question about Death Shriek

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Randar said:
I do not need to add any words or interrupt anything it's plain as day. Weapons or attacks no bs = 4+

Over years I have seen some very confusing rules and things needing a FAQ desperately. This to me is a no brainier big time!
Very clear rule. RAW no interputing needed.

Seen some good arguments too. This is just silly.......

Aside from being incorrect. In all your future games, when announcing your scream, please say, "Ok, shooting phase, my banshee is going to fire her howl at your unit." "And now my TG will fire it's Shriek..."

Sounds kinda wierd(silly), doesn't it? Doesn't it?
 
That's exactly what I say :) going to fire my TG at your x. During shooting phase An item can have multiple effects. Ie scabswraith sword. Can you only shriek with it when you use drevstating charge ? Also says when chalice is revealed shooting phase doesn't say anything about whole game. Wow you guys are great lawyers. If the glove doesn't fit you must acquit ???

If a wookie lives on endor than how can my client be guilty! Wish we could poll this I am sure majority would agree need 4+ or no scream

At this point. I am done you can RAI into oblivion boys :). I will play it like majority of normal players
 
No no, thats not exactly what you say, you dont fire your TG at the unit, you're not RAW. I thought u were a RAW guy?

U must fire the TGs shriek.
And fire the banshee's howl.

U see, the banshees or TGs themselves aren't weapons or attacks. They have hand weapons and claws and lungs, and their attacks or either in CC or special attacks in the shooting phase. So when they fire their lungs (which is the howl/shriek, i guess lol?) at things u roll a 4+ ;)
 
cmon guys. this started as such a nice debate and is now down to government political tactics (throwing sand at eachother in playground)

Maybe im stupid, but what I fail to see is why the oldass Chalice rule should override the freshfromthecrypt VC faq saying screams are immune to things that affects shooting attacks?

by the same logic you draw in that scream is a special/ other attack made in shooting phase and therefore fires, like an attack, you also make it a missile fire attack, making it, again immune to spells /items that affect this
 
Randar said:
Also says when chalice is revealed shooting phase doesn't say anything about whole game.

But if you read the sentence as you want to read it, it must be a continuous effect that lasts for the entire game.

You see, here's how the rule is written:

"One use only. At the beginning of the enemy shooting phase, the bearer can summon a storm...[fluff]. For the rest of the phase, all enemy missile units are at -1 to hit. Weapons or attacks that do not use BS may only fire on a roll of 4+."

The last sentence is in the same paragraph as the previous sentences, and they give it context. They tell you when the item can be activated, how many times, and which units it affects (i.e. missile units).

However, this seems to be how you want to read it:

"One use only. At the beginning of the enemy shooting phase, the bearer can summon a storm...[fluff]. For the rest of the phase, all enemy missile units are at -1 to hit.

Weapons or attacks that do not use BS may only fire on a roll of 4+."


In this case, the last sentence is made into a completely separate effect. It does not carry the restrictions of the previous sentence (and so can affect non-missile attacks). However, it also loses the context of when it can be used, and how long it lasts. Instead, you're turning it into an effect which must, because of how it is now written, be continuous.

And that's my point - the previous sentences give the last one context. If you choose to take it on its own, then you must take it completely on its own. You can't just pick and choose which context you want to apply to it.


Randar said:
Wow you guys are great lawyers.

Thanks.

Now, about my fee... :devil2:

Randar said:
If a wookie lives on endor than how can my client be guilty!

Because the wookie is the defendant and the murder took place on Endor? ;)
 
I don't think the word "fire" is the linchpin of any interpretation.
The VC faq regarding items and banshee howls is exclusive to banshee howls.
The second sentence of chalice entry does not use the phrase "missile units", just because it's not the beginning of a new paragraph does not mean missile units are the only ones effected.
I firmly believe any TO would rule that the TG needs a 4+ to scream, or any breath weapons, or any attack of any sort that happens in the shooting phase that does not use BS would also need a 4+.
 
bigbadbat said:
The second sentence of chalice entry does not use the phrase "missile units", just because it's not the beginning of a new paragraph does not mean missile units are the only ones effected.

I never once said that it did say "missile units." If it did, we probably wouldn't be having this discussion. :tongue:

What I've said is that missile units is the logical interpretation when you look at the sentence in context.

The previous sentence explains that the ability affects missile units, giving them -1 to hit. However, not every missile unit uses BS; so, the next sentence explains what happens in those cases.

Now, the second sentence could be worded so that it affects any attacks that don't use BS, as opposed to just those belonging to missile units. But, there needs to be something to clearly indicate that it refers to different units than the previous sentence. Even something as simple as the inclusion of the word 'other'. But, there are no such indicators.

Therefore, the only logical assumption is that the sentence refers to the same (missile) units set up by the previous sentence.

bigbadbat said:
I firmly believe any TO would rule that the TG needs a 4+ to scream, or any breath weapons, or any attack of any sort that happens in the shooting phase that does not use BS would also need a 4+.

You're free to believe that. But, as I said before, I'm not sure how that affects our discussion in any way:

1) Tournament decisions are often made quickly, and may well be seen as incorrect, once the relevant rules are examined in more detail. They may also take relative power levels into account, which rules queries should never do.

2) No such ruling exists. You are talking about a hypothetical tournament that does not exist, and has made no such ruling. If you believe in this, fine, but I don't see its purpose in a rules discussion. It would be like me trying to win the argument by saying "I believe that, if Jesus was here, he'd agree that I'm right."
 
It's not that tough, and this is getting beaten to death.
"For the rest of the phase" (the shooting phase in which the chalice is revealed, and the shooting phase is when the TG screams.)"all enemy missile units are at -1 to hit." Weapons or attacks that do not use Ballistic Skill may only fire on the roll of a 4+"

Now... nowhere in the BRB, or any faq that I'm aware of, are "missile units" defined. Missile weapons are alluded to, in the way of bows, crossbows, or slings. Would you also argue that pistoliers or leadbelchers are exempt? The action "fire" is not defined.
TG scream is an attack that happens in the shooting phase. Doesn't matter if it's a special attack, weird attack, unusual attack, it's an attack. It does not use ballistic skill.

Now I do pride myself in being a card carrying member of the RAW camp, and I wouldn't even let this get to the point where a TO would need to intervene.


What everyone is forgetting in this thread is: THE MOST IMPORTANT RULE!
 
Vipoid said:
midean said:
Shriek attack falls into the catagory of "other attacks" that do not use a BS. Have to agree with Magpie.

But 'other' is the key word there, and does not appear in the rule text.

My interpretation is that the rule refers to missile weapons that do not need to roll to hit - cannons, stone throwers etc.

THIS! That is exactly what they meant and echoes so many other things. Stormbanner, Iceshard...etc. But if someone is going to be that difficult about it, best to do a D6 roll off and keep the game going. Just be sure to say 4-6 it works in favor of the VC player. That way if you lose, you have a better chance of then rolling 4+ :D
 
Melle said:
no need to shout. ..
BBB , you refer only to the TG scream here. Is it same for banshee howl or that one is immune due to the VC faq?

Sorry for using caps lock:'(

The banshee howl I would say is immune as that is specifically noted in the faq.
 
bigbadbat said:
Now... nowhere in the BRB, or any faq that I'm aware of, are "missile units" defined. Missile weapons are alluded to, in the way of bows, crossbows, or slings. Would you also argue that pistoliers or leadbelchers are exempt?

That is an interesting point. From the definition of 'missile weapon' in the rulebook, I would be inclined to define a 'missile unit' as any unit capable of making a shooting attack. But, an official definition might be useful.

Out of interest, any idea if there was a clear definition of 'missile unit' in the edition the Beastmen book was written for?

bigbadbat said:
TG scream is an attack that happens in the shooting phase. Doesn't matter if it's a special attack, weird attack, unusual attack, it's an attack. It does not use ballistic skill

It is an attack, but it is not a missile attack, and that's the key point. The VC faq specifically exempts the banshee/terrorgheist scream from abilities that affect missile weapons.
 
bigbadbat said:
Where in the faq does it exempt the TG from abilities that affect missile weapons?

I am not aware of missile units being defined in the 7th ed. rules.
Like you, I would think it would include any unit capable of making a shooting attack.

Scream =/= Shooting Attack. Best I can come up with there.
 
What are the Weapons or attacks that don't use ballistic skill?

(You'll note I didn't say "all" because you don't need "all" in that statement for it to include every item.)
 
Vipoid said:
Again, 'other' is the key word, because otherwise it's perfectly reasonable and logical to read the second sentence as a clarification of the first. The first sentence says that all missile weapons get -1 to hit. The second sentence then says what to do for missile attacks that don't use BS. i.e. it refers to missile weapons and missile attacks.

If it said "Other attacks that do not use BS...", then it would logically refer to non-missile attacks. However, the current wording seems like it's meant to be read as a clarification on the aforementioned missile weapons.

Absolutely 100% flat wrong. As there is no qualification in the second sentence it is not limited to missile attacks.

The simple fact that you needed to include the word missile to make it "clear" shows that with out the word missile in it it applies to the general case of "attacks and weapons that doesn't use BS"

Cars that have big engines are fast. Cars that do not have big wheels are slow.
Is the second statement talking only about cars with big engines that have small wheels?
No only cars are being discussed.

In the same way that missiles are a subset of the overall group of "Weapons and attacks" so to are big engined cars a subset of the larger group "cars"
The first part applies to a specific sub-set the second applies to the whole group.
 
bigbadbat said:
The banshee howl I would say is immune as that is specifically noted in the faq.

Doesn't our army book consider these two attacks as applying the same rules? I left my book at my cousin's, but I believe the rules for Death Shriek compare directly to Ghostly Howl and even use the phrase "Ghostly Howl" right in the rules. I could be wrong here as I don't have my book in my lap. :/

Ogul said:
Saying that a special attack is not an attack is like saying nehekheran (spelling?) undead aren't undead.

Nehekeran Undead are not Undead and are not affected by the Lore Attribute of Light, for example.

Ogul said:
To you who fought someone who said the faq only covered the ghostly howl, not the death shriek. Your opponent should be okay with you ressurecting several hexwraiths then (Y) :)

I believe Vipoid's lectures about context apply here (but this is for another argument that went no where!! :rolleyes: ).


At any rate, if you want to go RAW -Mad 'At is your king here. The FAQ says ghostly howl isn't affected by items/spells that affect missile fire/units. Sooooooo the Chalice definitely fits into that FAQ. Regardless if the Chalice affects attacks that do not use BS, an FAQ overrules; they are amendments/editions. If you really want to get on the RAW soap-box, then you can't extrapolate (even a little, teensie bit) and you have to also say that Death Shriek wasn't in the FAQ. So roll for it.

But if Death Shriek specifically operates under the same rules as Ghostly Howl, well boys, an FAQ counts as a rule. Can anyone check their VC army book here? Otherwise I'd cite my claim...and validate my point.
 
Ogul said:
Saying that a special attack is not an attack is like saying nehekheran (spelling?) undead aren't undead.

BloodbathMcGrath said:
bigbadbat said:
Nehekeran Undead are not Undead and are not affected by the Lore Attribute of Light, for example.

Yes they are and yes they are.

Tomb kings FAQ:
Q: Are models with the Nehekheran Undead special rule Undead?
A: Yes.


Ogul said:
To you who fought someone who said the faq only covered the ghostly howl, not the death shriek. Your opponent should be okay with you ressurecting several hexwraiths then (Y) :)

BloodbathMcGrath said:
bigbadbat said:
I believe Vipoid's lectures about context apply here (but this is for another argument that went no where!! :rolleyes: ).

It was just a comment, wasn't meant to start a discussion, and it didn't until you brought it up. Though I have changed my mind on that one, they can be raised.. leave this here now.
 
bigbadbat said:
Where in the faq does it exempt the TG from abilities that affect missile weapons?

It says that the Tomb Banshee's scream is exempt, which can be taken as a precedent for the Terrorgheist scream.

It would be truly bizarre if the terrorgheist scream wasn't exempt, since there's literally no difference in how they operate, save for the number of wounds they cause. o_o

In any case, are you agreeing that the last sentence refers only to missile attacks? And so, my task is now to convince you that the terrorgheist scream does not count as a missile weapon.


Magpie said:
Absolutely 100% flat wrong. As there is no qualification in the second sentence it is not limited to missile attacks.

Also 100% flat-out wrong.

As I pointed out before, you can't just pick and choose context.

That sentence also doesn't say how long the effect lasts. Does that mean that it's a continuous effect, because the duration isn't printed in the same sentence?

Magpie said:
The simple fact that you needed to include the word missile to make it "clear" shows that with out the word missile in it it applies to the general case of "attacks and weapons that doesn't use BS"

I included the word 'missile', because a lot of people don't seem to understand that sentences are given context by the rest of a paragraph.

"all enemy missile units are at -1 to hit." This sentence sets up the effect - it tells us that it affects missile units, and what effect to apply to them.

"Weapons or attacks that do not use Ballistic Skill may only fire on the roll of a 4+"

Again, you'll notice that it does not say "Other attacks." Nor does it mention a different kind of unit. It doesn't need to. It doesn't need to say missile attacks and missile weapons, because the previous sentence has already set up that we're talking exclusively about missile units.


Magpie said:
Cars that have big engines are fast. Cars that do not have big wheels are slow.
Is the second statement talking only about cars with big engines that have small wheels?
No only cars are being discussed.

That's because your example is both useless and completely irrelevant to this discussion. The above is two separate statements, with no connection or contextual-relevance between them. You could print them on totally different pages of a book, and it wouldn't make the slightest bit of difference. :slapface:

On the other hand, if you separate the last sentence of the Chalice, then you completely change both the context and the effect.

Magpie said:
In the same way that missiles are a subset of the overall group of "Weapons and attacks" so to are big engined cars a subset of the larger group "cars"
The first part applies to a specific sub-set the second applies to the whole group.

You're misreading it - missile units are indeed a subset, comprising (presumably) all units that have shooting-attacks.

The next sentence then talks about a subset of missile units. i.e. those with attacks that do not use BS.
 
bigbadbat said:
Melle said:
no need to shout. ..
BBB , you refer only to the TG scream here. Is it same for banshee howl or that one is immune due to the VC faq?

Sorry for using caps lock:'(

The banshee howl I would say is immune as that is specifically noted in the faq.

np.

interesting.....
there is 3 differences between ghostly howl and death shriek.
1. The name.
2. The number of wounds 2d6+2 and 2d6+remaining wounds
3. the last sentence in first part of their rules.
banshee: if the tomb banshee is engaged in close combat her ghostly howl can only target an enemy unit in base contact.
TG: if the TG is engaged in combat its death shriek may target a unit in base contact

other than that, their rules share the exact same wording.
this, to me at least, tells their atracks work the same, and both are immune to the chalice
 
Anyone that thinks the faq regarding the Ghostly howl and items that affect missile fire, should somehow affect the Death Shriek is Extrapolating. Plain and Simple. The faq in no way supports your arguments regarding the TG's Death Shriek.

Here's why for all you alleged RAW campers...

Look at the first faq entry for VC.
"Can the Banshee's Ghostly howl or the Terrorgheist's Death Shriek...."

Now here we have set a precedent. They include both attacks in a single entry, meaning that any further mention of one without the other is exclusive to the one mentioned. i.e. the faq of banshee's ghostly howl that everyone keeps thinking applies to TG.

TG scream is affected by chalice. RAW.
 
bigbadbat said:
Look at the first faq entry for VC.
"Can the Banshee's Ghostly howl or the Terrorgheist's Death Shriek...."

Now here we have set a precedent. They include both attacks in a single entry, meaning that any further mention of one without the other is exclusive to the one mentioned. i.e. the faq of banshee's ghostly howl that everyone keeps thinking applies to TG.

Not necessarily. There's an alternate possibility that the answers were simply written based on the individual questions, and then combined later.

For example, in the first case, someone may have asked about the screams of both banshees and terrorgheists, and so both were included in the answer. On the other hand, someone may have only asked if the banshee scream counted as a missile weapon and so, only the banshee scream was mentioned in the subsequent answer.

Whether or not that's the case, we don't know. But, it is a possibility.


I guess this is an aside, but I just noticed this:

Q: If a Tomb Banshee wishes to use her Ghostly Howl attack in close
combat, does this have to be targeted against an enemy unit that the
Tomb Banshee model is in base contact with? (p31)
A: Yes.

So, if what you say is true, are we saying that a Terrorghiest in combat can aim his scream at any enemy unit in the same combat - even if it isn't in base contact?

bigbadbat said:
Anyone that thinks the faq regarding the Ghostly howl and items that affect missile fire, should somehow affect the Death Shriek is Extrapolating. Plain and Simple. The faq in no way supports your arguments regarding the TG's Death Shriek.

Here's my question - why would it not apply to the terrorghiest? What difference between these attacks would make one count as a missile weapon, and the other not? Neither are shooting attacks, and both follow identical rules in terms of how and when they are used.

I just don't understand why one would count as a missile attack, and the other wouldn't. o.o
 
Vipoid said:
I guess this is an aside, but I just noticed this:

Q: If a Tomb Banshee wishes to use her Ghostly Howl attack in close
combat, does this have to be targeted against an enemy unit that the
Tomb Banshee model is in base contact with? (p31)
A: Yes.

So, if what you say is true, are we saying that a Terrorghiest in combat can aim his scream at any enemy unit in the same combat - even if it isn't in base contact?

He can scream out of his combat, and if he is in combat with someone that isn't in base contact, he would need line of sight and 8" as usual.

Because the terrorgheist rules say he MAY target a unit in base contact, when the ghostly howl says it can only target a unit in base contact, if in combat.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu