Gunhearts OOC Thread - Not valid - Old Gunhearts

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Alright, Thread 2 is over. I would like to discuss some things.

At this point it’s fairly obvious that many of the original people signed on have left and we have left with only a few dedicated players. That’s good, in a way because we know who will post.

To continue on that I’m afraid that I am finding it harder and harder to write Guardsmen. I’ve always been a Marine writer to be honest. That and the fact that the platoon structure right now is seemingly not working very well.

I think this might be more enjoyable if we would play more….character centric or appealing characters. Like Marines, or Inquisitors, but I know I originally started this to make it a chance to look at the ‘’squishy’’ side of things with the Guard, but I’ve found it hard to continue with.

What do people think?
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Yeah, to be honest I think having lots of men isn't working. We need to all be in the same unit, so we are stuck close by each other all the time, so we can talk etc.

I also think that it should not just be "go and kill" as that can get repetitive. We need something where we think etc. For example if we were marines and discovered an abandoned space craft. We would have to work out why, give the different characters a chance to think and speak etc. This could then lead them to a space station, upon which more discoveries lead to a planet etc. Of course all the time the GM would need to keep it going, but I think something where the players are a bit more in control, rather than grunts who cannot do anything autonomous might help.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Hmm, I can understand that your a marine writer at heart, they are cool. But I must admit I like Guardsmen.
As to the keeping the squad together thing, that makes sense, but if we did that we would have to play either Marines or Guard, not both. My worry with marines is that it would be repetative: "Look, Cultists/Orks/Tyraninds! Blam blam slice slice oh look the uber-marines have wiped a load more aliens out, home for tea and medals." I would get bored of this very quickly. I want to keep playing Grince. Sorry to be contrary.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Oh I agree that whoever we play we should not be beating everything. But the issue with Guardsmen is that most of the time they are just being told what to do, i.e go and kill those bad guys. Especially if you are a trooper you won't be involved in discussions etc

If we were a small unit of whatever (maybe one specially thought up for the RP?), that is stranded on its own, so all are equal etc. Having something they need to solve, and of course have fights, I think it should be a lot more interesting.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

I know it has been some time since I posted in The Gunhearts and I'm sorry that I wasn't able to give this RP the time that it deserved (RL issues meant that I missed a lot and then found it difficult to reintegrate) but I have been following the story and I have to say Gree (and the rest of you) you've done a pretty good job of getting it this far. And if nobody objects I would like to contribute a few thoughts...

I think that Marines would suit most people better because there is more scope to be individualistic.. even within a single squad there are far more options available.. so it would be easier for players to express themselves without being so restricted as they would RPing a guardsman.

Secondly, those that RP in TVC are probably more used to RPing characters with a little more power and authority and Marines would offer these players a chance to embrace the more heroic side of themselves (or not as the case may be).

I also think that concerns about the Marines being repetitive wouldn't be so much a problem if those that RP them show the same levels of skill at giving characters personality as they do in TVC. I actually see an oppotunity to inject some humanity back in the SM. Instead of having them just turn up and blow everyone to hell, they could have to really fight for their victories and then there is the oppotunity to RP them during their periods of rest-bite.. allowing players to really express how a marine might think and feel.


Feel free to totally ignore my thoughts if you want, I haven't really earnt the right to share an opinion on the subject but I thought I'd share them anyway.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Not much to add to the above posters to be honest, I also believe that having more powerful characters will be better with more personal authority.
To me the problem with the guardsmen (even the odd ones like Riggins) was like of being able to dictate your own decisions due to the constraints of command.

Whilst Marines still follow the chain of command I can see it being easier to be creative with them than your average grunts.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Get of W said:
Not much to add to the above posters to be honest, I also believe that having more powerful characters will be better with more personal authority.
To me the problem with the guardsmen (even the odd ones like Riggins) was like of being able to dictate your own decisions due to the constraints of command.

Whilst Marines still follow the chain of command I can see it being easier to be creative with them than your average grunts.

This was what I was thinking of.

Don't get me wrong Marcus, I don't want to ruin your fun or the people here. I want to help create an experiance for everyone. I'm trying to find a formula that works and everyone can have fun.

Disciple of Nagash said:
Yeah, to be honest I think having lots of men isn't working. We need to all be in the same unit, so we are stuck close by each other all the time, so we can talk etc.

I also think that it should not just be "go and kill" as that can get repetitive. We need something where we think etc. For example if we were marines and discovered an abandoned space craft. We would have to work out why, give the different characters a chance to think and speak etc. This could then lead them to a space station, upon which more discoveries lead to a planet etc. Of course all the time the GM would need to keep it going, but I think something where the players are a bit more in control, rather than grunts who cannot do anything autonomous might help.

Yah, I thnk it's due to my inexperiance as a GM.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Ok I can see your point. And I get why everyone like the idea of Marines. But with the kind of character I want to play, in fluff-wise terms I just can't see him being a marine. I'm going to have to come up with a new character if your going to change. Now don't get me wrong, I will do, but I'll miss Grince.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Gree said:
Yah, I thnk it's due to my inexperiance as a GM.

Don't put yourself down. As with anything it takes time / practice to get something right.

As I said before, I am more than happy to help, I do have some ideas where in regards to the above posting so let me know.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Thanks DoN. First of all let's see what our options are.

Do people want to do Marines or Inquisition or anything else like Chaos? Or should we inculde some sort of Guard element?
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

I'm happy playing a Librarian, Sorcerer or Inquisitor

What ever will help the plot!

And if you need a hand with anything else, I have a fair bit of spare time heh
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Personally I think we need to be something that fits thus:

A group that can work on their own / make their own decisions or are stranded on their own.
I would definitley say good humans or at a push Tau. I say this because if you want a decent RP you want discussions, thinking, trying to work things out etc, which excludes many 40K races. Plus pretty much everyone can RP a human type character.
Whatever we are, we need to be in a situation where we are threatened, out of our depth.

Personally my suggestion who be unit of *insert race here* who were forced to abandon their ship in an escape pod. They manage to find another ship, only to find it is derelict. That's a decent starting point, leaving everyone on even ground, get everyone talking, and then things can develop from there.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Alright, that sounds good. I have another possible idea. We could be renforcements to an embattled planet and have our ship damaged in orbit to he battle forcing us to land into the planet deep behind enemy lines. There we can meet with with refugees, or locals or whatever and try to get back.

Or we could combine both.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

That also sounds good. As long as we are all together, having to make decisions ourselves (though we could do with a leader to help steer things maybe?), then it gives us reason to talk more as we figure out what to do.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Alirght, for races what do we want to do? I'm thanking we could include Marines, Guard, or any Imperial side really on the same team. If they are stranded then they would all be rendered equal anyway.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Not really. If a marine is there, no way is he going to consider guard equal and with good cause. Perhaps if you want to include him as a leader type character who is not actually a leader.....

Or!

Perhaps this was not just a troop transport? Perhaps it also had some civvies / dignitaries on it. So some people could RP a human other than a guardsman for a bit of fun?
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Disciple of Nagash said:
Not really. If a marine is there, no way is he going to consider guard equal and with good cause. Perhaps if you want to include him as a leader type character who is not actually a leader.....

Well I honestly wanted to play an Astartes. As did some other people.

Disciple of Nagash said:
Perhaps this was not just a troop transport? Perhaps it also had some civvies / dignitaries on it. So some people could RP a human other than a guardsman for a bit of fun?

We don't have to have everyone come from the same place. There could be plenty of room on a large transport of multiple ships crashing.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Marcus Von Drac said:
Well... As I said I like playing the sneaky stabby type, and you want equal killy power...
How about a mixed marine and ordo malleus/xenos/heriticus force - this gives the option for those who want to be human to play inquisitor/interrigator/assassin - all of which would be on level pegging with marines.

I was sorta thinking this.

Also what races are we thinking then? Imperium specific or just the more human-ish ones?
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Wallach said:
Well Ive seen stories written like it so I want to pitch the idea of marine aspirants we could be any chapter (space wolves would be very characterful.) and as time goes on we could eventually be marines?

Thats a nice idea, although I'm not much into space wolves :P

But I do like the idea of all equal aspirants (gives us our freedom) and character progression (eventually becoming marines)

Nice thinking xD
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu