bigbadbat said:
Where in the faq does it exempt the TG from abilities that affect missile weapons?
It says that the Tomb Banshee's scream is exempt, which can be taken as a precedent for the Terrorgheist scream.
It would be truly bizarre if the terrorgheist scream
wasn't exempt, since there's literally no difference in how they operate, save for the number of wounds they cause. o_o
In any case, are you agreeing that the last sentence refers only to missile attacks? And so, my task is now to convince you that the terrorgheist scream does not count as a missile weapon.
Magpie said:
Absolutely 100% flat wrong. As there is no qualification in the second sentence it is not limited to missile attacks.
Also 100% flat-out wrong.
As I pointed out before, you can't just pick and choose context.
That sentence also doesn't say how long the effect lasts. Does that mean that it's a continuous effect, because the duration isn't printed in the same sentence?
Magpie said:
The simple fact that you needed to include the word missile to make it "clear" shows that with out the word missile in it it applies to the general case of "attacks and weapons that doesn't use BS"
I included the word 'missile', because a lot of people don't seem to understand that sentences are given context by the rest of a paragraph.
"all enemy
missile units are at -1 to hit." This sentence sets up the effect - it tells us that it affects missile units, and what effect to apply to them.
"Weapons or attacks that do not use Ballistic Skill may only fire on the roll of a 4+"
Again, you'll notice that it does not say "
Other attacks." Nor does it mention a different kind of unit. It doesn't
need to. It doesn't need to say
missile attacks and
missile weapons, because the previous sentence has already set up that we're talking exclusively about
missile units.
Magpie said:
Cars that have big engines are fast. Cars that do not have big wheels are slow.
Is the second statement talking only about cars with big engines that have small wheels?
No only cars are being discussed.
That's because your example is both useless and completely irrelevant to this discussion. The above is two separate statements, with no connection or contextual-relevance between them. You could print them on totally different pages of a book, and it wouldn't make the slightest bit of difference. :slapface:
On the other hand, if you separate the last sentence of the Chalice, then you completely change both the context and the effect.
Magpie said:
In the same way that missiles are a subset of the overall group of "Weapons and attacks" so to are big engined cars a subset of the larger group "cars"
The first part applies to a specific sub-set the second applies to the whole group.
You're misreading it - missile units are indeed a subset, comprising (presumably) all units that have shooting-attacks.
The next sentence then talks about a
subset of missile units. i.e. those with attacks that do not use BS.