geordieclubba said:They should put the guess range back in for war machines.
geordieclubba said:They should put the guess range back in for war machines.
Infernal Skull said:I would change the way magic works back to the way it was in 6th Edition.
Much more reliable magic dice generation, and not as much "needless" dice rolling.
Vipoid said:How did it work in 6th?
The Sun King said:Why on gods earth would you nerf cannons? You don't think hydras, TG's, chimeras, greater daemons, HPA's etc. is good enough?
Infernal Skull said:Vipoid said:How did it work in 6th?
Player who's turn it is rolls 2d6 for their power dice pool and adds 1 die for each wizard level. (With a level 4 and a level 2 that would be 2D6+6 power dice.)
Other player rolls 2D6 for their dispel dice pool and adds 1 die for each level 1 or 2 wizard, and 2 dice for each level 3 or 4 wizard. (With a level 3 and a level 1 that would be 2D6+3 dispel dice.)
Wizards did *not* add their level to the casting/ dispelling rolls. Bound Items were auto cast at a set power level and didn't use power dice at all.
Pretty straightforward and reliable.
The Sun King said:Why on gods earth would you nerf cannons? You don't think hydras, TG's, chimeras, greater daemons, HPA's etc. is good enough?
RobTheWise said:I don't think that's how it was. I remember it being just 2 + the number of wizard levels and for dispel was 2 + (levels / 2) rounding up. So in an army with a level 4 and a level 2 would have 8 dice for casting and 5 for dispel. Dwarves generated 4 + what ever they had.
I hated this system. Because it meant you had to go big or go home with magic. There was no middle ground, it was either a level 1 with two scrolls (you could take multiple back then) or a level 4 and two or three level 2s
RobTheWise said:Nowadays you can take a single level 2 and still compete in the magic phase, even if your opponent has a level 4.
The Sun King said:Many of the canon-loving players in my meta is starting to complain that they "never do anything" - why? Because people have adapted and now taking artillery just means a waste of points.
The Sun King said:Re-introducing guess range is not to my taste because:

Vipoid said:The Sun King said:Re-introducing guess range is not to my taste because:
Whilst I'd like to see something done to cannons, I agree that guess range shouldn't be reintroduced.
If nothing else, it relies on the player's skill, rather than the skill of the actual crew - which doesn't seem right to me.
But then, if only there was some representation of the crew's skill at shooting. Some number that could be converted into a to-hit probability for them.![]()
RobTheWise said:If nothing else, it relies on the player's skill, rather than the skill of the actual crew - which doesn't seem right to me.
geordieclubba said:In regards to the cannon debate. Has anyone actually fired a cannon?
Believe it or not i have.
Incredibly accurate. They literally do a 'point and click' style accuracy.
geordieclubba said:In regards to the cannon debate. Has anyone actually fired a cannon?
Believe it or not i have.
Incredibly accurate. They literally do a 'point and click' style accuracy.
Its reflected in the game very well.
My main gripe is that i joined the warhammer universe for my love of monsters. But seeing as they die in one or two shots its just sad for me
I think the most sensible idea is dropping it to d3 wounds. I still think that a canon shouldnt count as hitting rider and mount. That should still be randomised.