Get of W said:Not much to add to the above posters to be honest, I also believe that having more powerful characters will be better with more personal authority.
To me the problem with the guardsmen (even the odd ones like Riggins) was like of being able to dictate your own decisions due to the constraints of command.
Whilst Marines still follow the chain of command I can see it being easier to be creative with them than your average grunts.
Disciple of Nagash said:Yeah, to be honest I think having lots of men isn't working. We need to all be in the same unit, so we are stuck close by each other all the time, so we can talk etc.
I also think that it should not just be "go and kill" as that can get repetitive. We need something where we think etc. For example if we were marines and discovered an abandoned space craft. We would have to work out why, give the different characters a chance to think and speak etc. This could then lead them to a space station, upon which more discoveries lead to a planet etc. Of course all the time the GM would need to keep it going, but I think something where the players are a bit more in control, rather than grunts who cannot do anything autonomous might help.
Gree said:Yah, I thnk it's due to my inexperiance as a GM.
Disciple of Nagash said:Not really. If a marine is there, no way is he going to consider guard equal and with good cause. Perhaps if you want to include him as a leader type character who is not actually a leader.....
Disciple of Nagash said:Perhaps this was not just a troop transport? Perhaps it also had some civvies / dignitaries on it. So some people could RP a human other than a guardsman for a bit of fun?
Marcus Von Drac said:Well... As I said I like playing the sneaky stabby type, and you want equal killy power...
How about a mixed marine and ordo malleus/xenos/heriticus force - this gives the option for those who want to be human to play inquisitor/interrigator/assassin - all of which would be on level pegging with marines.
Wallach said:Well Ive seen stories written like it so I want to pitch the idea of marine aspirants we could be any chapter (space wolves would be very characterful.) and as time goes on we could eventually be marines?