I'm sorry to risk ruining the whole thread by quoting from the first
Hellboy Movie, but reading this thread brought it into my mind, and as thanks for that remembrance (for good or ill) I'll share it with you lot:
What makes a man a man? A friend of mine once wondered. Is it his origins? The way he comes to life? I don't think so. It's the choices he makes. Not how he starts things, but how he decides to end them.
I find it somewhat relevant to the discussion. Bloodsworn has mentioned a fair bit of this already, so I don't need to dwell on it. For my own part I have loved reading the debate, but I don't think there's a copper-bottom answer at the end of it, other than "it depends", but that makes for a crap discussion. I would say I think everyone is in fairly equal amounts right and wrong. Still, the important thing in this discussion for me is
context.
To take Bloodsworm's (very good) example of a predator, such as a Lion, Tiger or Homo Sapiens Sapiens (i.e.
us) etc. Are they evil because they kill to survive? Perhaps we are worse, we can
choose not to. But the point here is the context, and the context of what perspective is used. In truth, evil and good are largely subjective, and invented concepts anyway. Morality is seldom fair to all, it is usually selectively biased. Likewise, a human in the World of Warhammer has a different perspective on life than a vampire. Technically a human isn't a predator, it's a social animal that has likely left the hunter-gatherer aspect behind, and thus loses any empathy for that situation.
The main problem is simply that a general precedent will not work. Vampires in general being inherently evil or simply misunderstood is a pointless observation without
context, and well, does every single vampire share exactly the
same context? Not really. Let's have a few
for instances.
For instance, the idea of feeding on the blood of humans as a default evil act. Is Abhorash no longer evil because he no longer needs to do so? The idea of blood itself comes with a variety of issues. I'm fairly sure I remember reading of willing blood vessels who pledge their blood to keep their masters alive in hope of one day receiving the blood kiss. Does that make vampires good by nature of avoiding killing people? It's never a straight answer, because most answers aren't. Not leaving drained corpses around definitely avoids detection (10 points to House
Hufflepuff Lahmia), which is at least a sinister thing to do, but then, considering detection means being persecuted to death by fearful humanity and the borderline Hammer Horror Witchfinder General Sigmarite Priests, not killing humans is logical, somewhat good and yet a little suspect all at once.
I suppose there is the technical explanation:
Chaos and Everything Affiliated = Evil, but there are some issues there. Many of which have definitely been mentioned. My
WHFB lore is shaky, but if I'm right this logic would surely mean
all Wizards are Evil, especially as they always
choose to manipulate the winds of magic. But following my survival line, this begs the question of what humanity would do about threats such as chaos if they
didn't wield it. And if questioning the right for vampires to survive by taking blood, the same token should be applied to humans wielding the winds of magic.
With Vampires it's tricky, even if we ignore those who
didn't choose the blood kiss for the moment. At this point, I should apologise again, although this time it's because I'll be linking people to TV Tropes, which is a fantastic site (particularly for writers),
but can ruin your life. So if you follow the link, be aware that you may tab browse constantly for the next fortnight and be lost to humanity; not to mention having your view of fiction, media and pretty much everything else skewed forever. So with that warning I absolve myself of all responsibility.
So with that in mind, TV Tropes raises one important point:
Dark is not necessarily Evil. Now, to what extent is this relevant to Vampires? Sure they kill,
but they need to. The context is important, here. Simply dying is illogical. We invented good and evil, and a lot of other things to aid our survival. Vampires who don't feed, die. It's nonsensical, even if it is self-inflicted, to not drink blood. That makes contrary morality invalid, because it's dumb in their context.
Batman is the weblink page's image, and he's a good example of the trope. He has a set of morals he sticks to, and he doesn't kill, although hospitalising and inflicting severe pain on people doesn't seem to register. Largely he's considered good, but his darker side allows the narrative possibility of exploring this, such as giving a villain a stinging comment (e.g. "we're not so different..." yes, you'll find that on TV Tropes too, not that I encourage you to look for it, unless you want to) to weaken their resolve.
It comes back to the Hellboy quote, I'd say. Designation (i.e. made by evil processes), isn't enough for me. It's far, far too easy to overcome. In the right circumstances, a vampire has a capacity to be fairly good. The trouble with a faction-filled wargame is where the measure comes from. Within any context, perspectives shift. That's why the good/evil scale applied to omnivorous predators by omnivorous supermarket patrons is a tad subjective.
If we were to try and drag it to general conceptions though, a large part of me errs to the evil camp. Even though there's no really obvious good guys in the Warhammer World (dig enough and you'll find dirt on the lot of them), there are some that are
more likely to be evil than others. Vampires are high up on the list. Maybe they start off with good intentions, but it doesn't last. As the Liber Necris aptly details, Vampires very quickly lose empathy for their prey. They become natural predators, who utilise dark magicks, cursed items, and well, the friggin' dead to achieve their own ends. That is pretty likely to rub off. Whether the vampires believe the stigma attached to them by humans, sooner or later most of them
become that stigma if it suits their own ends.
But just because the stigma sometimes fits doesn't mean it always is so. Fiction is usually devoted to exceptions to the rules they just made up. A good writer can make anything happen in the right circumstances providing they satisfactorily answer the question that they are right to do so in the first place. With vampires, I could see a few potential heroic examples. Trouble is, removing the "they feed on us" aspect is difficult. We tend to assign blame, and fear on the misunderstood. The fact they predate on those who fear them just makes it an easier conclusion to take.
Fear has a lot to do with it, and whilst real world logic is never needed for fiction compared to its own "in universe logic", the fact that Vampires inspire fear in this setting helps mark them out as evil. But, as H.P. Lovecraft said:
"The oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear, and the oldest and strongest kind of fear is fear of the unknown."
So the question is, are vampires an unknown quantity? To a large extent they are, hindered by the tropes that typify, stymie and yet aid the writer of tales: appearance, not being a classical kind of hero, having a physical abnormality, a different (necessarily) moral code etc. It means the argument is somewhat weighted. It will always be easy to call vampires evil, and humans as the good guys. Unfortunately, that's part of the way fiction works. But the great thing about fiction, is this feature can be used for a multitude of advantages.
Are vampires misunderstood as evil? Yes, no, maybe, possibly, why not, hang on wait a sec, and the classic: I will counter this with a question: such as "why do you think that?", etc. All of those. All at once. Yeah.
Well, that was more than I wanted to write. Got stimulated by a good conversation again. I hope it was useful for people anyway.