question about Death Shriek

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Highlander

Zombie
Feb 20, 2013
1
Zombies
1
The terrorghueist must to roll a 4+ to use Death Shriek if the beastmen player uses calice of the dark rain ?

Thank you
 
This was on warseer aswell. The wording is something along: attacks that do not use ballistic skill has to roll a 4+. It says attacks, not shooting attacks.
 
It's the beastmen book, and it's only in that one shooting phase.

All enemy missile units are at -1 to hit. Weapons or attacks that do not use Ballistic Skill may only fire on the roll of a 4+.

The counter argument is that it only affects missile units and the terrogheist isn't a missile unit.

I see it as the terrorgheist needs to roll a 4+ sadly, since the item says weapons or attacks. The death shriek is definitely an attack.
 
Oops got confused there. I have the beasts book and upon reading, it's confusing."Missile units" is weird, then it goes on to use the word "fire". Am I during my death shriek or banshee howl.
I would probably agree that it can only use it on a 4+ the turn the chalice is revealed.
 
I have to agree also. Death shriek is an attack. I would give it to the Beastman player. Although I do believe it was designed for use against missle units and wamahines and such. That's why the whole "fire" part is in there. But this is what happens when new books come out with new attacks that don't quite fit in with older books wording for certain items.
 
VC FAQ:

Q: Do items or spells that affect missile fire have any affect on a Banshee's Ghostly Howl?
A: No

If howls and shrieks are both special attacks in the shooting phase, then you can scream through chalices, storm banners, and through any other crap our opponents throw at us :)

But let's all be perfectly clear... A shriek/howl is NNOOTT a shooting attack. It's a ssppeecciiaall attack.
 
Ogul said:
It's the beastmen book, and it's only in that one shooting phase.

All enemy missile units are at -1 to hit. Weapons or attacks that do not use Ballistic Skill may only fire on the roll of a 4+.

The counter argument is that it only affects missile units and the terrogheist isn't a missile unit.

I see it as the terrorgheist needs to roll a 4+ sadly, since the item says weapons or attacks. The death shriek is definitely an attack.

This.
 
Fire isn't a keyword used only for shooting attacks. What other phrase would you prefer?

Is it a weapon or attack? Yes.

It applies.

Pretty straight forward.
 
Agree to disagree :)

TGs or Banshees aren't missile units, and their attacks don't use BS, or shoot for that matter. Is it an attack? Yes. Is it an attack, no not in a normal sense... a special attack.

If the wording was "any attacks in the shooting phase must roll a 4+ for that attack to occur" I'd agree with u.

But alas.

Think of it fluff wise... It's a dark rain... I'd have a hard time shooting an arrow, or throwing a rock at someone in the dark, while its raining...
Hell I'd have a hard time Firing a cannon with the rain and all (wicks get wet after all lol)

Ever scream at someone in the rain, in the dark, then it all of a sudden just as youre about to yell at him, it gets dark, then rains... But you were within shouting range right before it got dark and rained, and they didn't move bc it's your turn and all. Think he'd hear you?

Do whatever you want, but ill keep screaming at things in the shooting phase, through storm banners and chalices.
 
"If the wording was "any attacks in the shooting phase must roll a 4+ for that attack to occur" I'd agree with u."

Isn't "Weapons or attacks that do not use ballistic skill may only fire on the roll of a 4+" not exactly what you have asked for?
Using the word "fire" as the basis to say it doesn't work is a bit thin. I mean when it comes down to it you don't actually "fire" a bow or crossbow either.
 
No they're different statements.

You guys can roll your 4+ on the chalice and storm banner etc.

Meanwhile, the rest of us will play Warhammer correctly :rolleyes:

I'll revert to the VC FAQ 1 last time...

Q: Do items (THE CHALLLLICE) or spells that affect missile fire have any affect on a Banshee's Ghostly Howl?
A: No

And I'm done...
 
I think your extending the meaning of that FAQ to far.

The question only asks about items that affect missile fire, however the chalice affects missile fire and "weapons and attacks that do not use ballistic skill". It has one effect that acts differently on different attack types.

I'd also point out that (The Chalice) isn't actually in the FAQ that you quote.
 
Nagashizzar said:
Magpie said:
I'd also point out that (The Chalice) isn't actually in the FAQ that you quote.

The point is that the Chalice IS an item...

Thing is the Chalice doesn't ONLY affect missiles it also affects other attacks.

Not having the ability to affect missiles doesn't then eliminate the effects that is has on things that aren't missiles.
 
FAQ only talks about missile weapons.

Chalice affects other attacks in the shooting phase, including special attacks.
 
Does it? Does it affect other attacks in the shooting phase, including special attacks? Please show me where, in these two statements does it reference special attacks.


Beastmen book:
All enemy missile units are at -1 to hit. Weapons or attacks that do not use Ballistic Skill may only fire on the roll of a 4+.

Everybody keeps quoting the "weapons or attacks", but it doesn't say "other weapons or attacks", does it? No, no it doesn't. It references attacks that don't use BS (Shriek falls into this, yes). But then it references these attacks "fire" on a 4+. That excludes the Shriek. Crossbows certainly do fire to whoever said they didn't.

VC
Q: Do items or spells that affect missile fire have any affect on a Banshee's Ghostly Howl?
A: No

Holy heck.. Look at that word fire again.., looks like they were trying to reference something specific there. Things that fire, things that fire that are affected, by magic items...

Ppl say using the fire is pretty thin... Well addin words like other attacks is thinner than quoting the rules. I'm not making new rules, just interpreting them.

U guys do the math. This is the 3rd attempt at saying the same thing. But if everybody just reads what they think is written and not what's actually written, then we'll get nowhere... Like me ranting and raving in this thread lol ;)

In the end it doesn't matter that much, I guess... They are beastmen and I wouldn't start an argument with a Bman player over this. He's already playing beastmen so.... It's really the difference between 20-0 and 20-0 :(
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu