TVC II OOC General OOC Discussion

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
I didn't know there was a predetermined way to go about casting spells. Surely something like that would be open to a bit of creative license?

Or I am misunderstanding you?



As for the name of the supplements, I think we should go for something relatively short, instantly understandable, and fitting. In my opinion, "Flashback:" suits all three.

In my opinion, "Origins:" is too narrow, as these supplements can be any time in a character's history, not just their origin (whether of character or mission)
 
Harland said:
I didn't know there was a predetermined way to go about casting spells. Surely something like that would be open to a bit of creative license?

Or I am misunderstanding you?



As for the name of the supplements, I think we should go for something relatively short, instantly understandable, and fitting. In my opinion, "Flashback:" suits all three.

In my opinion, "Origins:" is too narrow, as these supplements can be any time in a character's history, not just their origin (whether of character or mission)

I agree, flashbacks work fine.

As for actually putting down spells...that COULD be interesting as long as we don't make the mistake of limiting players to those spells, after all imagination in writing about spells is part of the fun.
I personally like seeing what Morty or Kraskor etc will come up with next when in a battle scene.
 
Ghouly said:
but we also shouldn't let magic be the solve all remember this is warhammer its Grimdark using magic is like having a nose bleed while swimming with sharks

Agreed but there's still a large amount of imagination to cast spells allowed, especially for the more powerful wizards.
This has always been the case in TVC and, for me anyway, been a source of interest.

But the more "common" battle spells I could see being described and all in a thread, non-battle spells being the more complex ones in general can be ignored if the RPer doesn't want to describe them.

But I still strongly feel that we can't start limiting what spells each player can cast, that would make TVC fights alot more boring for me.

At that I should point out because Karl uses an unusual spell set I did have to describe his most common spells for everyone in the first TVC.
 
If people are bored they could read A story of mediocre quality!

As meh as it is written it DOES have characters from my other stories if anyone ever read them (Hans for example) and TVC peeps (Peter and Marc).

Yes, shameless bumping, it is my way :thumbsup:

As people probably know I love writing about TVC characters in my story so if anyone has a character who fits into the timeframe of that story and would like to make an appearance (as big or cameo as they like) then let me know!
 
Lol you guys Graveclaw is already entering the campsite while you, he's a Vampire he sneaks just fine, plus chaos guys don't really sneak so their unprepared for it
 
So are we all happy with calling the supplementals 'flashback', then? I'm fine with it and many other options; I just want to get started on the supplementals themselves! :vampire3:
 
Ghouly, I'm not going to lie, I don't feel like Graveclaw could be that stealthy. He's quite big, there's little to no cover in the Wastes (no foliage), and Chaos Warriors are some of the most well-trained, alert and vigilant beings in the Warhammer world. I feel like the possibility is definitely there; the role of the panther-like predator suits Graveclaw. But it's not his primary attribute, and I think if he could just sneak through the camp it would be too much.

Perhaps if he had some kind of magical support (but then he might not like that?), but just on his own I don't see a giant vampire ducking in and out of tents without a single Chaos Warrior (out of a whole army) noticing.

This is just my opinion, not criticism or anything. He's not done it yet, and you did mention it here in the OOC thread, so you've done everything right. :thumbsup: I just wanted to say this before you spent time on a post.
 
think more along the lines of a Crocodile or a Shark get as close as possible, then just charge and overpower with brute force. your also forgetting Graveclaw doesn't care if he survives or not.

Chaos Warriors are like Blood Dragons they kill what's directly in front of them, and march in a straight line they don't do nor understand stealth theres no glory in sneaking which is all that matters to Chaos Warriors
 
Ghouly said:
think more along the lines of a Crocodile or a Shark get as close as possible, then just charge and overpower with brute force. your also forgetting Graveclaw doesn't care if he survives or not.

Chaos Warriors are like Blood Dragons they kill what's directly in front of them, and march in a straight line they don't do nor understand stealth theres no glory in sneaking which is all that matters to Chaos Warriors

I see Graveclaw prowling around the camp certainly but not actually being able to sneak through it.

Also I got the idea that this Chaos Camp was quite well organised by a significant chaos lord. Am I wrong?

Barbarians they might be but I'm certain they have mastered the principles of deploying sentries like any decent army.
 
I agree with ghouly most chaos hordes are so sure they cant be beaten so dont bother with sentries or that (well in the books I have read anyway) also since they are usually just fighting amongst themselves to take much notice , besides even if they saw him they would think he is some chaos beast
 
I must say I agree with Get and Darvy. While it makes sense that Graveclaw can move relatively silently, I can't see him being able to avoid notice for long in a busy camp.

Ghouly said:
think more along the lines of a Crocodile or a Shark get as close as possible, then just charge and overpower with brute force. your also forgetting Graveclaw doesn't care if he survives or not.

Bear in mind that sharks and crocodiles live in water, so if they are submerged it is very difficult to see them.

Also, I don't think Graveclaw's disregard for his own life makes him any better at sneaking (although I'm guessing that wasn't what you meant).

Chaos Warriors are like Blood Dragons they kill what's directly in front of them, and march in a straight line they don't do nor understand stealth theres no glory in sneaking which is all that matters to Chaos Warriors

Just because they don't use stealth doesn't mean they can't spot someone, or know how to properly picket a camp.

Ghouly said:
the camp belongs to the Anointed of Tzeentch himself or one of his top lieutenants but any vampire could sneek past a Chaos Warrior even Nelly

This is more a personal disagreement for me, so bear in mind that this is just my opinion:

It doesn't sit well with me that all vampires are automatically good at some things. I do not mean strength, speed, or raw magical power - these are physiological. What I mean are skill-based talents, like sneaking. I don't believe a vampire is automatically sneaky; while they may have heightened senses, it's still something they might need to practice.
A better example would be sword-fighting. Yes, improved speed will help anyone with that, but a skilled swordsman, in my opinion, should be able to beat an unskilled vampire one on one. An unskilled vampire might just go for the kill, and be susceptible to feints and other such tactics. The same goes for magical skill and knowledge.
And, to me, this seems to be more or less the case in the TVC - most of the vampires are skilled at combat, but this is a gathering of the world's most powerful, so I would guess that vampires like Faust who are more or less entirely incompetent are not hugely uncommon. There are no vampires in this roleplay who just know how to use magic or a sword without centuries of training - hence why the young vampires like Alastor aren't hugely useful.

Thank you for listening. This has been a Harland certified opinion.

Count michael said:
I agree with ghouly most chaos hordes are so sure they cant be beaten so dont bother with sentries or that (well in the books I have read anyway) also since they are usually just fighting amongst themselves to take much notice , besides even if they saw him they would think he is some chaos beast

Now, overconfident or not, every army must picket their camps or expose themselves to devastating night raids. Chaos Warriors, who to me seem particularly professional, must know the importance of this; if anything, they would have learnt from past mistakes.
Furthermore, while I haven't read all of chapter 5, I believe there has been a battle of some sort (I could be very wrong)? If so, news must of travelled.

Regarding your other points, I still think that the Chaos Warriors themselves would be too professional to in-fight to that degree (please tell me if I am disagreeing with canon). However, it is perfectly reasonable to me that, from a distance, a skulking Graveclaw could be mistaken for a Chaos Spawn or the like.
 
Prowling around the camp, absolutely. I'm just not so sure he can run straight through it.

Of course, you could always blow your cover, but we kinda need DoN before we advance on the camp fully for any of his plot-plans that need to be enacted.
 
I'm really not budging on the pickets thing, there is no way they don't have some sort of lookout around camp.

I should point out I'm not saying that Graveclaw shouldn't do what he wants, just be prepared for what might happen.
 
Harland said:
This is more a personal disagreement for me, so bear in mind that this is just my opinion:

It doesn't sit well with me that all vampires are automatically good at some things. I do not mean strength, speed, or raw magical power - these are physiological. What I mean are skill-based talents, like sneaking. I don't believe a vampire is automatically sneaky; while they may have heightened senses, it's still something they might need to practice.
A better example would be sword-fighting. Yes, improved speed will help anyone with that, but a skilled swordsman, in my opinion, should be able to beat an unskilled vampire one on one. An unskilled vampire might just go for the kill, and be susceptible to feints and other such tactics. The same goes for magical skill and knowledge.
And, to me, this seems to be more or less the case in the TVC - most of the vampires are skilled at combat, but this is a gathering of the world's most powerful, so I would guess that vampires like Faust who are more or less entirely incompetent are not hugely uncommon. There are no vampires in this roleplay who just know how to use magic or a sword without centuries of training - hence why the young vampires like Alastor aren't hugely useful.


Regarding your other points, I still think that the Chaos Warriors themselves would be too professional to in-fight to that degree (please tell me if I am disagreeing with canon). However, it is perfectly reasonable to me that, from a distance, a skulking Graveclaw could be mistaken for a Chaos Spawn or the like.

Nights Dark Masters disagrees with you on that point a Vampire is a predator before anything else so they got all the predators skills.
even Blood Dragons move without making a sound, its not even a conscious thing.

Chaos Warriors don't need to sleep eat or drink, we already killed their look outs those outriders we murdered the only things in the wastes that will attack a Chaos Warband like that is another Chaos Warband that or a troll pack

I'm not going any further with this until DoN gets Back though
 
Ghouly said:
Nights Dark Masters disagrees with you on that point a Vampire is a predator before anything else so they got all the predators skills.
even Blood Dragons move without making a sound, its not even a conscious thing.

Chaos Warriors don't need to sleep eat or drink, we already killed their look outs those outriders we murdered the only things in the wastes that will attack a Chaos Warband like that is another Chaos Warband that or a troll pack

I'm not going any further with this until DoN gets Back though

We killed their outriders but they'd have patrols and stationary watchmen at the edge of their stationary camp.

Also I don't doubt vampire's can move without sound but they can still be seen which would the probably, especially with Graveclaw because he's biiigggggggg and the wastes don't really have much cover.

Is it night however? Or...do the Chaos filled wastes actually act have a proper night/day cycle?


But yeah we need DoN to play out the chaos peoples reaction.
 
Get of W said:
Ghouly said:
Nights Dark Masters disagrees with you on that point a Vampire is a predator before anything else so they got all the predators skills.
even Blood Dragons move without making a sound, its not even a conscious thing.

Chaos Warriors don't need to sleep eat or drink, we already killed their look outs those outriders we murdered the only things in the wastes that will attack a Chaos Warband like that is another Chaos Warband that or a troll pack

I'm not going any further with this until DoN gets Back though

We killed their outriders but they'd have patrols and stationary watchmen at the edge of their stationary camp.

Also I don't doubt vampire's can move without sound but they can still be seen which would the probably, especially with Graveclaw because he's biiigggggggg and the wastes don't really have much cover.

Is it night however? Or...do the Chaos filled wastes actually act have a proper night/day cycle?


But yeah we need DoN to play out the chaos peoples reaction.

there has only ever been one description of the wastes that I'm aware of and that's from Deamonslayer there's no plants the ground is gravely and its very mountainous lots of rocky cover
 
If the Wastes do have rocks and hills, a sensible Chaos Lord (and we can assume he's not a dumbass given he's sucking away Necromancy) would set his camp on a flat plain with little cover on the approach. And re: pickets I very much doubt an army that huge would have one group of outriders doing a massive circuit of the camp at all times (meaning only one tiny part of the camp is being watched at any time), and that every single Chaos Warrior is looking at the floor. Sound-stealth, yes, fits in with the predator aspect. Invisibility is another issue.

Not only that, but they're likely to have sorcerous wards and wizards that can detect things coming near. Of course, vampires might be harder to detect (hardwired sneakiness as you said), but not if you're running through the camp.

But I agree, we should wait for DoN. I now keep picturing Ghouly in an assassin's creed cloak... xD
 
I had assumed that we were on a rise looking down over the camp below us, but not close - quite a way away and huge!

On inherent sneakiness - I agree that vampires are natural predators, but that doesn't make them naturally sneaky (in my opinion).
Strigoi, for example, might be adept at keeping their presence in an old cemetery secret, by moving about at night, etc, when people aren't around, but that's not sneakiness, just common sense.

As for guards on the camp perimeter - there will definitely be guards! Maybe not around the entire thing, but regular pickets and patrols between them, with outriders scouting the land around them - they are in the Chaos Wastes, after all - not everything (in fact, very few things!) are friendly towards them. Chaos warriors will know this and have a solid defense in case of an attack.

With regards to a true day/night cycle, I think there must be some form of cycle, but what it is I'm not sure - although I thought there was something akin to the Aurora Borealis mentioned in one of the books I read
 
I know at least that in the Eye of Terror (40k I know but Realm of Chaos is same concept by same authors) there are worlds without any kind of day/night cycle.

The further North you go the more weird it gets, but if we assume we're neither deep North nor just on the cusp (good place to stage an attack without being too easy to spot or mutating in an instant) then there might be some kind of variation. But not clear-cut night and day.
 
Surely outriders would not be used in great numbers - otherwise they will be tired when the rest of the army is awake. Pickets and a rotating guard system (with Line of Sight in all directions, so probably evenly spread around the whole thing) would be the primary watch system.
Moreover, the further out they go, the more area they would have to cover a greater area, so it makes more sense for them to be used for investigating a specific place, such as the scene of the recent battle.

And as for day/night: don't forget that above the Arctic circle the sun never sets in the summer, and never rises in the winter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu