If you could change just one thing....

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
geordieclubba said:
They should put the guess range back in for war machines.

Your on to something, although with meassurment allowed in all other aspects of the game it might be a bit wasted. There could be a larger chance of the dice failing you however. Cannons should either have their bounce removed or be half str on anything other than a direct hit.
 
Cannons only d3 wounds, not d6

Stone throwers only x2 strength in the center hole, not x3. And CANNOT fire "indirectly", only if they REALLY can see the unit they want to shoot at.

Fixed war machines!
 
geordieclubba said:
They should put the guess range back in for war machines.

I generally don't agree with guess ranges because I don't think knowing in your head how long 34.5" is should make you a better Warhammer player. Also you would have to go back to the old rules of disallowing pre-measuring, which is a HUGE change.

There are a couple of things about cannons I would change;

- I always thought it would make sense if cannons scattered from the original target point and perhaps ignore the first misfire from the bounce roll

- D3 Wounds, not D6

- They would not hit both Monsters & Riders when hitting mounted characters (this is one of the biggest "wtf!?" rules out there IMO)

All that said, if I could only make one change it would have to be disruption of ranks == removal of steadfast. Though I would take it one step further and say it would only require one rank (not one rank bonus) to remove steadfast.

Army Specific: I think I would make WoC Demon Princes Unstable not Unbreakable.
 
I would change the way magic works back to the way it was in 6th Edition.

Much more reliable magic dice generation, and not as much "needless" dice rolling.

Since you never seemed to have enough dice for all your wizards in higher point games, it could even scale by having the 2D6 be "1D6 per 1000 points of army. So the standard 2000 point game would get 2D6 dice, but a 3000 point game gets 3D6, 4000 gets 4D6, etc.
 
Infernal Skull said:
I would change the way magic works back to the way it was in 6th Edition.

Much more reliable magic dice generation, and not as much "needless" dice rolling.

How did it work in 6th?
 
Vipoid said:
How did it work in 6th?

Player who's turn it is rolls 2d6 for their power dice pool and adds 1 die for each wizard level. (With a level 4 and a level 2 that would be 2D6+6 power dice.)

Other player rolls 2D6 for their dispel dice pool and adds 1 die for each level 1 or 2 wizard, and 2 dice for each level 3 or 4 wizard. (With a level 3 and a level 1 that would be 2D6+3 dispel dice.)

Wizards did *not* add their level to the casting/ dispelling rolls. Bound Items were auto cast at a set power level and didn't use power dice at all.

Pretty straightforward and reliable.
 
Its not a rule, but I would like all the army books(/codexes for 40k) for whatever edition to be written simultaneously (along with the core rulebook), allowing them all to be balanced against each other. GW could still do a staggered release.
 
The Sun King said:
Why on gods earth would you nerf cannons? You don't think hydras, TG's, chimeras, greater daemons, HPA's etc. is good enough?

Frankly, not really. Any army taking monsters, especially non-flying monsters, is pretty much giving away 200+ points on the first turn of the game if their opponent has cannons.
 
Infernal Skull said:
Vipoid said:
How did it work in 6th?

Player who's turn it is rolls 2d6 for their power dice pool and adds 1 die for each wizard level. (With a level 4 and a level 2 that would be 2D6+6 power dice.)

Other player rolls 2D6 for their dispel dice pool and adds 1 die for each level 1 or 2 wizard, and 2 dice for each level 3 or 4 wizard. (With a level 3 and a level 1 that would be 2D6+3 dispel dice.)

Wizards did *not* add their level to the casting/ dispelling rolls. Bound Items were auto cast at a set power level and didn't use power dice at all.

Pretty straightforward and reliable.

I don't think that's how it was. I remember it being just 2 + the number of wizard levels and for dispel was 2 + (levels / 2) rounding up. So in an army with a level 4 and a level 2 would have 8 dice for casting and 5 for dispel. Dwarves generated 4 + what ever they had.

I hated this system. Because it meant you had to go big or go home with magic. There was no middle ground, it was either a level 1 with two scrolls (you could take multiple back then) or a level 4 and two or three level 2s

Nowadays you can take a single level 2 and still compete in the magic phase, even if your opponent has a level 4.

@ Sun King, Hydras and HPAs are simply under costed and wacking cannons wont really make them that much better because of their regen. I don't mind Chimeras because while they are strong, they are also expensive and only have 4 wounds. TGs are awesome but big, clumsy, crap in combat and can't march when not near the general, you yourself said before that you never ran them because of your shooting heavy meta and they were an auto loss for you. I thought you of all people would be in favour of such a change.

My thoughts are with players who want to mount their characters on monsters but feel it is a massive waste of points because their 600 point dragon lord is just going to get cannoned first turn.

Cannons just irritate me because of their, "point and click - you're dead" nature. No skill, not even that much luck. Just cheap and easy kills. The fact they hit both monster AND rider is just dumb.
 
The Sun King said:
Why on gods earth would you nerf cannons? You don't think hydras, TG's, chimeras, greater daemons, HPA's etc. is good enough?

That seems like something off an odd statement with regard to the TG.

Didn't you say a while ago that you stopped using terrorgheists because they were basically cannon-bait?

RobTheWise said:
I don't think that's how it was. I remember it being just 2 + the number of wizard levels and for dispel was 2 + (levels / 2) rounding up. So in an army with a level 4 and a level 2 would have 8 dice for casting and 5 for dispel. Dwarves generated 4 + what ever they had.

I hated this system. Because it meant you had to go big or go home with magic. There was no middle ground, it was either a level 1 with two scrolls (you could take multiple back then) or a level 4 and two or three level 2s

I recall my group trying this system a while ago for our 2v2s. It shifted the balance from Lv4s (which was good), but also meant that you could easily ensure an overwhelming magic phase for yourself each game (not so good).

Saying that though, I don't think it's any worse than the current system - which is far too random and completely dominated by Lv4s.

RobTheWise said:
Nowadays you can take a single level 2 and still compete in the magic phase, even if your opponent has a level 4.

Compete seems somewhat subjective. I've tried this many times, any my opponent has always dominated the magic phase with his Lv4.

Likewise, on the rarer occasions when I've had a Lv4 and they've just had one or more Lv2s, I had all the advantages.

I think adding your level to the casting total makes Lv4s far too strong - and having completely random magic dice doesn't help much.
 
Dunno if thid has been mentioned.

But make all vampires and vampiric units not have the unstable rule.

Maybe slight increase in points would be required but would balance the crumble well
 
@ Rob & Vipoid: It's true that I never run TG's, that has to do with my meta, not artillery in general. My enemy brings cannons? I don't bring TG's = he just spent 200-300 points on nothing. Also I think you are taking my earlier statement out of context I also mentioned the insane amount of poison attacks in my meta. A good player adapts to his meta. Things only need fixing if they are broken, and IMO canons are not broken - they are a good counter to some units but they are also easily countered. That is what warhammer is partly about: countering what the enemy brings to the table.
Many of the canon-loving players in my meta is starting to complain that they "never do anything" - why? Because people have adapted and now taking artillery just means a waste of points. Most of the time the warmachines on both sides are just aiming at the other players warmachines... what a paradox :)
Re-introducing guess range is not to my taste because:
a) it means we'll have to rebalance the cost of all the warmachines AGAIN.
b) warmachines are not broken(as I said above).
c) the guessing game is not really in the spirit of 8th where you're always allowed to measure.
d) do we really want to guess? I dislike having to rely on my eyesight for something that should be mathmatically based.
e) if canons get nerfed everything will just turn into a monster mash... this is fine for people who like monsters. However I don't play pokemon the wargame, I play warhammer because I like ARMIES going against one another :D

Oh well I'll stop my rambling.
 
The Sun King said:
Many of the canon-loving players in my meta is starting to complain that they "never do anything" - why? Because people have adapted and now taking artillery just means a waste of points.

I think if you need to 'adapt' to a certain type of unit by simply not taking any of a particular unit, then there is a definite balance issue. Like in 7th, if you took infantry, especially expensive, elite infantry, you were pretty much handicapping yourself. Solution? Just take cavalry, chariots and monsters instead.

While this made our armies more competitive, it was hardly balanced because infantry were largely a waste of points.

It's a similar situation with monsters. You're basically shooting yourself in the foot when you take one because other units (cannons) are such hard counters. Yes, you can balance this by simply not taking monsters, but that only addresses the symptom, not the cause, and doesn't suit players (like myself) who love taking big, weird and extravagant units like Dragons and Terrorgheists or Mortis Engines.
 
The Sun King said:
Re-introducing guess range is not to my taste because:

Whilst I'd like to see something done to cannons, I agree that guess range shouldn't be reintroduced.

If nothing else, it relies on the player's skill, rather than the skill of the actual crew - which doesn't seem right to me.


But then, if only there was some representation of the crew's skill at shooting. Some number that could be converted into a to-hit probability for them. :innocent:
 
Vipoid said:
The Sun King said:
Re-introducing guess range is not to my taste because:

Whilst I'd like to see something done to cannons, I agree that guess range shouldn't be reintroduced.

If nothing else, it relies on the player's skill, rather than the skill of the actual crew - which doesn't seem right to me.


But then, if only there was some representation of the crew's skill at shooting. Some number that could be converted into a to-hit probability for them. :innocent:

Yeh, I don't think introducing guess range is the way forward at all.

I am totally with Vipoid on this subject. Why are cannons void of all hit modification, not matter how small the target?

The very idea that a steam tank or an Iron blaster can move and still pick out a character in a unit with a great big cannon and with pin point accuracy is simply ludicrous. In fact, the idea that a stationary cannon could achieve this is ludicrous.

Cannons are not a waste of points if the enemy aren't running monsters. There are still plenty of other juicy targets like chariots heavy cavalry and monstrous infantry / cavalry
 
So instead of all the fancy ideas why not just use the existing ballistic system? Have cannons etc require roll to hit. Then you could for example have dwarfs being much more skilled at hitting the right targets which make sense.

Finally if the roll to hit fails, then instead of nothing you could have an event to represent an off target cannon shot. So you could roll the scatter dice plus D6, measuring that location from the front of the target unit. That is where the cannonball actually lands and then resolve as normal.

Would make players also be more careful about firing near their own units, which again makes a lot of sense.
 
My Mortis Engines survive just fine in a meta that drips with poison and canonballs. The TG's problem is the base size and lack of a proper save - that's a problem few other monsters have, so I do not agree that warmachines are broken or need balancing. Also do note that I am one of the few on these forums who dislike using TG's and this is largely due to my playing style. I'm a control freak and make lists that can take insane amounts of beating without giving up points. This doesn't yield you 20-0 victories in abundance, but it does ensure a healthy amount of wins in total. Johnny actually dropped using his TG's because it was an Auto-win for him, so it's largely based on playing style. If the argument is that Sunny doesn't use TG's = canons are OP, then I think it's very faulty haha :D
 
RobTheWise said:
If nothing else, it relies on the player's skill, rather than the skill of the actual crew - which doesn't seem right to me.

That's my biggest gripe with cannons at the moment (with the possible exception of their hitting both monster and rider).

If we're going to move to TLoS and cover changing to-hit penalties, then cannons should roll to hit.

Even if all cannons get made BS5 as a result, then at least firing through cover will give them pause for thought.
 
In regards to the cannon debate. Has anyone actually fired a cannon?

Believe it or not i have.

Incredibly accurate. They literally do a 'point and click' style accuracy.

Its reflected in the game very well.

My main gripe is that i joined the warhammer universe for my love of monsters. But seeing as they die in one or two shots its just sad for me :(

I think the most sensible idea is dropping it to d3 wounds. I still think that a canon shouldnt count as hitting rider and mount. That should still be randomised.
 
geordieclubba said:
In regards to the cannon debate. Has anyone actually fired a cannon?

Believe it or not i have.

Incredibly accurate. They literally do a 'point and click' style accuracy.

So, even if you can only see your target through a mass of marching infantry - or even a combat between two blocks of infantry - you can still just aim it perfectly? Fascinating.
 
I'd like to see monsters always disrupt ranks, even from the front. (Not breaking steadfast or anything, but making them lose +3 CR would be cool.

I just feel like too often a monster biffs some attacks or a lucky wound or two pop through and the monster panics.
 
geordieclubba said:
In regards to the cannon debate. Has anyone actually fired a cannon?

Believe it or not i have.

Incredibly accurate. They literally do a 'point and click' style accuracy.

Its reflected in the game very well.

My main gripe is that i joined the warhammer universe for my love of monsters. But seeing as they die in one or two shots its just sad for me :(

I think the most sensible idea is dropping it to d3 wounds. I still think that a canon shouldnt count as hitting rider and mount. That should still be randomised.

D3+1 wounds. Fixed.

Now they're still deadly accurate and slightly better than stone throwers for those single targets. (Which cannons should always be aiming at.)

I also agree that hits should be randomized.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu