I prefer Black Knights all the way. I refuse to in any way, shape, or form model or use Blood knights.
Call it a personal decision, but to strategically back up my decision, here ya go.
Black knights have ethereal movement. BIG plus. I can not state how many times I've had my knights charge out of a wood and say hello while safe from near all reprisals simply because, well, they're behind trees.
Cheaper. Oh lordie! Money wise and points wise. 24 points for a 3+ armor save (2+ if barded) knight with one str 6 attack and one Horsie against what should be RnF troops? Oh, and by the way, he has killing blow, and magical weapons. What's not to like? You can get two Black Knights for every one blood knight.
Banner of the Barrows. Yes, this deserves its own mention. WS 4 isn't exactly stellar for Elites, but still. On most core troops you'll hit on threes, with this, you hit on twos. what other unit can hit on twos, I ask? Not man, if at all. Hitting on twos with Str 6, even a BT is looking at you askance because you have a simple -possibility- of doing significant wounds to him. You'd hit on threes, wound on fours, and those are darn good odds against that thing.
And, lastly, my Main reason for taking Black knights over their overpowered cousins.
I hate frenzy. Frenzy on an undead model is useless! You get an extra attack, yes. You do. But, you are forced to charge! With a steamroll unit, being baited into a bad situation is hugely ...just...bad. I play with Black Knights and laugh at WE's, instead of gritting my teeth as my Blood knights are once again misled into trees.
There, rant is over.
My personal views on why I use Black Knights instead of blood knights. They don't even deserve the Capital letter in their name in my opinion. Take care, have fun, and bring the ethereal bad boys!
