TinTip said:So now that we figured out that it is legal RAW,
what type of attack does red fury create?
The exact same attack that caused the wound or just a normal close combat attack?
Narenzade said:How is this thread still a thing?
It's this kind of shit that would make me slap the player across from me. It is clearly not intended that way. It doesn't work that way. I'd seriously just pick up my shit and leave if someone argued this asinine janky shit with me. ... And maybe body slam them into a porcupine.
Omnichron said:Narenzade said:How is this thread still a thing?
It's this kind of shit that would make me slap the player across from me. It is clearly not intended that way. It doesn't work that way. I'd seriously just pick up my shit and leave if someone argued this asinine janky shit with me. ... And maybe body slam them into a porcupine.
Agreed.
Narenzade said:It's this kind of shit that would make me slap the player across from me. It is clearly not intended that way. It doesn't work that way. I'd seriously just pick up my shit and leave if someone argued this asinine janky shit with me. ... And maybe body slam them into a porcupine.
Narenzade said:How is this thread still a thing?
It's this kind of shit that would make me slap the player across from me. It is clearly not intended that way. It doesn't work that way. I'd seriously just pick up my shit and leave if someone argued this asinine janky shit with me. ... And maybe body slam them into a porcupine.
Magpie said:Red Fury requires you to "cause a wound in close combat" not "cause a wound while engaged in combat" nor "cause a wound on a unit engaged in combat"
Vipoid said:Magpie said:Red Fury requires you to "cause a wound in close combat" not "cause a wound while engaged in combat" nor "cause a wound on a unit engaged in combat"
If you go by that logic, then if you want to cast a Hex spell on a unit in close combat, you can only cast it in your close combat phase. :tongue:
(Hex spells say that can be cast on a unit in close combat - not a unit engaged in close combat.)
Magpie said:Vipoid said:Magpie said:Red Fury requires you to "cause a wound in close combat" not "cause a wound while engaged in combat" nor "cause a wound on a unit engaged in combat"
If you go by that logic, then if you want to cast a Hex spell on a unit in close combat, you can only cast it in your close combat phase. :tongue:
(Hex spells say that can be cast on a unit in close combat - not a unit engaged in close combat.)
What it means is that because all Close Combats are resolved in the Close Combat phase and that the Close combat is over at the end of the phase; wounds cannot be caused "in close combat" outside of the close combat phase, despite the units still being "in" or more correctly "engaged in" close combat.
TinTip said:But Red Fury is a special rule from the AB that is allowing the attacks to happen outside of the Close Combat Phase, and since AB over rules BRB i see nothing stopping this.
^ThisMagpie said:The rule says the wounds MUST be caused in close combat, not "caused while in close combat" nor "caused while engaged in close combat" simply in close combat and the rules are pretty clear that close combats are resolved, i.e. the wounds are caused and can only be caused, in the close combat phase.
Magpie said:How does Red Fury allow for wounds to be caused outside of the Close Combat Phase?
The rule says the wounds MUST be caused in close combat, not "caused while in close combat" nor "caused while engaged in close combat" simply in close combat and the rules are pretty clear that close combats are resolved, i.e. the wounds are caused and can only be caused, in the close combat phase.
TinTip said:red fury does not specify the close combat phase, merely close combat.
TinTip said:but by your logic the death shriek could not be used during the shooting phase, because it is being used in close combat.
Magpie said:Death Shriek : "even if the Terrorgheist ..... or is ENGAGED in close combat" and "If the Terrorgheist is ENGAGED in combat..."
That's not "causing wounds in close combat" it's "causing wounds while engaged in close combat". Two very different things.
Magpie said:That's not "causing wounds in close combat" it's "causing wounds while engaged in close combat". Two very different things.