Will this work with Death Shriek

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
So now that we figured out that it is legal RAW,
what type of attack does red fury create?

The exact same attack that caused the wound or just a normal close combat attack?
 
TinTip said:
So now that we figured out that it is legal RAW,
what type of attack does red fury create?

The exact same attack that caused the wound or just a normal close combat attack?

It's not legal raw. It's a special attack in the shooting phase that can be used while engaged in close combat. It's not close combat, nor close combat attacks.

Close combat isn't a state that means that everything you do while youre engaged to it, is close combat. It's what you do IN close combat that's close combat. The Ghostly Howl isn't close combat because it happens in Shooting.

You can use magic while your engaged in close combat, that doesn't make the magic close combat though. It's the same with the howl, it's done in the shooting phase and isn't close combat.
 
How is this thread still a thing?

It's this kind of shit that would make me slap the player across from me. It is clearly not intended that way. It doesn't work that way. I'd seriously just pick up my shit and leave if someone argued this asinine janky shit with me. ... And maybe body slam them into a porcupine.
 
Narenzade said:
How is this thread still a thing?

It's this kind of shit that would make me slap the player across from me. It is clearly not intended that way. It doesn't work that way. I'd seriously just pick up my shit and leave if someone argued this asinine janky shit with me. ... And maybe body slam them into a porcupine.

Agreed.
 
Omnichron said:
Narenzade said:
How is this thread still a thing?

It's this kind of shit that would make me slap the player across from me. It is clearly not intended that way. It doesn't work that way. I'd seriously just pick up my shit and leave if someone argued this asinine janky shit with me. ... And maybe body slam them into a porcupine.

Agreed.

Double ditto......:thumbsup:
 
Narenzade said:
It's this kind of shit that would make me slap the player across from me. It is clearly not intended that way. It doesn't work that way. I'd seriously just pick up my shit and leave if someone argued this asinine janky shit with me. ... And maybe body slam them into a porcupine.

Also agreed.
 
Narenzade said:
How is this thread still a thing?

It's this kind of shit that would make me slap the player across from me. It is clearly not intended that way. It doesn't work that way. I'd seriously just pick up my shit and leave if someone argued this asinine janky shit with me. ... And maybe body slam them into a porcupine.

qft
 
I have actually left matches and even a tournament once ( that i was currently in and asured 1st place) Due to people that argue these very same things, I want to play and have fun not sit and argue all day about Item X or what Y means. Every person who picks up a BRB and army book seems to "READ" the exact same words diffrently......

I rather just agree unless its totally out to lunch. I win from tactics not luck of the dice or a key move going off the way i want lol.

I wouldnt do or use this even tho RAW wise coudl have some wiggle room. 75 point sword heck no! almost same points as 10 dire wovles!!!
 
I myself wouldn't allow red fury extra attacks from breath weapons under this statement

Q: Do Breath Weapon hits benefit from any other special rules,
equipment or magic items of the model that inflicts the hits? (p67)
A: No.
 
Page 46
"All close combats must be resolved during this phase"

and

Page 54, Taking A break Test
"..... -this close combat has finished for the turn"

Limit the ability to "cause a wound in Close Combat" to the Close Combat Phase.

Red Fury requires you to "cause a wound in close combat" not "cause a wound while engaged in combat" nor "cause a wound on a unit engaged in combat"

RAW says it doesn't happen.
 
Magpie said:
Red Fury requires you to "cause a wound in close combat" not "cause a wound while engaged in combat" nor "cause a wound on a unit engaged in combat"

If you go by that logic, then if you want to cast a Hex spell on a unit in close combat, you can only cast it in your close combat phase. :tongue:

(Hex spells say that can be cast on a unit in close combat - not a unit engaged in close combat.)
 
Vipoid said:
Magpie said:
Red Fury requires you to "cause a wound in close combat" not "cause a wound while engaged in combat" nor "cause a wound on a unit engaged in combat"

If you go by that logic, then if you want to cast a Hex spell on a unit in close combat, you can only cast it in your close combat phase. :tongue:

(Hex spells say that can be cast on a unit in close combat - not a unit engaged in close combat.)

What it means is that because all Close Combats are resolved in the Close Combat phase and that the Close combat is over at the end of the phase; wounds cannot be caused "in close combat" outside of the close combat phase, despite the units still being "in" or more correctly "engaged in" close combat.
 
Magpie said:
Vipoid said:
Magpie said:
Red Fury requires you to "cause a wound in close combat" not "cause a wound while engaged in combat" nor "cause a wound on a unit engaged in combat"

If you go by that logic, then if you want to cast a Hex spell on a unit in close combat, you can only cast it in your close combat phase. :tongue:

(Hex spells say that can be cast on a unit in close combat - not a unit engaged in close combat.)

What it means is that because all Close Combats are resolved in the Close Combat phase and that the Close combat is over at the end of the phase; wounds cannot be caused "in close combat" outside of the close combat phase, despite the units still being "in" or more correctly "engaged in" close combat.

But Red Fury is a special rule from the AB that is allowing the attacks to happen outside of the Close Combat Phase, and since AB over rules BRB i see nothing stopping this.


and i know i've said it numerous times but its a special attack, not a shooting attack and not a breath weapon, in fact if it was a breath weapon the argument would be over because those do happen in the close combat phase
 
For some reason, I have an image of Phil Kelly saying to himself "Why is no one using this? I made it to be the ultimate Vampire combo, but I haven't seen it used once. Why do they think I made Skabscrath so expensive? Why else would I price Curse of the Revnant so that a model can't have both that and Red Fury? I even made sure the scream counted as an 'attack'. And yet... no a single person has made use of this tactic." :'(


Whilst I'm sure this isn't the case, I would find it hilarious if it turns out this quirk was intended. ;)
 
TinTip said:
But Red Fury is a special rule from the AB that is allowing the attacks to happen outside of the Close Combat Phase, and since AB over rules BRB i see nothing stopping this.

How does Red Fury allow for wounds to be caused outside of the Close Combat Phase?

The rule says the wounds MUST be caused in close combat, not "caused while in close combat" nor "caused while engaged in close combat" simply in close combat and the rules are pretty clear that close combats are resolved, i.e. the wounds are caused and can only be caused, in the close combat phase.
 
Magpie said:
The rule says the wounds MUST be caused in close combat, not "caused while in close combat" nor "caused while engaged in close combat" simply in close combat and the rules are pretty clear that close combats are resolved, i.e. the wounds are caused and can only be caused, in the close combat phase.
^This
 
Magpie said:
How does Red Fury allow for wounds to be caused outside of the Close Combat Phase?

The rule says the wounds MUST be caused in close combat, not "caused while in close combat" nor "caused while engaged in close combat" simply in close combat and the rules are pretty clear that close combats are resolved, i.e. the wounds are caused and can only be caused, in the close combat phase.

red fury does not specify the close combat phase, merely close combat.

but by your logic the death shriek could not be used during the shooting phase, because it is being used in close combat.
 
TinTip said:
red fury does not specify the close combat phase, merely close combat.

Red Fury: "For each unsaved Wound that the Vampire causes in close combat...."

Not while in close combat CAUSES IN CLOSE COMBAT. As I showed before you can only cause a wound in close combat during the resolution of close combat and that can only happen in the close combat phase.

TinTip said:
but by your logic the death shriek could not be used during the shooting phase, because it is being used in close combat.

Death Shriek : "even if the Terrorgheist ..... or is ENGAGED in close combat" and "If the Terrorgheist is ENGAGED in combat..."

That's not "causing wounds in close combat" it's "causing wounds while engaged in close combat". Two very different things.
 
Magpie said:
Death Shriek : "even if the Terrorgheist ..... or is ENGAGED in close combat" and "If the Terrorgheist is ENGAGED in combat..."

That's not "causing wounds in close combat" it's "causing wounds while engaged in close combat". Two very different things.

How are these 2 different things, these are the exact same thing
 
Magpie said:
That's not "causing wounds in close combat" it's "causing wounds while engaged in close combat". Two very different things.

Engaged is not a key word. Those two phrases can be (and are) used interchangeably.

An effect can specify 'in close combat', but still refer to a unit engaged in close combat, as opposed to referring exclusively to the close combat phase.
 
Death Shriek makes the qualifier that is can be used by a unit engaged in close combat, so "but by your logic the death shriek could not be used during the shooting phase, because it is being used in close combat." doesn't follow. It is being used while engaged in combat, not "in close combat"

The fact still remains that "wounds in close combat" can only be caused in the close combat phase.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu