Vampires are not Inherently Evil (Just Misunderstood)

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Ordo Cruentus said:
Yeah. They are just a different flavor of evil.

That is what makes them so compelling.

They are suffused in evil, but have enough personality to do good. But they can never be good. Tragic really. But fun as hell to read about.

I think you're oversimplifying things. Chaos is primarily amoral, and more importantly since Chaos represents the 'darker' elements of our psyche made manifest, if being suffused in Chaos means that a vampire is necessarily evil then all mortals are also evil since the mortal mind is the place from which Chaos is born.
 
Sweeney Todd said:
Ordo Cruentus said:
Yeah. They are just a different flavor of evil.

That is what makes them so compelling.

They are suffused in evil, but have enough personality to do good. But they can never be good. Tragic really. But fun as hell to read about.

I think you're oversimplifying things. Chaos is primarily amoral, and more importantly since Chaos represents the 'darker' elements of our psyche made manifest, if being suffused in Chaos means that a vampire is necessarily evil then all mortals are also evil since the mortal mind is the place from which Chaos is born.

I think you misunderstand. In Warhammer, sentient races create Chaos, simply by feeling emotions, yes. More specifically rage/bloodlust, hedonistic desires, despair, and a thirst for knowledge/change. Mortal's are the source of the raw stuff of Chaos, but unless they actually worship Chaos, they are not actually filled with it. It's the difference between a part-time manufacturer, and a full-time warehouse (strange metaphor, but I think it works).

That may be a bit pedantic, but in Warhammer there are objective, measurable, things of good and evil. Mortals, for the most part unless devoted to a higher power, are base neutral. They have the potential to be either.

Hell, even members of races like the Dark Elves, Chaos Dwarves, and Skaven I suspect could be raised to be goodly, if taken from their toxic kingdoms and raised in a different one.

Vampires though? Vampires are dead bodies, animated by Dhar. Dhar is, and I quote: "...the primal Chaotic source of magic. Spells cast using dark magic use multiple strands of magic in its raw, unrefined form. Dark Elves are the most renowned users of dark magic, but specialized forms of Dhar are used in the Necromancy of Necromancers and Vampires, first harnessed and honed by Nagash to raise the dead on a vast scale. It is known that by sacrificing 'volunteers' it can increase the power behind the spells of Dark Magic."

So again, in Warhammer, while Vampires are sentient enough to do actions that we might consider good, they are at their very deepest core fueled by the darkest of evils. You can read the effects of this in so much of WH novels. Every time a Vampire has its senses rung, say through battle, contact with holy items, etc. they all revert to this bestial state. Only concerned with survival, like a mindless beast. However, unlike many beasts, it has to kill and drink the blood of others.

Even really "good" Vampires, people who might make the most altruistic of choices if given the chance, have to actively work at suppressing the beast. And the thing is, they can never succeed. Look at someone like Ulrika. If never made a Vampire, she would still probably be running around having adventures with Felix. However, now that she is all vampified, she has no choice but to do evil things. If she tries to resist feeding, it only weakens her, and makes the default evil beast take over.

Now imagine having to deal with that forever, unless death takes you.

So again, I break it down more simply: They are suffused in evil, but have enough personality to do good. But they can never be good.
 
On top of all of that, Vampires instinctively and naturally use Necromancy. Even mortal necromancers do this- Van Hal bashed in the heads of several zombies with a mace before he came to the realization that he was the one who raised the damn things. Some Vampires have more control over it, but many subconsciously create undead, attract ghouls, dominate the minds of others, etc.

As is shown in Dead Winter using necromancy (even just once) risks creating "Sympathies of Spirit and Mentality that must never be made". This is dead person from the land of morr lingo for some kind of spiritual and magical link between necromancers (it is part of how necromancers find each other and are drawn to vampires). This link even possibly links necromancers to the spirit of nagash itself.

Using necromancy opens up your mind and soul to influence by unfathomable and powerful evil. In most fantasy settings (including warhammer) using Necromancy is an inherently evil act that damns you for all eternity- its worse than murder or rape, and on par with the summoning of daemons.


.... and this is the magic that vampires can use without any prior knowledge or learning. It takes practice for them to get good at it, but they all (with the possible exception of Konrad) have the innate supernatural ability to use necromancy. Its like another organ of the body or sense to them.
 
Ordo Cruentus said:
That may be a bit pedantic, but in Warhammer there are objective, measurable, things of good and evil. Mortals, for the most part unless devoted to a higher power, are base neutral. They have the potential to be either.

I think I see the source of our disagreement now. If you use the Warhammer scale of morality, then Chaos is evil. The writers say so, the setting is made to be so, and that's that. No room for discussion there. However, if you use a morality closer to what we use in real life, then Chaos isn't evil so much as it is amoral. All the more so when you use the analogy of the vampire as a beast, since a beast is also amoral.

I refer specifically to vampires though, because necromancers are a rather different kettle of fish. The most significant difference being that some are given the Blood Kiss without their consent, but no one ever became a necromancer unwillingly/accidentally.
 
Sweeney Todd said:
I think I see the source of our disagreement now. If you use the Warhammer scale of morality, then Chaos is evil. The writers say so, the setting is made to be so, and that's that. No room for discussion there. However, if you use a morality closer to what we use in real life, then Chaos isn't evil so much as it is amoral. All the more so when you use the analogy of the vampire as a beast, since a beast is also amoral.

Oh yes, but I find trying to apply fictional "rules" (in this case what good and evil are, objectively) with real world standards to be...well, exhaustive really. You will always find that one person who goes all moral-relativism on everything, and then there is really nothing left to discuss. I find it best to discuss fictional moral issues, in this case the inherent evilness of Vampires, on the merits of the setting itself, and try not to get too meta about it.

Sweeney Todd said:
I refer specifically to vampires though, because necromancers are a rather different kettle of fish. The most significant difference being that some are given the Blood Kiss without their consent, but no one ever became a necromancer unwillingly/accidentally.

I'm not sure culpability really matters in the end with Dhar. Whether one chooses to use it, or is only sustained BY it, suffusion with it is the end result.
 
There are only two kinds of vampires. Those that choose to become vampires and those that do not. I think we can all agree that if you willingly choose to become a vampire; i.e. choose to devour the essence of your kind to sustain your unnatural life; you are evil.
The second kind of vampire did not willingly become one so the person is not inherently evil. So there is potential for this vampire to not want to devour the blood of the living much like Abhorash. Still even the most restrained and dutiful vampire lords devoured the very people he swore to protect. So it is impossible to stop the blood lust while being in the company of humans barring the drinking of a dragons blood which there are very few vampires that would be able to accomplish that feat. Warhammer does show what happens to vampires that refuse to drink the blood of the living and exile themselves in the story of the Strigoi. While not descended from Ushoran, too many parallels can be drawn from a Vampire who chooses to forsake his vampire lineage and the Strigany being exiled from the vampiric aristocracy. Ultimately the fate of all vampires that choose not to feed on living blood is that of the strigoi
At the end of the day a vampire is either someone who willingly forsakes his humanity and chooses to feast on his brethren to live forever or will hold on to their morals and become a twisted beast that will kill and feast on the living.
The path of the vampire is steeped in evil from its very inception. They are not misunderstood, they are evil to their very core.
 
I don't really see chaos as amoral. The creatures from the realm of chaos seem willing to do pretty evil things. They may not be doing these things for the sake of being evil, but you see, evil arises from a failure to be good. An "evil" corporation does not force people to work in sweatshops or pollute a river out of a desire to hurt those people or destroy the environment- it does so simply because it lacks the good morals to say "we should not do this".

The same can apply to chaos. Chaos is a reflection of sentient psychology yes, but its four main manifestations are beings that have shown a willingness to plunge the world into war, to destroy lives (and souls) and to do unspeakable things. They might have strange motives and a different point of view, but by any standard of good and evil, they are evil.

edit: you have to remember, that chaos is not just a reflection of human psychology. All sentient beings contribute- for every human being, there are hundreds of greedy, selfish, murderous skaven and dozens of bloodthirsty orcs. In addition, a large portion of humanity in the warhammer world lives in the north, worshipping the chaos gods directly. On top of that, the most extreme of human emotions are more commonly negative ones (hatred, anger, envy, jealousy, obsession, despair, sadness) as opposed to positive ones (hope, love, compassion, joy) and even then, the positive ones can easily turn into or feed the negative ones (love becomes obsession for example)
So it is small wonder that the realm of chaos is a source of corruption and war.
 
I think it's important to side-step the incredibly murky issues of what exactly constitutes good and evil. This way lies madness with all sorts of arguments backwards and forwards. Is a Vampire evil if he kills people? What if he only kills convicted murderers or Chaos worshipers? What if he only kills in the defence of others?

I think instead we need to use the rules as laid out by the setting. According to the setting, Chaos is evil. Dark Elves and Chaos Dwarves are evil. End of discussion. Orcs and Goblins are more like an act of nature, more like a hurricane or earthquake than something evil.

Vampires, as described in the latest book "were once human, with hopes, dreams and families of their own. Even though traces of emotion still stir in their shrivelled hearts, the Blood Kiss has transformed them into monsters without exception. Their once-humble aspirations have been consumed, twisted into a desire to conquer and rule over the mortals they left behind."

So this doesn't leave much room for 'good' vampires.
 
I belive the following:

The act of transforming a human into a vampire twists the mind and personality of the person to some degree. The transformation and satuation of dark magic corrupts the mortal into a being of evil. However, one can, as past fluff has shown us, retain vestiges of humanity through sheer force of will and personality, much like Jerek Von Carstein did. With his existance, along with others like him (Ulrika comes to mind), there is no denying that there are vampires who can be considered good to some degree.

And vampires aren't evil due to feeding on people, killing people, rising the dead from their graves etc etc. Those are simply a result of the vampires choice. Everyone, vampires included, are evil because they choose to perform evil deeds. If the vampire refuses to perform evil deeds, then he is not evil. For instance, Abhorash initially refused to feed on the living, he did not raise the dead, he hated being a vampire and he was loyal and honorable before eventually sucumbing to the hunger. Was he evil until he sucumbed, purely for being a vampire?

As for the debate concerning human killing animals for food vs vampires killing humans for food. Some say that this is considered "evil" due to in being some form of abomination as vampires used to be human. If you have a tiger who eats people, is he evil? No. If you take a human and magicaly transform him into a tiger, who then eats people, is the resulting tiger evil, simply because he once was something that he now is not? I can agree that the act of transforming said tiger was an evil one, since by that act one created a being that could come to eat people, but the fault is hardly the tiger's. I hardly consider vampires evil purely because they feed on what they need to substain themselves. That act is natural, and everything in nature does this. Look at the rest of the warhammer world. Lizardmen eat people, Ogres eat people, Dragons eat people, yet we hardly consider them evil, atleast not most of the time. And the Lizardmen and ogres are about as far removed from humanity as the vampires are. If some git of a wizard transformed a human into a saurus, would that saurus then be considered more evil than other saurus simply because he acts as a normal saurus now and eats people? No.

A vampire who feeds for his own survival and substains from other "evil" acts such as wanton slaughter, raising of the undead and all the rest is hardly evil in my eyes, but simply the natural order of things. A predator feeding on its prey. Most vampires in the warhammer world hardly follow this, and as such, the vast majority of vampires are indeed evil to some degree, but every once in a while, a person is turned with enough force of will, inherent goodness and streangth of personality to resist the corrupting influence of being what they are, much like Jerek did. Thus we have ourselves a... perhaps not a "good" vampire, but atleast one with lighter shades of grey within them.

Vampires are not inherently evil, they just have an enormous tendancy to become evil by performing evil acts, simply due to their nature. But they dont HAVE to.
 
I'm agreeing with Bloodsworn here, because that's my view of Vampires-being does not make a moral viewpoint, and acts done to survive are not evil (unless, of course, they are with evil intentions, for example stealing souls to prolong your lifespan).
 
I'm sorry to risk ruining the whole thread by quoting from the first Hellboy Movie, but reading this thread brought it into my mind, and as thanks for that remembrance (for good or ill) I'll share it with you lot:

What makes a man a man? A friend of mine once wondered. Is it his origins? The way he comes to life? I don't think so. It's the choices he makes. Not how he starts things, but how he decides to end them.

I find it somewhat relevant to the discussion. Bloodsworn has mentioned a fair bit of this already, so I don't need to dwell on it. For my own part I have loved reading the debate, but I don't think there's a copper-bottom answer at the end of it, other than "it depends", but that makes for a crap discussion. I would say I think everyone is in fairly equal amounts right and wrong. Still, the important thing in this discussion for me is context.

To take Bloodsworm's (very good) example of a predator, such as a Lion, Tiger or Homo Sapiens Sapiens (i.e. us) etc. Are they evil because they kill to survive? Perhaps we are worse, we can choose not to. But the point here is the context, and the context of what perspective is used. In truth, evil and good are largely subjective, and invented concepts anyway. Morality is seldom fair to all, it is usually selectively biased. Likewise, a human in the World of Warhammer has a different perspective on life than a vampire. Technically a human isn't a predator, it's a social animal that has likely left the hunter-gatherer aspect behind, and thus loses any empathy for that situation.

The main problem is simply that a general precedent will not work. Vampires in general being inherently evil or simply misunderstood is a pointless observation without context, and well, does every single vampire share exactly the same context? Not really. Let's have a few for instances.

For instance, the idea of feeding on the blood of humans as a default evil act. Is Abhorash no longer evil because he no longer needs to do so? The idea of blood itself comes with a variety of issues. I'm fairly sure I remember reading of willing blood vessels who pledge their blood to keep their masters alive in hope of one day receiving the blood kiss. Does that make vampires good by nature of avoiding killing people? It's never a straight answer, because most answers aren't. Not leaving drained corpses around definitely avoids detection (10 points to House Hufflepuff Lahmia), which is at least a sinister thing to do, but then, considering detection means being persecuted to death by fearful humanity and the borderline Hammer Horror Witchfinder General Sigmarite Priests, not killing humans is logical, somewhat good and yet a little suspect all at once.

I suppose there is the technical explanation: Chaos and Everything Affiliated = Evil, but there are some issues there. Many of which have definitely been mentioned. My WHFB lore is shaky, but if I'm right this logic would surely mean all Wizards are Evil, especially as they always choose to manipulate the winds of magic. But following my survival line, this begs the question of what humanity would do about threats such as chaos if they didn't wield it. And if questioning the right for vampires to survive by taking blood, the same token should be applied to humans wielding the winds of magic.

With Vampires it's tricky, even if we ignore those who didn't choose the blood kiss for the moment. At this point, I should apologise again, although this time it's because I'll be linking people to TV Tropes, which is a fantastic site (particularly for writers), but can ruin your life. So if you follow the link, be aware that you may tab browse constantly for the next fortnight and be lost to humanity; not to mention having your view of fiction, media and pretty much everything else skewed forever. So with that warning I absolve myself of all responsibility.

So with that in mind, TV Tropes raises one important point: Dark is not necessarily Evil. Now, to what extent is this relevant to Vampires? Sure they kill, but they need to. The context is important, here. Simply dying is illogical. We invented good and evil, and a lot of other things to aid our survival. Vampires who don't feed, die. It's nonsensical, even if it is self-inflicted, to not drink blood. That makes contrary morality invalid, because it's dumb in their context.

Batman is the weblink page's image, and he's a good example of the trope. He has a set of morals he sticks to, and he doesn't kill, although hospitalising and inflicting severe pain on people doesn't seem to register. Largely he's considered good, but his darker side allows the narrative possibility of exploring this, such as giving a villain a stinging comment (e.g. "we're not so different..." yes, you'll find that on TV Tropes too, not that I encourage you to look for it, unless you want to) to weaken their resolve.

It comes back to the Hellboy quote, I'd say. Designation (i.e. made by evil processes), isn't enough for me. It's far, far too easy to overcome. In the right circumstances, a vampire has a capacity to be fairly good. The trouble with a faction-filled wargame is where the measure comes from. Within any context, perspectives shift. That's why the good/evil scale applied to omnivorous predators by omnivorous supermarket patrons is a tad subjective.

If we were to try and drag it to general conceptions though, a large part of me errs to the evil camp. Even though there's no really obvious good guys in the Warhammer World (dig enough and you'll find dirt on the lot of them), there are some that are more likely to be evil than others. Vampires are high up on the list. Maybe they start off with good intentions, but it doesn't last. As the Liber Necris aptly details, Vampires very quickly lose empathy for their prey. They become natural predators, who utilise dark magicks, cursed items, and well, the friggin' dead to achieve their own ends. That is pretty likely to rub off. Whether the vampires believe the stigma attached to them by humans, sooner or later most of them become that stigma if it suits their own ends.

But just because the stigma sometimes fits doesn't mean it always is so. Fiction is usually devoted to exceptions to the rules they just made up. A good writer can make anything happen in the right circumstances providing they satisfactorily answer the question that they are right to do so in the first place. With vampires, I could see a few potential heroic examples. Trouble is, removing the "they feed on us" aspect is difficult. We tend to assign blame, and fear on the misunderstood. The fact they predate on those who fear them just makes it an easier conclusion to take.

Fear has a lot to do with it, and whilst real world logic is never needed for fiction compared to its own "in universe logic", the fact that Vampires inspire fear in this setting helps mark them out as evil. But, as H.P. Lovecraft said:
"The oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear, and the oldest and strongest kind of fear is fear of the unknown."

So the question is, are vampires an unknown quantity? To a large extent they are, hindered by the tropes that typify, stymie and yet aid the writer of tales: appearance, not being a classical kind of hero, having a physical abnormality, a different (necessarily) moral code etc. It means the argument is somewhat weighted. It will always be easy to call vampires evil, and humans as the good guys. Unfortunately, that's part of the way fiction works. But the great thing about fiction, is this feature can be used for a multitude of advantages.

Are vampires misunderstood as evil? Yes, no, maybe, possibly, why not, hang on wait a sec, and the classic: I will counter this with a question: such as "why do you think that?", etc. All of those. All at once. Yeah.

Well, that was more than I wanted to write. Got stimulated by a good conversation again. I hope it was useful for people anyway.
 
I haven't read everything in this thread, but I think what DDM was trying to say was that GW portrayed ALL vampires as revelling in their own evil - i.e. going, "We're evil, we know this and we love it," but many vampires are much more interesting characters than that - they believe that what they are doing is right or even good. So, whilst many vampires may well be evil, they certainly will not accept that and this psychological perspective is much better and understandable than "WE'RE EVIL! ISN'T IT GREAT!". This is the logic that GW is currenlty putting forward.
 
The Dread King said:
So, whilst many vampires may well be evil, they certainly will not accept that and this psychological perspective is much better and understandable than "WE'RE EVIL! ISN'T IT GREAT!". This is the logic that GW is currenlty putting forward.

Meh...gotta raise one point. Codexes and the like usually deal with the Warhammer setting in the Macro, not the Micro (the Micro is usually covered by the Black Library, and lo and behold, we have morally ambiguous Vampire novels in there!), and without looking much beyond the surface (and actually a little beneath the surface too), Vampires are overwhelmingly Evil. With a capitol E.

No matter how willful (see: Willing to be altruistic) certain Vampires may be, all Undead exist because of RAW EXISTENTIAL EVIL. It is the force behind every muscle movement, the energy that forces dead neurons to fire, and the insidious source of their thirst.

Vampires in Warhammer are Evil, objectively (because they say so). So, GW is quite justified in their Macro approaches.

But are Vampires evil (little e)? Probably. Eventually. Despite how much they might want to fight it...
 
Ordo Cruentus said:
Vampires in Warhammer are Evil, objectively (because they say so). So, GW is quite justified in their Macro approaches.

But are Vampires evil (little e)? Probably. Eventually. Despite how much they might want to fight it...

I think that's a good way to differentiate. Evil with a capital E, as opposed to the more common, everyday evil.

We can debate back and forth for years about what constitutes evil-with-a-small-e, and how that might apply to vampires, but at the end of the day they are unambiguously Evil-with-a-capital-E.
 
The predator argument is flawed. No lion choose to be a lion, also lions don't have a compulsion to eat other lions. For the most part and I'm talking 99% of warhammer vampires choose to be vampires. They choose to steal essences of other mortals to extend their life unnaturally. It doesn't matter who's essence they stole good/evil/awesome/sigmar/archeon that act is evil.
Secondly the Abhorash argument is flawed too. Abhorash is the absolute pinnacle of a vampire resisting it's nature. He tried desperately not devour the people he swore to protect and failed! Only after he devoured a dragons blood was he cured, and that is only recorded I believe only twice. The latter Vampire Zecharias was still evil to his core. This displays a very powerful truth about the evil nature of the vampire. It is unavoidable. Blutsauger is right
 
Vampires are
A) The Living Dead
B) Sustained by the blood of the living
C) Sustained by Dark Magic
D) Raise the dead to create armies to conquer the living.

ABC no contest.
D, Conquest is the point of Warhammer ain't it?
Yes, the vampires raise the dead to fight and work for them. But that makes them less not more evil than others who stay rich of the sweat of their peasants or force armies of the living into the nightmare of battle. I would say this makes the undead more human than the humans - they don't inflict that on the living.
 
ray fulcher said:
Vampires are
A) The Living Dead
B) Sustained by the blood of the living
C) Sustained by Dark Magic
D) Raise the dead to create armies to conquer the living.

ABC no contest.
D, Conquest is the point of Warhammer ain't it?
Yes, the vampires raise the dead to fight and work for them. But that makes them less not more evil than others who stay rich of the sweat of their peasants or force armies of the living into the nightmare of battle. I would say this makes the undead more human than the humans - they don't inflict that on the living.

There is nothing worse to be raised up as a undead as a part of the persons soul will be pulled stuck and she/he will be stuck inside a corpse. It is horrid, horrid torment.
 
theknightofjello said:
The predator argument is flawed. No lion choose to be a lion, also lions don't have a compulsion to eat other lions. For the most part and I'm talking 99% of warhammer vampires choose to be vampires. They choose to steal essences of other mortals to extend their life unnaturally. It doesn't matter who's essence they stole good/evil/awesome/sigmar/archeon that act is evil.
Secondly the Abhorash argument is flawed too. Abhorash is the absolute pinnacle of a vampire resisting it's nature. He tried desperately not devour the people he swore to protect and failed! Only after he devoured a dragons blood was he cured, and that is only recorded I believe only twice. The latter Vampire Zecharias was still evil to his core. This displays a very powerful truth about the evil nature of the vampire. It is unavoidable. Blutsauger is right

It would seem you did not read the argument in its entirety. A lion does not eat other lions (while being inaccurate from a biological standpoint), has little to do with the argument as I stated it, as it concerns cannibalism. A vampire feeding on a human is not cannibalism, due to the fact that a vampire is no longer of the same race as the human. As I pointed out, a saurus or ogre has as much in common with a human as does a vampire. Some might argue even more so, since the two former are actually alive, and the latter is not.

And 99% of all warhammer vampires choose to be vampires? Im sorry, but where is that information from? Nowhere does it say in the army book that all vampires are created from people who desperatly wanted to become vampires. Jerek Krueger hardly chose his fate, and lo and behold, he became quite the decent vampire.

And no, they hardly steal their essence to live, in any more profound way than any predator steals their prey's essence. They kill them (sometimes not, depending on the vampire), and drink their blood. The end. No different from a dragon who hunts down its prey and eats it.

As for Abhorash being the pinnacle of resistance... hardly. He was merely an example to point out the flaws of viewing someone as evil purely based upon their existance (sometimes named racism). Abhorash is without a doubt evil now, despite his lack of the thirst.


[/quote]

There is nothing worse to be raised up as a undead as a part of the persons soul will be pulled stuck and she/he will be stuck inside a corpse. It is horrid, horrid torment.
[/quote]

Again, from where comes the information that the soul of the person is stuck inside the corpse? I think you might be confusing necromancy with the Tomb Kings brand of raising the dead, which does indeed call back a persons soul to rest within the reanimated body (ironically, the Tomb kings are not considered evil for this). The vampire's form of necromancy is based upon simple re-animation of a body. True, it is mentiond in some places that "Skeletons remember how to block and strike etc", but this is hardly an allusion to the actual person still inhabiting the skeleton, but could simply be the magic of re-animation acting out residual memory left behind in the remains it animates. Again, this is simply speculation, but I cannot seem to find anything in the vampire counts book that dictates that they actually trap someones soul in the undead they raise. The tomb kings do this, as its stated outright in their fluff, but cannot find that the vampires do. If this is the case, that the vampires way of raising is far more benign than the tomb kings, as it allows for the soul/mind of the person to remain in whatever awaits them after death. Again, ironically enough, it is the Tomb Kings that are regarded as "neutral", and Vampire counts as "evil" even though they function in much the same manner.
 
Shareya said:
theknightofjello said:
It would seem you did not read the argument in its entirety. A lion does not eat other lions (while being inaccurate from a biological standpoint), has little to do with the argument as I stated it, as it concerns cannibalism. A vampire feeding on a human is not cannibalism, due to the fact that a vampire is no longer of the same race as the human. As I pointed out, a saurus or ogre has as much in common with a human as does a vampire. Some might argue even more so, since the two former are actually alive, and the latter is not.

And 99% of all warhammer vampires choose to be vampires? Im sorry, but where is that information from? Nowhere does it say in the army book that all vampires are created from people who desperatly wanted to become vampires. Jerek Krueger hardly chose his fate, and lo and behold, he became quite the decent vampire.

And no, they hardly steal their essence to live, in any more profound way than any predator steals their prey's essence. They kill them (sometimes not, depending on the vampire), and drink their blood. The end. No different from a dragon who hunts down its prey and eats it.

As for Abhorash being the pinnacle of resistance... hardly. He was merely an example to point out the flaws of viewing someone as evil purely based upon their existance (sometimes named racism). Abhorash is without a doubt evil now, despite his lack of the thirst.

There is nothing worse to be raised up as a undead as a part of the persons soul will be pulled stuck and she/he will be stuck inside a corpse. It is horrid, horrid torment.

Looking through the newest VC army book, I can't see anything saying that it is a torment ... To quote the book, it says -

'All that these long-dead fighters can recall of mortal life are faint impressions from battles fought in ages past. All that they feel is the compulsion to fight and obey their masters. They have no autonomy or intelligence, though some vestige of their battlefield training remains ingrained in their bones'
--Pg 35 of Vampire Counts Army Book, paragraph 5 (Skeleton Warriors entry)

So, it would appear that their isn't a huge amount of torment inflicted upon the dead who are raised - indeed, they seem to know next to nothing, apart from how to fight!

Bloodsworn said:
Again, from where comes the information that the soul of the person is stuck inside the corpse? ... Again, this is simply speculation, but I cannot seem to find anything in the vampire counts book that dictates that they actually trap someones soul in the undead they raise.

Actually, whilst the new army book doesn't say the soul is bound to the body, it says they're bound to the mortal plane, essentially -

'Such charnel fields attract Dark Magic, and the souls of some warriors remain trapped in the material realm. Some of the spirits are men betrayed by their commanders, others of cowards who were cut down as they ran, or of those who died a violent and unexpected death ... Provided their remains have not been blessed by the rites of Morr, a Necromancer or Vampire can use the coiling energies of Dark Magic to instil a semblance of life and a flicker of spirit into these dormant warriors'
-Pg 35 of Vampire Counts Army Book, paragraphs 1 & 2 (Skeleton Warriors entry)
 
Ah, then I can aceed on that point. But based upon your information, it sounds as if only the barest echo of the previous occupant inhabits the reanimated body. Which indeed means they are more or less mindless drones with no self-awareness. Thus, the process of re-animation should provide little in the way of torment, seeing as there is no actual personality left to experience it.
 
Bloodsworn said:
Ah, then I can aceed on that point. But based upon your information, it sounds as if only the barest echo of the previous occupant inhabits the reanimated body. Which indeed means they are more or less mindless drones with no self-awareness. Thus, the process of re-animation should provide little in the way of torment, seeing as there is no actual personality left to experience it.

Oh, I absolutely agree, based only upon the information provided within the army book. I don't know whether Shar has access to other information, but from what the AB says, it appears as if you are correct.
 
True, but as Shakespeare said, there is no such thing as good or evil but thinking makes it so: for example, if Vampires ruled, instead of cows humans might be farmed. As rulers, they would deem what was good and evil.

As our society, morals and beliefs mostly parallel The Empire's, it is fair to say Vampires are 'evil' based on the actions you listed (raising the dead, drinking blood etc).

However, it was mentioned no one would give a damp about killing a bug. I would agree with you, but playing devil's advocate, let's look at it this way: the actions of humans are, by some, as evil as any other's. I would say that all humans re inherently evil, as are Vampires. The one possible difference is that most humans try very, very hard to combat their innate urges.

If a Vampire did the same, I'd argue he was no less evil than anyone else.
 
Of course I do!

Both in the Nagash triology, Neferata and Master of Death there are plenty of examples of what vamps do the dead/souls/spirits and it's pretty fucking nasty. In Master of Death especially where Soran muses over it.

I can try to find some quotes in a bit.

Note this is just random stuff from Master of Death. I am not going to go through all of the books.

He felt the tormented spark of each spectre as it sought to numb its pain by swallowing the life of its former companions. The screams from within the last warren rose to a crescendo and he stretched, tasting the ashes of souls on his tongue.

Men, women and children, their hazy features twisted with incomprehensible agony. They moaned and screamed in silence, writhing beneath the weight of the chains.
< this example is how vampires bind souls of their victims into...almost anything. Traps, spells, weapons, vehicles.

I will find the example of how the witchlight in the undeads ( say skeletons eyes) is just the mortals essence burning and screaming in agony for being pulled back into the world of the living.
 
Ah, well there you go! I need to get Master of Death and actually bloody read Neferata. Reading The Vampire Wars at the moment though; may be old, and some of the fluff might be out of date, but it's a reasonable read nonetheless after all!
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu