Rule clarification for Black coach

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I will admit that I'm typically a bit of a rules lawyer, and I do find statements like:

Let us look at the spirit of the rule in question, and not the confusion caused by dealing with two different versions of the rules.

offensive. Mostly because it has the implicit statement that your spirit of the rules is better than my spirit of the rules.

As to the rest, LordFear I don't disagree with you as to the probable intent. Unfortunately, there is debate however. As soon as there is debate, GW has provided a rule to handle it...the active player decides. I see your argument that the first statement is not really a rule. So now remove it. The sequencing issue remains. Which again falls back on the active player.
 
If we accept that Active player chooses and Evocation of Death happens at the same time as Generating the Power Pool then Evocation of Death will only ever happen on your own magic phase if you choose to. I mean why would you opponent choose to resolve the Winds of Magic Roll before Evocation?

Seems pricey for something which only randomly breaks your own magic phases.

Aramoro
 
bored1 said:
As to the rest, LordFear I don't disagree with you as to the probable intent. Unfortunately, there is debate however.

Debate is fine, and I thank you for it- if people pretended these issues didn't exist, then there would be even less chance of GW solving them :)

As soon as there is debate, GW has provided a rule to handle it...the active player decides. I see your argument that the first statement is not really a rule. So now remove it. The sequencing issue remains. Which again falls back on the active player.

You have not really understood the argument. If you accept that the first line isn't a specific rule, and remove it, then you are just left with the command to roll the power dice- with no time directive which might cause a clash for the sequencing rules to kick in. At this point, the only possible way to follow the rule is to roll the pool dice when they have been generated- which, at the risk of repeating myself, is, well, after they have been generated :thumbsup:
 
midean said:
Greetings fellow Undead. Well, I have been lurking on other sites to...well....spy on what they say do and plan to do....xD...

One thing I specifically check is how they plan, think and deal with the black coach and PD absorption. Now, unfortunately some of the sites are under the belief that since both generation and our absorbing happen at the "start" of the phase and that they can use the sequencing rule and say on their turn the BC absorbs before they have to roll. Giving us nothing to absorb. Now, we all here know that is rubbish but as there is no general clarification it tends to lead to arguments about what happens first and sequencing.

Found the section we need to show them whats done first. Pg 47 under the Evocation of death section. Second sentence. "Roll the dice in the power pool". Don't need any more than that. For us to be able to roll the dice in the power pool they would have had to roll for the Winds of Magic. Seems a lot of people are missing this section so next time someone tells you you have to roll for absorption before they roll for winds show them this section. And suck their dice up and KILL them with'em.....:twisted:

Totally agree on that... we may find attrition when it boils down to Channelling... technically you may not have mages so no channelling, winds of magic are still rolled since they are not something that is connected to having mages (you roll the dice and then if you don't have mages you don't cast... but magic exists regardless of the existence of a mage in the game). Page 30 states it clearly: magic is derived from the same source: the fickle winds of magic that spills across the world... so there is no escape for those not bringing a magician in the hope of escaping the Black Coach power: it sucks magic (dice in this case) regardless of the presence of a magician in the opposed faction. (I should remind all of you of the order of events: 1. roll for the Winds... 2. Cast... you have no mage, there is no phase 2...)
 
Hmm, true LordFear. I suppose what it boils down to, in that case, is that most tournaments seem to be choosing to include the timing sentence as a rule, which I can certainly understand. As such, the sequencing rule does come into play.

Unlike previous editions, the Dire Wolf FAQ hasn't become broadly accepted as of yet, and there are no guarantees it will be. GW will have to FAQ it, and who knows when that will happen.
 
I would agree that RAW the order of resolution of the effects is down to the current player. Which has the unfortunate side effect that the Black Coach never works outside of your own magic phase.

Aramoro
 
note that it only works in your phase when you want it to. On a turn where you need your magic, you too can ignore its effects.
 
At that it's well overcosted. If thats how people are goign to play it then it's relegated to novelty lists.

Aramoro
 
I'm sorry but I really think that the Coach is not an overpriced trinket:
Winds of magic, as it clearly states on page 30 (side note) exist from the northernmost wastes of the Chaos region down to the southern most marks. What we do by rolling dice is we take a snapshot of the amount of power a mage can harness in the moment they decide to do so. There is no rolling outside the specific phase. This means that sadly or not, people will have to put up with the fact that there is no deciding: the Coach sucks dice regardlessly unless GW issues an Errata/FAQ.

To further try to solve this issue once and for all I also posted to the Rulezboyz... I'll keep you posted
 
vonkrolok said:
I'm sorry but I really think that the Coach is not an overpriced trinket:
Winds of magic, as it clearly states on page 30 (side note) exist from the northernmost wastes of the Chaos region down to the southern most marks. What we do by rolling dice is we take a snapshot of the amount of power a mage can harness in the moment they decide to do so. There is no rolling outside the specific phase. This means that sadly or not, people will have to put up with the fact that there is no deciding: the Coach sucks dice regardlessly unless GW issues an Errata/FAQ.

To further try to solve this issue once and for all I also posted to the Rulezboyz... I'll keep you posted

I'm afraid in a strict RAW sense you are incorrect. Fluff is not an valid argument. Both effects happen at the start of the magic phase, that is their timing slot. If you read pg10 'Sequencing'

Whilst every effort has been made to make sure that the sequencing of rules is utterly clear, occasionally you'll find that two or more rules are to be resolved at the same time - normally 'At the start of the movement phase' or similar. When this happens, and the wording in not explicit as to which rule is resolved first, then the player whose turn it is chooses the order.

Now although Evocation relies on the power pool it does not explicitly say that it happens after the winds of magic are rolled. Thus it is up to the player whose turn it is to decide the order of resolution.

Aramoro
 
You're right, they happen both at the beginning of the magic phase... like HE Vortex Shard, so like attacks of same initiative they should be resolved simultaneously, so for every dice that is rolled in the winds of magic a dice is rolled to see if it's sucked by the coach. If you don't roll for winds there is NO magic phase... sure, for me you can renounce to your magic phase if so you want to, because before the rolling of the winds there is the shooting phase wounds allocation.

Or, if you want you can play a tournament with "The Most Important rule" page 2
 
Aramoro said:
Now although Evocation relies on the power pool it does not explicitly say that it happens after the winds of magic are rolled. Thus it is up to the player whose turn it is to decide the order of resolution.

Aramoro, once again I ask you, where does it explicitly say that the dice should be rolled at the start of the magic phase? If you're going to focus on wording so specifically, then don't be haphazard about it.

Here's another one for you: the Charmed Shield lets the owner ignore the first hit he suffers on a 2+. So, when does this dice roll happen? When you suffer your first hit, obviously. But what also happens when a model takes a hit. You roll to wound. So, by the same backwards logic applied to the Black Coach, as both of these things are happening at the same time, the active player gets to decide when the Charmed Shield activates! And, obviously, that would mean that if it's a cannon shot or something in the attacker's turn, he could therefore say, the roll to wound comes first, and by that point it's too late to roll for the Charmed Shield.

Welcome to warhammer played the stupid way. If that's what you really want...
 
Attacks of the same Initiative have their own rules. They absolutely do not happen simultaneously. The active player chooses the order and resolves each rule in that order, that is exactly what the rule says. Each rule is atomic so you roll winds then evocation OR you Evocation and then roll winds.

This is a discussion about the RAW of Evocation of Death, the most important rule doesn't matter in this case.

Aramoro
 
If it's THE most important rule... then applies every time there is a discordance. And besides: if all Warhammer was "Active player decides" why not tossing the BRB in a ditch... you don't need it: you decide when it's your turn... common sense ALWAYS applies
 
Lord Fear said:
Aramoro said:
Now although Evocation relies on the power pool it does not explicitly say that it happens after the winds of magic are rolled. Thus it is up to the player whose turn it is to decide the order of resolution.

Aramoro, once again I ask you, where does it explicitly say that the dice should be rolled at the start of the magic phase? If you're going to focus on wording so specifically, then don't be haphazard about it.


Page 30, paragraph 1.

At the start of each Magic phase, the casting player determines the strength of the Winds of Magic by rolling 2D6

I am not being haphazard, simply read the rulebook.


Aramoro
 
vonkrolok said:
If it's THE most important rule... then applies every time there is a discordance. And besides: if all Warhammer was "Active player decides" why not tossing the BRB in a ditch... you don't need it: you decide when it's your turn... common sense ALWAYS applies

Right this is a discussion about the RAW of Evocation of Death. That is all. How you choose to apply those rules is entirely up to you and your opponent using The most important rule.

But the simple facts are, both effects happen 'At the start of the Magic Phase', pg 10 tells us what happens when 2 rules happen at the same time. The Active player decides the order to resolve them in. That is just the rules written in the rulebook.

I'm not trying to say that's how it should be played.

Aramoro
 
Jeez, can't believe you guys are still debating this.

imo it's pretty bloody clear in the FAQ

Q. Can I choose not to absorb magical energy with the Black Coach’s
Evocation of Death ability?(p47)
A. No.


So I can't choose to not absorb my power dice

Therefore why could my opponent choose not to?


People can blabber on about sequencing as opposed to not actually absorbing all they like, but it's pretty obvious to me as to what the clear intention of the rule is, and an official FAQ overrides all else.

Anyone who tries to say the ruling on it is contrary to the FAQ, is really just trying to be a pedantic arsehole. Normally I'm happy to concede a point to an opposing player if it's a grey area and they seem pretty into it etc. However this isn't a grey area, it's obvious what is intended, do we need them to write an entire page of legal jargon for each rule?
 
If you don't want to read the rules that's fine but intent has nothing to do with RAW and that is what is being discussed. The FAQ says the ability is not optional. No one is questioning that the ability always happens. It just might happen before Winds of Magic are generated.

If you don't want to discuss the RAW then I might suggest you refrain from calling people arseholes and leave the topic alone?

Aramoro
 
It's very clear in the FAQ

GW asked a question in the FAQ, and answered it with a simple and straightforward answer.

Asking essentially the same question, but in a different way, doesn't change the fact that it's the same question.



If you want to be a rules lawyer and debate it, then my comment in the previous post definitely applies to you :)


As complicated as this game can occasionally be, it's a game which is ment to be fun. However people trying to create a legal loophole in the game rules, when they can clearly see the intention of the rule, really isn't in the spirit of the game.
 
I agree it's not in the spirit of the rules and not how I ever play it. But that doesn't change the fact that as far as RAW goes that is exactly how it works.

As a long time Bretonnian player everyone know how Lances work in combat, the ranks are three wide. So I charge 12 Knights into your flank so I have Disrupted you and have 4 Ranks for the purpose of Steadfast right? Sadly not, despite everyone knowing exactly how this is intended to work it's getting ruled in tournies as Lances are never Steadfast and can never Disrupt. This is exactly the same thing, everyone 'knows' how it works but if your tourney judge reads the rules as the are written he could easily deny you it. Just something to be aware of.

Calling someone an arsehole for actually working out how the game works makes you a bit a one yourself, yes? :D

Aramoro
 
vonkrolok said:
At the start of each Magic phase, the casting player determines the strength of the Winds of Magic by rolling 2D6

If you don't do this there is no magic phase altogether

Rolling the Winds of Magic is not optional. Rolling the Winds of Magic happens at the start of the magic phase. I don't see what your point is?

Aramoro
 
Aramoro said:
I am not being haphazard, simply read the rulebook.

Oh dear oh dear oh dear. I was clearly and obviously asking you to tell us where it says to roll the dice for the Black Coach at the start of the phase. Because, it does not say it dirextly according to the holy bible that is RAW. Some common sense must be applied. In which case, you better be applying it both ways.

Given that you have such a problem with such basic reading comprehension, I don't think I can put much faith in your funky interpretations of "reading" rulebooks, and nor should anyone else :ghost:

However, no-one should be insulting each other, a bit of banter is fine, but no more talk of arseholes please or I'll have to go look in the closet for my mod hat!
 
Evocation of Death start with the line 'At the Start of every Magic Phase' That is when is happens, not just after the start or any other time.

You start the Magic Phase, you look for all the rules which happen 'At the start of the magic phase'

Winds of magic - 'At the start of the magic phase'

Evocation of Death - 'At the Start of every Magic Phase'

So they happen simultaneously. Nothing is simultaneous so we turn to sequencing on pg 10. The player whose turn it is decides the order.

If you have a rules based argument that isn't an ad hominem attack then I would love to hear it. I'm not being sarcastic in that I just like to see the truth of matters.

Aramoro
 
You just don't get it. You're not even trying. But then I knew you wouldn't. You've already made your mind up and are too busy playing the victim to actually engage with the arguments being presented.

EoD does start with that line. But then there's a fullstop and new line. What makes you think that the subsequent line about rolling the power dice only applies to the start of the magic phase? It doesn't say, "at the start of the magic phase roll the power dice". It says, at the start of the magic phase, the Coach does some undefined action. Then, new line, new command. If you want to play the snarky rules lawyer, then you have to analyse the new line completely independently. Roll the power dice in the pool, it says. It doesn't say to do it at the start of the phase, does it?

I've said this three times now, I hope you finally grasp it.

So, what'll it be? Common sense, or rules lawyering? Becuase BOTH support that you must roll the power dice. Anything else is sheer hypocrisy, because you're either only using one facet of RAW to support your position, while blatantly ignoring the other, or you're using common sense to ascertain that you should be rolling the dice at the start of the phase, yet not applying it to tell you that obviously, you can only roll the dice after they've been generated.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu