are:

My Argument:
1) I proposed a theory.

That theory is that a vampire lord kitted as I described has a good chance to kill a daemon prince if the daemon prince is wounded. I did not claim that such a lord could kill an unwounded prince easily or without luck. I merely stated that if you deal 1-3 wounds to a prince (either through screams or death magic) before sending this lord in, you have a better than average chance of killing him in combat.

2) I supported my theory.

The support of my theory was the math. I provided accompanying statistics results for the average wounds with or against various daemon prince builds based on what is logical. They all show that even if the prince passes his LD test at -3, the vampire lord at least has the same chance of doing a wound as the daemon prince does back. This supports my theory that the prince must be wounded first, as the vampire lord can't survive to trade wounds with him, but if he is wounded at least once, the lord can kill him in 2-3 or so rounds of combat. These odds improve, as I stated, if the BSB isn't near the prince, as the chance of failing the LD check is >50% if there is no re roll, and forcing re rolls to hit dramatically changes the outcome.

3) I tested my theory.

I explained that this theory worked in games. It did not only work once as a "glitch", this method of dealing with the prince worked in two different games (a repeatable experiment has more strength than one that was unrepeatable). The fact that the math supports this outcome and the fact that it was a repeated outcome suggests that it wasn't a glitch.

4) I concluded that this is one way to deal with a prince. I allow that it is not perfect, and requires prior wounds to be dealt, but if wounds are dealt, it is one way to deal with such a prince.

Logan's Argument:
1) He proposed a theory that my idea does not work.

Logan at least proposed a theory. But he limited himself by claiming that my theory cannot work, rather than suggesting that it will not work every time (which is an argument I could not counter--it will not work every game and I am perfectly willing to admit that, as the other units or spells in the warriors of chaos arsenal could influence the outcome. Likewise, vampire spells could also swing the combat more dramatically. I ignored both in my calculation to look at it on a relatively even footing).

2) No individual support of a theory.

Supporting a theory requires extra data. Maybe some additional calculations I missed. You proposed some, but did not calculate any. I calculated them for you and showed that even those did not prove my theory wrong.

Instead of supporting your theory with data, you instead said the math does not matter and discounted it/ignored it (a strong logical argument, there :lol: ). Saying something "doesn't count" is a flawed logical argument. It isn't even an argument. Generally, to counter evidence you need to provide some of your own that shows how the initial calculation/evidence is incorrect in some way.

3) You did not provide any anecdotes or experiments that directly proves this lord can't kill a prince. You gave no experiences/experiments that proves your support for the theory (though, you didn't provide any support for your theory to begin with, other than saying math doesn't matter).

You did provide an anecdote about a champion killing a noble. I agree dice can be weird sometimes. The difference is your outcome is not statistically likely whereas the outcomes of my two distinct experiments above are supported by statistics. Your anecdote isn't relevant to the discussion because it is a different circumstance, and is a circumstance that is not supported by math (the math only shows that it is possible, not that it is probable for your anecdote). My outcome is actually probable given my initial conditions, as shown by statistics. My experiments show that this outcome is achievable in an actual game.

4) You did have a conclusion, and that conclusion was that my method does not work, despite both the statistics and repeated trials suggesting that it can work. At no point did you provide any mathematical or anecdotal evidence relevant to my claim.

With that, I will let the OP and the forum in general determine which argument is stronger.
 
As Rothgar stated. The answer to dealing with the demon prince was on page 1. Scream it and/or sniper it to death.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu