I will admit that I'm typically a bit of a rules lawyer, and I do find statements like:
offensive. Mostly because it has the implicit statement that your spirit of the rules is better than my spirit of the rules.
As to the rest, LordFear I don't disagree with you as to the probable intent. Unfortunately, there is debate however. As soon as there is debate, GW has provided a rule to handle it...the active player decides. I see your argument that the first statement is not really a rule. So now remove it. The sequencing issue remains. Which again falls back on the active player.
Let us look at the spirit of the rule in question, and not the confusion caused by dealing with two different versions of the rules.
offensive. Mostly because it has the implicit statement that your spirit of the rules is better than my spirit of the rules.
As to the rest, LordFear I don't disagree with you as to the probable intent. Unfortunately, there is debate however. As soon as there is debate, GW has provided a rule to handle it...the active player decides. I see your argument that the first statement is not really a rule. So now remove it. The sequencing issue remains. Which again falls back on the active player.