Black Knight vs Blood Knight

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
May 25, 2009
20
Zombies
12
Since i begain playing Warhammer i have seen a lot of blood knight builds and not many black knight builds. I don't if this is true most of the time. (Maybe Rochester is just crazy.) Blood knights do have str 7 on the charge. However most core are not killing blow proof. (Ogres are a diffrent story.) Which is better?:?:
 
I prefer Black Knights all the way. I refuse to in any way, shape, or form model or use Blood knights.

Call it a personal decision, but to strategically back up my decision, here ya go.

Black knights have ethereal movement. BIG plus. I can not state how many times I've had my knights charge out of a wood and say hello while safe from near all reprisals simply because, well, they're behind trees.

Cheaper. Oh lordie! Money wise and points wise. 24 points for a 3+ armor save (2+ if barded) knight with one str 6 attack and one Horsie against what should be RnF troops? Oh, and by the way, he has killing blow, and magical weapons. What's not to like? You can get two Black Knights for every one blood knight.

Banner of the Barrows. Yes, this deserves its own mention. WS 4 isn't exactly stellar for Elites, but still. On most core troops you'll hit on threes, with this, you hit on twos. what other unit can hit on twos, I ask? Not man, if at all. Hitting on twos with Str 6, even a BT is looking at you askance because you have a simple -possibility- of doing significant wounds to him. You'd hit on threes, wound on fours, and those are darn good odds against that thing.

And, lastly, my Main reason for taking Black knights over their overpowered cousins.

I hate frenzy. Frenzy on an undead model is useless! You get an extra attack, yes. You do. But, you are forced to charge! With a steamroll unit, being baited into a bad situation is hugely ...just...bad. I play with Black Knights and laugh at WE's, instead of gritting my teeth as my Blood knights are once again misled into trees.


There, rant is over. :D

My personal views on why I use Black Knights instead of blood knights. They don't even deserve the Capital letter in their name in my opinion. Take care, have fun, and bring the ethereal bad boys! :D
 
Well I've never used Blood Knights, but as I see it their a blunt instrument. It's almost not worth being subtle, just a frontal charge and watch the enemy flee. Black Knights however are more subtle. Being able to waltz through terrain is, like Onikaigo said a big plus. The main reason I've stayed away from Blood Knights though? I'm a 16 year old with no job. I'm not going to spend £40 (or whatever) on five horsemen!
 
cost is an issue - although the blood knight models are rather significantly better than the black knight ones.

however, in teh game, for all the reasons listed above, I'd also go with the black knights.

don't forget though that blood knights can ALWAYS march and can enable units near them to march as well. They can also be joind by characters freely - joining a character to a black knight unit results in them losing their ethereal movement.
 
...except if that character is a Wight :-).

Being cheaper, Black Knights can be easier fielded in sufficient numbers to cause autobreak from fear. Though given the hitting power of Blood Keep Knights, this usually only comes into play against stubborn enemies.
 
dont black knights have weapon skills three? so even with the banner they only hit guys on 3's not 2's? i think Onikaigo is mistaken?
 
Onikaigo is indeed mistaken there, unfortunately. Both the grave guard and black knights have only got WS 3, which is a bit of a downer every now and then. :(
 
Also for suvivabilty Black knights are as tough as blood knights and half the price (2+ AS with barding and T4) and don't have to overrun.
 
i suppose I'll probably go down the route of converted Chaos Knights for Blood knights. They may be hammerlike. But if you've got to use a hammer, may as well reach for the biggest one around :D
 
I think both have their place, and it'll very much depend on who you are playing and what role you want them to do. Certainly, if you need to kill an unbreakable/stubborn ItP unit, nothing is going to do that quicker than blood knights, but black knights are much better as small quick flanking units, and will go where you tell them.

Really, decide what you need the unit to do, and then make a decision as to which is most suitable for that role.
 
.... and definitely convert from some chaos knights!

Here at least, blood knights are $110!!!!! (canadian dollars)

I don't care if they're nice models, they aren't THAT nice!!!!

More on topic - I stayed away from blood knights until very recently when I started including them on occasion... the enemy will throw everything they've got into taking them down... or the sly player will just redirect them, feed them garbage, or get them out of position to allow the carnasaur riding old blood to ram into their flank! (I'm not bitter about that one... seriously... o.o )

So I'm thinking that I'm returning to my original position that the black knight is preferable to the blood knight... cheaper, tactically flexible with the ethereal movement, killing blow, same AS, same T, NOT frenzied... did I mention cheaper????

but yes, the blood knights do hit like a truck.....
 
I've never use Blood Knights either (though I have acquired all the bitz needed to make them, $110 + CDN [umm... screw you, GW!]).

Black Knights are cheaper to buy [$ ands pts]. Ethereal is great, Frenzy is crap!

Personally, I'd reserve using Blood knights for huge games (like 3k) where losing THAT many points would be lessened by the fact that its a larger game.
 
Why I prefer Black Knights.

For one people react better to it. I'm trying to design VC lists that are tough, and competitive, without making my opponent want to punch me. "Tough, but not a jerk" basically.



Reasons why I prefer them anyways:

Ethereal movement. No need to worry about 6 or 7 wide being to wide to avoid that pesky edge of woods or anything. Very nice to have. Especially against wood elf armies.

Ethereal movement also helps in setting up a flank charge where they can bust the ranks and possibly pin a unit if they don't break it right away... or as a support flank charge to crush an enemy unit.

Killing Blow: Always a nice thing to have, especially against other knights, or heavily armored foot troops.

Character combo: I love putting a Wight King in here, and especially with Sword of Kings (assuming I don't assign that WK to bodyguard duty). If the WK with Sword of Kings is in there... suddenly they are dropping a lot of guys! Even with a regular Wight King (which is cheap) they are much deadlier.

Perfect unit for the Royal Banner of Strigos. Since they depend so much on the charge, the banner of Strigos can help make up for poor rolls. With S6 on the charge, they are likely to wound on a 2+ most of the time. So if I can make most hit, there will be quite a bit of dead on the other end!

No Frenzy. I absolutely HATE frenzy. I don't like opponents being able to manipulate my army easily. With how expensive Blood Knights are (and that they are likely a main unit) having a bunch of cheap units pulling them off to nowhere is frustrating.

Combo #2
Fighty Vampire Lord with Blood Drinker. While you lose Ethereal movement, the blood drinker is a nice little addition that keep the unit at full strength. Throw in x2 Unit Strength banner and you'll have a unit buster.


Plus I just like Black Knights from a thematic sense. They seem so much cooler. Why I can't stand the current models, they're a fun converting opportunity. Empire knights or Bret Knights work just fine for this... and look great too.
 
It's also quite true that at games of 2250 or below, it can often be a game of getting the blood knights to work, and your whole army needs to work around that objective, in a similar way to taking a Dragon. In that way, your games can be a bit win big or loose big, and might tend to be a bit less interesting for your opponent.
 
On the other hand it is fun to take the Blood Knights for the challenge. More difficult to use than the Black Knights can give your more insight and tactical experience. Plus I didn't pay £35.00 not to use them xd
 
I didn't pay anywhere near that for mine (that I'll be converting - prob about $40-50 CDN). Once I've got the time to assemble, convert, and paint them... I still doubt that they'll get a lot of use. Prob just be a once in a while unit.
 
They definately are fun to break out now and then to surprise people, but I don't think I'd want to take blood knights in every game I played.
 
I'm thinking of trying a unit of 5 KotBK, no upgrades. Not too many eggs in that basket, then it just comes down to how well I can screen them/disable shooting/protect them from magic etc. Besides, if everything goes crazy at this unit and lets my lords unit of BKs through mostly unmolested, it might almost be worth it.
 
That can work well. If anything, for the same points, I'd take 4 but with the Royal standard of Strigos (unless you're using it some where else). Generally, it'll get you more hits and will save you on those times when your knights suffer from rubber lances! They already have to do pursuit and overrun, so that no real disadvantage. The only real negative is one less wound on the unit and possibly giving up the VPs for the banner.
 
I've run both, and it's Blood Knights all the way! I run 6 with no champ or musician. No champ because then you don't have to accept challenges. The other great thing about the Blood Knights is that they have the vampire special rule and count as vampires helping to ensure that all your units can march. If you play intelligently you should never have trouble screening the knights or using Van Hel's to move them where you want them. I also run them with the banner that allows re-rolls to hit. Effectively, the unit gets 18 WS 5 attacks with re-rolls and S 7 to wound with a minus 3 to armor saves and also gets 12 S 4 attacks that are re-rollable to hit and -1 to armor from horses. Why would you ever want to run black knights instead of BLOOD KNIGHTS when considering all these pluses. If you are worried about ranged attacks just take a unit of 5 Wraiths and a Banshee and use them to screen as they are ethreal and will laugh at most ranged fire.
 
As Disciple of Nagash already mentioned it's a challlenge to use blood knights well against decent opponents.

against people who just started they will beat the crap out of them, but if you don't play well with you KotBK against a decent opponent you wil be slaughtered.


I like to have a challenge and I really really like the fluff of KotBK, thid is why I use them almost every game.

Btw the best way to run them is in my eyes:
vamp
dreadknight
inf hate

blood drinker

5 KotBK
std
(strigos or flag of the blood keep)
 
Seriously though, at my local store we have some of the best players in the country, and many would say world. None of the players here would ever consider running Black Knights without already having a unit of Blood Knights. Maybe the list we play is just more advanced than what the rest of you are seeing or playing. Or, possibly that the level of players is superior to other places, but I have only seen a rare time or two that the knights have not decimated whatever they played against. They never die (Invocation), can charge 22" in a turn (Van Hel's Dance), and as mentioned before have an amazing stat line. I do not understand the rationalization of others arguments that the Black Knights are better. I am more than willing to counter point any situation that you may have gotten into with helpful tactics and strategies, so your list and play will improve, if you ask.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu