logan054 said:
Gatti said:
Also note that for the soul stealer ability, if the daemon prince only deals 1 wound to the vampire lord, it has the same chance of regaining a wound as the vampire lord does with the hunger rule. I think we can agree here that those odds aren't that great.
As Vipoid said, you have the hunger rule wrong, you can only regain wounds by killing a model, wounding does not allow a roll.
Here is the problem
All your maths shows is that a 450pts character will have a slightly better chance of beating a 350pts character, however in a 2k game this means that you can only have a lvl2 wizard at most while the chaos player still has 150pts to spend on magic levels.
Firstly, what I meant by the hunger is that dealing 1 W with soul stealer has the same odds of regaining a wound as our vampire lord does when he kills rank and file infantry (a 1/6 shot, or 16.66% chance). It isn't likely.
Secondly, you seem to forget a vampire lord can be a LV 4. I play 2500, so my lord is a LV 4 as well. Also, a fully kitted daemon prince with LV 4 is about 600 pts anyway, so you also won't be seeing a fully kitted prince at 2k with a LV 4 as backup. You won't even be seeing a daemon prince with LV 4 in a 2k game. A prince is similarly costed to a vampire lord.
Also, your argument failed to counter the fact that my vampire lord thus kitted DID kill TWO Princes in two games. Proof is in the pudding, man.
QED.
logan054 said:
I don't care that characters hit on 6s. I can't imagine anyone taking this. If he does, cast magic missiles at him and laugh. Skinks will ruin him. Archers could kill him even. I don't think anyone will take this, it makes him too vulnerable to shooting (particularly ballistic shooting (RBTs, handgunners, crossbows, SKINKS, etc), and makes him too vulnerable to lower strength attacks. Not something I would expect for an all comers list.
Small arms fire is hardly a issue (it can however still have a 4+ save with a -2 to hit in h2h), the main reason here is that it isn't a large target and can use other targets to provide cover. Trolls or dragon ogres would be good for this. With wings it will have no issues charging over the screen either.
Of course the irony is killing me, heres my Vampire lord tooled up to kill a DP followed by "I can't see a -2 to hit daemon prince in a all comers list..
I don't know what to tell you. I only play all comers game. This IS my all comers vampire lord. I take him in every game, regardless of opponent. My entire gaming group only takes all comers lists as we are all tournament geared players. In my meta, I can't see it appearing because skinks are too common, and a unit with a 12" march that can march, free reform, multi shoot, and auto wound on 6s for a cheap core unit is too hard a counter for something with only a 4+ armor save and 5+ ward.
Also, being a large target doesn't mean he can't get cover. Large target only means he cant get cover from defended obstacles. Large targets can still get cover from intervening units if they are tall enough (like dragon ogres) Read the rulebook closer.
But this is clearly possible to be worked around, particularly by some units like skinks. If it weren't, you wouldn't see skinks sniping keepers of secrets as often as they do, or any unarmored solo models, large target or no. It can be worked around and I think that's a major problem with only a 4+ armor on him. That also means he can't take charmed shield, which is another hurdle if ironblasters or empire are common in your meta. It's a build with even more counters than otherwise. As I said, a prince can kill a
vc lord unless the prince is wounded (major premise of my strategy). The scales may make him survive against characters, but it weakens him against block units and makes him more vulnerable against other lists. That's why I see it as uncommon.